Added: 2 years ago
From: silverstream314
Views: 13,237
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (436)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • And if we were in Hawai`i we would have `elua `omole waha nui.

  • I get the feeling that 90% of the Creationist callers are drunk hillbillies from Tennessee...

  • @macmaasi79 Not only from Tennessee, from every southern state. Especially my home state of Texas.

  • stereo would be nice...

  • Why can't theists get that a thought is not an abstract nothing? It's an electro-chemical reaction in your brain. Without said reaction your thought would not exist and you would not have that thought.

    In fact writing this very post required brain chemistry. Which is an actual physical property of the universe that can be measured.

    It's the same with a lot of concepts, and if this guy was going to use numbers, he could have at least tried to talk about negative numbers or things like that.

  • @TheSkunkCat

    I mean, if someone asked about -3 or something like that.You could go into how math applies to reality. But if someone tells me to define two, I'd grab two items and go 'one, two'.

    If you have an item and you have another item, then together we call the amount of items two. If you have twice as many items we call THAT amount four.

    Sheesh... I think Willaim Lane Craig, that smug asshole started with the math 'argument'. And this caller has an even MORE halfwitted version.

  • @TheSkunkCat

    Kind of reminds me though of how much I'd like to strangle William Lane Craig whenever I listen to that guy for more then a minute. Such a condescending smug little shit.

    And he won't debate non-philosophers, because he know he'd get his self-congratulating ass kicked up and down the street and back if he debated to many people. Which happened to him whenever he DID debate a rationalist.

    Although me, I'd rather literally kick his ass, because otherwise I'd have to hear him talk.

  • If 2 was off by even a millionth of millionth of a decimal place, then 2 + 2 would not = 4.

    Obviously, an intelligent designer was required to make 2 + 2 = 4.

  • @punnet2 This is a nonsensical statement. One is quantified by its singularity and has no component of size to be its reference. Therefore, two is merely a word attached to the concept of having 2 ones. For instance 1 hair is still one and one elephant is still one regardless of its size. These are simply words that represent concepts of wholeness which requires no need for an intelligent designer.

  • Comment removed

  • @UncleFeedle

    Very deep. Or not.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • "Have you ever seen a mind without a brain?"

    I think you're talking to one, Tracie.

  • Since there was a first cause, then that cause must be from some sort of magical mind, and that magical mind must be God..What great logic lol

  • "Well you can't prove..."

    *proves it*

    "Well, no, you see, I meant..."

    *provides explanation to the next point*

    "Well, no, you see, it's like what I first said..." (proceeding to go back to the first thing that was already addressed)

    It's so frustrating to try to get people to think.

  • Did anyone else hear the deafening sound of a head being banged against a brick wall every-time the hillbilly babbled on?

  • I simply love when a person who believes in the supernatural bullshit squirms while trying to explain and justify the unexplainable and the unjustifiable.

  • Do you actually have to be an idiot to be an christian...or does it just help?

  • hahaha i love the beginning.... urshuuubeligjiajsdoiasjoafbasi­doasidsaoidjosidas

  • "Gunral rultivity"

  • NOBODY disagrees with Tracie and gets away with it.

  • Yes, I do believe artghen fhjels dorepr and you're immoral if you don't.

  • Whenever theists use mathematical axioms to prove god, all we have to do is this: Take ANY situation, create a mathematical expression, evaluate it to show that it ALWAYS evaluates to a single predictable answer based on the axiom. Now can you show that predictable behavior in god or prayer? No? Then they are NOT THE SAME!

  • From the end of the video, is there anything else other than time, matter or space such that a lack of any of those does not constitute absolute nothingness? It seems to me the caller had a point on that one. If there wasn't time matter or space, how was there anything at all?

  • @eggory I would say that is a very broad description of what quantum physicist and particle physicist are working on now. The answer is that nobody knows. Maybe the space time that we define as our know universe began to expand in some other currently unknown medium (wild guess). I think the point is that because there is always a limit to current human knowledge, we don't just insert a made up answer (god, leprechahns, etc.). We admit we don't know and continue our quest for knowledge.

  • When is a door not a door?

    When it is ajar.

  • And you're done.

  • is this guy stoned?

  • @keaco73 no...but I am

  • @keaco73 For his sake, I wish. However, I think the religious brainwashing he has received all of his life has taken its toll on his mind.

  • This caller couldn't think his way out of a wet paper bag with a chainsaw in each hand.

