Added: 2 years ago
From: katemillerheidkeVEVO
Views: 207,169
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (597)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • James better have accepted that apology!

  • It goes to show that you must never underestimate the power of being nice to someone

  • a beautiful soul

  • Great song that inspired the kids at Fahan School to create the video - Our Promise using Kate's song.

  • I was like James in high school. It's scary how much I can relate to this song. School was tough for me, but I've grown and forgiven the people who bullied me.

  • yeah it should have more views

  • this sounds so much like me but im james not kate

  • i was in love with this song and then i forgot about it but now that something happend in my like it makeme rember her name and now im in love with this some 10 times even more!!!!!

  • i Never Tired Listen This Song..Loves You Kate

  • Omg...The last verse is so sad....It really cuts to the heart...

  • Sometimes when i see hitch hikers, i throw the closest object out the window at them and then yell "bitch" as i drive off.

  • nice harmonies

    

  • I'd hit it.

  • this just remionds me og whenever i tell the teachers kids are teasing me about my guinea pig they say you should tell when bullying happens,but they don't always help the sittuation :[

  • amazing

  • SHE SAID IM SORRY

  • for those of u whoo call her a bitch and this sucks maby u should take a min. and think.....do u come from almost nothing and then become a star and have an amazing voice and a way to express it....do u know her how do u know thease things i highly dought u have met her....at mleast she can do something good with her llife maybe if u stop and smell the roses u can to...

  • @Lulure1335 YES

  • To anyone calling her a bitch because of this, need I remind you that it is about her getting bullied. James is imaginary and a way of telling her story. And for the comments of a song about the impacts of bullying, you should be ashamed of yourselves.

  • My friend showed this video as a part of her project, i didn't think this song would have anything to do with cyber-bullying, which is what she was talking about.

  • elle est belle

  • fucking bitch

  • what a bitch...

  • best in wirld

  • one way or another, whether the victim or the bystander or the perpetrator, everyone has had an experience like this to tell.

  • subscribe to me for a sub back :)

  • shes so pretty<3

  • this song is in our musical called (on the outside looking in)

  • There is an australian teacher in our school right now on a teacher exchange thingy, he showed us this song in assembly, now everyone is singing it around school haha ;)

  • i love this song so much, such a great message <3

  • F*ck you, backstabbing b*itch.

    - James

  • i love this song, in 2012 qand still listening. she sings with much emotion, it's like this actually happened to her.

  • @smartcakes303 It did actually happen to her.

  • @XxLittleLadiesxX why I said it..... poor james, lol he was prob a millionaire untill he got an arrow in the knee by the three guys......

  • @XxLittleLadiesxX How do you know?

  • @aa04796 In my school there's an Australian teacher and he showed us it then told us this actually happened.

  • @XxLittleLadiesxX This Happend at my school but it wasnt a austrailian Teacher and it probbaly wasnt at the same school :L Every on in my Class laughs at the bit when it says Sex Pistols LOL

  • @Georgia123456712 Well, he's a p.e teacher and not really meant to be here but I think he's filling in for another teacher. A few people in our year, in my school, laughed but not that many.

  • Like if u wish that you could take back something you did because youre sorry!

  • shes so absolutely beautiful in this video

  • what a farqin bitch

  • @nosotrosvamos I don't agree with you, you see she explains that she is sorry and that she was in the crowd which means that she didn't want to leave the crowd and stand up for him. but from Jame's eyes yes, she would be a "bitch" though she is not herself, she has gone through a lot in her life which is easy to tell by simply listening to how much emotion she places into the notes.

  • yay!

  • She's so epic! <3

  • Meth lab alert.

  • What a beautiful voice and intelligent to boot!

  • one day my dad show me this song and since that day i watch this all the time

  • This is me. I know it sounds weird. I'm in highschool. "When the kids called him weird he didn't try to deny it" I'm into "punk" if you can call it that. Friends are rare and hard to come across. But I tell you what, jut knowing people want to take back the things they said or did, it helps. It really does.

  • You just realised that James got ganged by 3 niggers

  • @deadsailors Racist...

  • Wow amazing voice my teacher in class used this as example of how bullying affects your entire life.

