I enjoyed the "sex talk talk" but the grandma part didn't do it for me. It would have been funnier if the guy was just a random drunk person and not the kid's father at all. I sort of thought it was going that way with the, "first kid you see" line.
Well...the video obviously wasn't one of your better shots. That said, I really loved the original idea of giving the "sex talk talk". There is a lot of potential for advice like "Don't give the sex talk when your kid doesn't feel he's ready - or you are for that matter"... also, I like the performance of your new actor (can we see more of him in the future?).
Unfortunately, the "punchline" really doesn't connect to the plot and removes the attention from it. I want to see a do-over!
I'm not sure I agree with that. That's like saying an artist should put out a sucky painting just so they can say that they put out a painting. I would rather them take their time with the videos if it means that they quality of the product will be better.
Not that this was as terrible as people are saying, it just wasn't one of their best.
Ugh, I'm sorry. But I think this is my least favorite of them all so far.
But that's just my opinion, just because one person didn't like one video doesn't mean you should stop making videos. Hell, I loved most of the other ones.
Anyone who says that you should stop making videos because they didn't like one is an idiot and should be hung in my opinion.
They should have ran with the "talking about sex talks like you would talk about sex" thing a little more. As it is, they just made one joke out of it, then jumped straight to the dead grandma, which seemed completely out of place.
I thought the end was funny, but I agree that they should have run with the "sex/sex talk" comparison a lot longer, which would have made the ending more jarring, and therefore funnier.
I agree. These videos are the live action version of the comics. Not adapted from any of the comics, but it's like they took the script from one his comics and filmed it rather than him drawing it.
Bad chemistry with the actors. Wagner is good, really good. I could see him playing a similar dad role in some kind of horror/thriller flick. Not to say he isn't funny in a dark way, but it clashes with Nickel's more cartoonish acting style.
Tough talk for a dead jerk >.> Ho yeah i killed grandma.
Taked me alot of relistening because of the talk talk of the begining i was only getting talk talk for a dead jerk, so i tough it was not funny >.> but once i understood the tough talk part, its got back at good video:)
For the record, I really like the rest of the videos. That said...
The ending was pretty unnecessary. It would have been more amusing if he just dismissed his grandma comment and continued talking about having sex with kids.
Did my suggestion not sound that funny? That's because the other joke wasn't either.
Even though this is one of the shorter videos, it's definitely one of my favorites.
SpazzyMcGee1337 3 months ago
"Tough talk for a dead chick".
That is a Schwarzenegger-esk one liner, LoL.
SpazzyMcGee1337 3 months ago
I feel like this one was improvised (and pretty well, I might add).
Veggieman87 10 months ago
whut?
Kogerii 1 year ago
the line about "and not the prettiest" was genius
midnightbelladonna 1 year ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
kill grandma, touch hi on the penis.
kingblargle 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Guys, the penis joke was played out thirty seconds into the Cosmopolitain video. Give it a rest.
leeshajoi 2 years ago 13
@leeshajoi whine about a joke then touch everyones penis!
TehHoboBear 2 years ago 4
@leeshajoi Give it a rest, then touch him on the penis?
HauntKettle 1 year ago 4
@leeshajoi request no more "touch him on the penis", then touch him on the penis.
aika092 1 year ago 18
Kill Grandma, touch him on the penis.
Ssalamanderr 2 years ago
Mens Lay-ya! Go!
hflevack 2 years ago
would you stop this please
skarlath2 2 years ago
Great drunken acting haha! Loved the crazy killer face at the end. And the grandma thing, "great non-sequiter" as the other guy said!
KptNapalmi 2 years ago
I actually think this is one of the funnier ones.
slimbot 2 years ago
Yeah, it's in the true SMBC style, unlike most of the videos.
Baalsaack 2 years ago
I enjoyed the "sex talk talk" but the grandma part didn't do it for me. It would have been funnier if the guy was just a random drunk person and not the kid's father at all. I sort of thought it was going that way with the, "first kid you see" line.
lordyamamoto 2 years ago 31
@lordyamamoto
no silly that was an analogy for fucking the first girl you see when you are drunk
dthclock 5 months ago
I loved it, such a great non-sequiter :D
praguepride 2 years ago
JP kicks ass, from superman to a silly little boy with a beanie to killing a modern version of 'whose on first'
seriously dude, you rock!
Illnevertellyoueverz 2 years ago 4
Started out good, but the whole grandma thing sort of killed it. Maybe you should have stuck with the sex talk talk thing.
