Your timing is all over the place, practice with a metronome and take it slow at first. Please take this as constructive criticism, I can't play the piano at all, but I do play the guitar. I love the tune :)
Although I understand that this is a hard song to play (and I read your comment in video description section), you played it way to fast and inconsistent, speeding up and losing tempo randomly throughout the song. You should do it again since I'm sure you improved in the last 4 years. :)
I suppose you started playing it too fast... you should've practised it more slowly at the beginning and got faster then... I make that mistake sometimes, too, especially with songs I already know, but it's quite extreme here.
Too fast... too many mistakes... Why is everybody bitching? I think its a great version and if I will ever learn to play the piano I couldnt do this in a million years, Im sure =) Great job buddy! It made me go back almost 20 years and it makes me smile to hear and see you play this epic tune!
First off you have no idea what kind of training I have as a pianist and who said I was trying to make myself look better than you. Read what I said laugh about it and move on.
You sound like you take comments too seriously in life. That is not a good characteristic to have in life. Too much to drink before playing this piece?
this song is at this speed and it really is a pain in the ass, i tried it for 10 minutes and decided that i ain't ever gonna learn to play this well and discarded the sheet music :)
It is not an objective oppinion, because it is too aggressive. How does he know that you don't feel what you play? That's called jealousy bro. I really like the way it sounds, despite the speed. Check my videos if you like Pink Floyd
Needs more practice, preferably listening to the sound track and get a good feeling to it. But, it's a good attempt for only about 4 or 5 days worth of practice.
theres a lot of mistakes there, its a good effort! but bcus its a jumpy piece of music your inclined to speed up, you play it too fast and it ruins it! and if u slow down u will make less mistakes :)
you play muhc too fast ad change your speed always keep cool and play it slower than you will have not that many mistakes and keep one speed over the whole song
tooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo fast!!!!!!!!!!!! You are good, but this is just toooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo fast!!!! Slow it down buddy!!!
too fast man.....more practise! ;)
IsiLduR69LaCamera 2 weeks ago
Fucking hell....
DRINK LESS
evanrrhodes 3 weeks ago
Your timing is all over the place, practice with a metronome and take it slow at first. Please take this as constructive criticism, I can't play the piano at all, but I do play the guitar. I love the tune :)
Moh1Z 1 month ago
too fast :/
Youdomme 1 month ago
Jesus christ that was bad...
impablomations 1 month ago
:| what's this shit?
fabrizietto 2 months ago
bad, too fast. delete it.
TechmanFred 2 months ago
I´d be ashamed if had done this crap..
MusicalPhD 2 months ago
This sounds awful :S
Occultfan 3 months ago
omg!!!!! i love t when it's this fast!! <3
MrPianist101 4 months ago
if that is your microphone throw it away
boxpilot 6 months ago
At what point did you think to yourself 'hmm i should upload this on youtube'
hamzie11 6 months ago
have you a sheet ?? please tanks
ilretaggio2 6 months ago
Never mind! I saw your newer version before this one but didn't pay attention to the user name :P
You thought of the same thing as I did but years ago :D And you're really amazing!
MoaBe5 7 months ago
Better than I will ever be able to play but you should practice even more and do kind of like an "after"-video ;D
MoaBe5 7 months ago
Although I understand that this is a hard song to play (and I read your comment in video description section), you played it way to fast and inconsistent, speeding up and losing tempo randomly throughout the song. You should do it again since I'm sure you improved in the last 4 years. :)
Cheers!
RandomlyDrumming 8 months ago 5
To fast! And very much mistakes... but not so bad!!!!
Patcher98 9 months ago
LOL 0:54 xD
Deadlybrownboy 10 months ago
make a tutorial mate :)
cgsmitherine3 11 months ago
The cannibals would not want to eats you you RANDOM FUCKING MUSCLE SPASMS make your to tendons stringy.
nuff said.
lethargicshark44 11 months ago
You're going too fast, and that causes careless mistakes.
Burntshmallow 1 year ago
It's hard song to play on the piano
szymek19995 1 year ago
The speed doesn't weight up for the sound quality...
MY EARS!!!
