Pugnani-Kreisler : Praeludium und Allegro

[andrewchou3g]

1:34 uh...

[andrewchou3g]

0:20 wrong notes?

[2007wesman]

But of course, my comment is not related to this video, just the many other videos here on youtube.............. O_o

[2007wesman]

I cringe when i youthful, but skilled player fails to intepret the piece, puts their performance on youtube, and then brags to everyone that they played this when they were a kid. I mean really, this is a MATURE piece, where style is just as important as the technique. If one is to perform this piece, it should be nothing but spectular, as the piece is itself.

[jumjum49]

BEAUTIFUL!

Gave me goosebumps.

[Katherine85]

Un misero inchino no,eh?

[pandiaz]

Very good expression. A little mistake in intonnation I think to listen at 1:34, but what great work at last!

[Jarahh]

Great job! I like to play the ending a lot more espressivo like. With all the emotion you can ever give to it. If you know what I mean :)

[Violinkoala08]

It was good , i love the technique and tone. The intonation could do better although the allegro is hard. Im working on this song too :D And it isn't very easy..

[MissLolzqueen88]

I like Itzhak Perlman's :)

But i think this is OK as well, cause its a really difficult piece, u noe

[MultiFormula1]

No Praeludium??

[jandychou]

she played some notes wrong. :(

[Lapsellinen]

omg she is so false from 0:29 to 0:41

[patcalisura]

Listen to my interpretation!!!! (just kidding)

[patcalisura]

Not bad but there is something better....Joo young Oh's interpretation!!!!

[creedbon]

i like joo young oh's interpretation of this as much as Itzhak Perlman's

[MKBurn15]

That was pretty good, but that was only the allegro! No Praeludium! =)

[MisterElliott89]

pfsh, the allegro is and always will be the fun bit! and there's not much challenge in the praeludium.

[ThisDay3]

depends on how u look at it...the praeludium can be very challenging if u want to play it beautifully with emotion and passion

[ecks001]

nice!

[Aletidus87]

not bad...but intonation is not an opinion

[charrogent]

Bello!!

[zzzzzzzzzzzzander]

i really like the interpretation.

[3NUNS]

naughty: a few wrong notes

[3NUNS]

better than the best

[SabakuNoDouglas]

*.* amazing

[Debi242346]

da bod da ti gacni lastis puko od mene i micike

[thaelen]

Maddiiiiiiii!!!!no sabia que estubieses en youtube...XD. mola la obra!

[Caramellatta]

Beautiful, expressive interpretation. I love the sound of her violin!

[asilelis4]

where is the PRELIUDE?!

[polinomio]

Sorry, it was not recorded here

[3NUNS]

Ummm you are bwilliant

[cfan1270]

wow. she is awsome (compared to me).

thx for the show. I learned some techniques that might help me on the Sinfonia.

[dadookacsa]

where is the prelude?

[sexyback10193]

amazing sound violin

[lallyrules14]

wicked - bravo xxxx

[zbaby82]

Nice.

[sallustiobis]

I think too!

lol

[charrogent]

Though one small mistake, she still played so beautifully, I'd like to have her skill, the sound is just so full, love the low tones!!

[Niftyviolinist]

You don't say no offense and then tell someone that they played a piece they worked extremely hard on was terrible. Seriously, you used some strong adjectives if you were trying to be diplomatic. Plus, the piece was never performed by Kreisler himself so it can be performed at a range of tempos...or as you call "speed".

[Silverfind]

Yes, I know that, Kriesler never recorded his piece, Praeludium and Allegro, but this is really slow. I meant Haslop as the guy who plays it really good.

[Niftyviolinist]

Who plays it really good? You're losing your argument here because of your grammar.

Of course she's not going to be as good as a world class violinist, but it's not terrible at all.

[Silverfind]

Yeah, but I'm just saying that it shouldn't be played in a theatre with that skill. Praeludium has to be awesome, it's such a disgrace to play Praeludium with that skill. I said BUT later no offence, you moron. Who cares of a single grammar mistake.

