You wrote in in your description that there is no science without experimantal data. Well all science started off as theory and no experimental data was available. If you want to talk about science then you should know what science is. Quran is not a book of Science , It is a book of Signs as Dr Zakir said. If it were to go against established facts not theory then it can be shown that it is not a book of GOD. That was the whole point of his talk but people like you cannot understand that.fail
Can you show me any scientific theory whose basis is not experimental data? After hypothesis is given, then more experiments are done to make that theory valid as multiple theories can exist for explanation of observations. Please first clear your basics of science and then comment.
Great video, spot on! The money that flows into these neferious Islamic institutions is further proof that money doesn't care who owns it. The money flow comes from scientific discoveries (oil) of educated, non-Islamic geologists.
Some Islamicists are born into money and religion. What a crappy mix.
I can only guess where the negative votes on your video came from.
Science in the koran is notheing more than contemptuous, transparent propaganda.
There is no commons sense to worship anything-any religion. But, of course there are negative effect for following religion as it can be seen from your foul language and rudeness...
Hi, what do you think of the Bible and Jesus? Do you have any formed ideas through reading the Bible? What do you think of the character of Jesus and his followers? All the best to you.
if u r 100 percent sure on ur words why dont u go face to face with dr zakir and ask him these things but u cant because u r coward u ppl only speak in ur homes or u tubes
I agree with this dude that Science and Religion should not be mixed. doing so will hurt religion more than the science.
However, he also makes some assumptions about conciousness/universal conciousness(which is hindu bull) as the purpose of religion. I think he defines science as a product of experimentation. Religous folks define it differently. And finally, Does it matter what scientists, acedemics think of it? What matters is what an average person thinks.
mr. also tried to tell his followers that alexander buit a wall of iron and brass to protect a tribe was also the story he heard in syria. no other historian ever recorded a wall of iron and brass built by alexander. it is recorded in koran only. complete fiction. or figment of mr. muhammad's imagination.
mr. muhammad also thought that sun and moon are travelling in fixed orbits at fixed speed. he learned it from greeks too. it wa the theory of ptolemy.
if there is a hint of science in koran, it is because mr. muhammad heard some stories of prevailing greek knowledge in syria. and he dictated them in his book called koran. most of that greek knowledge has been proven wrong like emryology , whic was copied in koran.
yes that is the case..Quran is quite influenced not only by Greek knowledge also by stoic greek philosophy--the idea of religion of poor-dwin- is nothing but prevailing ideas of stoic philosophy .
Well i agree with you for sake of argument. He could have copied it, but i have a question, how come he only copied the correct things and left everything that was wrong. So you think he copied, he must have been really smart considering lack of proof 1400 years ago. I think its impossible to copy ONLY the RIGHT things 1400 years ago which we only know it is right in the past century, don't you?
This poor man doesn't know what he spoke... whi is this bengali sounding guy....I feel pitty on him. Mr. Zakir speoke on established facts on research done. let him see vedio's of the great shcolar of the present time Mr. Zakir in order to find a way to live not like he is living in vein now....
OK The quran came 1400 years ago and in the quran allah mentions things about the earth and how he created them and now scientists have jus found out those things. Allah mentions the barrier between the sweet an salty water in surah ar-rahman. Nobody exept him noes wat it is no scientists no nothing. Dr. zakir naik is the best. And Quran is true and anything besides that is wrong Quran and sunnah.
Kaun sa Nasha mara tha bharvey.. kitni baar kaha hai sasta cheap nasha karkey video mat banaya kar.. ja munh dho apna aur dobara apney video ko dekh .. ek dum bikhari aur chor lag raha hai...
You are making an ad hominem attack, but his points are absolutely valid. It just goes to show that you probably have very little IQ or maybe your head is consumed by the garbage from Quran.
as much as some ppl might agree with you, its best not to say anything. May Allah forgive you and may Allah show him the right paht. Tongue is the one of biggest reason ppl will go to hell...Pleas control your tongue...Salaam
It has become a joke nowadays to say that several scientists have converted to Islam after reading Quran,(it is another matter that the names they give will be of some obscure author of a science text book and that guy has clarified later that it is not so).It shows -that "Islam is most embarrassed by science, and there is a fear that science may cause desertion in Islam, which is propmting some claims of science being found in Quran".A claer admission that Islam has been defeated by science.