DPJ93 1 year ago
sonic's my name speed's my game
ihazacheeseburger 1 year ago 3
the only reason i watched the whole thing is because i like seeing ppl fail!
intellegence63smart 1 year ago 2
Please check out my rendition of this song on my custom painted acoustic guitar!! woo it's on my profile!
WilsoniteX 1 year ago
Like the Monkey "Mojo" in the Scummbar, Part 2. =3
silentmonk3y88 1 year ago
Great... but seriously, you have to slow down, you wrecked the whole magical thing that is this theme by going this fast!
alvaro1121 1 year ago
too slow lol
ace2044 1 year ago 9
SLOW DOWN
WillReddish 1 year ago 4
faster is not better
exitido 1 year ago 2
your good but no soul plus do a tutorial for this i prefer to watch people play before i use sheet music
killthenerd5 1 year ago
I suppose you started playing it too fast... you should've practised it more slowly at the beginning and got faster then... I make that mistake sometimes, too, especially with songs I already know, but it's quite extreme here.
Feuerkerk 1 year ago
Yeah, this i a little bit to fast. But it doesnt make a sense or?
Great work!
Inquisito66 1 year ago
This is too fast.
TheLotharable 2 years ago
can you make another one but this time a bit slower... thx :D
MaTTTaX 2 years ago
your a good player but take it easy whit the speed okey you making many mistakes.
ThePaalanBoy 2 years ago 2
dude, feel the music. now u just playing the tabs without rythm.
Pellepluttskrutt 2 years ago
i think if u just slow it down u may b able to iron out those mistakes but still quite good ^^
tomolad93 2 years ago
well done master
Buddhabr0t 2 years ago
Too fast... too many mistakes... Why is everybody bitching? I think its a great version and if I will ever learn to play the piano I couldnt do this in a million years, Im sure =) Great job buddy! It made me go back almost 20 years and it makes me smile to hear and see you play this epic tune!
TechnoLunatic 2 years ago
umm, what's the rush? I think he has to go to the bathroom. "OMG I HAVE TO GO FASTER! IS THIS ALMOST OVER!??!?!? I HAVE TO GO!!!!"
SDTricker 2 years ago 44
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Such words told me, that ur not better than me and u try to make your self esteem better. . .
Sorry buddy, no chance!
MorteJachwe 2 years ago
Wow someone is kinda defensive.
First off you have no idea what kind of training I have as a pianist and who said I was trying to make myself look better than you. Read what I said laugh about it and move on.
You sound like you take comments too seriously in life. That is not a good characteristic to have in life. Too much to drink before playing this piece?
SDTricker 2 years ago
@MorteJachwe
Seriously, does it matter if he is better than you or not?
I mean i can tell if my dinner doesnt taste good without being a good cook.
And he is right. You are going way too fast.
Frogchen 1 year ago 4
@SDTricker INdeed not a good performance - but atleast you had fun
ArnoArtner 1 year ago
too fast and with too many mistakes :/
8899556644 2 years ago 2
Very very too fast.. :/
Deepth51 2 years ago 2
No, actually not. It's too fast. The original theme is slower.
NickyRamone77 2 years ago
timing would be nice
it doesnt make it a nice cover when you play it too fast
by the way you mke to many mistakes in this speed
FreeedCT 2 years ago
aggrr slow down you pirate!
darksaitoh 2 years ago 3
yikez! slowdown :EEee
Pellepluttskrutt 2 years ago
this song is at this speed and it really is a pain in the ass, i tried it for 10 minutes and decided that i ain't ever gonna learn to play this well and discarded the sheet music :)
durree22 2 years ago
Amazing!
aworldofpayne 2 years ago
Wow, i haven't thought of it before. that's a pretty damned tough thing to play isn't it?
the2500 2 years ago 3
Why do you play it so fast. If you would play it much slower you wouldn't have trouble hittin the keys. But still good work.
DrMabuuse 2 years ago
Keep up the good work!
lossuavesmx 2 years ago
The song it was actually at this speed
LuisJ11 2 years ago
too fast. maybe you should concentrate on hitting the right keys instead.
anakletor 2 years ago
faster is not better....
bananamilch 2 years ago 56
slower please! Oo
lnetol 2 years ago 2
too fast and too errors X(
20Lele12 2 years ago
lol i have trouble at that part too! keep practing and play it against the actual score to get the timing abit better.
