Nabeel Qureshi, Ahmadiyyat and Islam: Are Ahmadis Muslim?

[watchful38]

Nabeel was a true Muslim. Now he is a very good apologist for Christianity. A retired Catholic priest. Thanks, Nabeel!

[Shezi270]

dude your really gonna go wit the bible and leave the truth? U don't know that Jesus claimed he was god, and will never know. Maybe he never said he was and he was praised so much that ppl misinterpreted wat he said and took him as god. Also even history books can easily be changed and to wat ppl believe. Did jesus sign anywhere he was god? Use common sense, your saying a god came to convice ppl to believe in god? wtf, so y didnt he just destroyed anyone who didnt agree and prove it.

[imvoiceless]

quit twisting the truth guys, Ahmedis are simply not following islam, so stop confusing other people to make more members and money.

[livenlied]

guys, is this guy a singer or he just has the name of the singer nabeel qureshi (from khamosh dono)

[beel79]

Believing in the all the prophets of God is an article of faith in Islam. Sunni/Shia believe that Mohammed (pbuh) is the last. Ahmedis believe there are more that follow. Since both believe in this article, only one sect can be muslim. Even If this is "the only difference", this changes everything.

[southlondon88]

Excellent video brother Nabeel, nice to see Ahmadis spreading the truth about Islam and our beliefs. Ahmadiyyat Zindabad

[peaceloveforall1]

and how can u believe that jesus (pbuh) died for your sins. no one bears the burden of someone elses sin, thats injustice.

and ahmadiyya is the only true Islam, all these other groups are lost. just FYI.

[peaceloveforall1]

wow this is new and weird..and very random.

how can you convert to christianity after being an ahmadi?! Astagfirallah.

the trinity concept is messed up do u even know what you're folowing brother. There is only One Creator.. the worst thing u can do is associate anything with God. an all powerful God doesnt need a son doest make any sense. u might as well be hindu

[CiMBoMTurkiye93]

jesus isnt coming down to present new rules or laws, but is coming down to tell people they were led astray and to reaffirm the teachings of muhammed (saw), thats why he isnt the last prophet. ahmaddiyas also believe in some mirza guy who thinks he is the prophet reincarnated (estagfurallah). this is why ahmadiyyas arnt real muslims

[AhmadiyyaChannel]

To prove that nabeel qureshi was 'worshipping the devil' when he was part of the ahmadi cult, and not a muslim, you only need to see his conversion and he explains how he entered the bathroom, right foot first.

Muslims enter with left foot, and we believe the devil enters with the right foot.

oh dear, exposed yourself there.

ahmadiyya cult preaches a hatred of muslims which is why nabeel had so much in common with wood.

By the way you guys are a disgrace to the word 'christian'

[AhmadiyyaChannel]

so Mormons are christians?

you are pretty desperate nabeel.

[saldoczaidi]

shahzaadi03

Mirza needed no certificate to be a False Prophet. You have the right to remain ignorant & follow a False Prophet but you do not have the right to make it universal without evidence. Mirza is a prophet to you, he is a liar, cheat, vagabond, swindler, unkempt & disease ridden to Muslims. What you do not have the right is to claim that you are right and 1.57bn Muslims are INFIDEL. When you say that, I shall come after you to prove it. If you cannot then you are like your Mirza.

[saldoczaidi]

mirza as a prophet, zilli, bruzi & kashf are red herrings, excludes them from being Muslims.

KHAATEMUNNABIYYEEN, as Muslims accept is NON NEGOTIABLE. It appears that in Indonesia, the Amir Basit, has downgraded Mirza to Moa'llim. It is acceptable. However, whether they are practising TAQAYYA, a form of Deception, is only know to Allah.

You are wrong about who is a Muslim? It is Shahada, Beliefs & Aqaeds that are necessary to be a Muslim. Followers of Mirza do not qualify, failing of Aqaeds.

