Wilbur Pan - Bu De Bu Ai

[BlacknWhiteScribbles]

duz rainie yang sing this?

[merinho754]

muito boa a musica!! caralho!! gostei!!!

[skittlezgirl4ever]

I listened to this song when I was little I got upsessed with it and now I'm older I finally found this song and now I know what the name is :) I still love it

[shuurei18]

just to be honest. i think chinese rules when it comes to music

[HotwitSoul]

like if came here from chris brown song i wanna be

[fergybox]

why cant people just listen to this song and enjoy it?

[ayame510]

Uhm... my grandparents said the original is actually korean

thanks

[XxLiarsSmilexX]

Uhhh, just to get this cleared up.. Who is the original artist who first sang this? ^_^

Sorry, too lazy to search it up... -_-"

[iBOOMBOX]

Lol his hair XD LMAO I love Wilber mann XD he's so goofyish :]

[MrZhid]

@danny9880 try to sing that if you think that its trash. You cant even get near to their level of singing.

[azgigas3]

@danny9880 Why don't you upload a cover of this song sang by yourself in Korean? Then we'll see who's trash.

[MrGoDoK]

hey this is korean song -- wtf the chinese are thinking. they've copied the song exactly. how rude is it

[ArabellaStrobel]

kiddo, it's a cover. singers do covers sometimes. hard to believe, i know.

and it's not rude since they gave credit to the original composers

[shuurei18]

@MrGoDoK what song? tell me.. this was uploaded in 2006

[crackerjack113]

@wayne2626

hey now, don't turn this into a RACIAL thing alright?

or wait wtf, ur chinese

[yun4934]

wtf korean song is original.

[corqjffo1992]

The female vocal is definitely better than the one in korean version.

The rap part at 2:10 sucks balls though :)

[itsmyworldupsidedown]

im sorry if u think discussing with me is so meaningless.

i just think you dont make much sense. im just a girl trying to state an opinion.

if u dont like it. im sorry.

[azndudedowndastreet]

whos the girl

[itsmyworldupsidedown]

it's not a copy its a cover -.-

and there IS no such thing as orginal.

everythings copies of of others.

-.- <-- you juz copied my face!

NO! there's no such thing as copies in music every song was inspired by others.

thankkyou.

[GoldenShot09]

retard.

learn english first.

[RollonDeo]

i like both the korean & taiwanese versions.

i love the beat of the song.

^^

anyway wilbur pan is cute cute cute!~

[shopper231]

why don't they put ft and the girl's name by his name cuz she is singing some of it

[siuyutlong]

the chinese is better because the english in the korean one is just not right

[aperkins07]

says u.. the korean one sounds much better to me but than again it's always going to be different for someone else

[itsmyworldupsidedown]

agreeed with you. :) its all opinions i dont like how ppl are all going like "this is the copy version" "omg it sucks" seriously shut up! its not a copy it's a freaken cover! and keep ur nasty opinions to urself! thankyou for actually stating it's a opinion and different for everyone.

[fireyballss]

Timeless and Why and by the same person, both the Korean and Chinese ones are by Jang Ri In (dunno chinese name), she is under SM entertainment, a Korean company, it is like BoA or Dong Bang Shin Ki making a Korean version of a song and remaking it in Japanese, that isn't copying. but i guess Korea has copied some songs but what country doesn't? I don't really care unless people ignorantly don't know when a song is a remake or they remake a song without copyrights, oh well, they usually get sued

[angelicone1]

I can't not love you.

[smintjoseph]

Vietnamese version is the worst. Yuck!

[SparklyPickles]

This is a nice song C:

Try to express your opinions without all the cursing...

[1xhunniez]

I ddont bring up other countrys dumbass!!...if you dont have anything good to say, just STFUU!...no one asks for any of your negative comments....and if your saying Vietnam...go say that to a VEITNAMESE PERSON, AND SEE WHAT THEY WILL DO TO YOUR FACE...RETARDD...TALKING SHIT WHEN YOU SHOULD KEEP YOU FUCKIN MOUTH SHUTT!

[doobshop]

Original Song

Singer - Freestyle(Korean)

Title - Y (Please Tell Me Why)

Album released at 2004-07-16

Copy Song

Singer - Wilber Pan(chinese)

Title - 不得不愛 Bu De Bu Ai (Have To Love)

Album released at 2005-07-08

[iduno101]

Please, it's not China, just that some Chinese people are bad, I'm pretty sure that Wilbur bought the copyright. Also, if you are going to fuck a country, try Vietnam, they copy TVXQ!, Wondergirls, Freestyle(for this song), Pussycat Dolls etc.