[Niftyviolinist]

Moron? I believe my original point was that you can't follow no offense by an insult.

[WhitelighterMae1832]

And who the h*ll made you the f**king expert on violin? U can play for years and still not be an expert. To most people here, you are a bitter person who can't seem to say anything nice. In every one of your posts I read, it is negative. Like they say, if u can't say anything nice, don't say anything at all.

[joymoring03]

@Silverfind well, judging by what you've said, i think you are right-this piece does happen to be just one of those which has to be perfect. however, do you not agree that it is not right to be commenting so rudely on someone's playing? you CAN think that in your head! you ABSOLUTLY do NOT comment on people's playing saying their playing was a discrace!

[joymoring03]

if you do play the violin, and well too, you should have experiance and knollege, even if you're the least experianced, you should as a human have enough sense to know that you do not say if someone plays awfully (which this person actually didn't play discracefully, this person clearly tried their best, and maybe it just happened to be luck that she ended up with a couple of wrong notes:D) wether their playing was good or bad!xD (sorry, terribly confusingxD)

[Niftyviolinist]

Who plays it really good? You're losing your argument here because of your grammar.

Of course she's not going to be as good as a world class violinist, but it's not terrible at all.

[Silverfind]

Is that all you can say, handicap?

[sushisroxmysox]

Silverfind, instead of spending time on youtube commenting on all the violin videos you can find and saying they suck in some way or another, go practice and polish up your wonderful magnificent violin skills, as you imply they are, and leave the people who know how to post videos up alone. You don't want to sound as horrible as Maddi Arana now, do you? Ah, unfortunately nobody knows you real name, unlike Maddi Arana, now why is that so? Shame.

I hope you find happiness one day.

[ViolinGirlR]

i agree with sushiroxmysox. Also, you are not a violin critic, then you wouldn't be criticizing through youtube vdeos on violinists' styles. So stop spamming video comments on how you don't like their playing. If you don't have anything nice to say don't say it. I bet she worked really hard on that ok?

[Niftyviolinist]

Yep.

[wabitgirl]

Lovely recording. I find that the emphasis and emotion she puts in is really similar to what I like to put in, but her tone quality and precision (minus the couple of slips) is better.

[michejjipoo]

wheres the prelude?

[wabitgirl]

good question.

[enlast]

good!!!! have any of u herd kennedy plying this?? its v. good...this i too...i play this  yay!!

[Zhou9]

She still plays it 100x better than me.

[kevvio]

I prefer this piece faster!! It would sound nicer than. Keep up the gud work

[Silverfind]

Aww.... That wasn't the FUll video.

[47259285]

txiki!!oso urrun iritxiko zara musika munduan, ta emen oso argi ikusten da. jarraitu olan ta ez duzu arazorik izango. muxu asko!!!zure pianista rubia

[foxxml]

damn, can't see her face

[melancolia]

Conozco muy poco la música clásica pero este tema me apasiona desde adolescente. Ha sido un placer encontrar este vídeo aunque he echado de menos la primera parte !

Saludos.

[tyKi27]

I wonder what kind of standards the uhh "Vitoria -Gasteiz Music School" has for getting in lawl

[bambee]

If a Violin were to be played in the space it would be proven a much harder music instrument to learn...

[2934703]

I would like to have heard the very beginning. She is a helluva good violinist. She made music out of a piece that is mostly technical challenge.

[zuiakoezkertia]

jarraitu horrela madditxu. oso ondo jotzen dozu ta! oier

[Zhou9]

No spicatto? Rest is awesome.

[UrFaceYo]

spicatto???

[Zhou9]

You don't know what that is?

[UrFaceYo]

do you mean staccato?

[Zhou9]

No. Spicatto. Bouncing bow.

[EmulationGames]

OH, okay.

[hotviolin83]

esa maddy!!

muy buen sonido y muy limpio todo!

te escribe un excompanyero de atril tuyo en la presjovem de madrid...te acuerdas de mi??

jaja

[claudiacloclo1]

well done<!

its really good

[hersheysrulez]

very nice