I for one don't like some of Ostad Lotfi's comments about the experiments some of our younger musicians are doing and the way he condemns any tampering with the fabric of Iranian music. But every musician is entitled to his own opinion. AS for his music I like some of his work and dislike some other however that does not make him any less of a musician and I am sure a legend tomorrow. I always remember him as the person who help introduce Ostad Alizade to the World.
hameedreza111 jan age khafe shi ba in nazarate ahmaghanat kheyli mamnoon mishim ke az tarze sohbat kardanet maloome ke to hanooz to sohbate adit moshkel dari aziz.bazi vaghta khafe boodan kheyli mofide!!
You keep mixing politics in your argument to get somewhere also felling sorry for other people there not "musician like you".!!!
Stop using words like Sharlatan, todehei,pa manghahi, low class and etc... this is kind of conversation is not belong to musicians. As I told you I am not denying they were a lot of people before Lotfi they made their mark in our music and they would be more to come and Lotfi has his own foot print.
manzoretan ra vazehtar befarmaid,shoma be hamin rahati be digaran nesbate sharlatan va kalamte napasand midahid, okey agar ham be nazaretan paybandid injori mikhahid be bashariat chi yad bedid, tashakor
I am sorry that you are not a musician and I don't know how to tell you that according to any critria mr.Lotfi is a very low class player. Let me tell you that his son Omid has a far better technic than his father!all he has played in the past are available and they speak for themselves. he has million years of light distance with Ostad Shahnaz.
I REMIND YOU TO THE FAMOUS STATEMENT OSTAD SHAHNAZ MADE ON LOTFI'S STYLE OF PLAYING HE SAID : LOTFI TAR NEMIZANAD BALKE TAR RA MIZANAD! YANI TANBIH MIKONAD. MAN KHODAM DOCTOR MUSICOLOGY HASTAM AND KNOW I AM TALKING ABOUT ! i CAN ASSURE YOU THAT ALL THOSE WHO PRAISE MR.LOTFI ARE NOY MUSICIAN AT ALL!
hamsab, what are you talking about even Shahnaz doesn't make comment like you about Ostad Lotfi. ask couple more people or at least read or lsiten before making such a coment.
استاد شهناز مایه افتخار موسیقی ایران است و با تارشان کارهایی کرده اند که یکی از دیگری برتر است. اما شارلاتانهایی مثل لطفی که در زمان شاه با کمک اتبهاج به رادیو آمد و بعد هم توده ای دوآتشه ای شد و الان هم برای خامنه ای و پای منقل ایشان مینوازد!مایه ننگ موسیقی هستند
There is no question Ostad Shahnaz is one our greatest but the question is Lotfi with Aref assembly help Iranian to start loving traditional music or not? Manghal and other words which you are using not even help your case it shows what kind of logic you have.
I am sorry that you are not a musician and I don't know how to tell you that according to any critria mr.Lotfi is a very low class player. Let me tell you that his son Omid has a far better technic than his father!all he has played in the past are available and they speak for themselves. he has million years of light distance with Ostad Shahnaz.
shoma agar alayegh mana dide bashid ,shahnaz va asatide bozorge, ama ta key diktatori va nakhahim nazarate hame ra gosh bedim va beshnavim, man motasefam baraye yek doktore madraki music ke injori sohbat mikone, vali be har hal tashakor az goftane nazareton , mersi
please remember that before Lotfi was born many other great musicians had done their best to preserve and progress our music.starting from Vaziri, saba, Mahjoobi, Mousa and javad Maroofi, Khaleghi, Khaledi, Tajvidi, Paivar,Yahaghi, Badei Habib and Rahmatollah and ... worked so hard all these years without the huge supports that Hooshang Ebtehaj, Reza Ghotbi , Reza Pahlbod,gave to Lotfi! Please if you are not a musician do not judge our professional views point.
che tare ghashangi bah bah. merci
cirous74 1 year ago
jaye khoshhalye ke hanuz zakhmehaye be sabke ghadim bevasileye in seri az honarmandan navakhte mishe va in sabko negah midaran
emruze gushe adamo, ba tarhaye sabke jadido ,,soraat nevazi bordan
khosro7 1 year ago
من میتونم به سختی بفهمم که چرا شماها با هم دعوا میکنید اما اصلا نمیفهمم چرا انقدر جدی به انگلیسی؟؟
modir23 1 year ago
this is beautiful...nd i dnt knw anything about them lol. I just love the sound.....=)
tyrteasof010 2 years ago
I for one don't like some of Ostad Lotfi's comments about the experiments some of our younger musicians are doing and the way he condemns any tampering with the fabric of Iranian music. But every musician is entitled to his own opinion. AS for his music I like some of his work and dislike some other however that does not make him any less of a musician and I am sure a legend tomorrow. I always remember him as the person who help introduce Ostad Alizade to the World.
And thanks for this Video
farazzein 3 years ago
I believe it was Ostad Houshan Zarif whw was Ostad Alizadeh's teacher and discovered him as a new talent on Tar.
