超級星光大道-16強合唱指定賽-潘裕文+楊宗緯-你那麼愛她

[sfpro22]

like it..^^



[jasonofthel33t]

2:18 才开始

[TeaGreenMocha]

一班 the best!!

[516KAKA]

楊宗緯　用聲有Ｄ似 李聖傑

[skoovt]

潘裕文的音线有点弱.....不行..



[yiaphwee]

会听的人都听得出"洋葱"的声音明显单薄啦.........

[yiaphwee]

杨之所以能够在星光红 全因有小虫和张宇这两个没水准的评判!!无论杨唱成怎样烂(甚至­都还没唱)都已在心底给予高评价了!!! 在这首歌里,左听右听都听不出杨到底好过潘那里!!显现出小虫的­评语真的太过头了,烂评判!!!

[yaya38298]

楊宗緯好可愛!

[ellesun85]

I love Aska! I think he's really a talented singer. However, Pan is not bad too~ 

[stbu04124115]

看來看去 還是最喜歡一班

[pouiy23]

ASKA's vocal is superb! Caught my attention almost instantaneously! Although the "Super star avenue" has moved onto season 7, I still come back to watch the old footages from season 1, the true classics - ageless.

[pudhow]

我喜歡裕文剛剛好的感情

能讓人慢慢的進入歌然後感動

[superNR00]

Pan不适合这首歌。没有唱得多好或不好，只有选对了适合自己得­歌才能发挥得好。

[happy36e]

公道自在人心$

就我感覺  還是宗緯 唱的有說服力~~嘿嘿

[faifai1204]

本來心情係低落...

但聽完陶子的笑話心情就好多啦=)

[waihong001]

楊宗緯好像在模仿。。。

[love75315977]

超好聽的啦......:)

[s862056906]

小蟲的話說得真毒

最後還要陶子打圓場

「我完全沒有任何理你」

[waisun1227]

潘裕文比宗緯還好聽

為什麼評審這樣說...



[Natsumilovesmusic]

@waisun1227

我非常喜歡聽潘裕文唱歌, 也非常喜歡他那空靈純淨的嗓音, 不過我覺得就像評審老師說的, 或許潘是走比較飄逸的美聲路線 (所以唱月光和離人能夠扣人心弦), 但唱這首歌和楊宗緯搭配, 就顯得弱了一些. 這首歌是屬於那種要用比較厚實的嗓音來帶出濃厚的情感的. 老實說, 潘的聲音一出來我剛開始有點失望, 因為對這首歌來說較為單薄, 而且情感到高音時才全部出來. 不過後來潘在棒棒堂節目中和野獸合唱的那ㄧ次, 聲音的厚實度和情感都有出來, 令我驚艷. 潘王子還是最棒的啦!

[glamour2092]

that xiao chong is just biased. i think peter and aska were equally good.

[yagood0310]

這樣18分 從3 4班以後 18叫基本分吧??

[sweet840920]

星光大道

我最喜歡一班了

最愛看的也是一班

好希望他能夠從一班在開始做

[terry0706t]

一直以來都想聽楊宗緯唱李聖傑的歌

感覺他們歌路差不多

楊宗緯又是感情派的

[frommars03]

明明就超好聽,真希望現在還能夠看到他兩合作對唱....哀  不過大概已經不可能了吧

[HolyKiller43]

WTF!!! fuck that Xiao Chong la. Pan got so bad meh? zzz

for me,both of them are good match. lols!

[sccalvin]

我超喜歡陶子的!!沒了她, 我相信星光大道真的不太好看

[terry0706t]

難怪小蟲老師會被砲....

這講評真的是.....

唉....

[scooh]

@terry0706t

同意, 不是說是單位安排的嗎? 還一直講說潘裕文找死...

還有, 分數不是也高嗎...

[kitman]

其待物理再度合唱!!

[antingting]

我竟然比较喜欢潘裕文的表现，声音中听出到位的感动。杨宗纬的感­情有点太过了。。

[carinezXz]

@antingting 完全同意你的讲法！！杨宗纬真的太过了

[377830815tao]

潘的咬字有问题 。。

[Apt192]

Yes, Pan has serious pronunciation problem. He needs to fix it real fast if he ever wants to become a successful singer.

[cloudych]

我一直都不明白

潘裕文哪有评判说的那么差

我觉得唱的是很感动啊

而且最后无法自拔 的合音太好听了

[briliant96]

Pan Yu Wen so handsome

[vikki241]

聲音跟畫面不同步啊

[sheila6501]

個人覺得兩位搭配得很好, 歌聲和畫面都很棒!

[steveteen]

其實潘王子唱得也很好呀...

只是他和宗緯的風格不同...

我個人是比較喜歡啊潘的演唱風格..