  • I love the atheist experience but these people do not understand mathematics. Great stuff to say about theology and epistemology but - Oh man - bad math.

  • Why do so many people NOT understand that numbers simply describe the quantity of things? They think numbers are floating in around space or something...

  • @jsamari Whenever we see absolutes like the law of gravity, numbers, or chemical properties, people are quick to say they were programmed. This is because what human beings are capable of is so imperfect. We stink at programming, doing calculations, taking measurements, etc. People are fooled into thinking only something even more intelligent than a human can do this. It is a very narrow-minded construct that can only come from putting nature in mundane human terms.

  • @MunkyDrag0n Also I think ppl might think that numbers are an abstract concept because in school, students are given all of these math problems and equations of random numbers that aren't specified as to what they are actually counting, like money or molecules. They're just numbers. Then they grow up not knowing what they were doing.

  • @jsamari I disagree. I think a lot of emphasis is put on concrete amounts. When my little brother was a child, the teacher would always show him sets of items and ask him to count them for homework. However, she reminds him that very big numbers are too tedious to picture visually. That's where multiplication and exponential growth come in. It takes a big stretch of the imagination in the wrong direction for people to think numbers are more than quantities of objects.

  • @jsamari Buzz! That's incorrect. Numbers are abstractions that do not have existence outside of logic. We abstract and quantify reality not the other way around. Numbers are very, very, very tricky. Can you show me square root of two people? How much is 1+2i-17j-13k (quaternions)? Numbers belong to a class of algebraic objects upon which operations are performed but they are not just geometric or cardinal or ordinal. I don't want to beat you up it's just that math is vast and complex.

  • I have never seen a mind without without a brain. I have now seen a brain without a mind. The caller. Why don't people do some deep, I mean deeeep, thinking before they call. I have never seen any video where any generally accepted debater or intelligent person called them. This is the most sadist show there is. Is harrowing to see idiots being bludgeoned to death. I think those who know do not call b/c it needs more than a talk show to discuss philosophical question of this comport.

  • Comment removed

  • why the hell do people with no scientific understanding try to make scientific argument? Ha! Ha! Ha!

  • wow i feel sorry for christians sometimes.......but mostly i laugh

  • This was pretty painful to listen to.

  • poor guy.... he tried and failed. miserably...

  • FFS this 1st cause argument is such weak bullshit.

  • caller "on" something?

  • Aaaaaaarrrrrrrgggggghhhhhhh! Matt hit the 'DUMP' button and get rid of these morons who don't understand the creationist websites they are trying to quote. 

  • This caller is annoying.

  • I wish they would get some intelligent christians on their show! Oh wait! There aren't any!

  • @ThorTheOdinSon LOL, most of them became atheist or will be at some point in time. There are some exceptions however, they will actually compartmentalize their religious beliefs so that it can't touch with (the often contradicting) reality. That's how desperate people are to believe it. They never lived without the religion, they need it, like a junkie needs a drug.

  • @dutchbb1979 agreed

  • 2+2= God Exists!!!

  • Christians say Jesus rose from the dead so why do they get mad when I say he's a zombie?

    Zombie Jesus ate this guys brain!!!

  • @NoFartnFartlore, maybe you don't know what a zombie is. DEFINITION: the body of a dead person given the semblance of life, but mute and will-less, by a supernatural force, usually for some evil purpose.

    When Jesus rose from the dead he was alive. What happened to your brain. Did the cat get it?

  • @JackSShit

    The definition I used is the following:

    "zombie

    n. walking dead, dead returned to life, dead body controlled by supernatural power"

    ~Derived from the Babylon online glossary

    However, I like the part your definition adds about being "usually for some evil purpose" because that is so true if you look at all the evils caused in Jesus' name.

    BTW, the cat didn't eat my brain, JESUS DID!

  • @NoFartnFartlore, nah, the cat got your brain. He didn't get much did he?

  • @JackSShit "maybe you don't know what a zombie is. DEFINITION: the body of a dead person given the semblance of life, but mute and will-less, by a supernatural force, usually for some evil purpose."

    I can tell you haven't seen Return of the Living Dead. The zombies there are neither mute, nor will-less. They just have a strong desire to eat brains to stop some mysterious pain. Either way, you'd not bother objecting to Jesus being a zombie unless you had an emotional attachment to the story.

