EVERYTHING THE TEMPTATIOJNS MADE WAS A HIT!!! It was an era where a vinyl album was so chocked full of hits that every song was incredible. Unlike today where there may be only one good song on a CD and the rest of the songs are garbage. The music was original, the arrangements were creative, and the singers had genuine talent. How many of today's artist can make that claim?
i Wish I Was In Them Days Hair Slicked Back, And Nice Suits, )= My Dad Told me All The Hair Style's He Had And When I Watch Movies like The temptations And The Five Heartbeats they Fascinate Mii I Liked They Style
Eddie, Otis, Buddy especially Paul (My 4 Favorites) thanks for the music. I am a big fan and I'll never forget your music even though I was born in the 70's I am a solid fan.
@ColorOrStateOfMind No, people needed to get their ears checked at that time this should have easily been a hit!..I think it wasn't cuz maybe people were happy in their relationships or something so it was no need for it ^_^ but in reality it was good and should've been a hit!..
@Jeiygo Well it was the people from then that decided this song was not good enough to be a hit. And I'm pretty sure it was because there were tons of other songs to judge this one by. We're thinking this is a hit, but back then, the listeners had plenty of other songs that were even better. And going off your "people were happy" theory, you should look at the top R&B billboards from 1963. I know there were some conflict love music back then. lol
@Jeiygo lol... oh no... I wasn't talking about race. haha. I worded that a little unclear. I was saying what it sounded like you said that people were "happy in their relationships or something so it was no need for it," you were joking, but I have a habit of answering seriously when I know that. Horrible online sarcasm. : )
@ColorOrStateOfMind@ColorOrStateOfMind I didn't mean a specific race that was happy I'm sorry if I was unclear about that. I'm just saying this track deserved a shot just listen to the rest of the temptations backing up Paul in harmony- & Paul sounds great! I just don't understand..Every time I hear this and remind myself that this wasn't a hit it's just heart breaking..
This song reminds me of the good old days at Roosevelt Park, off Florence ave. in South Central L.A ...when it was still legal to cruise around in low riders. F13
@11302529ma I know what you mean, it does something inside.......I wish they will play it over and over again on the radio.. I love this song, makes me think of days of real love and music.......A million thumbs up to them, thanks guys!
this songs is so original, true, simple, soulful, and its not complicated. i love this song. to bad my generation musicians are to tough for words like these. i always catch my self listening and like more music from the past then today. im only 25, and thats weird to me. then again, i have been called weird my whole life :)
@Vintageappliguy I have been loving motown know since i was about 12. And as i got older i start listening to older and older sonngs and i found my self to really enjoy them.
I may be only 18 but i wish music these days was like the music in the late 50's and all the 60's. I would have loved to go to concerts. But the temptations are one of my favorite groups
@Apple12845 I could not agree with you more about music today....and I must say I think it is really cool that someone your age is into this music too..I have loved early Motown as well as early rock n roll since I was a little younger than you are (I am currently 35) and I applaud you on your good taste in music
F the 3 people who had a love they could not see because love is blind Ray Was blind all his life and he has children and married with a wife and kids in the since its 100% true "He had a love he could see" not with his eyes but with his hands and feelings...
@tamcar04 The Boys were smooth with alot of charisma. I learned to Cha Cha to this song with my Sisters and Cousins.....The Originals Liove On....Go Tempts...I'm a "Tempting Temp" forever
they have to be the best there was best there has been best there ever will be music to day sux godbless motown everyone involed thank you for posting beatles can not come no were near these men beatles over made cause they white and british call me prejuduc but i am white and beatles suk
In an interview 7 or 8 years ago, both Berry Gordy and Smokey said this is the one song that they are still baffled about. They said it should have been a huge hit. They blamed marketing and A&R. Gordy said "I want a Love I Can See is one of the best songs ever." They both agreed that Paul was the best of all the Tempts vocally and that his performance on all of the early releases blew their minds at Motown. I was not familiar with this song at that time; now I see what they were talking about!
@dienglee Yes...I agree. Best of all I heard in the 60's and I was there! I don't get it. This one should have been a number 1 hit for all time! Must have been a politics thing at Gordy. We still have it now to enjoy...and I do! I just wish for Paul- that it could have been what it should have been in his lifetime! WELL, thank you anyway, Paul...and God bless.......
