Added: 4 years ago
From: Mubahala
Views: 14,178
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (39)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • uck khomeyeni the piece of shit indian british mmother ffufuker i fuucck hssmother i fuck his sister javid shah

  • SALAM O SON OF ALI

  • مام صادق (عليه السلام):

    اءوحى الله عزوجل الى داود (عليه السلام): يا داود ان عبدى المومن اذا اءذنب ذنبا ثم رجع وتاب من ذلك الذنب واستحيى منى عند ذكره غفرت له واءنسيته الحفظة و اءبدلته الحسنة ولاابالى واءنا اءرحم

    خداى عزوجل به داود وحى كرد: اى داود هر گاه بنده مومن من گناهى كند و سپس از آن بر گردد و توبه نمايد و به هنگام ياد كردن از آن گناه از من شرم كند، او را بيامرزم و آن گناه را از ياد فرشتگان نگهبان اعمال ببرم و آن را به نيكى بدل كنم . و از اين كار مرا باكى نيست كه من مهربان ترين مهربانانم

  • دیوس عرب پرست

  • he was a kaffir

  • is it not kumany who has made halal sex changes. how can this guy talk about ali when he is scum. not only does he halal this action but he funds the operation for people in iran.

  • Khomeyni ridam tu ruheto va tarafdarane

    nafahmet.

  • You feel that he is suppressing an ocean inside of him. God bless him. He is a cool breeze for the oppressed believers.

  • fuck khomeini in ol muslms

  • it was a simple election ones with Ali ones with abu baker ......then ones with ali gave birth to children, does children didnt know that it was just a simple election brotherly competition, they started spreading hate to abu baker and his followers or votters, and thats how the islamic ummah first started weakining ...may we ll stay one hand shiite and sunnah

  • konde koskesh lajan

  • koskesh haramzadeh hendi

  • спасибо

  • be gour wasel schod

  • Very...very typical Shiah faith

  • Why do you take it as I hate them? I told that I don't but I clearly point out their mistakes and that is no wrong in that. Please refer me to source about Shia fiqh promoting hate of daughters of the Prophet(S). Who said Ali did attack Ali? Why did Abu Bakr become the first caliph? And what happened on the event of ghadir? Could you explain these events and provide sources for what you say in this regard.

  • Ali(3) should be the first caliph. when the people were doing election for the caliph, abu bakar came and said to Ali (3)"be away, I am the caliph, that's it"

    this is the great Khomeini, I think the errors that you are talking are from the translation. because in farsi and arabic language, you cannot translate exactly the same "sens" of the words into english

  • Hate for Allah ? Where does Allah order hatred of his messengers wives and daughters ? Or even Muhamamd saw himself ?

    Secondly it is the Shai who hate the daughtess of the prophet refusing to acknowledge them,rather saying he only had one daughter!

    All becasue the other two were given to the 'hated' uthman. Accepting their marriage to uthman would destroy the shia faiths thinking.

    When did Ali attack Ali ?! Provide proof brother !

    Provide proof oh shia !

  • Second Point, why do Shia follow Ali: Shia follows Ali because Allah and the Prophet order use to do that.

    Verily your guardian is Alláh and His messenger (Muhammad),And those who believe and establish the prayer,And give charity (alms) while they are (in Ruku`) bowing down. (al Máidah, 5:55),a) The highest sunni translators of Quran, like Zamaqshari and others, say the third guardian are Ali ibn Abi Taleb. And in many other verses and ahadith notes that Ali is the leader after the Prophet(S).

  • 3. Why Fatima?, The Prophet confirmed that the most beloved person to him is Fatima his daughter and that his family well come from here. And he also said: "Fatima is from me, who hurt/annoy Fatima, hurt me"// this hadith is narrated on Sihah. You also read same hadith about Ali, the Prophet said: "Who hurt/annoy Ali hurt me".

  • Those who annoy God and His Messenger will be condemned by God in this life and in the life to come. He has prepared for them a humiliating torment (33:57). 4. The Prophet are ineffable, you can read it on the Quran verse: 53: 3-5.

    He does not speak out of his own desires (3).

    It is a revelations which has been revealed to him (4)

    And taught to him (5)

    You can therefore read in Sunni books and shia books that Fatima when she died, she was anger and hurt by Abu Bakr and Omar.

  • Also all the Prophets are ineffability and also Ahl al Bayt are ineffability, because Allah confirmed that in the verse 33:33.

    That was a little bit, this area is too big and you can't talk about it in the you comments, you must read the history from both shia and sunni.