  • @2008Mariofan Mine did too

  • No, it's not real. In interviews, Kate has said that she was James. In school she was bullied, and she said that she liked to think that those kids who were mean to her would say sorry now if they could.

  • Kate, this video and song is so amazing! it made me cry :)

  • this is mi fav song from her i think shes kinda pretty

  • 15 people dislike this song because they probably bully people for fun .

  • Why doesn't this have 1,000,000+ views?! O_o

  • @MusicalAndTall The reason it doesn't over 1, 000, 000+ views is because good music is only recognized by a handful of people.

  • @xDaveeedo That and this vid was re-submitted by VEVO. The original vid on Kate's personal channel had nearly 3 million hits.

  • @MusicalAndTall VEVO

  • @MusicalAndTall I know!

  • @MusicalAndTall because it sucks

  • @MusicalAndTall because it sucks

  • @MusicalAndTall because it sucks

  • @MusicalAndTall because of vevo. also probably because of the terribly awkward things she's doing with her arms the whole time...

  • @MusicalAndTall because she doesn't wear a skin costume.

  • can i have my meth lab back?

  • amazing song

    

  • this is a true story ! the teacher told us yehh i no !!

  • She is soooo beautiful, im soo jealous, amazing talent too

  • It makes me wonder if this song is real. And if it is, has 'James' ever heard it? Has he forgiven her?

    It's a very passionate song.

  • @LiesBehindMirrors It is real. Here is some information from Wikipedia:

    "On Miller-Heidke's's official website she states, "Caught in the Crowd is a different kind of song, with a double tug of the heart-string behind the gentle texture of music, and the recognisably real story of a lingering childhood regret." As discovered on the official forum, the song had a working title of "Song for Elton"."

  • The girl you just called a Mudblood? She spends hours practicing spells hoping people will like her. The boy you just stupefied? His parents use the Cruciatus Curse on him regularly. That kid you just pushed? He is trying to use the killing curse on himself. That guy you just made fun of for crying? His mother was killed by a Death Eater. Put this on your status for an hour if you are against bullying in the Wizarding World. You never know what it’s like until you fly a mile on their broom.

  • sooo awseome song!!! love it <3 you got a pretty voice (;

  • GOD DAMN IT JAMES SHE'S SORRY!

  • In music class we were discussing this song and our teacher said the name of the song and the singer and no one had heard of it. But as soon as the music started everyone jumped out of their seats and said, "I've heard this!"

  • Love this song Like her hair shorter though

  • No you're not, not yet.

    - James

  • @BiggestBiebsBelieber

    We don't need to repost that shit.

    How the hell is it going to help stop bullies?

    Saying "95% won't" make's people feel like they should,

    which is wrong re-posting a comment doesn't mean in real life

    your going to stick up for someone it just means you feel like you should. xox

  • who is the real james

  • Dear bullies,

    See that boy doing his homework in homeroom? Last night he committed his friend out if suicide.

    See that girl you just called fat? She is starving herself.

    See that old man you made fun of cause of the ugly scars? He fought for our country.

    See that young boy you must made fun of for always being sick? He has to walk home in the snow cause his family is too poor.

    Re-Post this if you are against bullying. I bet 95% of you won't.

    ure life may not be as harsh

  • this song drives me insane at work, it gets stuck in my head so fucking bad!

  • she is so pretty and classsy looking

  • This song makes me feel bad for all of the students that i haven't treated good, even though i have never bullied anyone.......If i could go back and do it again- I'd be someone you could call friend.

  • my dad manages kate in America and she had her birth day at my house in 2011

  • This song is about a girl who reflects back on her high school days and recalls a loner type boy called "James". The girl sees James get picked on by some older, more popular guys and, feeling helpless, the girl turned her back on James despite him calling for help. Present day, she regrets ditching James and is now trying to say sorry.

  • it puts me into tears that he commited suicide after this happened :(. it reminds me to be nice to anyone thats nice to you no matter who they are. if they are mean then just ignore and stick with people who make you happy and always stick up for people your friends no matter what!!! Beautiful song and i understand the side of the singer, must be rough for her.

  • @KlowwnKiller did he commit suicied after that day :(

  • @mw2beast248 Sadly, yes :(

    

  • Sorry Ryan. I really should have been nicer and kept up with you over the years.