I think the only reason paul didn't get the shine he should have is because his voice reminded me of a male-MJB. His voice is best singing heartfelt painful songs. He had that natural "tear in his voice"
I Love Pauls painful, heartaching, soulful style of delivery actually a bit better that Ruffin's. Paul is definitely one of the 3 or 4 best barritones in music history. He is right up there with Otis Redding folks.....
@dienglee You are so right; dienglee he was great. He had an earthy baritone and sadly he didn't live long and when things went on, David Ruffin got the leads but this brother was beautiful.. he need more recognition..
I'm really sad how Paul was supposed to have died!! He was the best! He was the one who got the contract and the savay they had! My favorite farewell my love!!
this is one of my favorite songs, this is coming from a goofy white 13 year old, i listen to mowtown so much. i love good music, fuck the shit we have today.
Huggy lots of white kids back in the day loved soul music. Some weren't allowed to play it in their homes but those that could were big fans of soul music.
As always, the Temptations rule. They will go down in musical history as one of the GREATEST GROUPS EVER. Love the Temptations - everyone does. Thank you for this post.
every time I hear a MOTOWN artist it makes me want to go to the Hitsville Musem more and more...!!!! Ne body that came ota Motown is worth listen to.. welll not all... but most..
i cant believe in the movie they voted if they were down to there last dollar they would by a sandwich instead of this record this is one of my favorite songs ever
Na not this song, this song was written by Smoky Robinson, I think the song you are talking about is "Paradise" which was written by Berry Gordy. That's why after that song plays Berry Gordy asks the thing about the sandwich and when everyone answers sandwich he's like... thats cold... cause he wrote the song.
This has been flagged as spam show
thumbs up if your listening to this in 2k12!
JordanKyleSoto23 3 days ago
Ahhh, WHY wasn't I born back then?!!!
emmag4321 1 week ago
@emmag4321 i always say that too. lol
NIghtRider805 3 days ago
<3 this song!
Crob2014 1 week ago
love these temps
darkandlovely223 1 week ago
mmmmmm yea :)
NIghtRider805 1 week ago
Do it Tempts!!!!! Do it!!!
bjgoldilock 3 weeks ago in playlist oldies
I wanted to know the samething how was this not a hit
1andreph 3 weeks ago in playlist The Temptations
With this many views it's great to see I'm not the only one not born from this time with an appreciation for this music
doctorzaius77 1 month ago 4
Thumbs up if you are listening to this in 2012!
NoraWakelyTenley 1 month ago
If you were down to your last two dolars would you buy a sandwich or this record?
MsKelliGIzaStar 1 month ago 6
@MsKelliGIzaStar good movie haha
Lbuch44 1 month ago
@MsKelliGIzaStar this record :D
NIghtRider805 1 week ago
EVERYTHING THE TEMPTATIOJNS MADE WAS A HIT!!! It was an era where a vinyl album was so chocked full of hits that every song was incredible. Unlike today where there may be only one good song on a CD and the rest of the songs are garbage. The music was original, the arrangements were creative, and the singers had genuine talent. How many of today's artist can make that claim?
Twinkles5927 1 month ago 2
@Twinkles5927 True words indeed, mate.
Trixiekitsch2008 1 month ago
best picture of the classic Temptations
mello60ful 2 months ago
this is good music!
MsAshd8 2 months ago
are my speakers broke or your video??
JigabooCummin4U 2 months ago
@JigabooCummin4U
I can hear it loud and clear..check you're speakers mate
PaleRider81 2 months ago 6
i miss my friennds have fun heidie
Ronnie2376 2 months ago
Love this song...Remember it from the movie!!!
bjgoldilock 2 months ago
Right about now...we need way more of Paul....and less of everything else!
6000cat 2 months ago 4
Oldie but goody :-)
ArutPerumJoyti 3 months ago
4 people don't want a love they can see
yankeestarz1 3 months ago
This song is never long enough!>_<!
BoogieEffect 3 months ago in playlist BoogieEffect's favorites 3
Paul on lead vocal No. 1!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
zekmire 3 months ago
My no. 1 favorite Tempting Temptations song! No. 2 is For Once In My Life.