    And may Allah unit this Ummah and help this Ummah

    Wa Sallam

  • b) The Arabic language is where deep therefore we most understand it good, when Allah said, "Inama" in the verse, He (Allah) choosed the finest and highest form of separating between two things in the Arabic language, therefore we can consist that the people who the verse first talked about before the word "Inama" is not same people who the verses talked about after "Inama". Cause Allah has separated them.

  • First point is about Ahl al Bayt:In the holy Quran in verses 33 in Sura 33, Allah the most high says: Verily, Alláh wishes to drive away all evils from you, O Ahlul Bayt, and cleanse you thoroughly.

    a) The highest sunni translators of Quran, like Zamaqshari and Tarmithi say that Ahl al Bayt is the Prophet, Ali, Fatima, Hassan and Hussain.

  • I well begin to answer every question by point. But first I want all who read to think that when they answer, answer of knowledge in this area not of feeling and also remember that everything you say, well be judge one day.

  • ''the one that hates the daughters of the Holy Prophet(S) should question himself before he is questioned''

    It seems you have alot of questioning to do. YES i have met Shia's who hate sahabas, and Muhammad's wives and daughters.

    Read you own faith and see the hatred.

  • Research like what? If "hate" is for the sake of Allah then it is good and with some of the Sahaba or wifes this is something that could be discussed. But I don't understand those who "hate" the daughters of the holy Prophet(S)!

  • Continued...

    You Shia reject the prophets daughters other than Fatima r.a. because of her status and marriage to Ali r.a. The other daughters of the messengr of Allah are rejected becasue of their marriage to Uthman r.a whom the shia hate. It cannot be possible in the shia faith to accept the other prophets daughters because if Muhamamd gave his two daughters in marriage to Uthamn, who can they possibly hate him ?

    I await your response...

  • the one that hates the daughters of the Holy Prophet(S) should question himself before he is questioned. Have you encountered shia that dont respect or what is this claim based on? regarding Uthman, we dont hate him, we say he wronged. Hate is a personal issue and nothing to do with shia fiqh. Big difference, cause people have emtions that affect judgement. I hope you are doing well, praying for your success,

    Ws

  • In the name of Allah the most merciful the most compassionate, Salam Alekom respected brother and sisters, I hope everyone who discussing and comments in this area, are doing that for knowledge not for fighting and I also hope that everyone answer of knowledge not from feelings and hates. Remember that we are one Ummah and we have to get unit. Both sides witness that there is no God but Allah and that Muhammad is his Prophet.

  • @@ Mubahal Post 2 :

    Brother Muhammad saw was NOT incapable of error, as he did error sometimes. But he was sinless in the sense even before prophethood he never lied, or directly went against Allah. Therefore he was sinless. The Shia claim their imams are infallbile, which means they cannot make any mistake ever, which includes lying, speech, or everyday life. This is an attribute of Allah who makes no mistakes, but again the shia claim Allah makes mistakes in 'Usool Kafi'.

    Continued..

  • In Shia fiqh there is no hadith that is 100% sahih as you have. Therefore every hadith that is against the Holy Quran is only trash. But to not make sin=infallible cause otherwise he would have made sin? And the leader of a divine message must be infallible so as the protectors of it (the holy Imams(A)) so the message wouldnt be corrupt. And God says in the Quran that everything the prophet said/did was upon divine revelation, indirect you mean this is wrong?

  • As for the Jamal war AIsha r.a went out to encourage Ali r.a to be swift in punishement to the sabites who killed Uthman r.a. Aisha r.a was consequently attacked, and ambushed ; this cauing the jamaal war.

    Ali r.a walked Aisha r.a back after the incident, showing no enmity between the two.

    Those who slander the prophets wives are like the hypocrites of the incident of Al ifk, those who Allah rebuked, so please refrain from talking without knowledge brothers.

  • Could you use the button "reply" so it will be easier to follow what you write and what your answer is aimed at? Regarding the Jamal war, it was because they wanted to hunt the killer of Uthman, were is your information about request in swift punishment to that? Why fight Ali in this case, that doesn make sense. And Prophet(S) himself pointed at her house and said this house of scandal according to Sahih hadith, do you deny this hadith?

  • @@ mubahal post 1 :

    Hi brother,

    thank you for writing in a civil manner, rather than turning to calling me a 'nasibi' and 'kaffer' like most Shia's do. Thefull ahlel Bayt are the prophets household : firstly his wives, and children. Then as part of Ahlel Bayt Ali's r.a's house are honuary members. They do not live with the prophet but are part of Ahlel Bayt.