  • @Gnomefro WAY TO GO DUMMASS, show us some more scify or horror movies to prove your science. HAR HAR HAR

    EPIC FAIL

  • I will never let my kids attend what ever schools people like this caller attended. I can't believe how ignorant this guy sounds. How can you describe something you have never seen. If this is the argument that there just is a God with no evidence then the same argument applies to Unicorns and the flying spaghetti Monster.

  • I will never let my kids attend what ever schools people like this caller attended. I can't believe how ignorant this guy sounds.

  • They need to have Ken on at least once a month. Listening to him fumble around gives me endless entertainment.

  • Unless you use a pump there is no such thing as a jar full of nothing because there is always going to be air in it.

  • I've seen plenty of brains without minds.

  • Th space time thereom of rellahtivally spessiffully states....

  • I'm new to this channel. Can anyone recommend a video with an intelligent and informed challenge?

  • @kokopelli314 Depends on what you consider an intelligent and informed challenge. Just watch all the videos and make your own conclusions.

  • hey matt i believe jgcirydxifouv o if p ih d9tf0gpoh[u7tr yfoutfo uygp tup[j[ojbout

  • "Well it's very simple....just like me." Christ what a retard.

  • Ther'e looking at the camera.

  • what are they looking at if someone is "calling in"?

  • Why does 2+2=4?

    Oh god back to basics.

  • The.. the spacetime... continnuuum... huh...

    When I hear dumb people use scientific words I feel dirty.

  • lame call. cant watch whole thing.

  • Holy fuck. Silver bullet time!

  • Tracie is very, very smart, but lacks wisdom. On her walks does she not realize a miracle: gravity keeps her feet on the ground, air is the right mixture to breath, sun is not to close or far away, magnetic shield keeps harmful rays from destroying our planet, the moon keeps the oceans and weather stabilized, birds help seed new plants and it goes on and on. In our world ALL complex systems need a designer and creator, right?

    You may call it evolution, but we call him the grand designer God.

  • @yhenry77 So you basically just define god as evolution? if that's the case, then your definition of god is pretty useless since you're just calling evolution something else. the air is the right mixture to breath because we have adapted to our environment! the air didn't adapt to us! Btw, gravity and the distance between the earth and the sun is not what we call evolution... Evolution explains how species change over time.

  • @Chaaarge Your exactly right; how about we call it mother nature. What would do you call it?

  • @yhenry77 thing is, you're assuming that there has to be a designer for all complex systems. That's not a fact, just an assumption. The fact that our bodies work in a very complex way and that all species do their own thing, is not caused by any god (as far as we know), it's caused by natural selection. As far as what I would call things, I would call them what they are. I call gravity, gravity. I call evolution, evolution etc...I guess if you want a name for it all I'd call it "our universe"

  • @Chaaarge Let me try this analogy; you walk into large warehouse, the lights are on and the temperature is just right. On the shelves are many different items clock, microwave, computer etc. On the floor are cars of all types: sport, SUV, 4 door etc. In the air there are small model airplanes and helicopters flying. At what point do you say "I wonder if an Intelligent Designer is at work?" Why do we assume that small and large complex biological living systems are exempt from Intelligent Design?

  • @yhenry77 well, atheists don't really exclude the posibillity of an intelligent designer(because there could be). But the burden of proof is not on the atheists. it's on the person claiming that there is such a designer. All that atheists are saying is "we don't know". And you're just making a claim that our world looks "designed". To me, the universe seems relatively random to be honest. As far as the warehouse analogy goes: I know there was a designer because those things don't occur in nature

  • @Chaaarge A recent 15 year science project was completed by J. Craig Venter Institute; they were able to back-engineer a simple bacteria. It took 17 scientists (one former Nobel Prize winner) and supercomputer to assemble the DNA structure. They couldn't get it to spontaneously come alive (abiogenesis), but were able to use a host cell. This is the ONLY science project so far, that engineered a simple life form and was also able to reproduce. Wouldn't we call this an Intelligent Design project?

  • @yhenry77 I think it would be called a science project.

  • @yhenry77 Ah, the old puddle thinking. "This is an interesting hole I find myself in; fits me rather neatly, doesn't it? In fact it fits me staggeringly well! It must have been made to have ME in it!".

  • @yhenry77 "...air is the right mixture to breath, sun is not to close or far away... [that's why God did it]"

    Species that couldn't breath this air, went extinct, and those who could, survived. Species that couldn't withstand our sun's intensity, went extinct, and those who could, survived. [sarcasm] Right, there is absolutely no logic in this, therefore it had to be some kind of miracle. [/sarcasm]

  • Comment removed

  • wait a second... wait a second... isn't the caller that guy who works on the show? ......