ButterfliNabi 3 months ago
ya this is real music all talent no bullshit great summer song like down at revere beach
sheddski 3 months ago
I want a love I can see!
mrsberrios 3 months ago
one of the greatest temps songs, cant believe it didnt go number one
heropotts 3 months ago 2
i was born in the wrong time .
dwoods1995 3 months ago 5
@dwoods1995 But you can still listen now- that's good
oaklandonthecomeup 3 months ago
this song is awesome i love it
jsupremes 3 months ago
Ouch....just meant...when that best goes...I'll go with it.
6000cat 3 months ago
i Wish I Was In Them Days Hair Slicked Back, And Nice Suits, )= My Dad Told me All The Hair Style's He Had And When I Watch Movies like The temptations And The Five Heartbeats they Fascinate Mii I Liked They Style
William7263 4 months ago 5
@William7263 I feel you. PPL seemed classier back then.
queeneastcoast 4 months ago
Eddie, Otis, Buddy especially Paul (My 4 Favorites) thanks for the music. I am a big fan and I'll never forget your music even though I was born in the 70's I am a solid fan.
joeymaster2005 4 months ago 2
wow i love this song
jsupremes 4 months ago 3
One of the best songs the temps released; RIP Paul!!!!!! xx
metrociity 4 months ago
thumbs up if yur listening to this in 2k11
MrMARCFN94 4 months ago 62
@MrMARCFN94 enjoy it while you still can, kids...when it goes down- it's goin down.
6000cat 3 months ago
@MrMARCFN94 the basketball game?
dkthg 2 months ago
@MrMARCFN94 2k12
lrgonzalez74 1 month ago
@MrMARCFN94 i was listening in 2011 and now 2012 so thumbs up if ur listening to this 2012
mr101yobros 2 weeks ago 2
@MrMARCFN94
shout out if you are listening in 2012
darkandlovely223 1 week ago 2
This song is the truth..... As always the Temps come with that heat!!!!
psdlihc 4 months ago
the real TEMPTATIONS! :)
rogilest 4 months ago
THIS SONG IS COOOOOOOLLLLLL !!!!!
sheddski 4 months ago
Thanks Paul, Eddie, David, Otis, and Melvin.. love U guys coming straight from Nashville!!!
psdlihc 4 months ago 2
Smokey writteng the verses, Funk Brothers on the Track, The Temps bringing it...It gets no better
joejacksun 4 months ago in playlist Classic Music 5
How was this not a hit?
thatswhatdeacsaid 4 months ago 57
@thatswhatdeacsaid Every time I hear this I think the same thing!!!!!!!
awarren92 3 months ago in playlist Motown Baby!
@awarren92 Infinte times 100% agree with you ^_^
Jeiygo 2 months ago
@thatswhatdeacsaid That's the kind of level they were on. We think this a hit today, they had even better jams back then. lol
ColorOrStateOfMind 2 months ago
@ColorOrStateOfMind No, people needed to get their ears checked at that time this should have easily been a hit!..I think it wasn't cuz maybe people were happy in their relationships or something so it was no need for it ^_^ but in reality it was good and should've been a hit!..
Jeiygo 2 months ago
@Jeiygo Well it was the people from then that decided this song was not good enough to be a hit. And I'm pretty sure it was because there were tons of other songs to judge this one by. We're thinking this is a hit, but back then, the listeners had plenty of other songs that were even better. And going off your "people were happy" theory, you should look at the top R&B billboards from 1963. I know there were some conflict love music back then. lol
ColorOrStateOfMind 2 months ago
Comment removed
Jeiygo 1 month ago
@Jeiygo lol... oh no... I wasn't talking about race. haha. I worded that a little unclear. I was saying what it sounded like you said that people were "happy in their relationships or something so it was no need for it," you were joking, but I have a habit of answering seriously when I know that. Horrible online sarcasm. : )
ColorOrStateOfMind 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ColorOrStateOfMind @ColorOrStateOfMind I didn't mean a specific race that was happy I'm sorry if I was unclear about that. I'm just saying this track deserved a shot just listen to the rest of the temptations backing up Paul in harmony- & Paul sounds great! I just don't understand..Every time I hear this and remind myself that this wasn't a hit it's just heart breaking..
