It's not as wailing because it's live. As those that have seen her perform as I have it's impossible to have her perform at studio level. Takes nothing away, it's a unique situation
I was always nervours to hear anythang she sang live for a long time but now I actually like hearing some live versions better than studio recordings. Like Jimi Hendrix live in concert vs buing his albums, same thang...
I have to say I'm not happy with her choice to do this all mellow falsetto-- on the album version she is really wailing with full voice much more, so much so that her voice is doing that definitive octave-split thing that made me addicted to their sound. Her voice would split into the melody and this shrill wail 1 octave higher. Gotta hear it to believe it.
@daedrmr2dae I also prefer the studio version. For me there is more emotion in the way she sings it on the album. But I like hearing it done differently like this too. It's one of my favourite tracks and I never thought there'd be a clip for it!
@divinedgar no, youre totally off. i am bang on the money. i am sure elizabeth was just looking at me to check i was ok. this was my first year with the band and she was just being sweet. of course i make mistakes sometimes over the years, but i am pretty awesome so its very unlikely ; )
Music will never be this creative, prolific or magical every again. Imagine 3 people on a bare stage with a tape player making something this special these days. Never again.
Check out Rilkean Dreams posting and listen to the beauty at the end of Rilkean Heart before Half- Gifts starts. It will take your breath away, take you to a better place for 15 seconds and make your life a bit better for ever.
1000DRUMZ I love you mate!!! I have an old grainy B&W video recording of this, never seen it in colour before and its perfect. This is my favourite live performance pre Bluebell Knoll, youve no idea how delighted I am in seeing this!!
Imaculate playing (we can excuse Simons scratch!)and has Liz gives one of her most immaculate vocal performances which led me to rave about them to all and sundry.
Do you have the whole recording - I think there was 4 tracks recorded.
Nope, I don't know her. But she once implied that she smoked in an interview, so I wouldn't be surprised if she took the occasional swig to help her with performing. I'm a singer who suffers from the exact same issue. It's hard to be 100% there with an audience when you sing mostly for yourself.
HOW DID I MISS THIS CLIP up until now!? This is incredible. Was that alcohol she was drinking? That would explain the lack of performance nerves here... rare at that period. One of my CT favorites.
Wow, what a beautiful version... And I've never seen her smile like this, so relaxed. Must have been a great atmosphere in there! Thank you for posting this.
I wish sometimes that I had been of an age in the early eighties, sitting in a dark place with the Cure or Cocteau Twins playing right in front of me. Those people were so fortuante....
Listen, I remember when I was completely jealous of a bunch of friends who went to see the H or LV tour in Toronto in '91 that I didn't see them. But not one was all that enthusiastic about the performance...and watching live Cocteaus clips on YT I can see why.
They're a studio band. And there's no shame in that! It just is what it is. It doesn't take away from my sheer joy at seeing how as time passes the Cocteaus remain such an utterly timeless band.
jordimla this performance shows that Liz or CT for that matter isn't just a studio product. I have seen plentey of live performances that where awesome. just cause she isn't a narcassistic tart doesnt take away from her undeniable gifts.
Who gives a shit about journalists and their reviews! I certainly do not. Liz is amazing bottom line! I myself love her live performances. They may seem abstract or nervous to you,but it is her signature style to give abstract performances, often times twisting the lyrics around to make them her own and i love and respect her for having the guts to have her own way of singing. She is one of a kind and i love her for it! This website is not a journalist review site, its a fan site so get off!
One of the very few occasions that Liz jas managed to perform well live!!! I have seen the Cocteau Twins perform live in the Uk during their 4AD heydays and it was horrendous and very static. Whoever the Swede who taped this performance a lot of kudos to you for capturing Liz at her best.
Well, I only managed to see them live AFTER "their 4AD heydays" and they were out of this world, especially Liz! I've heard bootlegs from before and I honestly don't know what your problem is! Do they not move enough on stage for you? Were you looking for a show instead of a live music performance?
NO, I was not looking for a show, but a decent live performance from them. During their 4AD years, their set is continually racked by backing tape problems and Liz' constant attack of the nerves and vocal waywardness. Bootleg performances always chose the best gigs or else thye wouldn't sell...come off your Liz manic idolatry and admit that Cocteau Twins' music is a product of studio creation and best experienced in the living room than in a live setting!!!!