Well, I challenge all of you muslims including Zakir Naik to tell one scientific thing that Quran contains which is yet to be proved by science. Just one thing. I also challenge you to name one scientist who has converted to Islam and the name of his invention to prove that he is a scientist. I challenge you msulims to name one invention by a muslim scientist which we and you are all using now such as car,bike, shaver, blade, grass cutter, bulb, monitor, internet, lathe, any design, etc.,?????!
Science only recently in the past century has began to understand what the Quran is talking about in terms of science, in the fields of embryology and other such topics which the Quran describes accurately 1400 years ago.And the muslims scientist/mathematician Al Jabr invented algebra/algorithms which is tought in most schools across the world and without algebra many of the modern scientific and mathematical formulas would not be possible.
786, You are still in infancy of the youtube discussion.Type vedic mathematics n Google and yu will know that what is known as algebra was known to Hindus for 4000 years. Muslims learnt it from Indians and took it to Europe. So, don`t believe muslim propaganda which claims everything as muslim. Type 'zero`s origin' and you will get the same result. And don`t believe Zakir,you will end up red faced, because he lied, misinterpreted`s Qureal meaning to suit to bring embyologic words.Ask Zakir.
I don't know if zakir lied but yr lines on math, vedic went to muslim and then to europe r the truth. muslims can't believe that as they will feel naked if they do so.
With power did We construct the heaven. Verily, We are Able to extend the vastness of space thereof.
This is science of quran. see it ahs expalined the theory of expansion of the universe. Rest of the theory will be taught if you enroll in Taliban Madrasas.
you are just an ignorant. why you go far? look at the creation of human mentioned in Quran stage by stage, and science and ( experement) has proved it too. you search for science in Quran by Harun Yahya. he is not from Saudi either.
you my friend have obviously done your homework!!! I have to give you props! Good work on this Video!!!! I don't ever give anyone credit unless I actually really see that they have a valid point! 5/5 stars
There is no god but Jehova and allah'dalla is his servant. Lord Jehova created and expanded this universe just in six nano second. Allah is a very stupid guy with no formal education.
da guy here is a disbeliever dat's y religion is only for motivating self-esteem to him. look man, no matter wat, a disbeliever's view can never hv useful opinions bout religion simply the fact that he cannot understand the purpose of his life since it's useless no matter how smart you are, you're still going to die n all ur knowledge will come to waste EXCEPT faith. it's that simple.
-Well badboy,somehow you brought a word called 'extend', and now interpret it to mean 'expanding theory'. You also say "some translations vary" inside brackets. Arabic does not have amny words, and modern English has many words which science has to use, so,keep a Quran in one side, keep any book of science on the other side, match words, ( forget the rest of words as poetic,or usage of classic arabic, and put some words like context, and Lo, you hsve science in Quran.
And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander
a different translation
Surah: 51 Aya: 47
With power did We construct the heaven. Verily, We are Able to extend the vastness of space thereof.
None of these even remotely suggest that universe is expanding. Quran is saying that as more muslims come into heaven, Allah is creating more space for them. Besides, the expansion thoery is not yet proved, and may end up as false. Don`t jump, muslims.
first of all the man in this video i donot know what background he has and the things he is stating are merely from his mouth and not established facts and he should know that quran is a revelation by Allah almighty the ncreator of the universe and no one knows his creation better than the Creator so he must study Quran in detail he will also be able those facts which science has discovered 1400 years after it and many which science is yet unable to define and discuss
I have given the simple challenge--show me from Quran the 'hint' of background radiation [CMB] and Redshift [Hubble saw it]...those two are invariant fact--You are stupid-so believe in Allah..but to the world, who does not believe in your stupidity, you have to show experimental evidence..
Lol your such a moron...The quran does not say "BIG BANG" the quran speaks of the way the universe came into existance....some kind of explosion happened then the universe began to develope.....so your the idiot here LOL and im only 16 thats how dumb you are.
i guess you would say same thing about theory of evolution, would not you??