Antphoneigh 2 years ago
this is awsome brother!
kajarambler 2 years ago
awesome
777digger777 2 years ago
You put the fingers in the right keys but that's not enough. You really need to feel the music. Too speedy and too soulless but not bad played.
pleurotusp2 2 years ago 3
you are so fucking jealous!!!!
kajarambler 2 years ago
Comment removed
pleurotusp2 2 years ago
agree..but nice
skoda10 2 years ago
It is not an objective oppinion, because it is too aggressive. How does he know that you don't feel what you play? That's called jealousy bro. I really like the way it sounds, despite the speed. Check my videos if you like Pink Floyd
kajarambler 2 years ago
Needs more practice, preferably listening to the sound track and get a good feeling to it. But, it's a good attempt for only about 4 or 5 days worth of practice.
cowzilla8 2 years ago
Who gives a cheese if there's mistakes! if I could play like that i'd be proud as hell!!!!!
Scoztrix 2 years ago 3
theres a lot of mistakes there, its a good effort! but bcus its a jumpy piece of music your inclined to speed up, you play it too fast and it ruins it! and if u slow down u will make less mistakes :)
carlhowes17 2 years ago
too much mistakes
andaula 2 years ago 4
Great job playing the notes.
But slow down, music isn't beautiful without its proper rythm. "Faster" doesn't mean "better". Only "faster".
AlWoolridge 2 years ago 6
lol, monkey island on speed
funk192 3 years ago 5
Teehee. What a show off. Slow down, playing the piano isn`t just playing the notes mkay?
Nice job anyway. I couldn`t learn that...
I`ll give you four stars. ^___^
Sazzac 3 years ago
Your right, there were some mistakes, but there didn't have to be! Slow Down!
spongemonkey27 3 years ago
you have to buy a metronome!
CelluloidMash 3 years ago 5
too fast but incredible!
xcaperucitarosax 3 years ago
Disagree w/ metronome comments. Tempo dynamics FTW. However it is a little sloppy in parts, but still very impressive. Keep it up!
hmp22 3 years ago
LOL INVEST IN A METRONOME. joka. still sick tho! goin for it!
mulletboy39 3 years ago
Could't you wait another 4 or 5 days to practice enough?
hungariankiller 3 years ago
pf. i think w3sp still does this better =P
BuffaloMic 3 years ago 2
WOW
LennieMelvin 3 years ago
You should invest in a metronome >_>
17oodles 3 years ago 6
lol, and put a banana on it to stun the monkeys.
0Murray0 3 years ago 3
Hahaha my thoughts exactly!!! :D
user2212345 3 years ago
haha, good one :) you'll need a metronome to put the banana on first ')
SmellyStingFace 3 years ago 19
WTF. SLOW DOWN.
Rudimentarypenis 3 years ago 3
you are so speeder
trop rapide fo ralentir ça en é moche dsl
djmadman 3 years ago
you play muhc too fast ad change your speed always keep cool and play it slower than you will have not that many mistakes and keep one speed over the whole song
meeeega 3 years ago
too bad the quality of audio sucks
jk2exp 3 years ago 2
too fast playing... try to slow a bit and have the same speed all over the piece.
fokkeddie 3 years ago
Yerp i can see the mistakes clearly...but i can also see some good parts = D good job!
mrtini12 3 years ago
I think its not simple to play this song but it's too fast and you aren't able to play that fast. Try to keep one speed and it'll be perfect.
bringeldoo 3 years ago
Not to bad but a littleoff
kyoujinuk 3 years ago
fa abbastanza schifo
Dharack 3 years ago
mah, c'è di meglio, ma dai è abbastanza bravo
salagadula84 3 years ago
Keep your rhythm tight.
Anon13370001 3 years ago
fubar
theblogmoc 3 years ago
Good!