I just wanted to make it clear that Ostad Alizadeh was not Ostad Lotfi's student.
enayatm 2 years ago
hameedreza111 jan age khafe shi ba in nazarate ahmaghanat kheyli mamnoon mishim ke az tarze sohbat kardanet maloome ke to hanooz to sohbate adit moshkel dari aziz.bazi vaghta khafe boodan kheyli mofide!!
ayyydin 3 years ago
Faramarz jan, who is the Tar player in this video?
enayatm 4 years ago
Very nice work.
enayatm 4 years ago 2
بسیار زیبا
HFarmanesh 4 years ago 2
Majid! Jaan, Ghorbane Dastet beram . . . I am bijan from Esfahan, Dorane Honarestan . . . Violon Meezadam. Salaam ! Haji. Albete Alan America Hastam
bijantheuploader 4 years ago
You keep mixing politics in your argument to get somewhere also felling sorry for other people there not "musician like you".!!!
Stop using words like Sharlatan, todehei,pa manghahi, low class and etc... this is kind of conversation is not belong to musicians. As I told you I am not denying they were a lot of people before Lotfi they made their mark in our music and they would be more to come and Lotfi has his own foot print.
nassir1 4 years ago
I agree with you 100%. At last some voice of reasoning.
No one asks Bethoven, Davinci or Michael Angelo's political stance.
When looking at art we should measure the artistic value of the work not the political or even their personal values.
I believe after so many thousand years of culture we should have the maturity to differentiate that.
enayatm 4 years ago
manzoretan ra vazehtar befarmaid,shoma be hamin rahati be digaran nesbate sharlatan va kalamte napasand midahid, okey agar ham be nazaretan paybandid injori mikhahid be bashariat chi yad bedid, tashakor
faramarzkalantari 4 years ago
I am sorry that you are not a musician and I don't know how to tell you that according to any critria mr.Lotfi is a very low class player. Let me tell you that his son Omid has a far better technic than his father!all he has played in the past are available and they speak for themselves. he has million years of light distance with Ostad Shahnaz.
hameedreza111 4 years ago
I REMIND YOU TO THE FAMOUS STATEMENT OSTAD SHAHNAZ MADE ON LOTFI'S STYLE OF PLAYING HE SAID : LOTFI TAR NEMIZANAD BALKE TAR RA MIZANAD! YANI TANBIH MIKONAD. MAN KHODAM DOCTOR MUSICOLOGY HASTAM AND KNOW I AM TALKING ABOUT ! i CAN ASSURE YOU THAT ALL THOSE WHO PRAISE MR.LOTFI ARE NOY MUSICIAN AT ALL!
hameedreza111 4 years ago
hamsab, what are you talking about even Shahnaz doesn't make comment like you about Ostad Lotfi. ask couple more people or at least read or lsiten before making such a coment.
nassir1 4 years ago
استاد شهناز مایه افتخار موسیقی ایران است و با تارشان کارهایی کرده اند که یکی از دیگری برتر است. اما شارلاتانهایی مثل لطفی که در زمان شاه با کمک اتبهاج به رادیو آمد و بعد هم توده ای دوآتشه ای شد و الان هم برای خامنه ای و پای منقل ایشان مینوازد!مایه ننگ موسیقی هستند
hameedreza111 4 years ago
doste aziz:
There is no question Ostad Shahnaz is one our greatest but the question is Lotfi with Aref assembly help Iranian to start loving traditional music or not? Manghal and other words which you are using not even help your case it shows what kind of logic you have.
nassir1 4 years ago
I am sorry that you are not a musician and I don't know how to tell you that according to any critria mr.Lotfi is a very low class player. Let me tell you that his son Omid has a far better technic than his father!all he has played in the past are available and they speak for themselves. he has million years of light distance with Ostad Shahnaz.
hameedreza111 4 years ago
shoma agar alayegh mana dide bashid ,shahnaz va asatide bozorge, ama ta key diktatori va nakhahim nazarate hame ra gosh bedim va beshnavim, man motasefam baraye yek doktore madraki music ke injori sohbat mikone, vali be har hal tashakor az goftane nazareton , mersi
faramarzkalantari 4 years ago
please remember that before Lotfi was born many other great musicians had done their best to preserve and progress our music.starting from Vaziri, saba, Mahjoobi, Mousa and javad Maroofi, Khaleghi, Khaledi, Tajvidi, Paivar,Yahaghi, Badei Habib and Rahmatollah and ... worked so hard all these years without the huge supports that Hooshang Ebtehaj, Reza Ghotbi , Reza Pahlbod,gave to Lotfi! Please if you are not a musician do not judge our professional views point.
hameedreza111 4 years ago
بسیار زیباست آفرین
aashofteh 4 years ago
Very nice.
TacoMan1220 4 years ago
اشكال اساسي نوازندگان جوان اين است كه متاسفانه شناخت درستي از زيباي موسيقي ايراني ندارند. گناهي هم ندارند چرا كه اين هم از بركت نوازندگان بسيار ضعيف و بدي همچون لطفي , كه نگذاشته اند بزرگاني مثل استاد بزرگ تار جليل شهناز براي اين جوانان جايي پيدا كنند و دكان حضرات تخته شود
hamsab 4 years ago
who is the player?
TjockBallen 4 years ago
Thank alot...
who is the Tar player...?
mirsufi 4 years ago
Tha tar player is Mohammad Ali Mohebbi
setarmaker 4 years ago