I do not think scientist (to which you are referring to) ever claimed to find new scientific claim (which was discovered for the first time). What they said was Quran contained the knowledge which was discovered in last few centuries. You keep saying those scientists have been bribed. Do you have any evidence to support the claim or probably you think your belief is right.
I find it quite strange that, In discussion of science, it talks about Bin Laden'connection to Zindani. It could be possible that those scientists' statement could have been taken out of context or misled/coerced, however payment of trip for conference/hotel cannot be called bribe. In any case, it would be better if you refute the claim of scientic fact in Quran rather than accussing of bribery or coercion.
Well I do not think those scientist (referred in the article) ever claimed to find new knowledge or new theory or have made new invention using Quran. What they did say was that Quran already made reference to the knowledge recently discovered or probably discovered during ancient greek time (note those knowledge was NOT found using Quran). There is difference in discovering new knowledge or discovering a document which merely confim existing knowledge (and for that you do not need experiment)
If you do not agree with assertion that Quran contain recently discovered knowledge, then that is totally different matter. But my point is that you do not experiment data if a particular knowledge is already discovered (you might need experimental data to refute or to further expand or corrobate data).
The domain of science is strictly defined unlike religion. And this domain does not allow the existence of knowledge/conclusion without referring to a set of data-verified and reproducibly produced. Bigbang is just a conclusion based on CMB-CMB is what will remain unchanged but Big Bang will change.
Therefore talking about Bigbang without reference to CMB/Red Shift does not make any sense or any scientific knowledge. Did any Journal ever referred to Quran for any of their reference?
scientific journal did not refer to Quran for any reference because Quran is NOT a book of science. i do not think All those scientist and even Zakir Naik(referred in the article) also never claimed that Quran is a book of science. They only said it make reference to signs and i do not know why you have problem with such claims. If one finds a book (written in BC era) which mentions of sign that Earth is round (without going into inner details), would you object to such kind of book. Countinued.
journal would not refer to that book (which is NOT a book of science) except from historical perspective. In short Quran is a book of sign and it mention about the sign of universe. If those signs agree with recently discovered knowledge, then what the problem? Some people take pride when recently discovered knowledge has refuted some of the religion, however those very same people seem to have problem when any sign (mention in scriptures) agree with recently discovered knowledge.
first of all the man in this video i donot know what background he has and the things he is stating are merely from his mouth and not established facts and he should know that quran is a revelation by Allah almighty the ncreator of the universe and no one knows his creation better than the Creator so he must study Quran in detail he will also be able those facts which science has discovered 1400 years after it and many which science is yet unable to define and discuss
technologist,economist,chemist hai.Hey, hamare musolman bhaio aur bohino,sare din raat(day & night) Allahdall'a ki kitab Al-kuran porte(read)roho. Believe me, tum sob
(you all) bohut boriah muslim scientist, chemist bon jaoge. Kafir ko baat kobhi nahi
Yes, science was 'continued and improved by Muslims from Greeks and Indians who rejected Islam. Some day Orphan Pamuk, Taslima Nasrin, Salman Rushdi will also be great Islamic scholar because Islam is all about identity crisis
my friend u do not understand what the quran is about an by the way sicence was discovered by muslims (i hate closed minded people like u)an there is alot of sicence in quran
Narrow minded East Bengali BANGAL communalist muslim hater I LEFT HINDU ISM .
You hindu will always treat muslim bad its Jinnah who kicked you out for good reason u dont deserve to live in B DEsh you are traitor and Looking to India a enemy country of b DEsh & Pakistan.Turn coat trator communalist back stabbing HINDU
You cant respect other pronounce other name your self uneducated bangal foreign accent no american understand you .
You wrote in in your description that there is no science without experimantal data. Well all science started off as theory and no experimental data was available. If you want to talk about science then you should know what science is. Quran is not a book of Science , It is a book of Signs as Dr Zakir said. If it were to go against established facts not theory then it can be shown that it is not a book of GOD. That was the whole point of his talk but people like you cannot understand that.fail
sahirdonsocomeon 9 months ago
@sahirdonsocomeon
Can you show me any scientific theory whose basis is not experimental data? After hypothesis is given, then more experiments are done to make that theory valid as multiple theories can exist for explanation of observations. Please first clear your basics of science and then comment.
biplabpal2000 9 months ago
Great video, spot on! The money that flows into these neferious Islamic institutions is further proof that money doesn't care who owns it. The money flow comes from scientific discoveries (oil) of educated, non-Islamic geologists.
