Added: 4 years ago
From: timbuktukid
Views: 1,255,606
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (2,275)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • my favorite musician covering my favorite song!!

  • better than orginal 

  • this a shite version of a great song

  • 323 people had their lights turned out.

  • this is the best there's a light cover version that i've ever heard...

    i'm envy to you all russian fans, to watch this in live perform

  • shit version of a great tune from one of the brothers grimmmmmmmmm lol !! young governors i shit em !! i know loads of the boys and they aint ever heard of the brothers grimm !! i done glasto in security when oasis were playing and liam brother grimm got lairy with one of the wrong people !! a proper boy !! and he was told behave or get hurt he was a plastic hooligan and the boys doing security were the real deal !! and guess what ! liam shut up !! big egos dont cut it with the real people

  • @bristolcityifcation Right, you're clearly not better or anything. I mean, Noel Gallacher has made a career writing and performing songs and you appear to be illiterate. Sometimes life is so unfair, I sleep safe in the knowledge that you appear to be a cunt though. :)

  • @bristolcityifcation Your English is fucking atrocious.

  • @bristolcityifcation I'm sure Noel is wiping his tears with 50 pound bills you cunt. Noel Gallagher is a legend.

  • fuckin dreadful dreary "Quoasis" shite a real "smoke break" version god its fuckin dire isnt it

  • VIPmsg

    Get a life

  • Gay.

  • No this is just pants !!

  • бля ... он был в москве.

    я ненавижу себя

  • That, he is not . . .

  • Noel, you know its just wrong mate

  • To people who calls other musicians for covering songs:

    If you play an instrument, then I'm pretty sure that you've 'covered' a song. It's just the same apart from he's sat on a stage and he's famous.

  • In NG we trust

  • if u want to hear a good cover of this smiths classic cheak out neil finn and johnny marr

  • the smiths version is a gay version

  • its just a cover, im mozz fan, and this is a good one :).

  • Noel's no Morrissey and Morrissey's no Noel.

    Covers provide different aspects on both these legend's work.

    I like both versions.

  • Noel Gallagher is fantastic, isn't a cover a form of respect?

  • gallager brother sucks!

  • @FourJamLions written by an bigger shite

  • Oh the pleasure the privilege is mine

  • TO DIE BY YOUR SIDE

  • TO DIE BY YOUR SIDE

  • I was there....

  • @Aleksey80 где они выступали?

  • @saifytdin

    MSC B1

  • @Aleksey80 Точно, в начале на крупном плане видно над сценой. Жаль что не был там.. надеюсь еще раз приедут..

  • shit sound!!!!

  • 2:00 - 2:05 that crazy russian gave me the greatest laugh attack of the week

  • Crap

  • Oh dear oh dear I see a real intellectual heavy weight has joined the debate ! ! !

  • You musos are a hilarious bunch. Congratulations on being cunts!

  • Wrongo . . .

    Mozzer very much wrote it

    Smiths = way before Oasis

    And hugely better . . . In my opinion

  • swear he wrote this for the smiths anyway?

  • Like so wot ?

    Smiths original version far superior and by a country mile at that !

  • oasis most views video = wonderwall 29000000 views

    smithsmost views video  = There is a light that never goes out 10000000

    shut up

  • @NJCC94 So? I guess you think Lady Gaga is the best ever. People who quote sales total or views are children.

  • this sux

  • Search:

    A Smiths Tribute Band- There Is A Light Live

    For our version of this beautiful song

  • @GeminiiGuy81 That's a ridiculous thing to say.......why would anyone respect Noel?

  • 2:00 - i laugh every time. CRASHES INTO USSSS...lol. Russians.

  • @GeminiiGuy81 dont respond to me again ok or i will report you fro harassment since you want to bring grassing into it, threatened to kiss someone.........very aggressive lol. I won't even respond to your ignorant ill-informed views about Scotland since anyone with half a brain would know the truth from the fiction. Yes decent and treat others how I want to be treated which is not some idiot on youtube sending me a narky nasty little comment when I had never spoken to them in my life b4

  • first it was "i am the walrus", and now this.. ffs.

