She did pretty well, but she's obviously too young to play Chaconne. This is Bach's most difficult piece to understand. 'the man writes a whole world of the deepest thoughts and most powerful feelings'. How can a ten-year-old girl understand the whole world??? I would say you can never play with deep feeling unless you are over 40.
I love this precious little lady. She's amazing, adorable, incredibly talented, and like magic on the piano. Doe's anyone know her full name or where she's from? I hope she records, as I would buy anything she puts on CD. Also hope she continues her musical career. To play this well at any age is amazing, but to be this good at 10 is almost unbelievable. What a brilliant, gifted little doll.......My prayer is for her blessing, happiness and success in her music and life.
Ok, well, it's a start. But, with all the omissions in it, the piece has almost been cut in half, timewise speaking. Some nice parts in it too, though.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
evil asian parents, stop taking your children youth and fun away by making they learn stuff since they are 3 years old, so you can brag yourself about it...sorry im against children slavery. thats like a hmmm competition against asian parents ? because all the "8~9~10 year old" playing stuff incredibly hard like that are asians.
Bravo Szuyu Su, a beautiful interpretation; if violinists listened to piano you would have a triple view count here, a famous Bach. Oddly, listening to you I start hearing, simultaneously in my head, a left hand of Brahm's G Minor Rhapsody, Op. 79, no. 2. Mystery!
Dude, "maybe she will record later"? If you've watched the other dozen or so videos you've posted of your girl, you'll realize that she's a genius and quite talented for her age. So she makes a few mistakes on one piece - which I can't hear anyway. Big deal. She's about nine or ten, right? Geeze, when I was nine I played "March of the Troll Dolls" for my talent recidal. lol.
Unless the "maybe record later" was meant for us. Then I totally take my entire post back and apologize if offense taken.
I am used to listening to the violin play this (or the guitar). It was certainly a different experience hearing it played on the piano. It sounded great....like it was meant for the piano. Yes, A few errors...never mind.
Amazing talent. Someday she will own the piece, the piano and the world. Don't ever give up, Rachel.
jast11 4 months ago
She did pretty well, but she's obviously too young to play Chaconne. This is Bach's most difficult piece to understand. 'the man writes a whole world of the deepest thoughts and most powerful feelings'. How can a ten-year-old girl understand the whole world??? I would say you can never play with deep feeling unless you are over 40.
frankyoung13 1 year ago
@frankyoung13 LOL. She's only 10. She's doing her best to TRY and understand. You jealous? Give her a break omg.
TheJackHarkness 1 year ago
I love this precious little lady. She's amazing, adorable, incredibly talented, and like magic on the piano. Doe's anyone know her full name or where she's from? I hope she records, as I would buy anything she puts on CD. Also hope she continues her musical career. To play this well at any age is amazing, but to be this good at 10 is almost unbelievable. What a brilliant, gifted little doll.......My prayer is for her blessing, happiness and success in her music and life.
Lpmgato1 1 year ago
i knew when i saw both hands it ws not the Busoni or Brahms versions.She is very musical .Voicing etc will come .
lovesGenet 1 year ago
Very impressive ! Much talent. All my encouragements to pursue if you like music. Many thanks.
ANNAHMELIA 2 years ago
wt version is it?
self-transcripted?
Tiszt 2 years ago
@Tiszt u have in description, by Hideo Kobayashi
punkviolin1 2 months ago
or viola!
bystroffc 2 years ago
c'est super cette transcription !
papillondenuit1970 2 years ago
Ok, well, it's a start. But, with all the omissions in it, the piece has almost been cut in half, timewise speaking. Some nice parts in it too, though.
jsnauwaert 2 years ago
No puedo creer lo que mis oidos están escuchando... y viendo!
StillViolin 3 years ago
coincido contigo, no puedo creer que esta chacona me tranmita tanto, creo que es lo mejor jamas escrito para violin...
zicekanelo 2 years ago
you play very well! Bravo
astronomo16 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
evil asian parents, stop taking your children youth and fun away by making they learn stuff since they are 3 years old, so you can brag yourself about it...sorry im against children slavery. thats like a hmmm competition against asian parents ? because all the "8~9~10 year old" playing stuff incredibly hard like that are asians.
crapzors 3 years ago
so powerful, but still meant for violin in my opinion!
backhand4 3 years ago
yes ... it is too loud
JCS200412 2 years ago
Bravo Szuyu Su, a beautiful interpretation; if violinists listened to piano you would have a triple view count here, a famous Bach. Oddly, listening to you I start hearing, simultaneously in my head, a left hand of Brahm's G Minor Rhapsody, Op. 79, no. 2. Mystery!
BarNuun 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
why use pedal??
airmiumiu 3 years ago
I almost forgot to congratulate you for this breath taking interpretation! 恭喜！祝你成功！
coverfactory 3 years ago
I thought this piece had been translated by Ferruccio BUSONI. Did Hideo Kobayashi translate it as well ?
coverfactory 3 years ago
This composition has been transcribed by many. There are more 30 piano transcriptions for Chaconne. Also it has been orchestrated by many!
Tsobanian 2 years ago
You are incredible!
argerich68 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She's too young to play this piece. Children shouldn't play Bach, too deep for them. Just wait.
filsuf 3 years ago
你有一双非常修长且结构合理的手,和非常卓越的音乐天赋,不过我可以想象你付出的努力...你会成为声明显赫的未来之星
foxcat612 3 years ago 5
god that was beautiful
and so different than what i had heard before.
sometimes the absolute perfection of the timing takes me into an alient world..but it is always an amazing journey.
im vey greatful
thank you
C21Troy 3 years ago
日本人？中国人？韩国人？
pusudeganwu 3 years ago
台灣人
sallychuang 3 years ago 2
Absolutely amazing!!!!!
Thank You!!!
bionic88 4 years ago
damn shes talented and TURNING 10 THIS MONTH!!! i can play this on the violin but only on a rewritten simplified version! amazing
marylovesbubbles 4 years ago
不错！弹得非常漂亮！
你是多大岁数？
skyblue999 4 years ago
She will trun 10 this March
yw1935 4 years ago
Dude, "maybe she will record later"? If you've watched the other dozen or so videos you've posted of your girl, you'll realize that she's a genius and quite talented for her age. So she makes a few mistakes on one piece - which I can't hear anyway. Big deal. She's about nine or ten, right? Geeze, when I was nine I played "March of the Troll Dolls" for my talent recidal. lol.
Unless the "maybe record later" was meant for us. Then I totally take my entire post back and apologize if offense taken.
ForumCoEditor 4 years ago
I know Aimi very well and I never heard she wrote that transcription.Maybe it's another Mr.
Kobayashi ( very common name in Japan ) Now, of course, I can be wrong
klingsor93 4 years ago
The mystery has now been solved! Rachel has now noted in the description that the Bach transcriber is Hideo Kobayashi!
piano6861 4 years ago
5 stars for you. And i can only say the same as Hamiltonrww.
antraciet 4 years ago
I am used to listening to the violin play this (or the guitar). It was certainly a different experience hearing it played on the piano. It sounded great....like it was meant for the piano. Yes, A few errors...never mind.
brian777999 4 years ago
favourited!! nice transcription!! and wonderful playing
Liranm89 4 years ago 2
Bravo!
that's the word that came to my mind!
clizarb 4 years ago 2
Wonderful !!
chuckchicki 4 years ago 2
Bravo~~~~!!!!!!!!
Your playing is extremely adorable indeed!!
hanjiangs 4 years ago