[alexw]

it's called sampling, you fob/dumbevilcomputer.

[Taiwan101]

Evilcomputer2008, Control yur anger dumbshit..

all i see is words and no action..

[deanb707]

fuk u mother fuk fuking fuk fuk fuk!

go fukin fuk urself u mothaa fuk fuking fuk fuk fuk!!

go fuk ur retarted fuking mother that fat whore go fkk urself mother fuk fuk fuker!

fuking teasing fuken fuk chinese peoples ima fuk ur mother fuk lol

ddnt make sense but juss had to put my anger from a kid i wanna bash sumwhere lol but there is no fake songs lol

[Taiwan101]

theres no fake songs dumbass

[bgd1029]

verry good its reallly cute (:

[AznSpartanz]

is there violin sheet music for this song anyone know?

[0710800073]

woman ur english is awful

[aznboix6]

hold up im lost so this isnt the korean version the wut version is it???

[orrickvang]

chinese... korean version is by freestyle and is called please tell me why

[ccarlu]

No - keep fighting

The Korean Version is 1000 times better

[kookievue]

I agreeeeeeeeeeeeee.

[d0ubled3e]

What difference does it make, music is music.

[kimchisawi]

cheap lousy faggot. be creative please LOL. create your own song. hahahahaaha~

[sfy62wkl]

you guys are pathetic arguing about music copying.

[CrossingBlueSky]

Though I do have to agree about people arguing with foul language... I still think it is not pathetic to talk about music copying ^^

But I have to say. Both this one and Korean one is great. But for some reason I just feel that the Korean one is a little more deep. Not sure why though.

ANYHOW!!! I love the rythm and the soothing feeling in both songs.

[zhongtiandao]

South Korea copying a lot of American music! How you say???

[zhongtiandao]

China also has a lot of their music!!! Korea also copying other people!!

[tyzen]

Another Korean Song! The mordern Taiwanese pop is a rip off of Kpop. If u copy kpop, Do respect koreans, other wise get an international ashame from Youtube. Search for &lt;Taiwan copy kpop&gt; in Youtube.

[SamPhan96]

Wilbur looks so much beta here dan i the drama Miss No Good! I like his hair :P

[missminzi]

i dont think everyone arguing whose song is really better or not its jst prejudice PLKEASE TELL ME WHY IS THE ORIGIONAL but.. THERE BOTH REALLY GOOD CHINESE AND KOREAN

[Wathyreckk]

you never heard of cover versions in another language?then you muz be total shit.you dunt even noe music?get out!

[Wathyreckk]

I pity you for not knowing that wilbur pan is a TAIWANESE.

means you suck.

[bytemefreak]

wow you fuckwit, Wilbur Pan is a TAIWANESE singer. I feel sorry for you, your view on the world is so disgustingly narrow. Never been out of your country have you? Pathetic

[DBSKxSUJU]

luv dis song!!....

[animecrazy102]

OMG That's exactly what I said before until these freaking Chinese racists attacked me =P

[animecrazy102]

I am tired of you people responding to my comment on the Bu De Bu Ai video you ignorant loser. ALL I SAID was I preffered the Chiense version better. I didn't say the korean version SUCKED. Why is it that whiny jerks like you guys always have to get on other people's backs when we are just stating our opinon? Yeah and the korean people are ahead of the chinese music industry, THANKS like I didn't know that already. Who gives a shit who's ahead? It's all based on opinon what music people prefer.

[stuffx999]

i like this version better too but generally i like korean music better

[animecrazy102]

Very coolio

[milkjug1]

Is that all you can say? Avoiding my point completely? Is there a problem with being a nerd? Today's society is governed by them. I bet your one fked up bogan - proven by your inability to respond properly and relying on random assumptions. Its probably extremely clear to everyone who reads your post, your just a retard who can't stand any criticism to Korea.

[milkjug1]

The ability to use the english language does not weaken the validity of an argument - pakamnon u are also a hypocrit so quit it

[milkjug1]

Do you have a problem with being educated?

[redfeveret]

i loveeeee diz sOng.. hm,

[animecrazy102]

Idk I like the chinese version better. It just SOUNDS better =P like the singers can actually hit the notes and stuff. IDC if it's a remake. I'm just making a comment on the song so don't get all pissy and moany about culture and shit. i'm not being a racist just a critique about the songs.