  • Science proves that the universe is created 15 billion years ago ....... created?

  • these guys are hilarious! so God the supposed creator of nature itself doesnt exist because we can't measure him? lol! these guys think the God that theists talk about is a an old man with a beard that lives in outer space.

    if God exists, then of course He is not an demonstrable object in nature, he's the creator of it. what exactly do they plan to use on measuring god? a really long ruler? a scale? hes not physical! he's the CREATOR of the physical world.

  • @semajgnik

    But the question they're asking is:  How do you know that?

    Ancient Greeks thought the gods live atop Mount Olympus. We've climbed the mountain, no gods. Ancient people used to think that heaven was up in the clouds. We have airplanes now. No gods up there. So, the modern concept of god has shifted to, "he exists outside of nature." The more we learn about reality, the farther away we push god, so that he becomes impossible to touch.

  • @semajgnik He must exist on some plane, and as existence demands a creator, what created him?

  • @silencesoloud12 What makes God, God, is the fact that He is eternal and self existing. He is at the back of everything. If there is something beyond God, then THAT's God.

  • I do believe abakaradwakalarakarkai but it sounds stupid the way he says it.

  • I love this guy.

  • Man this caller is just angering me by his absolute stupidity.

  • Stevie Wonder and Matt Dillahunty. My mind just imploded.

  • @bibhuna well don't worry, it wasn't very big anyway. You probably should have thrown it out years ago.

  • @MaximusArurealius I'll overlook that, just because it gave me such a laugh.

  • "You'll believe someone walked over water, turned water into wine, that somebody spent 3 days in the stomach of a giant fish, but Evolution blows your mind?"

    Diamond.

  • "I Submit to you that you cannot believe a claim, you do not understand. for example. do you believe that Smerablab gunanabdest nunuyatunu, DO YOU?"

    Gold

  • If god is "a disembodied mind", then how were we created in his image???

  • @DTiberius God exists transcendent to the universe. In this way, he is disembodied.

  • @benabaxter

    Yeah, the "disembodied" and the nonexistent bear a striking resemblance to each other.

  • @DTiberius good question ..... LOL, I would like to know that also

  • @DTiberius It depends on if god has a foreskin.

  • tracy looks kinda hot in this one :D

  • @ 5:48 hey this guy has a valid argument!, you invited this with your philosophical mumbo jumbo with the dice (yes dice not die) What is two? the cosmological argument are both in that realm of thought. If you can't take the heat stay out of the kitchen or better yet stay the f@ck away from Philosophy and stick to Science!!! Stop digging your own graves, leave that to the theists!!!!!!!!! you're lucky he mentioned the invisible man in the sky or you guys would have looked pretty stupid....

  • @ 5:48 hey this guy has a valid argument!, you invited this with your philosophical mumbo jumbo with the dice (yes dice not die) What is two? the cosmological argument are both in that realm of thought. If you can't take the heat stay out of the kitchen or better yet stay the f@ck away from Philosophy and stick to Science!!! Stop digging your own graves, leave that to the theists!!!!!!!!!

  • dam stupid negro

  • The caller apparently learned, that morning, to walk erect.

  • This caller doesnt even understand half of the words that he tries to use.

  • @TheDrunkenAtheist

    Or pronounce them correctly.

  • 2+2 = 4? Of course it does. why? because YOU defined it as this. You can't put a mere definition on God and who he is. God is not bound by constraints of this world. It's amazing to me that no matter how smart these people seem to be they can't grasp the concept that there is someone out there more powerful than them. With all of the human limitations that exist I don't understand why this is so difficult. god Bless!!

  • @chica0616 Its not that they couldn't grasp the concept, its that the concept itself doesn't have any valid evidence to support it. Yes 2+2=4, not because we define it as such, because the base concept holds true through verifiable testing. God, however, cannot be verified to exist, or to not exist for that matter. W/ out any evidence...what reason is there to believe?

  • @chica0616

    Oh I can grasp the concept, alright. But unless you have evidence for your god (however you wish to define it), I am under no burden to take it seriously. Why is that so difficult to grasp for you?

  • @chica0616 Can you provide ANY evidence that there is a God?

  • All the people who call this show must have IQ's under 60.