Have you watched any of the other live videos on here? I'm sure you are capable of finding them, and they are after the 4AD yrs! No backing tape problems!!!
And do you think CT bootlegs sell like hot cakes? How many have you bought? And from where? You're living in another dimension!
I am a music journalist. And my esteemed opinions are publish and read!!! Wish I can say that about yours!!! Bottomline is the Cocteau Twins are horrid live and none of your rabid fan hysteria can convince of other wise. She may be "the voice of GOD in the studio, but on a live context she's nothing more than a scared waif singing for her supper!!! End of story.
Well, that's your opinion! Do you think yours are more valid than anyone else's cos you somehow manage to get them published? Have you even looked at the other amazing videos here on YT of CT live? Obviously, not, going by the end of your comment.
P.S. I hope you don't write English language journalism, cos your grammar is not up to scratch!
Iam a huge fan of the cocteaus and i couldnt agree with you more. The first time i saw them i was actually embarrassed for poor liz. She sounded as if she was a strangled swan. But on the milk and kisses tour she was brilliant, due to the removal of her head set, which she used in prior tours. Once the head set was gone it made all the difference. I agree, they definatley are a studio band....
there's nothing scared about her performance, she's really relaxed and it's a different spin on the song. love's easy tears, orange appled, pink orange red. and you MUST hear "The Angel on Ruskin"
'respected music journalist'. yes, your views are so much more valid than that of us mere mortals. the number of sub-standard bands that 'respected music journalists' give the thumbs up to is amazing.
i am not talking about their albums or eps. they are meticulously produced and are flawless. my main gripe is about the inconsistency of their live performance of which liz is the main culprit.
even so, if you listen to them on their album it doesn't seem like their shows would be much upbeat and energetic. it would be like something you just watch and let the music take ahold of you
i never expected an upbeat or energetic show when i came to watch their concerts...what i expected was to be emotionally moved and to be carried over some great heights of spiritual bliss. Unfortunately, that never came about, because of frequent problems with the backing tapes (they used backing tapes from 1982-1988)and liz' problem with her voice due to her nervousness.
you do what most 'esteemed' journalists the world over do - drop a semi-realised, half idea into a discussion, and, upon backlash, you shrug and say 'who, me?'. Then you go on to contradict yourself by using 'horrendous' and 'heyday' in the same clause. NEVER receive a live thumbs up? Check your old NME's, Melody Makers and Sounds. As is usual with 'esteemed' journalists you're let down by poor research. I saw them six times from '83 onwards, glad I didn't waste money on Level 42 and King,dig?
I was one of the people in the audience and at that time I was not very impressed by the performance. My impression was that Liz was very nervous between the songs and the sound was not good. The concert was recorded by the Swedish public service TV and I guess we should be grateful to the TV technicians for the quality since Liz looks fantastic and the sound is great in this video. When I here the music today I realise that they were so ahead of its time.
wow I love how laid back she is here. what a sweet smile. oh and the song is lovely. it's so fortunate for us that they where created and then created such ethereal music.
I can remember the first time I heard this, on a free cassette with a music magazine. Goosebumps then, & now. I started writing to her after 'Garlands' was released and her letters & postcards are amongst my most treasured possesions. I hope she is happy & well :)
Absolutely one of my favorite Cocteau Twins song, when I listen to it, I feel as if I am not even listening to human music, it's like something dreamlike...almost out-of-this world! What a nice arrangement with the quite vocals!
If I'd only known then what I know now.
dannenvance 10 months ago
Music treasure, TY for upload :)
Aristosek 1 year ago
It's not as wailing because it's live. As those that have seen her perform as I have it's impossible to have her perform at studio level. Takes nothing away, it's a unique situation
bearleton 1 year ago
i like it
ManeOfMorinia 1 year ago
"respected music journalist" is an oxymoron
pinkorangered88 1 year ago
<3 Amolap
Screeaw 1 year ago
She was happy at those days...
ordnajelAoneuB 1 year ago
Better than the album. Much quieter and delicate.