Jeiygo 1 month ago
@thatswhatdeacsaid i don't think it became popular until after paul died
EJOHNSON2708 2 weeks ago
@dahotness408 that was the same way i felt about this song when i found out some years ago.
astrix1251 5 months ago
in the temps' biopic, they said when they released this song, it wasnt a hit. i could never imagine why the hell not
dahotness408 5 months ago 4
@dahotness408
seantemple71 5 months ago in playlist seantemple71's Favorited Videos
Okay paul just blew me the hell away I love this song.
kennacole89 5 months ago
My fave BY FAR!!!
redhawley 5 months ago
awsome
lilrebs44 5 months ago
This is an AMAZING song! Only the master Paul Williams could sing a song like this.
qwertymanor 5 months ago 3
This song reminds me of the good old days at Roosevelt Park, off Florence ave. in South Central L.A ...when it was still legal to cruise around in low riders. F13
traviesof13 5 months ago
SSSHHHYTTTTT WATCH OUT
smartyshort 5 months ago
THE MIGHTY TEMPTATIONS...MIGHTY MOTOWN..LET THE MUSIC PLAY ON...
MegaMusicman09 5 months ago
I must say it again Five Tall Drinks Of Water that could blow In my day (Blow meant you could really sing)
mello60ful 5 months ago
Don't make em like this anymore. Thanks!
HottestCoupleEver 5 months ago
This is one of their best. The musical accompaniment is awesome; LOVE that piano!
wiseoldude 5 months ago
Man, I wanna know where the 4 people are who can dislike this. They need to have their hearing checked.
superrogue17 5 months ago 3
Great soulful artists!!!!
yolandavv 6 months ago
Wonderful
Bounceyable 6 months ago
~~❤TEMPTATIONS 4EVER❤~~
UtubeWasMyIdea1 6 months ago
amazing, just so raw and heart felt.
aaronmimi123 6 months ago 2
Five gifted musicians
mello60ful 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
4 People have a love they CANT see
Prostylefilms 6 months ago
@11302529ma I know what you mean, it does something inside.......I wish they will play it over and over again on the radio.. I love this song, makes me think of days of real love and music.......A million thumbs up to them, thanks guys!
LadyP4u2 6 months ago 4
i really feel bad for those who are able to dislike music like this. dis shit slapz
SouthStackGrinda 6 months ago
sang paul R.I.P paul
TEMPTATIONS FOREVER BABY :)
JaeMilinaTV 6 months ago
i really like this song
11302529MA 6 months ago
love the Temptations
q7518 6 months ago in playlist fav so far
I LOVE YOU BUGSY! 90304, <3 GORDA!
T0aNNa310 6 months ago
Paul was actually talking about a LOVE he couldn't see..it was IN him! God bless you, Paul. You brought it!
6000cat 7 months ago 4
I liked this song so much but come to find out that the Tempts recorded this song around the time I was born and I loved it even more
Savvynlady 7 months ago
hell yea thats fucken gangster shit the temptations are the fucken top dawgs
princessymamichula 7 months ago
Heyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy!!! this is the stuff that dreams are made of.
cheecheedivine 7 months ago
Love them always
TheAngienorton01 7 months ago
The great Temptations...
jblackasia 7 months ago
This song didnt make the charts!? What!? This is my favorite song. I love Paul Williams!
srhodes1108 7 months ago 2
@srhodes1108 I know; I bet them folks think twice on that now. Paul tore that song off the hinges there. He was a true baritone and is really missed.
Savvynlady 7 months ago 2
is there any surviving members? they were truly gifted artists. there music is timeless.
ElizaBessss 7 months ago
@ElizaBessss yes Otis is still alive
dirtyna 7 months ago
Thumb's up
VintaqeeTOKYO 7 months ago
Love the temps and this is one of my favs Paul could warble!!!!!
missmsmusings 7 months ago
One of my faves of the Tempts...Happy Birthday to Paul Williams (RILP) July 2...
21melendez 7 months ago
this makes me sing with my broom microphone when im cleaning lol
itsmytimetoshine11 7 months ago
@itsmytimetoshine11 LOL!! me too.
HottestCoupleEver 7 months ago
@HottestCoupleEver lol yea good music
itsmytimetoshine11 5 months ago
@itsmytimetoshine11 you can say that again. It brings back so many memories.
