I don't know his history beside he was in jail with Rafsanjani, Khamenei, and other that alone makes him worth hearing even if he were a communist which when young one can seem great but thats why Ideas and reality are two totally different things. BTW Socialism is not communism and believing in social and economic equality is something as a catholic I can say marxist got right. My hope is their can be evolution in Iran to a more open society and do the peoples will.
This is not history. It's negationism. A little background: Abbas Milani is a former leftist Commie who was jailed by the U.S.-backed Shah. The Hoover Institution is a right-wing think tank supported by the likes of foreign policy hawks Condoleezza Rice, Donald Rumsfeld and Ed Meese (of Iran-Contra fame). Consider the source.
For the truth, just Google this article:
Their Myths—and Ours: A Response to Abbas Milani's "The Great Satan Myth" by Arash Norouzi
@Mossadegh Do you imagine that just calling someone a communist is enough to prove a point? Not all of us are paranoid McCarthyites. We don't all go into a 2 minute hate session when someone brings up Condoleezza rice either.
@GaiusIuliusTaberna Tell me what was good for having a board member of Chevron working for the U.S gov with her own tanker named after her, oh that is right to make it okay for a false reason and illeagal invasion of Iraq for the purpose of supporting our pipeline project for Afghanistan. By the way McCarthy was correct in many of his charges
Sanctions are working, there is another thing that is working; the internet! Get in touch with as many Iranians as you can and communicate with them and spread this vid. Jimmy , the peanut, Carter is clearly the idiot of the century, his argument was " it is the will of the people " and " its their democratic right " !
@MultiUniv3rsal Oh I get it. I get it. It's not the United States' fault or the CIA's fault for the Iranian Revolution but JIMMY CARTER's fault. Once again right wing apologists attempt to pass the blame for blowback resulting from policies they supported onto a democratic president.
Milani is obviously intelligent but fails to dispel the "myth" of the "American Satan" - he freely admits the US's involvement at the behest of the British - yet places the blame at Carter's feet. Shameless.
great speech.
TheMorgenland 1 year ago
I don't know his history beside he was in jail with Rafsanjani, Khamenei, and other that alone makes him worth hearing even if he were a communist which when young one can seem great but thats why Ideas and reality are two totally different things. BTW Socialism is not communism and believing in social and economic equality is something as a catholic I can say marxist got right. My hope is their can be evolution in Iran to a more open society and do the peoples will.
NateRiley3000 1 year ago
@NateRiley3000 All communists are socialists, they even self-identify as socialists.
Re5Publica 1 year ago
great lecture. thank you
chicorastaman 1 year ago
This is not history. It's negationism. A little background: Abbas Milani is a former leftist Commie who was jailed by the U.S.-backed Shah. The Hoover Institution is a right-wing think tank supported by the likes of foreign policy hawks Condoleezza Rice, Donald Rumsfeld and Ed Meese (of Iran-Contra fame). Consider the source.
For the truth, just Google this article:
Their Myths—and Ours: A Response to Abbas Milani's "The Great Satan Myth" by Arash Norouzi
thank you
Mossadegh 1 year ago
@Mossadegh Do you imagine that just calling someone a communist is enough to prove a point? Not all of us are paranoid McCarthyites. We don't all go into a 2 minute hate session when someone brings up Condoleezza rice either.
GaiusIuliusTaberna 1 year ago
@GaiusIuliusTaberna Tell me what was good for having a board member of Chevron working for the U.S gov with her own tanker named after her, oh that is right to make it okay for a false reason and illeagal invasion of Iraq for the purpose of supporting our pipeline project for Afghanistan. By the way McCarthy was correct in many of his charges
mikeoli 1 year ago
Sanctions are working, there is another thing that is working; the internet! Get in touch with as many Iranians as you can and communicate with them and spread this vid. Jimmy , the peanut, Carter is clearly the idiot of the century, his argument was " it is the will of the people " and " its their democratic right " !
Tralgit 1 year ago
Abbas Milani was a Leninist-Marxist revolutionary in late 1970s.
Winston2004 1 year ago
This should be mandatory viewing for all US citizens. Very informative speech.
MultiUniv3rsal 1 year ago
@MultiUniv3rsal Oh I get it. I get it. It's not the United States' fault or the CIA's fault for the Iranian Revolution but JIMMY CARTER's fault. Once again right wing apologists attempt to pass the blame for blowback resulting from policies they supported onto a democratic president.
Milani is obviously intelligent but fails to dispel the "myth" of the "American Satan" - he freely admits the US's involvement at the behest of the British - yet places the blame at Carter's feet. Shameless.
mikepalomino 1 year ago