LunaSeaSane 1 year ago 3
FUCK SAKE
AtticPhace 1 year ago
I was always nervours to hear anythang she sang live for a long time but now I actually like hearing some live versions better than studio recordings. Like Jimi Hendrix live in concert vs buing his albums, same thang...
quantafunk 1 year ago
I think this is wonderful!
tinkerkor 1 year ago
I have to say I'm not happy with her choice to do this all mellow falsetto-- on the album version she is really wailing with full voice much more, so much so that her voice is doing that definitive octave-split thing that made me addicted to their sound. Her voice would split into the melody and this shrill wail 1 octave higher. Gotta hear it to believe it.
daedrmr2dae 2 years ago
@daedrmr2dae I also prefer the studio version. For me there is more emotion in the way she sings it on the album. But I like hearing it done differently like this too. It's one of my favourite tracks and I never thought there'd be a clip for it!
chrisnoaro1 1 year ago
Awsome!!!!!
thestone09 2 years ago
ok. i might be totally off.
but to me, simon keeps missing some important changes and liz is looking over at him thinking " are you ever going to hit that right"?
it could be a problem with his volume, but something isn't there.
divinedgar 2 years ago
liz used to always do that look off to the side thing
poshgoth 2 years ago
Comment removed
madsketcher 2 years ago
Thats because she was quite shy.
NorrisGeez1986 2 years ago
@divinedgar no, youre totally off. i am bang on the money. i am sure elizabeth was just looking at me to check i was ok. this was my first year with the band and she was just being sweet. of course i make mistakes sometimes over the years, but i am pretty awesome so its very unlikely ; )
simonraymonde 1 year ago 5
The most sensual, romantic and dreaming sound in rock history! The soundtrack of heaven..
carcinofagus 2 years ago 2
Love it!!!!!
isign69 2 years ago
Que ca fait du bien ... : )
s17007 2 years ago
3.25 "what r u doing, simon ?" lulz
birkenowjenn 2 years ago
Music will never be this creative, prolific or magical every again. Imagine 3 people on a bare stage with a tape player making something this special these days. Never again.
BrotherBearAZ 2 years ago 5
2.00 beautiful liz <3 she's stunning here, so young and healthy lookin
joellyshooshoo 2 years ago
So different from the album version which I know well and love: a whole new dimension for me to consider and imagine.
Thank you.
vazjam 2 years ago 4
Maravilloso!
AyahuaskaPop 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Check out Rilkean Dreams posting and listen to the beauty at the end of Rilkean Heart before Half- Gifts starts. It will take your breath away, take you to a better place for 15 seconds and make your life a bit better for ever.
andreaneilcmc 2 years ago 2
Su sonrisa es... descansar en un sueño hecho realidad. Cocteau twins son lo mejor.
galhard 2 years ago 2
Millimillenary has always been
one of my favorites--
and this version is gorgeous as well.
Vadrian7 2 years ago 2
This is wonderful! thank you!
adin200 2 years ago
memories galore !!!
driftwoodbeech 2 years ago
100th rating. So what do I win?
LunaSeaSane 2 years ago
This is an amazing performance! Wow. Thanks for posting!
SBSandknop 2 years ago
Wow, what a beautiful performance. Thanks for sharing.
Otherness 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
LunaSeaSane 2 years ago
Comment removed
LunaSeaSane 2 years ago
I can't stop playing this song again and again.
DavorShearer 3 years ago 3
Neither can I, and I don't even like the Cocteau Twins.
Sesquipedaliantique 3 years ago
Awesome and Brilliant performance.
DavorShearer 3 years ago 2
Do you know what angels sound like?
Listen here.
barrycw1 3 years ago 27
relaxed, confident, she is so beautiful here. Love this version too. it's good to see Liz so relaxed and even smiling here.
milkandkisses78 3 years ago 31
Queen - that's what she is!!!
DyllamDop 3 years ago 3
No luv. that's Freddie Mercury.
This is Cocteau Twins...
LunaSeaSane 2 years ago
As far as I know it was just pure orange juice. Fantastic band!
tosh2804 3 years ago
1000DRUMZ I love you mate!!! I have an old grainy B&W video recording of this, never seen it in colour before and its perfect. This is my favourite live performance pre Bluebell Knoll, youve no idea how delighted I am in seeing this!!
Imaculate playing (we can excuse Simons scratch!)and has Liz gives one of her most immaculate vocal performances which led me to rave about them to all and sundry.
