so great. From Ann Arbor, Michigan. Next visit I recommend, the Greenwood Church. I will ask them to invite you. I somehow knew Lucy Kaplansky was a person you would know. Your music and songs, are in the Heart Step to Step and Beat so good.
Reid - well done man! I was listening to the original today and wanted to share it with a musician friend who's driving a cab to make ends meet till the economy revives (for him), and chose your version (better audio) - and it's great to see a home grown cover. Thanks! James
Very nice job. This song gets me deep, every time. Did you know it's also supposed to be about the time just after 9/11? Thus "the meters dark" , meaning that cab drivers were not charging for a time after that...or so I've been told.....
Hey Reid, being a great Shindell fan from Germany I found you while looking for Shinell Songs. Since then I follow your channel and I love it. Great singer you are. Beside this one I love your performance of "May you never!" You are great and a great inspiration aswell.
I think the sad day the song refers to is a likely miscarriage which, of course, is balanced a year later by the birth or Hope or Grace.
With regard to 9/11 Shindell did do a beautiful song "I Am" that was finally released released on a bonus CD with his most recent release Not Far Now. There is another 9/11 song that deals with the unfortunate aftermath called "The State of the Union". Reid did a really good cover of this song. I will look for other postings of his. Thanks!
I agree with everyone else who said what a fine performance this is. Thnks or posting it so I can learn to play this really beautiful song. Shindell really IS one of the best songwriters, isn't he!? Another one that moved me just as much is Reunion Hill!
Great job. Richard would approve, I'm sure. I always felt this was about the same couple, post 9-11. She thanks him for turning off the radio-"I could not bear another word." Saw RS last year, but he didn't sing this. He is fanastic in concert.
I am a hugh Richard Shindell fan as he is such a great songwriter/musician so I usually don't expect much when I hear someone doing a cover song of his. Matter fact I'm usually disappointed majority of the time when I hear singers on YouTube covering many artists I listen to like Joan Baez, Sandy Denny, Donovan, etc.But you are the exception! I was pleasantly surprized to hear how very good a singer/musician you are after hearing your cover of this song.Your voice/guitar playing is outstanding!
thanks for the kind words. i've always really liked this song. i heard richard shindell play just once at an old barn in Vermont and this song knocked me out. second favorite is cancion sencilla. i just got back from buenos aires for a wedding and that song was a big hit with the argentines.
i'll check out sandy denny. never heard of him/her (?)
Just wondering if you could make a video singing one of my very favourite Richard Shindell's song called, "Sparrows Point?"
You might want to look up a folk singer named Jackson C. Frank. He only had one album out & there is a lot of information about him on the internet. Sadly, he did pass away in the 1990's. British folksinger, Sandy Denny was his girlfriend for a short time &recorded some of his songs. I think you might like his songs.He was American but spent a lot of time in UK.
Wow. I have to say I was expecting the worst. trying to cover Shindell--probably the greatest living American singer-songwriter today--usually results in disaster, but this was damn fine! Beautiful, rich, guitar, and acoustics. Very pleasantly surprised!
I must say that you surprised me. I think Richard Shindell is the single most gifted American singer/songwriter alive and he is so subtle that most covers are heartless by comparison. But you did a great job. By the way the song is about 9-11 and it's not the same couple. A classic song of despair and renewal. You have good taste in music as well as talent.
I'm not sure this song has anything to do with 9-11?? Is there some ifo you have that confirms this? The opening lyrics don't seem to support that. I think it is the same couple. He picks them up first, after she has a miscarraige, then a year later after actually having a baby. But I could be mistaken...
Yeah, I thought it was the same couple as well. But it's not. When I first heard it I had no idea it was about 9-11 either. That was conformed straight from the horse's mouth when I saw Shindell perform in 2007 and he talked a bit about the song. As is the case with his many of his best songs written in the "first person" there is a lot of universality regradless of whether the song is vague like Last Fare or specific like Che Guevara T Shirt. The mark of a great writer.
Wow, I just can't make a connection to 9-11. He says "saw them standing in the rain"...considering there was no rain on or after 9-11 for days...I don't get the lyric. Unless it's a metaphor for all the crap in the air raining down on people. But then again, the GWB was closed after the attacks, so there was no way to take a cab to Englewood, NJ on 9-11....
The same couple? hmm- I never thought of that- I took it as if the the first couple was an elderly couple- "she might fall if he let go"- nearing the close of life..and obviously the second couple being much younger- celebrating new life.
My first impression was that there was some sort of compare and contrast going on...with the road representing life...(I over analize too much I guess..)
BUT- the idea that it's the same couple has a nice ring too it...I'll have to think about it..
nicely done. subscribed done. :)
ryanmalham 6 months ago
so great. From Ann Arbor, Michigan. Next visit I recommend, the Greenwood Church. I will ask them to invite you. I somehow knew Lucy Kaplansky was a person you would know. Your music and songs, are in the Heart Step to Step and Beat so good.
myblimpyburger 10 months ago
Reid - well done man! I was listening to the original today and wanted to share it with a musician friend who's driving a cab to make ends meet till the economy revives (for him), and chose your version (better audio) - and it's great to see a home grown cover. Thanks! James
CarolSuemoo 11 months ago
Very nice job. This song gets me deep, every time. Did you know it's also supposed to be about the time just after 9/11? Thus "the meters dark" , meaning that cab drivers were not charging for a time after that...or so I've been told.....
dewq17 1 year ago
Hey Reid, being a great Shindell fan from Germany I found you while looking for Shinell Songs. Since then I follow your channel and I love it. Great singer you are. Beside this one I love your performance of "May you never!" You are great and a great inspiration aswell.