Some Islamicists are born into money and religion. What a crappy mix.
I can only guess where the negative votes on your video came from.
Science in the koran is notheing more than contemptuous, transparent propaganda.
CHAS1422 10 months ago
Science and Quran...What a Joke!
Padephole and Quran ....Yes it makes sense!
They want to try to match Hinduism/Buddhism and Sikhism
Whole world knows Islam is Mere Crap and Mere Crap.
mediawatchable 11 months ago
Hey Zakir baby can only make fool of Indian Sub-continent, nobody gives a damm about him as he is a Liar and terrorist supporter.
mediawatchable 11 months ago
Excellent video!
123backinyerface 1 year ago
Great video dude. I am an ex-muslim. Islam contains no science. It is very clear. Whatever it contains absolute rubbish. Even it is immoral.
khalidsayd 1 year ago
Dude Cool man!
dheer1231 1 year ago
Good video brother...
kusalaviro 1 year ago
thanks dude your not the only one who is seeing that naik zakir is a fraud and many people made a video about the Exposing the lies from naik zakir
thanks for this video it helps againt the dirt called islam
006kkk 1 year ago
as long as they have the oil this will happen. once oil runs out, these ppl will fall flat on their own face.
tumhum1 1 year ago
well said! It's high time these idiots have been exposed!
hellocomeinnow 1 year ago
You are very brave to post this video! I haveread the quran andfound very little science and a lot of hatredfor unbelievers.
Ramshobraja 1 year ago
Listen first of its no the Jakir, its Zakir ....!!
NicheXclusive 3 years ago
How can God be separate 4rm Science.If God created universe an everthing in it,Then surely he created science.
vaj99 3 years ago
There is no commons sense to worship anything-any religion. But, of course there are negative effect for following religion as it can be seen from your foul language and rudeness...
biplabpal2000 3 years ago
I am also surprise and getting conviced about rise of radicalism among UK Muslims..
biplabpal2000 3 years ago
Hi, what do you think of the Bible and Jesus? Do you have any formed ideas through reading the Bible? What do you think of the character of Jesus and his followers? All the best to you.
basiladeeb 2 years ago
if u r 100 percent sure on ur words why dont u go face to face with dr zakir and ask him these things but u cant because u r coward u ppl only speak in ur homes or u tubes
don1schon 3 years ago
I requested a public debate with this kid Nayak...they have not replied...
biplabpal2000 3 years ago
den they r cowards if they dont
don1schon 3 years ago
I agree with this dude that Science and Religion should not be mixed. doing so will hurt religion more than the science.
However, he also makes some assumptions about conciousness/universal conciousness(which is hindu bull) as the purpose of religion. I think he defines science as a product of experimentation. Religous folks define it differently. And finally, Does it matter what scientists, acedemics think of it? What matters is what an average person thinks.
Good by to my Coconut friend.
akrasd 3 years ago
consciousness has nothing to with Hinduism..it is a standard topic of body-mind duality in any philosophy-please read
fosaacTV 3 years ago
again i give a life of 25 years to all religions and a life of 10 years to islam.
it will all be over in 25 years. and people will have enough common sense to discard the crap of religions.
zulfitareen 3 years ago
mr. also tried to tell his followers that alexander buit a wall of iron and brass to protect a tribe was also the story he heard in syria. no other historian ever recorded a wall of iron and brass built by alexander. it is recorded in koran only. complete fiction. or figment of mr. muhammad's imagination.
zulfitareen 3 years ago
mr. muhammad also thought that sun and moon are travelling in fixed orbits at fixed speed. he learned it from greeks too. it wa the theory of ptolemy.
zulfitareen 3 years ago
if there is a hint of science in koran, it is because mr. muhammad heard some stories of prevailing greek knowledge in syria. and he dictated them in his book called koran. most of that greek knowledge has been proven wrong like emryology , whic was copied in koran.