[saldoczaidi]

Mr Q, first is the Belief: aamantu billahe wa malaikatehee wa kutubehee wa rusulehee wal yomulaakhir. there is no 6th. Then Obligations: Shahada, organise salat & pay zakat, fast & pilgrimage. Please stop Evangelizing Islam like Pat Rotbertson or Billy Graham. Islam needs no Evangelizing. re the followers of mirza, they are nonMuslin not because of Politics but because of their acceptance of a False Nabi. No matter how much they appear to be like Muslims, but due to their aqeeda in accepting

[saldoczaidi]

as they are now protecting their protege. Your total population of less than 3 million shall be a Holocaust. I deplore persecution on the basis of religion. I feel very sad for that day. It is not if but when? I don't much care the rhetoric of Mr Qureshi. His argument is devoid of the most important Tenet of Islam: FINALITY OF PROPHETHOOD ON MUHAMMED (saws). Curse your false prophet MG & become a true Muslims, like your ancestors before the False Prophet. Otherwise, your future is bleak. Sad

[saldoczaidi]

So, stop badgering. Go away & get lost. I am really sick & tired of your lies on your MTA/Rahe Huda & alislam.org. You are nothing but a proper miscreant for Islam, portraying loyalty but changing the meaning of Terms and words. No matter how diversified we are, we have one thing in common, not your hatred, you nincompoop, FINALITY OF OUR PROPHET ON PROPHETHOOD.

Your belief in MG as a prophet puts you out of the pail of Islam. Just get lost. I fear the day when West shall not be as powerful as..

[saldoczaidi]

Mirzai are not Muslims, period. No discussion. You should from here to high heaven, but nothing shall change that. You have your Nabi, MG, you are Mirzai, not Muslims. Your own Kh declared you nonMuslim at the counting of Gurdaspur in 46. Prior to that your declared nonMuslimd in Mauritius & in Bahawlpur. In April '74 you were declared nonMuslims by Rabiatul Aalam in Mecca by more 150 Learned People of Islam. You were declared nonMuslims not because of politics but because of your religion.

[iwantyou9944]

ahmdya never be a muslim mohmed pbuh said he is the final prophet dont lie nabeel you are twisting the fact and mohmed pbuh never said he is an ahmdyia lol you are funny

[uriaz87]

You have largely summarised the Ahmadi beliefs correctly. However, to say that Ahmadis don't follow the Fiqh or that they just follow what the Promised Messiah (as) and the Khulafa is wrong. Fiqh is the Islamic way and Ahmadis absolutely follow the Fiqh. There are books written by Ahmadis on Fiqh and Ahmadi missionaries are taught Fiqh in Jamia etc. I thank you for being impartial, but please do correct these things!

[Londoner36]

creed members comon lets talk from the bible your own bibel would you mind ?

[Londoner36]

Nabeel Qureshi and Farhan (orthodox ) are the best exmpel for those pepole who dont have knowldge of Ahmadiyyat and Islam and start debating there own they end up in some times to not bellieving on GOD even so that is the main reason why jamaat prhobid to making debates with out getting knowldge please all Ahmadies bear in minde we can all arguments of Nabeel qureshis from there own bible if he have courge to talk about it then we talk face to face i wil show him the way out from his bible

[Creed26Ministries]

@Londoner36

Londoner, I'm glad you commented. I've been hoping to get an Ahmadi (any Ahmadi, preferably a Murabbi or amir jamaat) to actually be willing to publicly discuss and debate the history of the Qur'an. Before trying to talk from the Bible, I think it would be good for you to know about the Qur'an.

Unfortunately, no Ahmadi has been willing to debate this yet. Can you find someone who will publicly and intellectually stand up for the Qur'an? Thanks, my friend. - Nabeel

[ayounb]

@Creed26Ministries Nabeel that's contrary to what I have heard about you from your cousins. is it true that you sat down with Murrabies in US, and yet you still just kept on your misguided principles. I understand your mentalilty, that you want to be someone signifant in this life, and since that Apologetics murderer got to you, you feel on a high horse. Its ironic that you also wanted to go to Jamia as well.

[sunnyrules1]

@Creed26Ministries i might be able to help you with that, you can start on my channel. (im an Ahmadi)

Disclaimer: Im not a Murrabi or amir (because they are too busy to talk on the net if you can talk to someone in real life you can then talk to me)

[GollaGandaLova]

@Creed26Ministries don't ahmadis believe that their leader mirza ghulam ahmad was the fullfillment of Jesus Christ ?????

[Creed26Ministries]

@Londoner36

Londoner, I'm glad you commented. I've been hoping to get an Ahmadi (any Ahmadi, preferably a Murabbi or amir jamaat) to actually be willing to publicly discuss and debate the history of the Qur'an. Before trying to talk from the Bible, I think it would be good for you to know about the Qur'an.

Unfortunately, no Ahmadi has been willing to debate this yet. Can you find someone who will publicly and intellectually stand up for the Qur'an? Thanks, my friend. - Nabeel

[TronicMart]

@Londoner36 he said one of the pillars believe in angels and jin, wrong, one of the pillars is believe in His angels, there is no jin in there, but yes we believe in jin, but not in that concepts, please try to give correct information because it is big responsibility.