  • @GeminiiGuy81 your a complete idiot if that's what you think, I couldn't care less what you think or getting into a debate with the likes of you, your statement was just pathetic. Oasis shite upon you mate and whatever crappy little music you can come up with, now buzz off don't reply to me again or you can reply in Glasgow city centre and we will welcome you with our lovely Glasgow kisses

  • Bad recording but great song done by an equally brilliant musician. End of!

  • he's no Morrissey

    

  • @paulflounders Really??

  • @paulflounders your right hes a brilliant songwriter and singer

  • @paulflounders Thank god... sorry but i never understood why people like Morrissey's music IT'S FOOKIN SHITE!!!!!!!

  • @paulflounders But he's Noel

  • awful !!!!

  • It shouldn't matter how well he covered the song. He's clearly a big Smiths fan, and he's showing his love for their material by performing it. Go Noel! :-)

  • Yep. Gotta know your limitations. Just make me love Morrissey more.

  • Man's gotta know his limitations.

  • QUE BOSTA !!!!! NUNCA MAIS FAÇA ISSO , A MUSICA ESTA PESIMA O SOM ESTA PESSIMO TUDO RUIM!!!

    DEIXA QUEM TE TALENTO FAZER ISSO , ÉSSA MUSICA FOI FEITA EXCLUSIVAMENTE NO TAMANHO E TIMBRE DO MORRISSEY .

  • qué tal eh?

  • Amazing cover

    LOVE YOU NOEL

  • Now go back & listen to the original just to know how truly great it is.

  • why do all the Morrissey queens go all hissy fits about this? Its JUST a cover version, that's what musicians do! they compliment other musicians who they respect and admire by doing covers of their songs from time to time, they don't do it to be better, very seldom do you get a cover that's better than the original! I'm sure Morrissey's version of Don't look back in anger wouldn't sound that's great! but who cares! Let musicians do innocent versions of songs by their influences & stop moaning

  • @TheMrmoonlight

    Great statement. Shame the whole 'Morrissey queens' statement makes you look like a lollygagging fucking foetus.

  • @TheMrmoonlight How did I know a Noel fan would be protecting him in the top comments...

  • @xILambyIx Because Noel is singing the song?

  • @stevebruce13 What I should've said was having a go at Morrissey rather than protecting Noel.

  • @xILambyIx Dont agree with Noel or Moz bashing why are people arguing? They both make real music and real songs that appeal to people who care if you prefer one or the other you don't need to make a choice. This is merely Noel paying homage to the genius of Marr and Moz he aint trying to be better then them just paying tribute to them. So enough with bashing from either side as there's no need to create sides both are class whoever you prefer is your choice, peace. LIVE FOREVER

  • @stevebruce13 I haven't bashed anyone, so don't lecture me.

  • @TheMrmoonlight "Hissy fit?" Friends TV. Smiths and the fans were too clever and cool to have one.

  • @TheMrmoonlight

    1. The quality  of the recording is terrible.

    2. Noel Gallagher would go to Downing Street to kiss Tony Blair's arse to further his career.

    3. I cannot imagine Morrissey singing any of Noel Gallagher's nice but not really challenging songs.

  • @TheMrmoonlight It's just because Noel Gallagher is a muppet.

  • @UnderTheAffluence hahaha Noel is a god of the music

  • @MyAntonio987 Oasis were an impression of the Beatles. Noel Gallagher and the High Flying Pigs are an impression of Oasis doing an impression of the Beatles. DULL AS DITCHWATER.

  • @UnderTheAffluence Dull aint the word man pure fuckin shite version of a fantastic tune

  • @TheMrmoonlight your spot on totally, hes actually paying homage to the smiths and obviously its a track hes liked since he was a kid. END OF !! nothing more

  • what the hell is this Noel? could you make that song sound any more dull, i almost picked up my pen and stabbed it in my ear. jesus. No wonder you played this rendition to the russians.

  • @jcooke222 UR ISLAMPHOBIC OKAY!!!  WANNA CONDOMS £6.49 OKAY!!!

    SOMEONE SHOULD SMACK YA 4 WEARING ONE DURING INTERCOURSE OKAY!!!

  • @mor1222 muzzy prick!

  • noel youll never be mozza

  • i.ve heard a fella at bond street tube station play a better version than this, i like noel and the early oasis stuff, but this is ,............well, i hope morrissey not heard it,

  • This is just a genius cover from Noel to say the least.