  • 15 people are bullies! They never regret their mistakes!

  • this song is what happen to me i still try to find the guy from my school,,, haven seen him for 6 years,,, i promise if i see him,, i will hug him and say "im sorry"

  • This still makes me cry when i hear it.. and still to now, i wonder if the guy in the story died idk but for some reason i think he died in the story line :( i lov ethis song <3 inspirational, and truee in some many ways :)

  • Sure the song and clip are utterly heartbreaking, but what strikes me is her sheer weight of guilt and desperate longing for forgiveness. Gets me every time

  • Like if you want to take back something you did

  • @1999Twiggy like if you forgive yourself.

  • God she is stunning.. we had a guy called james too at school that we all gave a hard time :(

  • @carebearninjabear Wow you write this on Youtube you dont deserve f**k all go say it to her face and give yourself at least some self respect you worthless Pr**k

  • Half of you idiots who complain of bullying you probably havnt been your life maybe once or twice wow... maybe if you wernt annoying pricks you wouldnt get bullied..

    

  • @shuffleduk YOU HAVE NO IDEA WHAT YOIUR TALKING ABOUT

  • She is gorgeous. And ever so talented.

    I for one have not been bullied (or bullied myself ... at least not that I'm aware of.) and it's song like this that make sure I never will.

  • wow- she is stunning

  • In English class my teacher showed this video to everyone. The project was to write a creative story on the theme 'bullying' it was supposed to stop bullying. I'm still bullied badly. My best friend just died and I'm getting teased fr having a dead best friend!

  • Good song. Incredibly depressing comments section. Just very, very sad. Sorry you had to go through shit like that, everyone reading this. It... it sucks.

  • The government told her to make this song so kids would stop bulling. never worked i still get bullied everyday.

  • I relate to this song soooo much as i was bullied horrifically in primary school.... so bad that i cant even write :( this is an amazing powerful song

  • I thnk everyone can relate to this song somehow...

    well I know I can.. :(

  • I was bullied dreadfully at school, I was abused by my best friends father, living in a small town all the kids who bullied be found out and started calling me a Sl*t even though i was the victim, I attempted to kill myself many of times, my parents moved our family to the city to get me away from those people, ive forgotton most of their names but not their actions, but instead of blaming them i forgive them though i will never like to see them again. bulling does hurt in more then one way...

  • @MsKerryn1988 opposite for me when I moved to the city from a small town I lost all of my friends, infact my whole school in the small town respected and loved each other and always helped

  • what a beutyful voice

  • I look back... and Raven if you ever read this... I am sorry I wasn't thinking about you I was thinking about my own sick popularity. I was wrong. I lost a person that could've been my friend... and I ended up getting suspended and i deserved it for what happened to you... Raven I'm sorry. If i could go back I never would have done what I did..

  • id tap that 

  • this is the sadiest song eva and the best and her hair is so blonde is that her natural hair but a short song

  • This is my auntie Katie! :D

    Yes, she my daddy's step-brother's wife's brother's wife.

    I see her sing at weddings sometimes :)

  • @littleprettyblondie YOUR IN NO WAY RELATED IDIOT STOP CLAIMING

  • i cry in this song and its my quir song cause its a true story:\

  • LUNA LOVEGOOD! :D

  • Comment removed

  • if thats correct than i dont get it but if its not than that is a very sad story and very mean for her to turn her back on him, i mean im short and i used to get bullied ALOT but now not as much and my friends stand up for me i mean how cruel to just leave a person who is begging for help i mean is it REALLY that hard to help a person in need???

  • LUV IT!!!! :)

    i sang this song in front of my whole skool last year it was sooooo much fun!! :)

  • I hope James is okay

  • Effin Brilliant!!

  • Seeing her on QandA brought me here. What a voice.

  • we watched this in class we r like studding it. our teacher has spoken to her and a parentliy james comited suwiside befor the end of school!! :( :(

  • Everytime I watch this I always shout- "NO, WHY DID YOU DO THAT!"... everytime

  • she reminds me of Luna in harry potter

  • this girl is soo hot

  • Turning your back to that person who is in pain is the worst gesture to hurt and devastation

  • This gives me goosebumps. <3

  • @stuckupcurlyguy and @bechilled202 I wish we could all get along like we used to in middle school... I wish I could bake a cake filled with rainbows and smiles and everyone would eat and be happy...