Still good though, loved the dad's acting.
dmh3000 2 years ago
I agree
felixjerms 2 years ago
Well it fizzled a bit at the end, but the dad's acting made up for all of it; it's first-rate.
chilledsanity 2 years ago 2
Ha. That's good times. I think this would be twicely hilarious if a little kid played the little kid.
beefcube333 2 years ago 4
Christ, people are being to analytical. I thought it was funny. Good show.
chickensalad 2 years ago 4
I thought the delivery of the "tough talk for a dead chick" line was fantastic, but other than that I'd say it was average-ish?
DeliriumPig 2 years ago 5
If you stop watching the video at that point, it is solid gold.
fgsfdsmonkey 2 years ago
Well...the video obviously wasn't one of your better shots. That said, I really loved the original idea of giving the "sex talk talk". There is a lot of potential for advice like "Don't give the sex talk when your kid doesn't feel he's ready - or you are for that matter"... also, I like the performance of your new actor (can we see more of him in the future?).
Unfortunately, the "punchline" really doesn't connect to the plot and removes the attention from it. I want to see a do-over!
Silkenfist 2 years ago 4
Posting regularly is more important that always having high quality.
It's more important to give people something to complain about that not give people anything at all. Thanks guys.
btw: this last sketch was lousy. better luck next time.
kamuizot 2 years ago
I thought it was okay. Not uproariously funny, but the Sex Talk Talk is a nice concept.
nitzwalsh86 2 years ago
I'm not sure I agree with that. That's like saying an artist should put out a sucky painting just so they can say that they put out a painting. I would rather them take their time with the videos if it means that they quality of the product will be better.
Not that this was as terrible as people are saying, it just wasn't one of their best.
JulE0n 2 years ago
I thought these were supposed to have punchlines?
labmonkey912 2 years ago
This one's a little off. You guys will have more amazing videos next week.
BUT THE RELATED VIDEOS HO HO
*browses*
technicallyabsurd 2 years ago
could've done a lot more with this, good starting premise but execution...eh...
ATribeCalledEly 2 years ago
..huh
I had to watch the video like a dozen times just to hear what they're saying, what's with the speaking quality?
jthmguitarist 2 years ago
Ugh, I'm sorry. But I think this is my least favorite of them all so far.
But that's just my opinion, just because one person didn't like one video doesn't mean you should stop making videos. Hell, I loved most of the other ones.
Anyone who says that you should stop making videos because they didn't like one is an idiot and should be hung in my opinion.
soulhunter4444 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
SMBC stop making these videos! The only plus is they are consistently terrible. Stick to the comics.
Elemarth25 2 years ago
Sorry if the kind of humor you like is the sloppy type like X-Play dishes out. Ratings speak for themselves. Eat it.
Vlaew 2 years ago
quit complaining they do the comics on their regular schedule as well as the vids
LupinDa3rd 2 years ago
This one is a miss, boys.
galazero 2 years ago 2
Dont worry guys, they gave you like 20somthing good videos, not all of them will be the best, even though this one still is pretty good! :)
waypastthat 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
★★★★★
Hey everyone
Theres this kid at my school and hes trying to get more popular on YouTube.
He has got some really funny videos up and id really appreciate it if you could check him out, you wont regret it =)
He just uploaded a video called Random Thoughts and its sooooo funny hahahaha xD
His account is calmo69
Please also subscribe to him, hes currently the 40th most subscribed Australian comedian and he would really like to get into the top 30
thanks =)
scuberstrings 2 years ago
Yeah, the sex-talk talk part was really funny, but it didn't go on nearly long enough for the ending to work.
Like, at all.
Monologue 2 years ago
Everyone says this isnt very good compared to the others. I guess i just dont understand your usual humor becuse i think this is by far the best.
jackminardi 2 years ago
They should have ran with the "talking about sex talks like you would talk about sex" thing a little more. As it is, they just made one joke out of it, then jumped straight to the dead grandma, which seemed completely out of place.
Ditocoaf 2 years ago
@Ditocoaf:
I thought the end was funny, but I agree that they should have run with the "sex/sex talk" comparison a lot longer, which would have made the ending more jarring, and therefore funnier.
vaderwalks 2 years ago
Obviously you haven't read the comic that much. That sort of random jump is what SMBC is made of.
RatDude1996 2 years ago
I agree. These videos are the live action version of the comics. Not adapted from any of the comics, but it's like they took the script from one his comics and filmed it rather than him drawing it.