  • The Smiths, Oasis, Stone Roses. Proof The Best music comes from Manchester.

  • @rockguru123

    I'm a proud Southerner & I have to find fault with your comment. You've not mentioned The Buzzcocks, Joy Division/New Order (and probably many others)!!

  • @gartennelke Oh god yes mate I forgot about them! There's too many bands to count!... Although if you wanted to be fickle Joy Division came from Macclesfield not Mnachester;)

  • @rockguru123

    If you want to be super-fickle 2 of them came from Macclesfield & 2 from Salford!

  • Why do people bash artists they seem to listen & linger long enough 2 B compelled to write something shitty. Me...... I don't care. I do however love this song & performance . Me Like

  • god this guy sucks.

  • this is shit

  • calm down!

  • wanker

  • @capinyoassproduction surely sayin 'fail' is fail nowdays no?!

  • Noels birthday is coming up on 29May. Before that we will all watch "Oasis (Noel Gallagher) - Wonderwall live 2002" :) the best version of Wonderwall which has only 400000- something views. For the greatest Singer - Songwriter EVER. :D We can do this. Give it a listen.

    We are Oasis fans man. We do anything. WE ARE THE SUPERSONICS :D

    Thumbs up(so everyone can see) and pass this on.

    May You and Noel, LIVE FOREVER :)

  • @aditkobe007 hahahah the greatest songwriter don't make me laugh

  • Noel should have gone solo from the start.

  • noel!noel!noel!

    

  • good going Noel~nice tribute.R!

  • good going Noel~R!

  • Comment removed

  • @capinyoassproduction a crap like that... yeah right, shut the fag up !

  • Gallagher should be banned from singing this song.

  • this guy is good, but not that good !

  • Nothing wrong with this version. I actually like it being played in Eminor, in first position rather than capoed on 4th fret. It gives it a lovelly open, ring quality when played on an acoustic.

  • @AussieEuro me too .. Plus Noel's voice got something weird in it !! it is really awesome, and still holding that broken soul in it :)

  • God talk about murdering a bloody good song.

  • Okay, it's obviously not as good as the original, but let's be fair. He stayed true to the spirit of the song, and had enough respect for the original not to try (and likely fail) to sing it like Morrissey. The guy's not untalented, though one could make a case for him being overrated.

  • its actually a very decent version....you morrissey loving queers should get a grip.

  • I don't understand why people watch something they don't like and then comment on how much they don't like it, seems like a waste of time tome...

  • HORRIBLE

  • Ewwwww

  • how dare they even attempt to do this song.

  • @chuckydog probably because of the fact he's from Manchester, and grew up listening to The Smiths, copying them, borrowing a guitar from Marr y'know bascially being in awe of them... I wouldn't say it's the greatest cover, i don't hold Oasis in very high regard, but i think if anyone tries to cover a song, regardless of whether that cover is good or bad, it is just a flattering testament to the song, let's face it, covers help immortalise songs, and i for one don't want this song to die :)

  • @Hammondeggz it just makes me sad when someone as untalented as noel gallagher does a cover of an excellent song.

  • @chuckydog Untalented?? You clearly dont know talent then. Johnny Marr who wrote the music for this song is a big Noel Gallagher fan. So if you say Noel is untalented, then you disagree with the writer of this 'excellent song'..

  • @Xiolablu3 yes i do Disagree with Johnny Marr about this yes. It's called opinion.

  • @Xiolablu3 what? So if the author of this song likes that bloody bastard that means that is talented? The author of this song is human and humans make mistakes

  • @MrMunive No, Johnny Marr is friends with Noel and is a fan

  • es uno de los mejores cover q eh escuchado y si tenia q ser de the smits

  • oasis is fucking terrible.

  • not a very good version of an awesome song , fair to poor audio. Sj200 is cool!!!

    STILL........Can I have my 5 min back

  • noel doing morrissey...i love it

  • noel doing morrissey...i love it

  • nixon men- your a silly  fucker

  • noel is the shit.. calm the fuck down. he loves the smiths, please just see it as a cover. jeez. lighten up!

  • He dumbed it down, lost some of the chords that made it special.

  • horrible

  • Way to ruin a class song.

