American Idol Season 10 Most Shocking Elimination

[punkinnugget]

Pia was the most shocking but hello, where is HALEY?!? lol

[JBearzoneeight]

"America must really hate me cuz I got eliminated twice.....it's like 'oh you suck' and then 'you know we'll give you another shot, oh no you suck again'".......he's the funniest person I have ever seen and I swear he is the twin to my cousin

"Hey guys what are you talkin about?" "Oh.....just nothing" "Thats what I thought" Casey and James = scared of Pia

[thedisneygirl1234]

James at 1:54 LMAO i love all these top 11 people they are so funny together.

[trelovessinging]

pia is right that was shocking

[Caslanah]

Pia has no personality

[rockerr01]

When I first saw this on tv, I was like "No, I thought Pia was the most shocking elimination" then after about a minute .. Pia comes in LOL awesome :)

[meghan1250]

press 1 ;P hahahah yo yo yo yo

[cowfluf7]

pause at 1:30 XD

[FOUxGUITARExFILLE]

"...I was sad!"

Lolol ohhh how we love our Jamieee and Caseeey <333

[MrBlex96]

1:11

[90si]

That Ginger kid deserved to be eliminated, hes a goof

[viciousLUA]

@90si

a goof who's got personality and raw talent.

[FlamingARROW000]

"eghksdjfh daughtry safjkanumber four" bleh

[AmericanIdolz2011]

Casey + James = Casey James (Season 9)

[XOSiren18XO]

Ugh, the people I wanted to make it to the top three didn't make it.

[key22341]

Pia DEFINITELY wins

[felaipechev]

HALEY

[thedisneygirl1234]

Lol James sticks his tongue out at Pia at 1:54. I love the chemistry of the top contestants in this season so much! I think they were the closest out of all the seasons.

[pammie2323]

James was the best one by far.... he should have won....can't wait until Monday when we can hear his new cd-------JAMES DURBIN ROCKS!!!!!!!

[MegaStevieb123]

james



[weluvthebieber45]

casey :)

[brianok01]

Pia wins.

[CalissaSelenaGomez]

Thumbs Up If Pia Toscano Was The Most Shoking To YOu Guys...

[valroks89]

James may have been one of my two favorites (Scotty was my other favorite). But, I agree that Pia was the most shocking. She was the best girl in the entire competition.

[tophitslister101]

oh my god now they're just bragging.....

[daydreamer526]

hahahaha James: I WAS SAD!

Doctor: You want some water?

Casey: Nah, some JUICE!

[sheor16]

i loved this cuz it was all true. but chris daughtry still falls above all. :)

[missclairetx]

haha, this shizzz is hilarious(:

[HaleyReinhartForever]

top 3: haley, casey, james

[TheHpluvr247]

@HaleyReinhartForever EXACTLY! They soooo should have been top 3! Who wants someone who holds their mic like a flute to win, and a girl who cant even talk properly to be runner-up?!

[HaleyReinhartForever]

@TheHpluvr247 yes!!!! i tottaly agree!! 

[TheHpluvr247]

@HaleyReinhartForever right lol

[Idolfan21785]

James Durbin reminds me of Ashton Kutcher

[lillyssi1228]

james face @ the end kills me

[TheHpluvr247]

@lillyssi1228 lol RIGHT!!!!!

[loganidol]

If they admitted Pia was the most shocking, why the hell didn't they let her do a full solo performance, for Christ sake?

[Daeduluus]

@loganidol They did on a little show called Dancing with the Stars.

[ToughRoughAndMuffins]

my top 3 were lauren, pia, scotty. that was before since the top 24, im not one of those people that just says their favorites were the winners, i actually liked them the best.

[iLoveLeahRemini]

@ToughRoughAndMuffins same here, they should have been the top 3! pia was the first elimination that i cryed, from all 10 seasons,

[ToughRoughAndMuffins]

i love the part:

Casey: "Are you kidding me? I was way more shocking! The doctor had to come wheel me off. I dropped the microphone."

James: " You just dropped an $8,000 mic. Be more courteous than that"

It just makes me crack up. Nice comeback James.

[simpsonsfan2007]

I'm going to agree with Stefano and say James' elimination was the most shocking. It should've been Haley going home that week, especially after her tantrum the previous night. I was even more shocked than the week Pia left, only because of the disappointment of seeing my fellow Aspie leaving the show. I was an emotional train wreck up until after I got home from work the next day. I still believe James should've won the whole thing and had no business leaving that week.

[gnangy20]

@kobi005 my top three would be lauren, pia, james

[TheIlovesnickerss]

Yeahh I Want TheeJazz Guy To Win ! :D

[floodedtick]

who the hell is Randy blowing kisses to in the beginning?? nobody likes him so....and Haley was the most shocking for me

[thejtcam]

@floodedtick i know!!!! i wanted haley to win the whole thing!!!!!!