Do you have the whole recording - I think there was 4 tracks recorded.
selsmeister 3 years ago
No, doubt it was alcohol. Used to watch them all the time round about the early eighties and never seen her drunk. Did you know her well?
tosh2804 3 years ago
Nope, I don't know her. But she once implied that she smoked in an interview, so I wouldn't be surprised if she took the occasional swig to help her with performing. I'm a singer who suffers from the exact same issue. It's hard to be 100% there with an audience when you sing mostly for yourself.
madsketcher 3 years ago
HOW DID I MISS THIS CLIP up until now!? This is incredible. Was that alcohol she was drinking? That would explain the lack of performance nerves here... rare at that period. One of my CT favorites.
madsketcher 3 years ago
What an absolute treat!
Thank you a million times!!!
Absolutely lovely, gorgeous, divine!
cocteaulady 3 years ago
God, she's so radiant here, and serene, too! Wonderful performance!!!
bobbysevensevenseven 3 years ago 4
lets just say,i wouldnt kick her out of bed for eatin toast
bunkerpoopie 3 years ago
This must be the show SVT aired on Bagen, right?
ubik71 3 years ago
Wow, what a beautiful version... And I've never seen her smile like this, so relaxed. Must have been a great atmosphere in there! Thank you for posting this.
SoZen08 3 years ago 3
absolute perfection. a beutifully restrained version of this stunning song.
anvilscepe 3 years ago
millimilenaria esta song , beautiful,gorgeous, con un toque de melancolia!!!
joecocteau 3 years ago
Those eyes, that mouth......
AlphaMaleMonkey 3 years ago
More soft and lyrical than the album version.
experimentalactor 3 years ago
O.K., no one else has come right out and said it so I will - Liz is downright SEXY in this performance!!
None of the apprehension or tension present here; good grief - she even SMILES in this video!
Yeesh, watching this made me feel like my old Kate Bush crush era from the early 80's, lol.
Now, back to the usual "Voice of the Angels" comments that are normally made...
fractaljack 3 years ago
Liz has always been sexy...well, except for recently...she didn't age very well....
motodude1 3 years ago
Thanks for sharing this one, I didn't know this song at all. As usual, absolutely gorgeous.
heyjudes59 3 years ago
I wish sometimes that I had been of an age in the early eighties, sitting in a dark place with the Cure or Cocteau Twins playing right in front of me. Those people were so fortuante....
eccentricblonde 3 years ago
Wow, Terrific (-_-)
secondhanddaylight 3 years ago
AWESOME and BRILLIANT performance... in 1984!
Eternal thanx for uploading this gem!
cocteaulab 3 years ago
a wonderful archive moment...simon playing guitar too, the concentration!!
clarissespader 3 years ago
The icy audience dont realize what's in front of them- a legend band
orenatz 3 years ago 2
Listen, I remember when I was completely jealous of a bunch of friends who went to see the H or LV tour in Toronto in '91 that I didn't see them. But not one was all that enthusiastic about the performance...and watching live Cocteaus clips on YT I can see why.
They're a studio band. And there's no shame in that! It just is what it is. It doesn't take away from my sheer joy at seeing how as time passes the Cocteaus remain such an utterly timeless band.
fuggybootnling 3 years ago
Amazing! Wish I could've seen them when they were touring, but alas I was still swimming around in my dad's sack with this came out!
perpitbla5 3 years ago 3
Awesome live!
clinpsydoc 3 years ago 2
Oh my, I think I have a girl crush!
santoshasong 3 years ago 5
jordimla this performance shows that Liz or CT for that matter isn't just a studio product. I have seen plentey of live performances that where awesome. just cause she isn't a narcassistic tart doesnt take away from her undeniable gifts.
milkandkisses78 3 years ago 7
Who gives a shit about journalists and their reviews! I certainly do not. Liz is amazing bottom line! I myself love her live performances. They may seem abstract or nervous to you,but it is her signature style to give abstract performances, often times twisting the lyrics around to make them her own and i love and respect her for having the guts to have her own way of singing. She is one of a kind and i love her for it! This website is not a journalist review site, its a fan site so get off!