zulfitareen 3 years ago
yes that is the case..Quran is quite influenced not only by Greek knowledge also by stoic greek philosophy--the idea of religion of poor-dwin- is nothing but prevailing ideas of stoic philosophy .
fosaacTV 3 years ago
Well i agree with you for sake of argument. He could have copied it, but i have a question, how come he only copied the correct things and left everything that was wrong. So you think he copied, he must have been really smart considering lack of proof 1400 years ago. I think its impossible to copy ONLY the RIGHT things 1400 years ago which we only know it is right in the past century, don't you?
arafatsahil 3 years ago
religions will be over in 25 years. islam may not last even 10 years.
zulfitareen 3 years ago
i agree with you 100%.
zulfitareen 3 years ago
i love you brother
zulfitareen 3 years ago
This poor man doesn't know what he spoke... whi is this bengali sounding guy....I feel pitty on him. Mr. Zakir speoke on established facts on research done. let him see vedio's of the great shcolar of the present time Mr. Zakir in order to find a way to live not like he is living in vein now....
QCParvez 3 years ago
Did u see any drunk ever understood he is out of mind?
biplabpal2000 3 years ago
Not Science but SIGNS!!!!
If you are looking in Quran for Formel and Details........
In the Quran we are talking about SIGNS!!!
Think the Quran are speaking to the Arab vor 1400 Year and the man of today...
Example in the Quran: we are reading there the univers is expanding.....
Again SIGNS and not Science
almao2006 3 years ago
Keith L. Moore
almao2006 3 years ago
OK The quran came 1400 years ago and in the quran allah mentions things about the earth and how he created them and now scientists have jus found out those things. Allah mentions the barrier between the sweet an salty water in surah ar-rahman. Nobody exept him noes wat it is no scientists no nothing. Dr. zakir naik is the best. And Quran is true and anything besides that is wrong Quran and sunnah.
afglala 3 years ago 2
LAUGH IS ON YOU IDIOT...Quran is not a Science bookits A BOOK OF SIGNS
khanbhai7860 3 years ago
Kaun sa Nasha mara tha bharvey.. kitni baar kaha hai sasta cheap nasha karkey video mat banaya kar.. ja munh dho apna aur dobara apney video ko dekh .. ek dum bikhari aur chor lag raha hai...
akidupakidu123 3 years ago
Is it me or is it really hard to understand what this guy is on about?
786GAF 3 years ago
you don't even know what you're talking about..!
Rai242 3 years ago
Talking about science in religion is a criminal offense? what are you smoking? where do you live?
momin8888 3 years ago
Nice microphone
UwereCreated 3 years ago
OMG these ugly black indians are every where and the worst is that they are very stupid and still start talking about anything that they don't know!
Fuck you ugly indians.
Mustafa4u 3 years ago
You are making an ad hominem attack, but his points are absolutely valid. It just goes to show that you probably have very little IQ or maybe your head is consumed by the garbage from Quran.
statickk14 3 years ago 2
as much as some ppl might agree with you, its best not to say anything. May Allah forgive you and may Allah show him the right paht. Tongue is the one of biggest reason ppl will go to hell...Pleas control your tongue...Salaam
mm498 3 years ago
It has become a joke nowadays to say that several scientists have converted to Islam after reading Quran,(it is another matter that the names they give will be of some obscure author of a science text book and that guy has clarified later that it is not so).It shows -that "Islam is most embarrassed by science, and there is a fear that science may cause desertion in Islam, which is propmting some claims of science being found in Quran".A claer admission that Islam has been defeated by science.
uddathunni 3 years ago
Well, I challenge all of you muslims including Zakir Naik to tell one scientific thing that Quran contains which is yet to be proved by science. Just one thing. I also challenge you to name one scientist who has converted to Islam and the name of his invention to prove that he is a scientist. I challenge you msulims to name one invention by a muslim scientist which we and you are all using now such as car,bike, shaver, blade, grass cutter, bulb, monitor, internet, lathe, any design, etc.,?????!
uddathunni 3 years ago
Science only recently in the past century has began to understand what the Quran is talking about in terms of science, in the fields of embryology and other such topics which the Quran describes accurately 1400 years ago.And the muslims scientist/mathematician Al Jabr invented algebra/algorithms which is tought in most schools across the world and without algebra many of the modern scientific and mathematical formulas would not be possible.