[pakmano7]

Yeah, too bad your critique makes no sense. The singers can hit the notes and stuff??? The singers in both songs hit the notes... They wouldn't sell a recorded version of a song with incorrect notes... So, no, that's not a valid statement at all.

[animecrazy102]

Wow, and it seems you constantly watch the comments on this page. You must have no life if you're going to waste your time reading comments and replying like some sort of "Smarter-Than-All" jackass. Get a life and give up being a hater. You fail ultimately, just advice loser. People all have different opinons so just accept it and move on.

[pakmano7]

Yeah, you fucks keep responding and I keep getting emails. That's the point--it's one thing if it's your opinion. Just SAY, "I like it better just because I like it better." Don't bullshit and pretend to spit out facts.

[animecrazy102]

You're in denial. It's actually sad to notice. Bless you ass hole.

I just made a comment about MY opinon about the song and you attacked me. What's wrong with fucks like you? Don't answer that.

[pakmano7]

It's different when you state an opinion just to state it; when you start fabricating reasons like "the singers hit the notes better" that make absolutely NO SENSE, then there's a problem. It's just hilarious to see people say shit like that, pretending that they're sooooooo smart. You do realize that in recorded versions of songs, all the notes are right, don't you? This isn't a performance... You can't judge the singers' real talents. God. People are so freaking dumb sometimes.

[animecrazy102]

Replying to me everytime I make a comment isn't going to change my mind about anything now is it? You worthless schmuck. Find something else better to do with your time b/c this is the last time i'm going to fucking respond to you. Get. A. Life. You must have no self confidence since you sound like you rely on self assurance that you're smarter than others to feel good about yourself. Anyways, In the grand scheme of life, IT DOESN'T MATTER WHAT I SAID ABOUT THE SONG SO SCREW YOU!

[pakmano7]

LOL. It's not supposed to change your mind, it's supposed to show others your stupidity. If it doesn't matter what you said about the song, then just STOP REPLYING. I don't have a life, yet you too are here replying to me after every comment. Hypocrite? Uh, yeah.

[animecrazy102]

1) You replied to me first

2)You're still a schmuck

3) I actually have a life and am going to college

4)Last time I reply to you, and even if you call me a hypocrite you still are.

5)And when I said "it doesn't matter what I said" I meant, just because someone thinks the korean singers SUCK ASS doesn't mean you have to be a pussy and get all deffensive.

6)Once again, last time I actually reply.

--And to make this comment now relevant to the video

CHINESE VERSION OF BU DE BU AI PWNS KOREAN

[milkjug1]

Yeh, big whoop I misread your comment, whatever.

[pakmano7]

No, not whatever. You go around calling people retards but fail to function yourself... Lesson? Make sure you're not at fault before you point out those of other people.

[milkjug1]

Ummm, I'm a retard because I mispell? I don't function properly because of this? That makes sense doesn't it? The fact is, your simply angry because your pro-korean, and couldn't find anything wrong with my argument except for the fact that I mispelt a word.

[pakmano7]

Yeah, honestly, you are. It's not that you can't spell, it's that you use words & don't know what they mean, or mix them up. I'm not angry b/c I'm pro-Korean; I actually prefer the Chinese version 'cause it's more fun to sing along to (the Korean one is mostly in English so it's not as fun). I wasn't picking on you for your view--just your inability to use the English language.

[iCHiRiNNOHANA]

I like this version A LOT better than the Korean one. I dont care if its a remake.

[milkjug1]

I find the korean one a bit repetitive

[pakmano7]

By the way, they say "bu de bu ai" like five million times... And the Korean one is repetitive? LOL.

[skypoo]

dude what is the point picking on fights all the time? People are just stating their opinions thats all

[maplegirl100]

yeah i noe but like i fucking shit hate the fat RACISTS

[milkjug1]

You wanna site that? Stop posting random stuff, retard.

[pakmano7]

Site what??? You mean CITE that??? Don't go around calling people retards if you're a big one yourself. Dumbass.

[milkjug1]

How am I being a retard...? The guy I replied to was obviously stating that Wilber got sued. I just want to know if that was true? How am I being a retard? Your the dumbass, make sure your comments make sense before you post.

[pakmano7]

LOL you clearly have no idea what I was accusing you of. You used the wrong word, fool. The word "site" is a noun and usually refers to a place. The word you're looking for is "CITE" which is a VERB. What exactly do you mean by "your the dumbass?" The dumbass is mine??? You mean, "YOU'RE the dumbass?" Your is possessive. Wow. Learn to read & write before you go shooting your mouth off.