Lynster8 3 years ago 4
One of the very few occasions that Liz jas managed to perform well live!!! I have seen the Cocteau Twins perform live in the Uk during their 4AD heydays and it was horrendous and very static. Whoever the Swede who taped this performance a lot of kudos to you for capturing Liz at her best.
jordimla 3 years ago
Well, I only managed to see them live AFTER "their 4AD heydays" and they were out of this world, especially Liz! I've heard bootlegs from before and I honestly don't know what your problem is! Do they not move enough on stage for you? Were you looking for a show instead of a live music performance?
pur69 3 years ago 3
NO, I was not looking for a show, but a decent live performance from them. During their 4AD years, their set is continually racked by backing tape problems and Liz' constant attack of the nerves and vocal waywardness. Bootleg performances always chose the best gigs or else thye wouldn't sell...come off your Liz manic idolatry and admit that Cocteau Twins' music is a product of studio creation and best experienced in the living room than in a live setting!!!!
jordimla 3 years ago
Have you watched any of the other live videos on here? I'm sure you are capable of finding them, and they are after the 4AD yrs! No backing tape problems!!!
And do you think CT bootlegs sell like hot cakes? How many have you bought? And from where? You're living in another dimension!
pur69 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Just for your reference, the Cocteau Twins' have never,EVER receive a thumbs up from respected music journalist for their live performance.
jordimla 3 years ago
So, you take your cue from music journalists? You can't make up your own mind? I don't need music journalists to tell me what is good!
pur69 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
I am a music journalist. And my esteemed opinions are publish and read!!! Wish I can say that about yours!!! Bottomline is the Cocteau Twins are horrid live and none of your rabid fan hysteria can convince of other wise. She may be "the voice of GOD in the studio, but on a live context she's nothing more than a scared waif singing for her supper!!! End of story.
jordimla 3 years ago
Well, that's your opinion! Do you think yours are more valid than anyone else's cos you somehow manage to get them published? Have you even looked at the other amazing videos here on YT of CT live? Obviously, not, going by the end of your comment.
P.S. I hope you don't write English language journalism, cos your grammar is not up to scratch!
pur69 3 years ago 5
Iam a huge fan of the cocteaus and i couldnt agree with you more. The first time i saw them i was actually embarrassed for poor liz. She sounded as if she was a strangled swan. But on the milk and kisses tour she was brilliant, due to the removal of her head set, which she used in prior tours. Once the head set was gone it made all the difference. I agree, they definatley are a studio band....
brianmckinleyharris 3 years ago
there's nothing scared about her performance, she's really relaxed and it's a different spin on the song. love's easy tears, orange appled, pink orange red. and you MUST hear "The Angel on Ruskin"
sayin all that, i never saw them live myself XD
joellyshooshoo 3 years ago
'respected music journalist'. yes, your views are so much more valid than that of us mere mortals. the number of sub-standard bands that 'respected music journalists' give the thumbs up to is amazing.
bleedingpepper 3 years ago 3
you may be right...MAYBE...but let's look at their music shall we...
Half of their albums are 4 out of 5 stars. it means they are doing something right.
TheHell2Come 3 years ago
i am not talking about their albums or eps. they are meticulously produced and are flawless. my main gripe is about the inconsistency of their live performance of which liz is the main culprit.
jordimla 3 years ago
even so, if you listen to them on their album it doesn't seem like their shows would be much upbeat and energetic. it would be like something you just watch and let the music take ahold of you
TheHell2Come 3 years ago 2
i never expected an upbeat or energetic show when i came to watch their concerts...what i expected was to be emotionally moved and to be carried over some great heights of spiritual bliss. Unfortunately, that never came about, because of frequent problems with the backing tapes (they used backing tapes from 1982-1988)and liz' problem with her voice due to her nervousness.
jordimla 3 years ago
you do what most 'esteemed' journalists the world over do - drop a semi-realised, half idea into a discussion, and, upon backlash, you shrug and say 'who, me?'. Then you go on to contradict yourself by using 'horrendous' and 'heyday' in the same clause. NEVER receive a live thumbs up? Check your old NME's, Melody Makers and Sounds. As is usual with 'esteemed' journalists you're let down by poor research. I saw them six times from '83 onwards, glad I didn't waste money on Level 42 and King,dig?
deejaybee 3 years ago 6
Just luv liz and the cocteaus!!!