786GAF 3 years ago
786, You are still in infancy of the youtube discussion.Type vedic mathematics n Google and yu will know that what is known as algebra was known to Hindus for 4000 years. Muslims learnt it from Indians and took it to Europe. So, don`t believe muslim propaganda which claims everything as muslim. Type 'zero`s origin' and you will get the same result. And don`t believe Zakir,you will end up red faced, because he lied, misinterpreted`s Qureal meaning to suit to bring embyologic words.Ask Zakir.
uddathunni 3 years ago
I don't know if zakir lied but yr lines on math, vedic went to muslim and then to europe r the truth. muslims can't believe that as they will feel naked if they do so.
pearl1729 3 years ago
Surah: 51 Aya: 47
With power did We construct the heaven. Verily, We are Able to extend the vastness of space thereof.
This is science of quran. see it ahs expalined the theory of expansion of the universe. Rest of the theory will be taught if you enroll in Taliban Madrasas.
uddathunni 3 years ago
You have not *EXPOSED* anything, except the fact you need to wash your face and take a shower.
ozmanbro 3 years ago
you are just an ignorant. why you go far? look at the creation of human mentioned in Quran stage by stage, and science and ( experement) has proved it too. you search for science in Quran by Harun Yahya. he is not from Saudi either.
mkhoubiari 3 years ago
you my friend have obviously done your homework!!! I have to give you props! Good work on this Video!!!! I don't ever give anyone credit unless I actually really see that they have a valid point! 5/5 stars
SecillianOEspanol 3 years ago
There is no god but Jehova and allah'dalla is his servant. Lord Jehova created and expanded this universe just in six nano second. Allah is a very stupid guy with no formal education.
yusup2 3 years ago
go to the references and check for yourself
In the Quran chapter: 51 Verse: 47
And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander
a different translation
Chapter: 51 Verse: 47
With power did We construct the heaven. Verily, We are Able to extend the vastness of space thereof.
The universe is mentioned as 'heaven'
badboy642 3 years ago
so what theres no god? we die and thats it?
after all the hard we work and livin 4 50, 60,70 or 80 years, thats it?
Think about it
There are scientific evidence in the quar'an read it yourself, dont listen to what others say. read it yourself.
muslimpwincess21 3 years ago
da guy here is a disbeliever dat's y religion is only for motivating self-esteem to him. look man, no matter wat, a disbeliever's view can never hv useful opinions bout religion simply the fact that he cannot understand the purpose of his life since it's useless no matter how smart you are, you're still going to die n all ur knowledge will come to waste EXCEPT faith. it's that simple.
khairulridwan 3 years ago
The big bang is a theory yes.
But the universe expanding is a fact.
In the quran it say's
Surah: 51 Aya: 47
With power did We construct the heaven. Verily, We are Able to extend the vastness of space thereof.(some translations vary)
The quran does not talk about the big bang but about the expanding universe
badboy642 3 years ago
Koran does not speak about expanding 'universe but skys falling apart--that is not expanding universe/./so stop fooling yourself//
biplabpal2000 3 years ago
go to the reference i gave you from the quran and check for yourself
Surah: 51 Aya: 47
And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander
a different translation
Surah: 51 Aya: 47
With power did We construct the heaven. Verily, We are Able to extend the vastness of space thereof.
badboy642 3 years ago
-Well badboy,somehow you brought a word called 'extend', and now interpret it to mean 'expanding theory'. You also say "some translations vary" inside brackets. Arabic does not have amny words, and modern English has many words which science has to use, so,keep a Quran in one side, keep any book of science on the other side, match words, ( forget the rest of words as poetic,or usage of classic arabic, and put some words like context, and Lo, you hsve science in Quran.
uddathunni 3 years ago
go to the reference i gave you from the quran and check for yourself
Surah: 51 Aya: 47
And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander
a different translation
Surah: 51 Aya: 47
With power did We construct the heaven. Verily, We are Able to extend the vastness of space thereof.
badboy642 3 years ago
and where does it speak of 'expansion'??
biplabpal2000 3 years ago
EVIDENCE to prove quran is from god: Surah 30 Ayat: 2,3
The Romans have been defeated In the LOWEST land, and they, after their defeat will be victorious.