[koyasofFiji]

Excellent exposition.

[kashmoniez]

Asslamo Alaikum bro, I found your video extremely interesting and true, but my question to you is, why would you convert to Christianity and leave the peaceful religion of Islam and the sect of Ahmadiyyat?

[Creed26Ministries]

@kashmoniez Thanks for the question. The 2 main reasons why I left Islam: the case for Muhammad's prophethood is poor, and the case for the divine origin of the Quran is weak. I embraced Christianity for three main reasons: History defends Jesus death by crucifixion, and certainly not the Quran's account; the best explanation for the events surrounding Jesus death are that he rose from the dead; from the records, it seems Jesus claimed to be God. Please Google 'creed 2:6' and read my testimony.

[AhmadiyyaChannel]

@Creed26Ministries

no you left a punjabi cult, I know it gives you brownie points with your 'mentor who likes to parade you around, but you were never a muslims

ahmadiyya is not islam, its a cult.

[AhmadiyyaChannel]

@kashmoniez he left after ahmadiyya cult scrambled his brains and taught him to hate muslims, he therefore qualified to join david the 'anti christ';

[akramkhalid]

I have face to face meeting with him at Our Jalsa Salana 2011, I think He is still Muslim & Ahmadi & go on....

[Daz20s]

Ahmadis are as Muslim as Satanists are Christians. 

[TheChristianityWatch]

"God has revealed to me that anyone to whom my message has reached and he has not accepted me , he is not a muslim." (Letter of Mirza to Dr. Abdul Hakeem Khan Patialvi)

"It is our obligation that we do not consider non-ahmadis as muslims and do not pray behind them, because for us they have rejected one prophet (Mirza Ghulam) of God. This is a religious matter and no one has any right to do anything in it." (Anwar-e-Khilafat, by Mirza Mahmood, Khalifa 2, p.90)

[TheChristianityWatch]

Well Nabeel you didn't even mentioned Gulam Mirza, what he believed in and what he said. He's is the creator of the Ahmediyya movement. A guy who claimed that no one is going to heaven if they don't believe in him? "Except for the CHILDREN OF PROSTITUTE, whose hearts have been sealed by God, everyone else believes in me and has accepted me." (Aina-e-Kamalat-e-Islam, Roohani Khazain vol.5 p.547)

[Creed26Ministries]

By the way, for all those who wish to see a written treatment of this topic, please visit the website in the description of the video. Cheers.

[Creed26Ministries]

Farhan, good to hear from you. Your assertion that "Ahmadiyyat is essentially what Mormonism is for Christianity" has already been addressed on my blog. I have analyzed the position and find it lacking.

You say its underpinnings are antithetical to Islam's. I say that's entirely unsubstantiated and you can't leave that assertion bare if you wish to be persuasive. Please go to the blog and make your arguments there. I am waiting for good arguments on this issue, and you're the man to do it.

[RefutingActs17]

@Creed26Ministries

The manner is which you addressed it evaded the quintessential underpinnings of Ahmadiyyat that differentiates it from Islam. Whether you 'analyzed' or 'addressed' the problem at hand does not change the fact; that Islam does not recognize the Ahmadiyyat faith. You're the one whose made it quite explicit that Ahmadis are not recognized as true believers by the Paksitani government, nor are they by the Muslim World. Furthermore they have been banned from entering KSA.

[RefutingActs17]

@Creed26Ministries

My suggestion: stop being so disingenuous when history and intellectual scholarship proves you wrong.

[1MoreMuslim]

@Creed26Ministries I don't think you were a devout Ahmadi either. What books of MGA have you read?

[ndntakeover24]

@Creed26Ministries I don't think that was Farhan Qureshi hehh

[farhan00]

Ahmadiyya is essentially what Mormonism is for Christianity.

.

While Ahmadiyya outwardly adheres to all Islamic beliefs and practices, the internal meanings behind those beliefs are very very different from the normative tradition. Its very premises and philosophical underpinnings are antithetical to Islam's. This video downplays that reality.

.

To say he is a former Muslim is deeply misleading.

[Thuva44]

Muslims cant accept the fact that people do come to know the truth and covert out of Islam for various reasons. They will try to find ways to say o thats wrong o this is wrong but they are only fooling them selves. There are so many things Islam cant answer in the Quran and I have read and did a study on the Quran. Nabeel your doing an awesome job, and I pray that god will continue to bless you and your ministry.