    That is the full ahlel Bayt. Also Ahlel Bayt- Muhamamd includes those who are pious as Muhamamd saw said, whoever is pious

  • Why do you write "Hi"? We Muslims are obliged to send peace to each other. Assalamo Aleykum dear brother. Thanks I believe that discussion should be done in a civil manner for mutual respect and that is how The Holy Prophet(S) and the holy Imams(A) discussed. Ok, but that is a point of disagree. What is the source that indicate that all you mention is Ahlul Bayt(A)? Please refer to it. Could you also refrain from making childish comments about our respected schoolars? Have Islamic Akhlaq.

  • Answer the question brother. Please fine me ONE khomeini sermon on Muhamamd only not Ali ra.

    We sunnis follow the full Ahl Bayt not that just of Ali r.a.

    The Jamal war was caused by Abdulla Bin Saba the founder of Shi'sm.

    Muhammad is not infallible, he was sinless but not infallible .e in everything including speaking, mathmatics, mistakes etc.

    He was sinless in that he nevber disobeyed Allah.

    Now please find me proof why Shia's reject the prophets daughters and accpet Fatima Ali's wife .

  • Do you mean that he never spoke about the Prophet(S) just because you have not seen it? I checked Youtube but there is nothing, visit Iran and I am sure you will find videos there or recordings about this matter. The "full" Ahlul Bayt? Who are they? Please exlain it to me brother. I think you have to read history again, cause it was one of the wifes with some companions of the Prophet that instigated the Jamal war. We can discuss otherwise if you are interest.

  • How can one be sinless but not infallible? This is totally contradictory. Please read what you write and think of the meaning. If someone does not commit sins, then he is infallible. Otherwise he would commit sins. As all humans do. To do injustice to a poor servant is injustice and disobeying Allah when he says that He sent the Prophet(S) as an mercy. Which daughters do we reject? Please clarify this for me.

  • Answer the question brother ! Who do you follow Ali or Muhammad ? Regardless if they are the same ! Where are khomeinis sermons on Muhammad ?!

    Muhammad NEVER ordered you to follow Ali completely : shunning the prophet and following Ali ra, beating your selfs mercilessly on muharam for hussain chanting 'ya hussain!', cursing the sahaba!

    Did Muhammad order slandering of Aisha and of Umaar and Abu Bakr his great friend, the companion of the cave ?

    What has sura abasah have to do with this ?!

  • We follow the Prophet of course. And there is a lot of sermons on Prophet(S), search and you will find. Yes, Prophet(S) indeed ordered to follow him as his successor. Before you question about slandering, read your books and see what it says about people fighting the caliph of their time - and read history to find who exactly did that on Jamal war, why are YOU slandering them then?

  • You said that the Prophet(S) was sinless, if that is the case, then he must be infallible. Do you agree?

  • ''How much do you know if this man? Have you read about his life or studied? And didn't the Prophet(S) say that Ali(A) was part of him? ''

    Ali was a great sahaba. But answer the question, when was a sermon of the prophet last delivered ? Shia islam is misguided, follow Muhammad pbuh not ali r.a.

    Muhammad was sinless, ali was not.

    Muhammad was a prophet Ali was a follower.

    Follow the person Ali followed not Ali.

  • There is a lot mentioning of the Prophet(S), but every muslim agrees upon his status in Islam - therefore it is important to explain matters that are not an agreement between the muslims, as it is with the leadership of the master of the believers - Ali ibn Abi Talib(A). Who does Surah Abasah refer to if you then think the Prophet(S) is sinless? Ali(A) wasn' only Sahabah (cause there were hypocrites among them) but he belongs to the family of the Prophet(S).

  • Actually it is you who are not following the Prophet(S). Please follow Ali(A) as the Prophet(S) ordered. And Ali(A) was also sinless according to the holy Quran. He was the successor of the Prophet(S) and not only a follower. Big difference. You are right, I dont follow people who disgrace the Prophet(S) by questioning his Prophethood(S) and exclaiming that he is hallucinating?!? The Holy Prophet(S) is far above those charges!

  • When was the last time Muhammad s.a.w was mentioned by Khomeini ? Is it Alislam or Islam ?

  • How much do you know if this man? Have you read about his life or studied? And didn't the Prophet(S) say that Ali(A) was part of him?

  • You just told everyone "Don't speak, don't think, just obey"!!! What propaganda and brainwashing!

  • he didn't say anything like that

    what he explained was that Imam Ali's character could not be adequately described in full, so that he would not attempt to do so.

  • I can recall a saying of Imam Ali (a.s.) that

    "When Knowledge increases, speech/talks decreases"

    prophet (pbuh) said-

    " There's no limit of 2 things ; Knowledge & Understanding"

    was'salam

  • Lovely Response by Ayat. Khomeini.

    Thank you.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more