Sylar03 2 years ago
Eh.
Totema1 2 years ago
Bad chemistry with the actors. Wagner is good, really good. I could see him playing a similar dad role in some kind of horror/thriller flick. Not to say he isn't funny in a dark way, but it clashes with Nickel's more cartoonish acting style.
KingTaco7 2 years ago
that was good
dicekar 2 years ago
2/5 from me...
spearman792 2 years ago
eh...
L33tPwner1337 2 years ago
Sorry. I have to concur. Not very good, especially compared to your others.
goldgrae 2 years ago
that was hilarious!
KingDavid73 2 years ago
Punchline goes where?
iWinxtehxinternets 2 years ago
very disappointing
DrSpacemann 2 years ago
wait, waht?
BLA5HPHEMY 2 years ago
what happened? you guys were on a roll and then this dud came along. I hope the second short this week can re-start your momentum.
duncman21 2 years ago
ended a la two towers. pretty decent i guess
NasaCortis 2 years ago
I thought you were going somewhere with that... but damn. Good setup, why didn't you run with it?
RippDrive 2 years ago 2
lol
christiankarlsson 2 years ago
Not that goos guys.
tehredmage 2 years ago 2
Eh, not the best, but I got a smile out of it.
NavarrB 2 years ago 2
Swing and a miss lads
Adrosser 2 years ago
This is pretty gay.
Sconz32 2 years ago
weak
CHoboapple 2 years ago
Tough talk for a dead jerk >.> Ho yeah i killed grandma.
Taked me alot of relistening because of the talk talk of the begining i was only getting talk talk for a dead jerk, so i tough it was not funny >.> but once i understood the tough talk part, its got back at good video:)
Pandor25 2 years ago
i thought the joe was going to be a sex talk talk, where the dad talks to the kid about talking to the kid about sex,
disturbingly subverted
ThatMonsterMan 2 years ago
swing and a miss
pellaken 2 years ago 2
Agreed, I was thinking the same thing as ThatMonsterMan. The first SMBCT sketch that hasn't made me laugh out loud.
4rcit4 2 years ago 4
Not the best, but still funny. Love the sketches.
Graehaus 2 years ago
I'm guessing the pedophile joke went over everyone's heads. 0:20
mudbuck 2 years ago
Well you were pretty sharp to catch it, being all obscure and everything.
Sconz32 2 years ago
I thought this was hilarious, the "sex talk talk". It's a talk about the sex talk! And that sound effect at the end was awesome.
aznfyrepixie 2 years ago
I don't know what ya'll be talking about! I laughed! I do agree I was somewhat hoping they'd get to the sex talk!
bbfreak2006 2 years ago
Not bad, but seems a bit too short for my liking.
RQ6 2 years ago
That's what she said.
lmm85 2 years ago 3
it's an SMBC short. a SHORT meaning SHORT sketch.
DelMonteOnSteroids 2 years ago 2
I know, but I was commenting so that someone would do what lmm85 did.
RQ6 2 years ago
Strike one
zerosozha 2 years ago
HAHAHAHAHA.
Seconded.
AliceHatt 2 years ago
For the record, I really like the rest of the videos. That said...
The ending was pretty unnecessary. It would have been more amusing if he just dismissed his grandma comment and continued talking about having sex with kids.
Did my suggestion not sound that funny? That's because the other joke wasn't either.
HouseFantastic 2 years ago
reminds me of the WKUK drunk dad sketch
Monkeyboy92037 2 years ago
woo 7th poster
tihs wasnt that good.
it was terrible.
lolomatick 2 years ago
I think the "I killed grandma" part was unnecessary, as the rest of the joke was presented quite well.
It's like a Buckley Box, but with video.
ritcheyz 2 years ago
Damn, and I thought it was weird when I got the sex talk!
amortussique 2 years ago
Not terrible, but still the worst one yet. 2/5
NukeMTV 2 years ago
meh.
showoffjp 2 years ago
First mom, now grandma. Sheesh dad.
theboredone 2 years ago 3
loved it, good job
SPAZ111 2 years ago 3
tough talk for a dead chick
jhansell 2 years ago 2
This one isn't so good.
RubilacEx 2 years ago
bahahahahahaha
gabrielpoissant 2 years ago 3
you might give it to the first kid you see
elijahtheworm 2 years ago 2
and not the prettiest!
YouGuysArnt 2 years ago