[milkjug1]

Its clear now your losing the battle and relying on grammar to pretend to be good debater.

[pakmano7]

LOL You and I aren't debating anything so there's no battle to be lost. I commented on nothing but your "grammar." Hahahahaha such a retard.

[myriem6]

They asked permission to remake the song!

So they didn't steal it!

[mykemashi]

can i ask what bu de bu ai means?

[sandy1543]

gotta love

[sandy1543]

or have to love

[dudadeda1234]

Koreans and Chinese are very close culturally and historically. Unfortunately, Japan though, in the past centry or so, they've been seen as a step child beating and robbing on his own parent in far estern Asian continent.

[dudadeda1234]

Please get the fact straight. This song - Free Style 305 Y - Please Tell Me Why (不得不愛-韓文版) is originally written and performed by 프리스타일 (Freestyle) - Y (Please tell me why) Korean singer. Wilbur Pan - Bu De Bu Ai is a remake of Korean song. It does not really matter. Chinese and Koreans always swip swap for centries. Now Japan in last centry joined in to false claim everything from China and Korea as theirs. This mentality stemed from their past colonializm.

[dudadeda1234]

this is a chinese version of the korean song called Tell me why. by: Freestyle. lots of asian music is influence by Kpop korean pop. But i dont know the chinese version. the original is tell me why by freestyle though.

[krncoppertopez]

It probably wasnt copied! either they made a chinese verison OR they asked freestyle permission to do this. if they didnt i think freestyle would haved sued and it would have appeared in the news and shit.

[09887777]

베껴놓고 최소한 오히려 한국이 베꼈다곤 하지마라. 쓰레기들아.

[goodnicefoot]

fuck u ya racist bastard, have u no life to stoop down to insulting ppl just coz they're different to u?? grow up dick head

[laydeehkoostah123]

d00de the guy is finnnneee in here!! mhmm.

[furrycar]

O.O well i think the chick is hot!! lol

[cifeso]

the chick is... HOT O.O

[azndrifter183]

seriously, really? yeah she is

[Abusedjerk]

라딤둠 댜미드챠멥 쟈루

ㅋㅋ..

[unice105]

they took it legally man!!

jus shut up and listen alright?? ppl hu thinks that they had copy are really stupid to say so!!

iif it's illegal, they had already been sue into court alright??!

[silverthief]

베껴놓고 최소한 오히려 한국이 베꼈다곤 하지마라. 쓰레기들아. 우리가 얼마나 어이없겠니?

[silverthief]

copy copy copy copy copy copy.

Apologize to Freestyle. ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ I'm so angry

[MeowmixSymphony]

Wow...why do you care if it is a copy

You may not like it, but someone else might have a different taste.

And they took it legally, plus it's music ENJOY IT stop complaining about the background of where the song came from.

[jackpelton]

JawKneeYeah RULES the song, they should pay him royalties

[iloveeltoncho]

ya ya...watever...i believe wilber pan's music company or watever pays royalty to the owner of this song too...and has the approval from the korean owner anyway...so stop all these crap abt Chinese singers copy Korean songs...or watever....koreans themselves copy lots of japanese tv programmes, steal our chinese culture and also copy many other things and call it their own...look at their "korean sushi". Crap, ppl who visit korea knows they have little but borrowed culture from japan and china!

[JangYoonJung]

fine then, china japan and korea all copy from each other, why can't you just leave it at that instead of bashing on korea?

I don't really care if everyone copies from each other, but i heard that this song was copied ILLEGALLY and was sued by freestyle. = __ ="

I like freestyle's version better cuz I actually understand it lol. .__.

this one's pretty nice too.

[a901219]

and like always

the chinks copy the song without paying royalty

[AznYoun]

any copyrights?

chinks?

it's copyright infringement

this song is originally sang by freestyle

and u guys are freaking addicted to this song

pretty sad,

this song is hardly recorgnized song in south korea

[happysukmin]

fucking cheater

[abykim]

Even though I don't understand a word they're saying, I totally luv this song! The girl has such a beautiful, sensitive voice.

[GiftedVietz]

This is the best song i ever heard!

[som3AZN]

if u like this dude Listen to JAY CHOU

[Jtapangxx90]

Boa sounds really good

[nrzbstory]

Why, you're talking as if rap songs are forbidden to play in restaurants. You must eat at home everyday boy

And where in my comment did i say that charts are abuot the looks?I said charts don't dictate the quality of the the song because i'm sorry to tell u this but most Korean charts have ppl like Wondergirls and those pretty looking boys at the top.

