I was all "Oh, my God!!", too. and I almost hit my head on the coffee table. lucky for me there was a three inch gap between the table and the couch and I missed. and I'll bet my neighbor was happy for Kris...I could hear stamping feet coming from atop of my living room celing.
Kris Allen's album is the lowest selling album by a winner yet to date! Where as Adams album is platinum over seas and Canada and has sold over 800,000 copies in the U.S. Numbers don't lie!
i think they both are great! but adam is more famous than kris.. btw..why should anyone te adam?! whats wron with him...he's an amazing singer,....i just dont get it....haters~~!!! dont bea hater!! i love them both!!nothin's wrong with that
If Adam lost because he was gay, then he might as well not gotten to the final at all. All this is past and gone. Both of them are enjoying their careers and are friends. At this point Adam is leading in sales but Kris is earning more because of his co-writes. I learnt he's getting about $30,000 off every 80,000 copies of his albums sold just for his 8 co-writes and i sole write. Whilst Adam needs to sell almost 3x that to earn that much . So both are equally good.
where did you get that info. You are just being delusional. Both guys are doing okay and don't forget that we never knew who was getting most votes though tje judges wanted us to believe Adam was the front runner all season. I feel Kris was leadind at some point when other contestants got voted off. Their fans were voting for Kris. And Kris had a well organised fanbase in his homestate. We southerners are like that. Don't expect anyone from CA to win idol.
Just to let everyone know, at the end of each show this comment pops up on the screen really fast, and it says that the Producers of American Idol are allowed to veto the decision of the votes. In other words, the Producers of American Idol decided they wanted Kris to win because they did not want a GAY American Idol. Adam is the real winner. The same thing happened with Clay Aiken and Ruben Studdard, because Clay was rumored to be gay.
Adam was a good singer but surely was not the best. He didn't deserve to win mainly because he did the same thing in every song he performed...he screamed! Kris liked to mix it up. Plus Kris was a better musician then Adam. How many times did you see Kris with a guitar in his hands or playing a piano? How many times did you see Adam? And to sum it up Kris's voice was way more dynamic. He deserved his win.
sorry BlackSharpiesLive but maybe Adam don't play instruments but he is a singer and a brilliant performer(!!!) and just a reminder it's a singing contest!
you really should read the article- "Opera experts rate Idols Adam Lambert" (google it) this will explain the issue about his "screaming"
How sad...even doogie was bored...sorry but Adam will definately go furher..Kris is like cute n all...but the winner is Adam.Unless we don't get real judges judging then this show will always be rigged...why is someone allowed to vote hundreds of times??
in 1908 a lady named sally rusa was in the woods looking for a dog until a ghost came and killed her so if ur reading this u will find a bloody body in your closet hanging there haunting you and will kill you and ur family and if u want to stop this just sends this to 6 videos in 30 mins or this will happen good luck
people are caling kris a dark horse because he really looks like a horse!!!!it would be better if you call him white horse!!!adam is too good for that amateur regular karaoke bastard!!!!
A Ad Ada Adam♫ Adam W Adam Wa Adam Was♫ Adam Was R Adam Was Ro Adam Was Rob Adam Was Robbe Adam Was Robbed♫ ♫ADAM♫LAMBERT♫ WAS ROBBED COPY AND PASTE IF YOU THINK ADAM LAMBERT SHOULD HAVE WON AMERICAN IDOL
It doesn't matter who wins it seems the runner up always gets to be successful too. Maybe even more than the winner. I dont really watch the show though.. so I don't really know who either of them are
I hate how they call him the underdog. Obviously people liked him more because he won by a large margin. It's just that American Idol didn't give him enough attention.
i hate when people are so full of themselves that they think they're opinion is the only one that matters. it wasn't rigged. no matter who won it was obvious people would say it was rigged. adam has a good voice but dear lord his scream was annoying. kris allen won because he is talented. they'll both go far and they are both good singers but kris is an artist, adam isnt. and it wasn't rigged.
omg that was hiilarious:L i didnt watch american idol..cos well im nto from america but use all seem to get reallly into it:L like all the reactio vids are so funny:L
I'm not a big fan of American Idol, but it is obvious that Adam will be 10 times as successful as Kris...I guarantee it. There are plenty of Kris Allens out there. Adam Lambert is a unique talent. They are both stars, but whenever they were on stage together, Adam shined the brightest.