特別是"你深愛她 這是每個人都知道呀"這句真的很好聽

[konoez]

agree!

[jiingleful]

yea....he's an evil judge

[thomasiceson]

哈哈

[s79999]

陶子好衰呀後尾...*0*...

[scopioworld]

小虫老师说话好狠啊~~王力宏《完全没有任何理由理你》唱的是他­么？

[xXdevilcoleenXx]

Pan Yu Wen so CUTEEEEEEE :D

[aki1996322]

聲音跟畫面不同步阿 0.0

[peipei0611]

lol..wtf..pan yu wen sing until very nice larhh k..dun simply say larhh..

F*** u

[26yi]

what is the song that 楊宗緯sang at 1:44?

[peipei0611]

good bye my love我的爱人

[elvinleecheevoon]

not nice....agree with the judges...

[Freeze123789]

你聽誰說的?

[annelyy613]

如果你有看,就知道了

[GeniusComposer]

小虫？妖！！完全！！没有！！ 任何，理由！！理你！！！！！

[cloudych]

always feel hurt that Pan was being criticise like that by the judge, I feel comfortable listen to their duet, they just have different style...

[show0616]

真是經典

好希望能唱ㄉ跟他們一樣好

至於原唱...神啊~

[nicoltst]

我觉得潘王子的声音很好听啊，现在的偶像，几乎都是靠样貌，不然­飞轮海和棒棒堂怎么可能那么红。潘王子能看又能唱，已经算很不错­了！！

[yogre89]

Lol you say Yang Zong Wei 不能看 ROFL

[ahCh1Ng0320]

@nicoltst 其實棒棒堂是能唱能跳能搞笑;飛輪海也是能唱能跳;大家都不同了­:-D

[b23054488]

@ahCh1Ng0320 你確定棒棒堂能唱嗎?!?!在跨年或節目上的時候那個聲音總是走­音的團體 我可以承認能跳能搞笑 不過唱歌這方面實在有待加強 飛輪海也是時好時壞 出道這麼多年  進步的幅度真的太小了 這樣看起來還是外貌加分比較多ㄚ

[ahCh1Ng0320]

@b23054488 請留意一下棒棒堂是怎麼出來的; 他們六個好像也只有兩個是唱歌的.四個都跳舞吧~ 到外面表演沒走音就好了拉-______- 如果他們能唱就都來星光了。 飛輪海也不怎麼會跳吖~ 但我也不覺得他們唱得差;} 看.有人也說了潘王子能唱能看他也不能跳嘛~~. 一樣道理;D

[isaacbai]

看看四班的給分 再看一班...唉

[ffm1986hk]

他們2位...都各有特色....2位都喜歡....

[jossygu220]

老师讲话。。。严厉

[dreamilylibra]

不管隔了多久，挺他们俩唱歌就是幸福啊^_^

[yzwluvsag]

cocodeoxys:你说比较好看的是说潘浴文吗？ 他是第三名耶！ 你这样讲他，那第4，5，6，7，8，9，10。。。全部都等于­不会唱歌咯？ I cannot believe there is such a person who would say this kind of thing!! OMIGOSH!!

[zeddydd]

lol the host is so funny!

[ay1200kimo]

最後陶子跟宗緯開的玩笑

他那個訝異的表情,真可愛

[lauchunting]

鴨子好靚

[Mesam0001]

支持人太过分了。。

[twwy6016]

兩個都很好!

[alanstillair]

雖然一開始有點音有點不準

不過其他都不錯！

棒！

[raikage90]

i luv this song

[nicoltst]

你凭什么说他声音不好听，你声音很好听吗，那你去参加啊。

[williampk02]

小胖也沒他們唱得好啊，所以他沒資格當評審囉

[IvanIvanIvan2008]

在6分23秒中,潘裕文笑得好可愛....

[tea550]

兩個合唱還不錯聽 但是楊宗緯明顯實力比較強

[mrskok]

好听

[SwanSwen]

潘裕文超帅的，他的歌声好好听哦！超爱潘裕文的！

[lilylunapotter]

爱死物理！！！

[FatalDevil]

i think not bad leh, but yang zhong wei own pan yu wen a little...

[raikage90]

not own la.. they have different styles of singing.

[highburycatherine]

I agree, don't understand why people think it's poor. Probably those from Taiwan province don't agree,haha

[bao0808]

No matter who you are,

you are the one that

is really stupid for

saying something like

that!

[highburycatherine]

Where the hell did you get that from?

But it's stupid and low-class of you saying that

I don't like you

[yyyou88]

百聽不厭

[ohretro]

peter is damn amazing. <3

love his voice.

soothing & powerful.

[unicorn40550]

物理萬歲!

[shirli3]

Even though she's joking, implying Aska is ugly is over the line. If I were Aska, I would be really hurt by that comment.