  • Interesting how the one defining attribute / constant regarding God, so taken for granted and rarely queried, is His divine gender-specificity. That of our self-appointed ruling class. LOL. You couldn't make it up.

  • I had pondered about this since I was a child and I guess it is better to let the matter rest and focus on things that matters most, priorities. We can still live a meaningful life, leaving this 'mystery' aside and reject religions which are man-made. Rather, focus on the universally basic principles of good and bad, that are needed for self preservation and co-existence. Balancing survival of the fittest and co-existence can be difficult though, in practice.

  • show them your fingers! you may call them in any languages and the logic still applies.

    What that dim wit caller may be trying to explain is the cause and effect principle. All that we see can't have just happened by themselves (the effect) and must have caused by something and we call it God. The problem with this logic is that who created God. The way some got round this was to say that this cannot be explained and must accept it (blind faith) otherwise we will be pondering forever.

  • show them your fingers! you may call them in any languages and the logic still applies.

  • show them your fingers!

  • matt hit the nail on the head when he said the guy is just using buzz words, that was what i was thinking almost from the start of the video. he just keeps saying things that he thinks make it sound like he has a clue what he is talking about, but on examination or questioning he makes it clear he is just rambling.

    fun to watch :D

  • I wonder if god watches this show?

  • Pure comedy. Love it. The caller was so out gunned intellectually. I'm continually amazed by how little people have thought stuff through.

  • @MrMegatruth

    Hi transtlantic

  • @WildCatsKitten1

    lol... you still annoyed that people exposed your idiotic beliefs in fairies.

    tell people about your retarded notions of morality. that one always makes a room to laugh! LOL

  • @MrSeymourButtz

    do you think we did not landed on the moon?

    just wondering because you are friends with nasafakedit

  • @MrMegaPedophile

    

    Hi translantic

  • @MaximusArurealius

    tell everyone how we did not land on the moon, this should be good

  • @MrMegaDouche aka translantic

    How about your telling us why you don't know anything about the Van Allen belt?

  • @MaximusArurealius

    tell why you think that the radiation belt would stop us?

    this should be good

  • @MaximusArurealius

    lol... you still denying the moon landings? AHAHAH

    what's next? Lizards rule the world? LOLOL

  • @transpedophile, so you think they actually made it to the moon? HAR HAR HAR you fucking dunce. You deny God but you believe in all the fake shit in the world, moon landings, evolution, carnival geeks, etc., etc. hahahahahaa

  • @MaximusArurealius

    i know they reached the moon. ergo the experiment with the lasers proving that.

    let me guess another bullshit crap that you believe in...

    Homeopathy, right?

  • @transpedophile, Homeopathy? HAR HAR HAR ATTENTION FOLKS

    transpedophile's medical studies are in homeopathy! hahahahahahahaa

  • @MaximusArurealius ATTENTION FOLKS;

    MaxMagoo said Darwin danced naked around a fire in South America.

    Isn't that precious?

  • @MaximusArurealius

    Considering that the vid i have at the front of my profile mocks homeopathy and i have plenty of anti-quackery vids marked as favorites... your claims are always amazing...

    simple pitiful lies is all that you can provide.

  • @transpedophile, so you DO admit that your degree is in homeopathy. I knew it! har har har har hahahahahahaaa BTW you're a self-confessed liar.

    FAIL ASSHOLE

  • @MaximusArurealius

    lol... you are delirious... the claims you pull out of your arse are pure comedy gold

    FAIL MAXASSHOLE

  • @MaximusArurealius Somebody needs a hug.

  • @Mayhamsdead we'll see if we can get transpedophile to hug you.

  • @MaximusArurealius Somebody needs a bigger hug.

  • @transpedophile, ATTENTION! A simple minded little twit here needs you to give him a hug. His name is MaybeAmDead. HAR HAR HAR

  • @MaximusArurealius I wish I could be as cool as you when I grow up :'(

  • @MaybeAymDead, don't count on it. I have been cool like this ALL my life. It just comes natural. If you have it you have it. If you don't you don't. YOU DON'T. You're a fuck up now so don't expect it to change. Once a fuck up always a fuck up. I am really sorry for you.

  • @MaximusArurealius Want to have gay sex yet ?

  • @MaximusArurealius

    you accuse others of whining? lol...

    who the heck is going "wah wah" all the time?!?!?! LOLOL

    you are PWN agaiN! LOSER

  • @MaximusArurealius We have proof that humans have been to the moon. Just as we have proof of evolution. What planet do you live on?