It's obvious that Adam is better but it is still good that Kris won because now Adam will be able to make the music he wants to. If you win American Idol you have no control over what type of album you make, they decide for you.
It's interesting to watch the various reactions from different fan camps. All the top 13 were very talented. After Kris sang "Heartless," I thought it was in the bag. Not surprised at all that he won (although I did smile and applaud!).
And as Ann Powers of the Los Angeles Times pointed out, "Allen has his undeniable strong points. In terms of the music industry, he cuts a more contemporary figure than Lambert: Many stars now (specifically rock-oriented, male ones) tend to do better when they draw themselves to scale, offering songs that make fans feel warm and connected, not blown away."
Stupid result. Adam is the best singer that American Idol has ever had. Kris is just an average singer. This is proof that most Americans are homophobic bigots.
I cried! I couldn't watch the rest of idol! I mean I couldn't bare watch Kris sing ADAMS SONG!!! I couldn't bare it, had to go outside and cry for a half hour. So depressed! Biggest upset in Idol History, America totally got that one wrong, and it shows on all the judges faces, and even kris said himself Adam was the one who deserved it!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
no dis was not n upset last year was and kris should of won he is da true star he can play alot of instraments and can sing but adam can barely sing!!!!!!
oh my god, you people are acting like this is a presidential election or something... dude its a friggin reality tv show! get over yourselves! and besides american idol was so not adam's thing. he did not belong in this competition. he is more of a theater sream-in-your-face type of guy. kris is more down to earth, reagular joe, under dog... he truely is an american idol.
adam should have won!!! Everyone knows it
hollowayj1000 4 months ago
I was all "Oh, my God!!", too. and I almost hit my head on the coffee table. lucky for me there was a three inch gap between the table and the couch and I missed. and I'll bet my neighbor was happy for Kris...I could hear stamping feet coming from atop of my living room celing.
maziebunny2 1 year ago
kriss alllens sucks baby dick
Pjsproductionz 1 year ago
@Pjsproductionz i like u!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
psychogrl3 9 months ago
I almost cried when Kris won, I was so pissed off. I was like "Damn, I need to get my hearing checked cause I know he didn't just say Kris won!!"
It was a bad year^^
wolfalchemistofmoon 1 year ago
the dog was obviously a adam lambert fan!
billywish 1 year ago 3
Kris Allen's album is the lowest selling album by a winner yet to date! Where as Adams album is platinum over seas and Canada and has sold over 800,000 copies in the U.S. Numbers don't lie!
gizz88 1 year ago
TOP 5 Best Ever Idols :
1- Adam Lambert
2-Carrie Underwood
3-Kelly Clarkson
4-Elliot Yamin
5-Melinda Doolitle
PuteraMeor 1 year ago
your stupid Kris didnt deserve it
MegaGood5 1 year ago
@MegaGood5 the words you said totally shows your stupid...
lulushi8 1 year ago
i think they both are great! but adam is more famous than kris.. btw..why should anyone te adam?! whats wron with him...he's an amazing singer,....i just dont get it....haters~~!!! dont bea hater!! i love them both!!nothin's wrong with that
superstar7soso 2 years ago
i hateeeeeeeeeeee adam
gypsyboyinboston781 2 years ago
@gypsyboyinboston781 shut the fuck up i hate u
psychogrl3 9 months ago
lol the dog was like wtf
Zeus1845 2 years ago 3
If Adam lost because he was gay, then he might as well not gotten to the final at all. All this is past and gone. Both of them are enjoying their careers and are friends. At this point Adam is leading in sales but Kris is earning more because of his co-writes. I learnt he's getting about $30,000 off every 80,000 copies of his albums sold just for his 8 co-writes and i sole write. Whilst Adam needs to sell almost 3x that to earn that much . So both are equally good.