GO search for the lowest land on earth( close to dead sea exactly where the battle happened) and then judge for yourself.
Atrinz7 3 years ago
Surah: 51 Aya: 47
And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander
a different translation
Surah: 51 Aya: 47
With power did We construct the heaven. Verily, We are Able to extend the vastness of space thereof.
None of these even remotely suggest that universe is expanding. Quran is saying that as more muslims come into heaven, Allah is creating more space for them. Besides, the expansion thoery is not yet proved, and may end up as false. Don`t jump, muslims.
uddathunni 3 years ago
first of all the man in this video i donot know what background he has and the things he is stating are merely from his mouth and not established facts and he should know that quran is a revelation by Allah almighty the ncreator of the universe and no one knows his creation better than the Creator so he must study Quran in detail he will also be able those facts which science has discovered 1400 years after it and many which science is yet unable to define and discuss
ravian214 3 years ago
The big bang is a theory yes.
But the universe expanding is a fact.
In the quran it say's
Surah: 51 Aya: 47
badboy642 3 years ago
The big bang is a theory yes.
But the universe expanding is a fact.
In the quran it say's
Surah: 51 Aya: 47
With power did We construct the heaven. Verily, We are Able to extend the vastness of space thereof.(some translations vary)
The quran does not talk about the big bang but about the expanding universe
badboy642 3 years ago
I have given the simple challenge--show me from Quran the 'hint' of background radiation [CMB] and Redshift [Hubble saw it]...those two are invariant fact--You are stupid-so believe in Allah..but to the world, who does not believe in your stupidity, you have to show experimental evidence..
biplabpal2000 3 years ago
Lol your such a moron...The quran does not say "BIG BANG" the quran speaks of the way the universe came into existance....some kind of explosion happened then the universe began to develope.....so your the idiot here LOL and im only 16 thats how dumb you are.
dkamath 3 years ago
ame tumare ki masli band kardga to tum ronay lagjaga
dodica54 3 years ago
Jesus is Savior
ofreshartist 3 years ago
i guess you would say same thing about theory of evolution, would not you??
I do not think scientist (to which you are referring to) ever claimed to find new scientific claim (which was discovered for the first time). What they said was Quran contained the knowledge which was discovered in last few centuries. You keep saying those scientists have been bribed. Do you have any evidence to support the claim or probably you think your belief is right.
sameer9900 3 years ago
It has been well established that they have been bribed or their comments coerced..please read the report from wallstreet journal..
biplabpal2000 3 years ago
the link of the journal is posted in the description of the video..
biplabpal2000 3 years ago
I find it quite strange that, In discussion of science, it talks about Bin Laden'connection to Zindani. It could be possible that those scientists' statement could have been taken out of context or misled/coerced, however payment of trip for conference/hotel cannot be called bribe. In any case, it would be better if you refute the claim of scientic fact in Quran rather than accussing of bribery or coercion.
sameer9900 3 years ago
This has been clearly refuted in video-there is no science without documented experiments..
where is document of experimental result?
Science is domain of knowledge that does exist without experiment..
biplabpal2000 3 years ago
Well I do not think those scientist (referred in the article) ever claimed to find new knowledge or new theory or have made new invention using Quran. What they did say was that Quran already made reference to the knowledge recently discovered or probably discovered during ancient greek time (note those knowledge was NOT found using Quran). There is difference in discovering new knowledge or discovering a document which merely confim existing knowledge (and for that you do not need experiment)
sameer9900 3 years ago
If you do not agree with assertion that Quran contain recently discovered knowledge, then that is totally different matter. But my point is that you do not experiment data if a particular knowledge is already discovered (you might need experimental data to refute or to further expand or corrobate data).
sameer9900 3 years ago
The domain of science is strictly defined unlike religion. And this domain does not allow the existence of knowledge/conclusion without referring to a set of data-verified and reproducibly produced. Bigbang is just a conclusion based on CMB-CMB is what will remain unchanged but Big Bang will change.