[Ariale]

Aww, I thought they sang well together! It would be really annoying if they kept trying to battle each other in the song, it's nice this way. :) Different voice tones, that's what their duet special. Physics! \o/

[counterjk]

2 of the best!

[myhxmbuzz]

hahahha.. yay for both of them!! ;p anyway.. i think the mc is really MEAN!! how could she said such things to aska?!?! ahahahhhha.. i love aska! i think he's really GOOD! ;P

[itsTrish]

aska is a strong singer but I really like the other guy's voice - maybe not AS powerful but I would definitely listen to his album!

[bao0808]

Aska and Peter, excellent combination!

[lovestar2002]

兩個唱得都不錯啦

,最少潘裕文的聲音和aska唱的我覺得是合在一起的

現在看回頭,物理什麼時候再一起合唱呀....

[rootppl]

oye aska is better alot then that pan yu wen ~~ hahaha.... +u+u aska love u forever ^.<

[myhxmbuzz]

owhhhh!! aska is SOOOOOOOOO GOOD!!! ;P ahahahahhaa.. i love his voice! ;p hehehhee... the mc is so bad!! she didnt believe aska bout his girlfriend!!! hahahaha.. ;p

thanks for uploading ;p

[vvv777000]

應該說是兩個人的音色不同吧

潘裕文的聲音是非常溫柔的，應該去細細品嚐的聲音

他的聲音不會給人太大的撼動，卻可以把人引入故事情境裡頭，被那­細膩的聲線和情感影響、感動

如果說楊宗緯的聲音是色彩鮮明的油畫

那潘裕文的聲音就是簡單柔和的素描

在這之後，他們也有再合唱過幾次，你會發現潘裕文的聲音出來了

[handsomemood]

nice

[xxsuchadr3amxx]

great song, love their combination,

Aska's voice is impressive and touching

[tcss]

aska voice sounds very similar to sam lee!!!

[dragonblade117]

NEVERR!! lol. aska is waaaaaaaaaaaay better c(=

[dragonblade117]

why does pan yu wen look like he's scared of yang zhong wei lol

[DeSpErAte2BeYouRs]

but that passes because their relle close friends!! yay!!!

[startingsprinter]

OMG can't believe the host makes fun of Aska, they're both the same

[tstars201]

well the host is seriously reallyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy­yyyyyyyy uglyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy, and thats wut she looks like wit makeup on

[Puppylove88]

......haha yang zhong wei no girlfriend lo..... haha tao zi ..... scarcastic him..

[acytoh]

Tao zi is so funny

[vvv777000]

Roger講的中肯，兩個人的音質完全不同

兩個男生對唱情歌...

如果用對幹的想法去唱會有點奇怪吧||b

[71903139]

so cute ~~~~~~

[sillycow87]

dun be too bias against taozi lah.. she is a good host.. she is just kidding and i think she can do that becos they are really close in reality.. her husband also teaches zongwei stuff..

[dragonblade117]

lol yeah. I think it's messed up, but she just having some fun. and he don't seem to get too pissed or embarrassed about it.

[nanzii]

so mean.............

[sweetpopz]

.... normally i'd find tao zi witty with her barbed remarks, but it's just plain rude to keep piling on the sarcasm about Yang Zongwei's looks! Sheesh! His beautiful voice overshadows EVERYTHING. You won't even pay attention to the visual aspects when he sings!

[bogy7300]

日本有對化學超男子團體 台灣出個物理超男子 哈  真的好好笑

也幽默感比較不會得病 節目效果一笑置之即可

[tazbloc21]

thaz GOLD stuff

so hilarious!!

[keilin]

還滿好笑阿~><

[YkouyouY]

物理的介紹aska講的好好笑XDD

[taipeisnow]

一點都不好笑阿,就算為了製造效果也沒必要死纏爛打的問

[Phoenix9907]

i like her hosting...but the joke she made on that guy's look was quite stupid ( imagine how u would feel if she cracked that joke on u in front of so many people, wonder if u can still say "節目效果而已嘛" )

[nafe1983]

太嚴肅對身體不好哦~~人生會過得很辛苦...

桃子講話很好笑

[macaugarlei]

no offense but she sounds like a bitch.. kept picking on them..

[damnday09]

你是被陶子搶男友哦?

哈哈哈哈!!~這句話好經典

[plu5ann]

唱得真正好 主持的也好 不要亂罵人啦

[Kikachu]

我不知道ㄝ　我喜歡陶子　可是他損那男生的話，聽了很不高興

[waning]

don't judge a book by it's cover

[hellocindy]

桃子很討厭 醜女

[sea4504]

樓上你是被陶子搶男友哦? 幹麻那麼氣，節目效果而已嘛~

[pbh98]

王八蛋

有沒有腦啊

人家紅是有原因的

TMD I hate people like you