TheVice1234 2 years ago
cheyenne,
where did you get that info. You are just being delusional. Both guys are doing okay and don't forget that we never knew who was getting most votes though tje judges wanted us to believe Adam was the front runner all season. I feel Kris was leadind at some point when other contestants got voted off. Their fans were voting for Kris. And Kris had a well organised fanbase in his homestate. We southerners are like that. Don't expect anyone from CA to win idol.
TheVice1234 2 years ago
Just to let everyone know, at the end of each show this comment pops up on the screen really fast, and it says that the Producers of American Idol are allowed to veto the decision of the votes. In other words, the Producers of American Idol decided they wanted Kris to win because they did not want a GAY American Idol. Adam is the real winner. The same thing happened with Clay Aiken and Ruben Studdard, because Clay was rumored to be gay.
cheyennesummersexton 2 years ago 2
I NEVER hear anything about Kris....only Adam. Adam won that night, regardless. I bet even Kris knows it too.
honiotes1 2 years ago 2
I WAS MAD WHEN ADAM LOST MY MOM TOLD ME TO SETLE DOWN!!!
Adam Should of won
AdamLambertsCool 2 years ago
0:56.You scared the doggie!
bradlove79 2 years ago
wtf orange shirt girl. its ok to be excited but your on camera
rcrawf7799 2 years ago
Adam was the best contestant ever ben on AI!!!
gwini1 2 years ago 7
Adam was a good singer but surely was not the best. He didn't deserve to win mainly because he did the same thing in every song he performed...he screamed! Kris liked to mix it up. Plus Kris was a better musician then Adam. How many times did you see Kris with a guitar in his hands or playing a piano? How many times did you see Adam? And to sum it up Kris's voice was way more dynamic. He deserved his win.
BlackSharpiesLive 2 years ago
sorry BlackSharpiesLive but maybe Adam don't play instruments but he is a singer and a brilliant performer(!!!) and just a reminder it's a singing contest!
you really should read the article- "Opera experts rate Idols Adam Lambert" (google it) this will explain the issue about his "screaming"
gwini1 2 years ago
Yes but it's also a contest based on who can do the best musically.
BlackSharpiesLive 2 years ago
in this case Adam will definitely do better... just wait and see (by the way he's already doing better)
gwini1 2 years ago 2
Whatever floats your boat.
BlackSharpiesLive 2 years ago
how is he doing better? Kris is out selling him on the digital download charts and is making the MOST for the tour.
naitch4life 2 years ago
where the heck did you get that idea?! Kris has already been on the download chart! Do your research!
leah1597 2 years ago
adam sucked but all the lambert fans apparentley didnt vote a lot times i voted almost all night
maggiemay95 2 years ago
how does Adam suck??
AdamLambertsCool 2 years ago
WOO KRIS!!! he deserved it
HalfDeadFatGuy0 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
kriss>adam
kalvenandothers 2 years ago
yeaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa 314 votes for kris for the finale!
laurlaur888 2 years ago
kriss is just cute adam has the pipes!lmao
hahalolmayawilliams 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Congrats Kris!
Love your music
forquan 2 years ago
are fucking kidding me?
get a life
mdady24 2 years ago
Si eres latino o el español es tu primera lengua haz lo siguiente en el orden que aparece y quedaras asombrado:
1.) Lee lo escrito anteriormente una vez mas.
2.) Pega este comentario en 4 videos mas.
3.) Cierra los ojos por 4 o 7 segundos.
4.) Mira hacia atras.
TE SORPRENDISTE VERDAD
jgsith92 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Si eres latino o el español es tu primera lengua haz lo siguiente en el orden que aparece y quedaras asombrado:
1.) Lee lo escrito anteriormente una vez mas.
2.) Pega este comentario en 4 videos mas.
3.) Cierra los ojos por 4 o 7 segundos.
4.) Mira hacia atras.
TE SORPRENDISTE VERDAD
Crazymurderer10 2 years ago
Great reaction video! I was shocked, too, having been a Lambet Lover since the audition. I think he was the best and most consistent all season.