  • we were doing a bullying thing in school and they showed this song

  • awesome song!

  • orale... que chika

  • i'm really proud of her for telling what really happened. if i was making a song like this (even with the chorus as it is) i still would have been too ashamed to say tha i'd walked away.

    i knew a kid like james. i wasn't his friend but i wasn't his bullier. i was an observer, which i now know is just as bad if not worse, because it tortures me like it tortures him-i like to think so anyway.

  • Oh how I adore this woman<3

  • The girl you just called fat? She is overdosing on diet pills. The girl you just called ugly? She spends hours putting makeup on hoping people will like her. The boy you just tripped? He is abused enough at home. See that man with the ugly scars? He fought for our country. That guy you just made fun of for crying? His mother is dying. post this to another video or 'Thumbs up' if you are against bullying. I bet atleast 95% of you wont. Please prove me wrong.

  • I Balled My Eyes Out @ This Song, Because This Happened To Me. I Turned My Back, & Just Walded Away . . . (I'm Sorry)

  • @JustOnce You see, I know these things already. So I don't need to post it on videos I know you think you're helping, but really, it's just spam when you've seen it posted on every other video. Which means it's more annoying than anything else.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @camryan504 She was in HIGHSCHOOL! She's grown up and wants him to at least know how she feels NOW. Who are you to insult her? No one.

  • Why in God's name doesn't this have more views?

  • Did she evr get a reply from James?

  • The thing that makes me cry in this video is that I was that young boy...but i'm a girl haha and I had people turn their back on me. And as harsh as it is I will never fogive them. Im sorry that I dont accept your sorry...

  • this nearly brought me to tears, it made me realise i probably should change

  • This girl is absolutely Gorgeous & has an amzaing voice !

  • love it!!

  • her voice seems to come as easy and natural to her as breathing does... such an inspirational song

  • why doesnt she ride a bike when she says it! duh

  • this song is so inspirational it gives me gosebumps...SO AMAZING :)

  • 1:05 No film in the projector

  • does eney one no a good kate miller song lol

  • Katie went to an all girl school. St Aidan's Anglican Girls School to be exact.

    Anyway what i'm trying to say is that Katie IS James. She was just writing it from a different perspective.

    "Song lyrics are not always the literal truth." - Katie Miller-Heidke

  • @ShuffleDuk lol my aunts went there.

  • @ShuffleDuk Such angelic face and philosofical mind.

  • @ShuffleDuk hey i live near there

  • @4JustOnce for once, chain messages mean something :)

  • @4JustOnce see that girl you just called a slut with a baby? she got raped at the age of 8 :) remember that one!

  • @4JustOnce See that guy spamming on youtube videos? He's an idiot.

  • @4JustOnce oh shut the fuck up, copy pasting shit doesn't make you a good person

  • @stuckupcurlyguy Couldnt've said it any better.

  • @16945pie youre dumb too, if you dont believe in ideas DONT THINK!

  • @bechilled202 Actually, i just dont believe in idiots spamming youtube.

  • @stuckupcurlyguy raising awareness makes a difference jackass, what youre doing is saying 'all those people who wear ribbons for breast cancer troops etc, arent being good cuz theyre essential just copy and pasting others messages that they agree with' if you support an idea or message, let it be known

  • @bechilled202

    The fuck? The people who wear ribbons BOUGHT them, for two bucks each. That adds up. One youtube comment on a song about bullying is nothing more than preaching to the converted. "Supporting an idea" is a complete cop out so that you can FEEL good, instead of materially changing things. Go work in a soup kitchen or something instead of preaching to me. I do my bit.

  • @stuckupcurlyguy wow, sooooo im not allowed to support others ideas, only actions? are you dumb ideas are the foundation of everything that humans have accomplished, plus ideas can evolve into any number of actions, so one idea can literally be responsible for a BILLION different actions, like go to the soup kitchen lets say, and just so you know, im just rephrasing a point made by the dalai lama, just "supporting his idea"