FanatCH 3 years ago
Well, it wasn't so bad! Anyone else should see "More info".
hungariankiller 3 years ago
You broke the song.
powerfury 3 years ago
calm down guy you play so much too fast that ruins the song... would you play the original tempo and practise a lil more you would do great
meeeega 3 years ago
aghhh that ruined the song
mapach0 3 years ago 2
youre werry talented but and im sure you can play it well, but not today ... there is still a lot of work ... tempo, thats big problem
ge0rgecz 3 years ago
srry but why are u playing so fast its a bit bas u made a 2 minutes song into a 1 minutes wich meens uve played twice as fast as u should
xg42 3 years ago
... there was no cadence at the end - you cut the video too soon!
mduckworth 3 years ago
You would have less mistakes if you didn't play so damn fast.
starerik 3 years ago 3
I think this would sound better with a lower tempo.
jeheij 4 years ago 6
I absolutly agree...
OneLove260507 3 years ago 4
wow I been playing like 8 years and you pwn me hardcore O.O Great job :)
ghoti17 4 years ago
woah that's fast
randalfthewise 4 years ago
whos your timing? and you too Fast. use an metronom
SecondCure 4 years ago
don't put a banana on it though. or you will get distracted :o
rovemcanus 4 years ago 2
This man speaks the truth
christoffff 3 years ago
and someone could get you and would use u as an adjustable spanner ;P
moetube1337 3 years ago
omg :( memories....
hamzie11 3 years ago
zu schnell
Keeper5544 4 years ago
sweet!
hoefnerguitars 4 years ago
It's a shame the video goes out of sync, but this is still really impressive.
NinpoDeath 4 years ago
out of sync, too bad
AcidJoseph2k 4 years ago
im not gonna lie its pretty sweet.
edwfooball22 4 years ago
Yeah, you're really good, but it's way too fast, and you're making some mistakes due to your, eh, "fastness"?
Good job, though!
Totinoarg 4 years ago
Boah, naja, okay, ich kann es ja (noch) nicht besser... ;-)
Das dumme ist nur, dass ~30-50% der Noten von w3sp falsch sind, also ich rede vom Bass (linke Hand).
Nunja, er hat es eben nach dem Hören gemacht, und nicht nach dem Exportieren. ;-)
Runthar 4 years ago
Holy crap... Quite frankly, you pwn me on the piano xD
Entwisle780 4 years ago
maaan i want it faaster!! double the time!!!
perroazul64 4 years ago
no more drugs for you xD
xwcg 4 years ago
Ohhh SPASTIC IS ALWAYS NICE! Where you high when playing this? That looked fun. HAHA JK...
Duckzilla5 4 years ago
holy crap, dude don't take this pills anymore plz ^^
anyway, cool!
OrDog696 4 years ago
you play well since that song started, I mean played that 00:24 part pretty well, at right speed. rest of that is too fast
sunmax1 4 years ago
tooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo fast!!!!!!!!!!!! You are good, but this is just toooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo fast!!!! Slow it down buddy!!!
peddaz55 4 years ago
not so good
lord4kai 4 years ago
Way too fast ( 2nd part ), but nice technique.
Sorcerer88 4 years ago
with a little more practice this would be bloody amazing!!!! :D I loved it
C84141 4 years ago
Some chords arent right.
nexxogen 4 years ago
Great :D Love this theme :D
xoxoxoxowwwz 4 years ago
too fasty!!
ivi100 4 years ago
really LOVED this fast version!
Plopita 4 years ago
Oh man! Its toooooo fast! You NOOB
Magister528 4 years ago
excellent stuff, a bit too fast though! great never the less :)
manoobe 4 years ago
too slopy . . .
too many mistakes, slow down for fuck's sake
Dread098 4 years ago
Really cool... yeah a little bit fast :-/
MI 4 President!
DIELANEULE 4 years ago
holy cow this is tooooo fast
Noilsnomis 4 years ago
where did u get the notes(is notes th right word?) from
PeachJworks 5 years ago
wtf its to fast slow down
robertmacho 5 years ago
your hands are going to burn lol its very fast .But amazing ;) Try it a lottle bit slowly
pepepepe 5 years ago
too fast!!!
svenglenn 5 years ago
Pretty good! :D
That's w3sp's arrangement, isnt it?
ANd yeah, slow down a wee bit and you'll see =)
Nalghati 5 years ago
Gotta agree with LAMBA77. Your many mistakes could be a result of your speed. :S
lem0ns0ur 5 years ago
Good ! .. but ur too quick.. try slowling down.. it'll turn out great :)
LAMBA77 5 years ago