But Adam seemed genuinely happy for Kris, and he showed a lost of class when it was announced. It makes me love him more.
maxtexture 2 years ago 2
adam should of won i liked him since his audition
alexa1rocks 2 years ago 2
How sad...even doogie was bored...sorry but Adam will definately go furher..Kris is like cute n all...but the winner is Adam.Unless we don't get real judges judging then this show will always be rigged...why is someone allowed to vote hundreds of times??
udonthavetotellme 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
in 1908 a lady named sally rusa was in the woods looking for a dog until a ghost came and killed her so if ur reading this u will find a bloody body in your closet hanging there haunting you and will kill you and ur family and if u want to stop this just sends this to 6 videos in 30 mins or this will happen good luck
zomgProductionStudio 2 years ago
Adam was robbed girls.poor him.Adam definitely is the BEST ever idol.
PuteraMeor 2 years ago
woow. way to copy. haha.
mrsjoejonasforev 2 years ago
:32 over and over and over again lmao the girl in the orange xD
trumpetgirl5 2 years ago
LOL You're so bad!
anselmsim 2 years ago
COPPIERS.
natxxjessx3 2 years ago
aww look at the dogg =(
andyelde 2 years ago
lol. the dog was like "wtf". back to sleep.
natetechur 2 years ago
Look at the fat old fuck off to the far right. He looks like he legitimately cares and is surprised. Wow. You are an inspiration to us all.
simmsinns 2 years ago
people are caling kris a dark horse because he really looks like a horse!!!!it would be better if you call him white horse!!!adam is too good for that amateur regular karaoke bastard!!!!
pastaym 2 years ago
u look like horse! u stupid
10respect 2 years ago
WTF!!! do you know what music is. Adam is the BEST and is uncomparable. Adam Rocks the World.
iloveadamlambertmuch 2 years ago
that girl in orange was crazy but funny lol
katelynmiracle 2 years ago
Showed these 14 year old girls freaking over Kris winning..but this was better..
Ecksntrick8 2 years ago
That was fun to watch you all's reaction - I'm with the girl in orange --- YAY Kris!!! =-)
GoodSnowQueen 2 years ago
wow, its not like u won the lottery lmfao.
ajdis 2 years ago
get a life... all of you
84westrock 2 years ago
lol at including the dog. haha
newyorkmusicconcerts 2 years ago
your freaks come down...
JOSH1669 2 years ago
the dog doesn't seem too happy.
the psycho woman almost punched those other girls in the face.
dang.
it would've been funner if she'd kicked the dog on accident.
wassup9 2 years ago
its the same shitt as david cook
lilblackfish2009 2 years ago
u ppl suck adam should have won kris sucks
surfergurl345 2 years ago
girl in orange is beast. YAY! kris allen!
macbookchris00 2 years ago
umm... whats american idol... im guessing its a copy of pop idol but for america...and yes girl that screamed he one get over yourself...
liviudrop 2 years ago
HAHAH The girl with the glasses owns
ryjo911 2 years ago
Love the girl in orange! Aahhaha
TrueGuy 2 years ago
lol at the girl in orange and the dog
ashmeera101 2 years ago
the dogs like "fuck american idol, im gonna put my gina on your rug"
smittymx6 2 years ago
Now I know why you were screaming "oh my GOD", because apparently that's what that show has become to you...(your god)
What could one expect though, I mean it is called American "Idol". and in the bible, Idols are forbidden.
BloodTar 2 years ago
oh brother, get over it BloodTar! Your an idiot.
txboi1805 2 years ago
the girl in orange ought to be proud after successfully casting over 50 million votes for kris allen
Bub26 2 years ago
Actualy, she voted for Kris once and Adam once. ;]
TMDtv 2 years ago
Yes. The girl in the orange IS awesome. LMFAO
^.^
tarynmcmaster 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
lusivaa 2 years ago
It doesn't matter who wins it seems the runner up always gets to be successful too. Maybe even more than the winner. I dont really watch the show though.. so I don't really know who either of them are
CanwllCorfe615 2 years ago
LMAO i love her reaction :D hahahah
PyroKinetic 2 years ago
LOL AT THE DOG.