  • @ELblimshaw

    did we see the same video? I hopt not, because the video above your comment is CLASSIC and absolutely amazing. and it's so good that he did it in another way than the original song

  • brilliant cover of a wonderful musician!the original song is amazing,the smiths are too,morrissey as well.but noel is a bloody genious.

  • @billydc2 no im sure most oasis fan's would agree that oasis are much better than most... the jam and the beatles are the two you named there that are debatable ...i love the stones but oasis are much better LIVE FOREVER

  • Noel Is God!

  • Nix - Noel is shit man! Bon jovi is Better! best of the world!

  • @NixonMen ???????????????

  • Nixon  -- Noel is shit man, Bon Jovi is better, best of the world!!!!

  • @NixonMen shut up.

  • @karitogallagher  noel is shit

  • Anybody know the 3 chords he's playing in this?

  • @Guitar126

    LOL ... :)

  • Охренеть!! я это видел! до сих пор не верится)

  • Definitely Maybe album is so much better than The Queen is Dead...

  • @nhadz16 Trololololo.

  • @nhadz16 *facepalm*

  • How in the world do you people think you can compare an acoustic guitar and snare to the completely studio produced song. Come on...

  • I think Oasis are good its just the singer pisses me off so much, i genuinely can't stand his voice :/, but you can't judge a band just by the singer, the rest are good

  • Oasis is much better than the smiths

  • when I was in high school Noel Gallagher stole my girlfriend. I guess better him than Eddie Vedder.

  • when I was in high school Noel Gallagher stole my girlfriend.

  • @drzendoom I shagged her aswell mate.

  • @hgvneil You bitch! what's wrong with you? You read this comment and then you found my old high school girlfriend and 'shagged' her just because you read my comment!?! ... mmm yeah ok respect good for you man.

  • @drzendoom he is such a bastard!

  • @drzendoom Lucky bastard =o

  • @drzendoom

    I went Barlow as well

  • @drzendoom When I was 12 Noel Gallagher stole my soul with his music :)

  • @muyalpedo11 I guess he did us both a favor. lol.

  • @drzendoom lol, yes he did!! ... cheers from argentina brother!

  • @drzendoom no, cause you're from russia

  • @billydc2 you don't have a clue, oasis came at a time and SAVED music and give it the boot up the arse it so desperately needed ...oasis are no enemy's of the smiths and i don't see why your acting as if they are........THEY ARE TWO OF THE GREATEST BANDS EVER

  • @dalton1888 Im sure Oasis may be in your top two bands ever. But obviously Oasis arent one of the top 2 bands ever. Im sure that die hard oasis fans will agree with me on that one. They are a good indie band but better than zep, floyd, jam, stones, beatles, cream, radiohead, verve, need i go on??

  • @billydc2 ..... You left out The Who and The Kinks.. Oasis is the 7th greatest band EVER... Sit and spin . 

  • Ooh, Lucksmiths did it better. It's on here somewhere...

  • Tune <3

  • mostly of the haters don't even know how to play a damn guitar..people should respect the persons they will never be.

  • Great song this I love morrisey would love to surport him with my origanal indie melodic groove band MANDRAKE from Manchester England type in MANDRAKE MANCHESTER theres 4 songs on there from our album as posted recently by Oscar Novak or go to our my space on w w w . my space . com / mandrakemanchester lo I have had to word the myspace like that with spaces as it wont let me post the link on here. Pls have a listen guys and hope you may like our sound thanx

  • @billydc2 someones jelous move along please

  • @plasticbudgie How on earth did you get jealousy from his statement? This version is pretty crap.

  • @lynus111 K . . .

  • GENIAL MASTER!!

  • the new stuff noel is writing has so much lyrical content!! "forgive me if i spoke too soon, but my eyes will only, follow you around the room, cos your the only, god a man could ever need"! thats genius! and the more i listen the more i think he has matured into one of the best song writers of the last 20 years! shakemaker was good, supersonic etc but they had great guitar hooks and liam singing them! now noel has to do this on his own and he has pulled the rabbit out of the hat again!!!

  • @Garethfeb16 No, genius is Einsteins theory of relativity, Newtons phsyics, or mozarts requiem, this is some mouth twat on the guitar, playing 3 chord bollocks. get some perspective. It doesnt take much to rip off a few lyrics and play Cm G and Am on a guitar.