[floodedtick]

@thejtcam yeah she was the most talented by far and out of james and casey i thought casey was the most shocking cause I liked him more hehehe anyways... I dont get how people liked James so much!! yea he was talented but when he went high he sounded like he was just screaming im serious and HALIENS FOR EVERRR!!!! lmao

[JuliaStorms]

@thejtcam same here!!! She's from my hometown!! I was rooting for her!!! She was shocking to me!

[thejtcam]

i thought either casey,haley, or pia waz gonna win the whole thing. my dreams where wrong. :( love you haley casey and pia! im your biggest fan!!!!!

[zeebestfreind]

is James wearing a Nexus shirt?

[shimada1999]

Pia rocks!!

[peyton7987]

Top 3 were supposed to be Haley, James, and Casey.

[floodedtick]

@peyton7987 I agree 110% thats exactly how i wanted it to be

[peyton7987]

Casey is so hilarious.

[ballet901ami]

pia is so pretty!!!!!

[kathfor]

This is hysterical!

[fallforyou45]

i loved the way james said i was sad hahaha

[kobi005]

@fallforyou45 lol, yeah, james is funny

I have to say that the top 3 for me were Casey, James and Haley, I always loved hearing them sing, thats why i always downloaded their songs. but i have to admit that i would have put Pia instead of Casey as well, doesn't matter if i don't connect to her singing much, she's got amazing quality

[TheatureGirl]

i think pia was the most shocking- she shouldv'e at least gotten to the top 3 ;3

[Panda000People]

Yeah you suck no well give you another chance no you suck again.

[KassieLovesYouXoxo]

Haha this is so funny :)

[MegaGirlygirl2000]

Most shocking was James because I thought he was gonna be the runner up and Scotty would win

[Idolzfan0919]

@MegaGirlygirl2000 i thought the same thing!

[puppyluvr135]

i think james was most shocking. i kind of knew casey wasn't going to go all the way and honestly, it was only a matter of time before pia left. she wasn't really that unique. but i really thought james was going to make the finale.

[morganb147]

I'm actually glad Pia went that early... it wasn't that shocking that she went. All she wanted to do was belt a song and do ballads... nothing special about that. She has a nice voice but it's not very unique. I think Haley or Casey were the most shocking in my opinion... though, Haley was the most talented on the show and Casey I just want to be his best friend! hahahhaa... So I may be a little biased.

[pokemonfan8881]

@morganb147 well i think they were all unipue but i think haley and casey had to much growl and rasp to there voice i thought pia was the best singger and if you look at it she was one of the only who got a standing ovathion and she didn't blurt out all she did was follow her notes

[morganb147]

@pokemonfan8881 yeah but all she wanted to do was sing a ballad.

[JandK813]

i hated casey. i got mad when he called james a cry baby. james was my favorite. when casey called james a cry baby, i was like yelling at the tv "ITS NOT HIS FAULT!!!!" he mentioned at his audition that he had a high functioning autism as a kid. SHOW SOME RESPECT CASEY! AND BTW, DON'T BELIEVE EVERYTHING A MAGAZINE TELLS U!

[peyton7987]

@JandK813 He wasn't being seriously.

[LakesharkEps]

all 3 of them were shocking but the most shocking for me was James

[sbarlow1728]

"America must really hate me 'cuz I got eliminated twice. It's like 'oh you suck,' and then 'You know we'll give you another shot, oh no you suck again'" :) Luv ya Casey!! The Magizene was right....

[vchrissybaby1]

haha i LOVE casey!! i wanna marry him!

[aema171]

Pia's elimination was really shocking .. and neither of the other 2 eliminations were shocking.. instead they should've been eliminated erliear :/

for me Karen's elimination was shocking because she sings very well like Pia Toscano..

[xdaakotax]

hahahahah this is funny

Casey, James and the rest xDDDDDDDD

[TheBoldenb]

my pick was Pia, Casey and Haley

[simpsonsfan2007]

Interesting how James and Daughtry had about the same reaction on being eliminated.

[chiopeefillin]

Honestly, i was shocked when James, Pia, and Casey were eliminated.

[scottymclover]

haha this was very funny one of my favorite parts of the whole finale... besides the part where they announced scotty the winner



[3spn4life]

I love Pia

[iamgillian24]

verrrrrrrry cute vid !!!! no dislikes. yay !!!

[KristiannaStephani]

CASEEEYYY<33333333333333 ;D

[kyoodlenoodle]

Love this!!!!!!!!

[batiele]

so funny and clever!!