Sovetskikh 2 years ago 2
I know!! LMAO. She makes sure all's well and then takes a snooze!
maryquant1967 2 years ago
rolfmao xD
the girl in orange... hilarious haha
sweetroxi23 2 years ago
All idol is turning into is a nick show for girls..... I have no idea of i'll watch season 9... Idol needs big changes......
teeftaller7 2 years ago
I hate how they call him the underdog. Obviously people liked him more because he won by a large margin. It's just that American Idol didn't give him enough attention.
britneyrocks 2 years ago
LOL I love how the orange girl is the only one who's happy and everyone else is like "..........."
iAsian92 2 years ago 10
girl in the orange is AWESOME
Barre1998 2 years ago 3
wow u guys r boring
aaronfuegopop 2 years ago
Wow this is sad.
ArmadylGodSwordsmen 2 years ago
Yea Kris Won Adam Goth!!
cutieviki 2 years ago
I love Kriss!
hephersmith08 2 years ago
basicaly everyone hates kris allen but he won..................this is so RIGGED
ThisIsSpartaBob 2 years ago
i hate when people are so full of themselves that they think they're opinion is the only one that matters. it wasn't rigged. no matter who won it was obvious people would say it was rigged. adam has a good voice but dear lord his scream was annoying. kris allen won because he is talented. they'll both go far and they are both good singers but kris is an artist, adam isnt. and it wasn't rigged.
AVERYfunperson 2 years ago 4
wait, i'm confused. r they happy that kris won or r they sad?
tvfreako374 2 years ago
read the discription. :P
TMDtv 2 years ago
well i like this one since it doesn't make my head goes crazy hearing the screams
dazzledazzlezah 2 years ago
LOL!!
when the orange was excited the dog was lyk r u okayy??xD
xMissAngelique101x 2 years ago 2
haha girl in orange
DisneyAlias47 2 years ago
look at the little girl beside her.shes covering her ears hahahahaha....!@!!!:-)
piperdawn000 2 years ago
i think tat was a guy lol if ur talking bout the right side of her
RQisbetter23 2 years ago
He's a boy~ he just has long hair.
TMDtv 2 years ago
callate gorda puta
surfistamalucko 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You would not believe my firnds reaction!!! It was explosive!!! I posted it on my page too!
utubesuckstube 2 years ago
You would not believe my firnds reaction!!! It was explosive!!! I posted it on my page too!
utubesuckstube 2 years ago
my reaction was very similar to orange shirt girl's. :D
idolrox52 2 years ago
The Dog is Hilarious!!!
kennethjefferylocke 2 years ago
That's not a dog, that's a girl in an orange shirt you jerk.
DAORIGINALC65 2 years ago
OMG Kris is the American Idol.... woooooooooohoooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
smileyfan16 2 years ago
omg that was hiilarious:L i didnt watch american idol..cos well im nto from america but use all seem to get reallly into it:L like all the reactio vids are so funny:L
Le0ah 2 years ago
kris is good @ singing and he is hot!!!!!!!!
emmaloo49 2 years ago 2
omg girl in orange . she is tooo happy : ) no one else is happy
hebamikbel 2 years ago
I'm not a big fan of American Idol, but it is obvious that Adam will be 10 times as successful as Kris...I guarantee it. There are plenty of Kris Allens out there. Adam Lambert is a unique talent. They are both stars, but whenever they were on stage together, Adam shined the brightest.
Shay5590 2 years ago
It's obvious that Adam is better but it is still good that Kris won because now Adam will be able to make the music he wants to. If you win American Idol you have no control over what type of album you make, they decide for you.
sora0900 2 years ago
KRIS WONNNNN :D !
yeahh obviouslyy many people didnt want adam as THE american idol ? cuz in only ONE state kris got 38 million votes out of 100 millioonnn .
kiss that (:
thabammboomshow 2 years ago 2
It's interesting to watch the various reactions from different fan camps. All the top 13 were very talented. After Kris sang "Heartless," I thought it was in the bag. Not surprised at all that he won (although I did smile and applaud!).
GeorgiaPat 2 years ago
Adam should have won.
end of story.
xXeniRawrx 2 years ago
Didn't happen, End of story...haha, who cares he's going to have a record deal anyways.
markmata44 2 years ago 2
AHAHHAHAHA TAKE THAT ADAM THE FAG FUCKIN SHOWIN US UR TOUNGE SCReAMING
LOL NOT A BIG FAN OF SHOW MOSTLY FAMILLY WATCHES IT BUT IM HAPPY HE LOSt
syraus13 2 years ago
stupid
SearchingYT 2 years ago
ADAM IS SOOOOOO MUCH BETTER
FUTUREsTar676 2 years ago
woot the girl who liked kris allen is smarrtttt. :D
brtnyblck 2 years ago
lmfao @ girl in orange.