HottestCoupleEver 5 months ago
this songs is so original, true, simple, soulful, and its not complicated. i love this song. to bad my generation musicians are to tough for words like these. i always catch my self listening and like more music from the past then today. im only 25, and thats weird to me. then again, i have been called weird my whole life :)
disk987camal 7 months ago
@disk987camal You're not weird...on the contrary you have good taste.
HottestCoupleEver 7 months ago
Comment removed
jcblue15 8 months ago
Comment removed
jcblue15 8 months ago
it's too bad this song didn't make the charts this is a great song and i would love to record this
BCF125 8 months ago
@Vintageappliguy I have been loving motown know since i was about 12. And as i got older i start listening to older and older sonngs and i found my self to really enjoy them.
Apple12845 8 months ago
I may be only 18 but i wish music these days was like the music in the late 50's and all the 60's. I would have loved to go to concerts. But the temptations are one of my favorite groups
Apple12845 8 months ago
@Apple12845 I could not agree with you more about music today....and I must say I think it is really cool that someone your age is into this music too..I have loved early Motown as well as early rock n roll since I was a little younger than you are (I am currently 35) and I applaud you on your good taste in music
vintageappliguy 8 months ago
I love this song...such a smooth voice. I had to hunt for this one..thanks for posting.
REALTALKCEO 8 months ago
It don't get no better than this...
cleteconnor 8 months ago
3 people are autotuned
theonewhowillprosper 8 months ago
This song sound so sensual.
taleeni 8 months ago
F the 3 people who had a love they could not see because love is blind Ray Was blind all his life and he has children and married with a wife and kids in the since its 100% true "He had a love he could see" not with his eyes but with his hands and feelings...
chamblizi 8 months ago
SANG PAUL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
tamcar04 8 months ago 43
@tamcar04 The Boys were smooth with alot of charisma. I learned to Cha Cha to this song with my Sisters and Cousins.....The Originals Liove On....Go Tempts...I'm a "Tempting Temp" forever
sshaft47 7 months ago
what if sometimes you have a love you can see? (x
MandyyCasillas 8 months ago
they have to be the best there was best there has been best there ever will be music to day sux godbless motown everyone involed thank you for posting beatles can not come no were near these men beatles over made cause they white and british call me prejuduc but i am white and beatles suk
mjy325 8 months ago
In an interview 7 or 8 years ago, both Berry Gordy and Smokey said this is the one song that they are still baffled about. They said it should have been a huge hit. They blamed marketing and A&R. Gordy said "I want a Love I Can See is one of the best songs ever." They both agreed that Paul was the best of all the Tempts vocally and that his performance on all of the early releases blew their minds at Motown. I was not familiar with this song at that time; now I see what they were talking about!
dienglee 8 months ago 4
@dienglee Yes...I agree. Best of all I heard in the 60's and I was there! I don't get it. This one should have been a number 1 hit for all time! Must have been a politics thing at Gordy. We still have it now to enjoy...and I do! I just wish for Paul- that it could have been what it should have been in his lifetime! WELL, thank you anyway, Paul...and God bless.......
6000cat 8 months ago
@dienglee I agree. I am 50 yeras old. This is my favorite temp song. I listen to it all the time.
pointeman777 8 months ago
think bout u everytime i hear this song baby!
T0aNNa310 8 months ago
I LOVE THIS SONG, BRINGS BACK ALOT OF FUN!! MEMORIES.. DOING THE CHA CHA..
terryissacfred 8 months ago
this is the jam right here ;)
Elgatonegro65 8 months ago
the black beatles :))
cynthia42096 8 months ago
@cynthia42096 lol they was round way before beatles...beatles may the white temptations ;)
Caveman1006 8 months ago
@Caveman1006 makes more sense :D
cynthia42096 8 months ago
I WAS LOOKING FOR THIS SONG!! THANKS SO MUCH!!!
MasterChief865 8 months ago in playlist The Temptin',Temptations
Yeah- you CAN see love in this world. This is one!
563four90 8 months ago
They don't make music like this anymore!
TheGena369 9 months ago
Dam this is the Jam!
botvinnik64 9 months ago
I think the only reason paul didn't get the shine he should have is because his voice reminded me of a male-MJB. His voice is best singing heartfelt painful songs. He had that natural "tear in his voice"
chikkengrease 9 months ago 3
- This video, love I can see...