Heck, talented singers like Brown Eyed Soul never come first in the chart or land anywhere near it, but their songs are the most beautiful ones.

[Sha767]

ok wilber pan asked freestyle if he can make a remake of his song "please tell me why" nd he said yes end of story

[nrzbstory]

idiot =_= charts dont explain anything.

IT does not explain the talent of the singer nor the quality of the song. Just because it's not #1 in the charts doesn't mean the song is unknown. Dude, some of the most beautiful songs and singers don't even land on the Top whatever because its flooded by Korean idol groups. Also, when the song was just released i was actually in Korea, and yenno what? i heard the song getting played in lots of restaurants and shops.. Try explaining that u dumbshit

[nrzbstory]

fucked in the head much?

Where does it say that the version was unknown?

[129815]

is this lyk a cover in chinese of the korean one?

[anon9009]

This song sounds similar to S.H.E - Give Me More

(给我多一点)

[eldr4g0n]

again again plz!!!!!!

[crazyazzn]

Who's the girl who sings it with him?!? PLEASE REPLY!

[AznmadmanX]

yo mama xD jus playing idk

[FQYD]

aha...

i just read the comment above and just laughed

[famousulzzang]

there was a lawsuit for the song

[watch4theDROP]

lolz that was just a rumor -_-

in fact, the artists from the chinese and korean one came together to do a concert lol

[watch4theDROP]

makes sense right?

"hey we just sued the shit outta you, lets go do a concert together!"

[Magiic96]

Awesome song, but JawKneeYeah has a better version XD. It's really funny

[milocapslock]

Hey,this song appears in AuditionSEA!

Love it.

[TheMermaidSamis]

He´s soooooo sexyyyY ;)

[mrkuppy]

this song was so huge.

[XxMaiLuvHimxX]

I luv this songz, i dont care who sings it or made up the lyrics i luv this song. xD

[ameliaKane]

This girl has an amazing voice that's the only reason i like this version better, does anybody know her name?

[tunnguyen22]

how do we find the amercan version of the lyrics ?

[Tanpopos]

Its called Karma K.- Forever You and I

[DreamsOFHim]

who it the girl i love her voice

[OwNKun]

iam korean, i think this version is better. i like her voice

[PinkCandiiLover]

i love this song

[redfeveret]

i watch diz vid again -.-

[redfeveret]

nice2..

[redfeveret]

pause at 2:08

[nahcey]

i don't get it

there's nothing special on 2:08

:S

[leonang]

Wilbur Pan explicitly does covers of other artists' songs get over it. I listened to the korean version and its very sloppily done with terrible singing. I have to give Freestyle credit for making such a nice tune/rhythm to the song.

[darkpro44]

ow...this version sounds ok. Personally, I prefer the original one by FreeStyle..well, at least the girl in the vid is hot.

[zxc4455]

what the fuck this is Korean song!

CHINESE copied again!!

what the fuck

[watch4theDROP]

ughh get over yourself you conceited piece of shit

we copied one song from you guys. WOW big deal

like nobody in this worlds ever made a remix to a song before -_-

you people make me sick argueing about this bullshit

[nahcey]

no need for the rude manners though.

[famousulzzang]

lets see um

jinusean - tell me

turtles - come on

sound familiar?

[catmincenz]

Pfft Chinese versions are always better

[nahcey]

hahahaha gd joke

[kagome4514]

omg who cares who thought of this song its just a song, artists are always copying other artists anyways so why does it even matter

[zxc4455]

your country's hobby is copying~~

china~~'

pooooooor

[biggie129]

for how much

[smin7132]

for $13 billion(130 billion yuan). a big suit.

[smin7132]

$13 million , sorry.

[sporeexpat]

So it was 20 billion, then 20 million, and now you're saying 13 billion and then back to 13 million again? haha.. u ever heard of defamation and libel? Since it is such a huge sum and typically an intellectual property case, the judgment should be accessible so perhaps u can paste a link that everyone can read on?

[smin7132]

Freestyle sued Pan last month at last

[smin7132]

Freestyle sued Pan Wilber last month (Oct.2007) at last.

Beijing court will handle this case. Let's see how it will go.

[smin7132]

Sorry. some errors in numbers.

It's 20 billion US dollars

or 200 billion Yuans.

[smin7132]

20 million dollars, sorry.