Gaabxx7 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i
is
is a
is a f
is a fa
is a fag
XAVideos 2 years ago
The dog looks unimpressed.
sixtydiamonds 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
fredninaisaballerina 2 years ago
OK is this kris's family or some fans?!?:P
KHGKid 2 years ago
Girl in orange: OMG!!!
haha i love that XD
UchihaDani169 2 years ago
girl in the hippie orange shirt should have jumped and screamed like the hulk!!!!
jadenhotguy 2 years ago
hahahahaahaaah . i'm happy Kelly Clarkson won this season
djcap2001 2 years ago
I mean seriously, do you really have to film things like this? Scary effects of YouTube... xD
kathy025 2 years ago
LOL look at the dog ! (: Omg and the women in the middlle was SO my reation! freaking out !! (:
Lappedykker2980 2 years ago
YES KRISSS!!!!
david90531 2 years ago
I think people need a life if the results affect them that much that it needs to be documented on film. Aw, cute doggy!
missa21 2 years ago
biancatwilight98 2 years ago
i thought adam was gonna win but was a true kris allen fan!!! VIVA KRIS ALLEN!!!
biancatwilight98 2 years ago
goo kris!
RsMark051 2 years ago
i love how the dog got up!!!! hahahaha
melissatucker82 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
And as Ann Powers of the Los Angeles Times pointed out, "Allen has his undeniable strong points. In terms of the music industry, he cuts a more contemporary figure than Lambert: Many stars now (specifically rock-oriented, male ones) tend to do better when they draw themselves to scale, offering songs that make fans feel warm and connected, not blown away."
gzel37 2 years ago
the girl in glasses creeps me out lol.
jaguarsrock8 2 years ago 5
i was in denial when kris won i was so pissed after that i turned the tv off and sobbed for the hole nite
gymnasty13 2 years ago 3
hello sissy....are you here again????
Amazone0310 2 years ago
The dog was a Kris Allen fan. It's an underdog thing. lol
jagmorr 2 years ago 3
Hahah! that was funnny....
monleo1705 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Stupid result. Adam is the best singer that American Idol has ever had. Kris is just an average singer. This is proof that most Americans are homophobic bigots.
mark756music 2 years ago
the is so funny! i luv how kris won! :]
PuppiLuv97 2 years ago
HAHAHAHA those three people on the left reacted PERFECTLY
MissNaminette 2 years ago 3
girls are silly- Adam will be big- I like kris too but I might fall asleep at his concert- better on radio
sanfrancaman 2 years ago 4
I cried! I couldn't watch the rest of idol! I mean I couldn't bare watch Kris sing ADAMS SONG!!! I couldn't bare it, had to go outside and cry for a half hour. So depressed! Biggest upset in Idol History, America totally got that one wrong, and it shows on all the judges faces, and even kris said himself Adam was the one who deserved it!
xspacyxmacyx 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
no dis was not n upset last year was and kris should of won he is da true star he can play alot of instraments and can sing but adam can barely sing!!!!!!
omggg3456 2 years ago
Uhm.. David Cook winning was not an upset. The complete opposite, actually.
Loser.
ucantseeme8916 2 years ago 2
u suck
ThisIsSpartaBob 2 years ago
oh my god, you people are acting like this is a presidential election or something... dude its a friggin reality tv show! get over yourselves! and besides american idol was so not adam's thing. he did not belong in this competition. he is more of a theater sream-in-your-face type of guy. kris is more down to earth, reagular joe, under dog... he truely is an american idol.
baytay360 2 years ago 3
i dont people pissed this much shit over the election just watch some more videos you'll be suprised lol
YuNgStUnTa610 2 years ago
ahha i loved this. so glad kris won
noclue07 2 years ago
I agree!! Adam was over-rated. Kris wasn't that great, but Adam's style was just plain obnoxious.
JimboVids 2 years ago