Yeah! liz did suffer badly with nerves,on live
events,like lots of stars!!!brill stuff!!
Thanks for the video mate!!.
shum65 3 years ago 2
It's nice to see this here. Liz looks like a living breathing painting.
milkandkisses78 3 years ago 7
wow Liz sounds and looks amazing in this! What a beautiful song!
Lynster8 3 years ago 2
Wow, I love this live version of 'Millimillenary'! Thanks for posting it!
paulushook 3 years ago 2
I was one of the people in the audience and at that time I was not very impressed by the performance. My impression was that Liz was very nervous between the songs and the sound was not good. The concert was recorded by the Swedish public service TV and I guess we should be grateful to the TV technicians for the quality since Liz looks fantastic and the sound is great in this video. When I here the music today I realise that they were so ahead of its time.
BEAMXX 3 years ago
Hermoso!
AyahuaskaPop 3 years ago
I could watch this all day long.
santoshasong 3 years ago 7
tis one of the best songs
klonedklein 3 years ago 4
Beautiful. Thanks for posting this.
ahantabarzin 3 years ago 8
be still my beating heart! just too good for words - only liz speak could do it justice. Thanks for this one too.
johnchiwilson 4 years ago 4
Awesome, great track and great performance.
rawk72 4 years ago 4
wow...just wow.........
Robin's guitar sounds so beautiful...only one guitarist I know who can replicate a sound like this...
TheHell2Come 4 years ago
Yes...Simon Raymonde
davesixtysix 4 years ago 3
not who I was thinking...
I was going to say Kenny Hickey
TheHell2Come 4 years ago
Excuse my ignorance....don't think I know him?
davesixtysix 4 years ago
most people don't
=)
he's the guitarist from Type O Negative.
watch the live video for "Christian Woman"
about halfway through, you'll see what I mean
TheHell2Come 4 years ago
o tak Liz jest Aniołem :-)
qncept 4 years ago
Oh God (i.e. Oh Liz) !!! You will go definitively to heaven for posting this !!
Thanksssss
alaala666 4 years ago 2
I've never seen her looking so beautiful. 02:02 an angel smiles. Wow!! i could watch this forever
Hirsute63 4 years ago 3
Thank you for that.
jojo808 3 years ago 3
wow I love how laid back she is here. what a sweet smile. oh and the song is lovely. it's so fortunate for us that they where created and then created such ethereal music.
santoshasong 3 years ago 7
I can remember the first time I heard this, on a free cassette with a music magazine. Goosebumps then, & now. I started writing to her after 'Garlands' was released and her letters & postcards are amongst my most treasured possesions. I hope she is happy & well :)
REPLICESS 4 years ago
Cocteau Twins 4-ever.
NortelN07 4 years ago
I am awestruck and speechless by this magic. Maybe the audience is too, and that would explain their lame-ass response to this amazing performance.
-otherworldly- This is one of my favorite live performances of CT as of late..
snaulkter 4 years ago 2
What an upload! Bravo. The first Twins song recorded in the studio with Simon i believe.
shamu311312311 4 years ago
this is soooooooooo ahead of its time. The audience doesnt realize that they are hearing history in the making.
brianmckinleyharris 4 years ago
Absolutely one of my favorite Cocteau Twins song, when I listen to it, I feel as if I am not even listening to human music, it's like something dreamlike...almost out-of-this world! What a nice arrangement with the quite vocals!
Excellent!
JohnnySwitchblade 4 years ago 2
Nice one! I wonder why this song wasn't put on Lullabies to Violaine?
minedarea 4 years ago
oh my goawd did you see that angel smile...wow..
doesnthurt2try 4 years ago
Fantastic, thanks for sharing this. Do you have any more of this set. If so, please please please upload, i'm begging you :)
rp61wasinnocentok 4 years ago 2
mi cancion preferida de 'the pink opaque'
jaureiscis 4 years ago
Oh oh oh! This is so wonderful! I get so excited everytime I hear Liz sing! Thank you so much for this I really enjoyed it.. <3
caoq 4 years ago 2
Ditto!!
pur69 4 years ago
Oh Mon Dieu !!!!!!!! Amazing !!! Thanks 1000DRUMZ
CAROPASK 4 years ago