Therefore talking about Bigbang without reference to CMB/Red Shift does not make any sense or any scientific knowledge. Did any Journal ever referred to Quran for any of their reference?
biplabpal2000 3 years ago
scientific journal did not refer to Quran for any reference because Quran is NOT a book of science. i do not think All those scientist and even Zakir Naik(referred in the article) also never claimed that Quran is a book of science. They only said it make reference to signs and i do not know why you have problem with such claims. If one finds a book (written in BC era) which mentions of sign that Earth is round (without going into inner details), would you object to such kind of book. Countinued.
sameer9900 3 years ago
journal would not refer to that book (which is NOT a book of science) except from historical perspective. In short Quran is a book of sign and it mention about the sign of universe. If those signs agree with recently discovered knowledge, then what the problem? Some people take pride when recently discovered knowledge has refuted some of the religion, however those very same people seem to have problem when any sign (mention in scriptures) agree with recently discovered knowledge.
sameer9900 3 years ago
first of all the man in this video i donot know what background he has and the things he is stating are merely from his mouth and not established facts and he should know that quran is a revelation by Allah almighty the ncreator of the universe and no one knows his creation better than the Creator so he must study Quran in detail he will also be able those facts which science has discovered 1400 years after it and many which science is yet unable to define and discuss
ravian214 3 years ago
Yea kafir kobhi nehi manegi Allah subhanu d'alla kitna boriah(great) scientist,
technologist,economist,chemist hai.Hey, hamare musolman bhaio aur bohino,sare din raat(day & night) Allahdall'a ki kitab Al-kuran porte(read)roho. Believe me, tum sob
(you all) bohut boriah muslim scientist, chemist bon jaoge. Kafir ko baat kobhi nahi
sunna(never listen).
Well done Biplob. It is sad no disillusioned
ex-muslim dared to come forword to debunk the
salesman zakir naik.
yusup2 3 years ago
Quran is not a book of science my friend
naiyyer 3 years ago
Awesome dude you are awesome period
suryak76 3 years ago
many scientist converted to islam due to scientific information in quaran. so you have your speeching, but it is not true for many scientist.
naquibmahmood 3 years ago
Yes..and many of them were bribed to pose for a video as --look out at their profile..mostly East European scientists --poorly paid so they need
petro dollar--in USA only 8% scientists believe in God--forget about Islam..you are just a victim of Arab petro dollar..
biplabpal2000 3 years ago
God bless USA
naquibmahmood 3 years ago
Yes, science was 'continued and improved by Muslims from Greeks and Indians who rejected Islam. Some day Orphan Pamuk, Taslima Nasrin, Salman Rushdi will also be great Islamic scholar because Islam is all about identity crisis
biplabpal2000 3 years ago
so true
iqbalnaved 3 years ago
my friend u do not understand what the quran is about an by the way sicence was discovered by muslims (i hate closed minded people like u)an there is alot of sicence in quran
xlegendarymox 3 years ago
Narrow minded East Bengali BANGAL communalist muslim hater I LEFT HINDU ISM .
You hindu will always treat muslim bad its Jinnah who kicked you out for good reason u dont deserve to live in B DEsh you are traitor and Looking to India a enemy country of b DEsh & Pakistan.Turn coat trator communalist back stabbing HINDU
You cant respect other pronounce other name your self uneducated bangal foreign accent no american understand you .
SadhuNag 3 years ago
some parts of kuran are copied from jews, cristians and hindus, the part that are not copied are ridiculous pseudo-science
VedikGyan 3 years ago
Great video! A very insightful video! It is very nice to see such an articulate person as yourself point out this very important issue.
iviewthetube 3 years ago 2
Zakir Naik lost all credibility with me when I heard him calling for the death sentence for apostates.
The Quran lost all scientific credibility when it said "torture" "kill" the unbelievers.
These types of coercions undermine inquiry and the scientific method.
One cannot say, "Believe in my "scientific theory" or else you will be tortured or killed;" that is not how the scientific method works.
iviewthetube 3 years ago 2