Thank You
WithLoveforPaul 9 months ago
The Funk Brothers made this song something special, that's for sure. : )
prodigyofpeace1983 9 months ago 2
awsome song love it
freshboylance 9 months ago
I loved Paul! This is one of my favorite songs on this movie. Paul's voice is so great I can listen to it all day.
denkellsma 9 months ago
I Love Pauls painful, heartaching, soulful style of delivery actually a bit better that Ruffin's. Paul is definitely one of the 3 or 4 best barritones in music history. He is right up there with Otis Redding folks.....
dienglee 9 months ago
@dienglee You are so right; dienglee he was great. He had an earthy baritone and sadly he didn't live long and when things went on, David Ruffin got the leads but this brother was beautiful.. he need more recognition..
Savvynlady 9 months ago
I'm really sad how Paul was supposed to have died!! He was the best! He was the one who got the contract and the savay they had! My favorite farewell my love!!
MrHotrodjones 9 months ago
I love Paul's voice.. him and David were my favorites!
mscutthroat 9 months ago
this is one of my favorite songs, this is coming from a goofy white 13 year old, i listen to mowtown so much. i love good music, fuck the shit we have today.
huggybobo88 9 months ago 3
@huggybobo88
Huggy lots of white kids back in the day loved soul music. Some weren't allowed to play it in their homes but those that could were big fans of soul music.
winsome1235 9 months ago
I love this song!!!!! This should of made it to top ten back then.
Blackahki 9 months ago
i love paul's voice
ChocolateBox88 9 months ago 2
2 people dont like the temptations....
Ashia971 9 months ago
PAUL WILLIAMS KILLED DIS
LILDJ71288 9 months ago
As always, the Temptations rule. They will go down in musical history as one of the GREATEST GROUPS EVER. Love the Temptations - everyone does. Thank you for this post.
gva0917 9 months ago 2
2 racist pricks can't tell colors (green) (red)
MistaChubbz1 9 months ago
@MistaChubbz1 ??...wow
Ashia971 9 months ago
2 People have a love they CANT see...
EazyE275 9 months ago 41
@EazyE275 this is one of my fav
MsLyssa23 7 months ago
@EazyE275 - Great comment!
wiseoldude 5 months ago
@EazyE275 Ah, its four now.
MrIvanko25 5 months ago
Saw this on the movie and I just loooooove it cant get enough!
francisjamdown 10 months ago
I want a love I can feel...RIP Paul Williams
sherylsworld 10 months ago 2
HEY T.T
mizzjuicy38 10 months ago
every time I hear a MOTOWN artist it makes me want to go to the Hitsville Musem more and more...!!!! Ne body that came ota Motown is worth listen to.. welll not all... but most..
angelaricks1 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Paul sings like a across between Dennis Edwards and Levy Stubbs. "Superstar". No question
TheRoland1947 10 months ago
Paul sings like a across between Dennis Edwards and Levy Stubbs. "Superstar". No question.
TheRoland1947 10 months ago
i cant believe in the movie they voted if they were down to there last dollar they would by a sandwich instead of this record this is one of my favorite songs ever
fresh33333 10 months ago 2
@fresh33333 No that was for Paradise, this was an almost hit especially in Detroit.
qwertymanor 10 months ago
Na not this song, this song was written by Smoky Robinson, I think the song you are talking about is "Paradise" which was written by Berry Gordy. That's why after that song plays Berry Gordy asks the thing about the sandwich and when everyone answers sandwich he's like... thats cold... cause he wrote the song.
nhcaptain5 10 months ago
Good Stuff. I love it!
Wolf251982 11 months ago
this is a badass song
israelloveswomen 11 months ago
That James Jamerson Bass line is what DOES IT along with paul's soulful delivery!!
HaliB75 11 months ago
one idiot doesnt know the real soul
iphonemanorappleman1 11 months ago
1 person cant hear
3104627323 11 months ago
When did this song first come out?
billchew450 11 months ago
@billchew450 63'
millz320812 11 months ago
1 person iz heartless and duznt know what real music iz....
DaHateR11 11 months ago 2
I grew up with alot of old people and this was the only music I usually heard
briamae1 11 months ago