B4Bevier 1 year ago
good job! this is one of my favorites by him.
drydusk 1 year ago
I think the sad day the song refers to is a likely miscarriage which, of course, is balanced a year later by the birth or Hope or Grace.
With regard to 9/11 Shindell did do a beautiful song "I Am" that was finally released released on a bonus CD with his most recent release Not Far Now. There is another 9/11 song that deals with the unfortunate aftermath called "The State of the Union". Reid did a really good cover of this song. I will look for other postings of his. Thanks!
DCV321 2 years ago
You show Shindell a great compliment by playing and singing as well or better than he does. Thanks for posting...really.
1969tr6 2 years ago
I honestly never like covers of anyone i listen to, but yours was really amazingf!
NateontheGuitar 2 years ago
I agree with everyone else who said what a fine performance this is. Thnks or posting it so I can learn to play this really beautiful song. Shindell really IS one of the best songwriters, isn't he!? Another one that moved me just as much is Reunion Hill!
ScottBentley64 2 years ago
wow. fantastic voice. video made my day.
jtbernard1 3 years ago
Great job. Richard would approve, I'm sure. I always felt this was about the same couple, post 9-11. She thanks him for turning off the radio-"I could not bear another word." Saw RS last year, but he didn't sing this. He is fanastic in concert.
stars1861 3 years ago
I love this song. I came here looking for Cat Stevens' "The Wind" but I am so pleased to hear this song too!
really wonderful version!
ragandbone 3 years ago
I am a hugh Richard Shindell fan as he is such a great songwriter/musician so I usually don't expect much when I hear someone doing a cover song of his. Matter fact I'm usually disappointed majority of the time when I hear singers on YouTube covering many artists I listen to like Joan Baez, Sandy Denny, Donovan, etc.But you are the exception! I was pleasantly surprized to hear how very good a singer/musician you are after hearing your cover of this song.Your voice/guitar playing is outstanding!
folkmusicgirl 3 years ago
hey there,
thanks for the kind words. i've always really liked this song. i heard richard shindell play just once at an old barn in Vermont and this song knocked me out. second favorite is cancion sencilla. i just got back from buenos aires for a wedding and that song was a big hit with the argentines.
i'll check out sandy denny. never heard of him/her (?)
till next time,
reid
reidospeedo1234 3 years ago
Hi Reid:
Just wondering if you could make a video singing one of my very favourite Richard Shindell's song called, "Sparrows Point?"
You might want to look up a folk singer named Jackson C. Frank. He only had one album out & there is a lot of information about him on the internet. Sadly, he did pass away in the 1990's. British folksinger, Sandy Denny was his girlfriend for a short time &recorded some of his songs. I think you might like his songs.He was American but spent a lot of time in UK.
folkmusicgirl 3 years ago
Wow. I have to say I was expecting the worst. trying to cover Shindell--probably the greatest living American singer-songwriter today--usually results in disaster, but this was damn fine! Beautiful, rich, guitar, and acoustics. Very pleasantly surprised!
AllagashSinclair 3 years ago
I must say that you surprised me. I think Richard Shindell is the single most gifted American singer/songwriter alive and he is so subtle that most covers are heartless by comparison. But you did a great job. By the way the song is about 9-11 and it's not the same couple. A classic song of despair and renewal. You have good taste in music as well as talent.
GEOHHADDAD 3 years ago
I'm not sure this song has anything to do with 9-11?? Is there some ifo you have that confirms this? The opening lyrics don't seem to support that. I think it is the same couple. He picks them up first, after she has a miscarraige, then a year later after actually having a baby. But I could be mistaken...
AllagashSinclair 3 years ago
Yeah, I thought it was the same couple as well. But it's not. When I first heard it I had no idea it was about 9-11 either. That was conformed straight from the horse's mouth when I saw Shindell perform in 2007 and he talked a bit about the song. As is the case with his many of his best songs written in the "first person" there is a lot of universality regradless of whether the song is vague like Last Fare or specific like Che Guevara T Shirt. The mark of a great writer.
GEOHHADDAD 3 years ago
Wow, I just can't make a connection to 9-11. He says "saw them standing in the rain"...considering there was no rain on or after 9-11 for days...I don't get the lyric. Unless it's a metaphor for all the crap in the air raining down on people. But then again, the GWB was closed after the attacks, so there was no way to take a cab to Englewood, NJ on 9-11....
AllagashSinclair 3 years ago
The same couple? hmm- I never thought of that- I took it as if the the first couple was an elderly couple- "she might fall if he let go"- nearing the close of life..and obviously the second couple being much younger- celebrating new life.
My first impression was that there was some sort of compare and contrast going on...with the road representing life...(I over analize too much I guess..)
BUT- the idea that it's the same couple has a nice ring too it...I'll have to think about it..
joecoolmccall 3 years ago
What kind of guitar is that? It looks like a Martin something and it sounds fabulous!
jpg0572 3 years ago
Mr. Maclean, This is my single favorite Richard Shindell song, and you do it the justice it deserves. Bravo, sir.
ronerin 3 years ago