Really heart touching song. and the dance is awesome. love this song. Thanks a lot for uploading this song. Thanks again to the uploader.She is the best actress in Bollywood. She deserves the best actress award in India.
Really heart touching song. and the dance is awsome. love this song. Thanks a lot for upload this song. Thanks again to the uploader.She is the best actress in Bollywood. She deserve the best actress award in India.
It iz such a BEAUTIFUL composition that i cannot believe that it iz been composed by COPY CAT yes PREETAM and i still believe that it must be adopted from the another versions of SOUTH If any body knows kindly let me know Salute to UNKOWN composer HATS off to SHERYA GHOSHAL and I AM PAKISTANI 03332604292
its not at all brillian as d malayalam version..... her performance is so damn not gud as shobana's n those u who think dat dis is brilliant/... u r wrong.. once if u see d malayalam version u will change ur ur words.....
wow people r fighting over dance?? who cares man jus listen to the damn song. why do we always fight over stupid shits. the people who choreographed this song know wht they've done..
this is not the whole bengali version and one more thing
we are all indians it doesn't matter that if the movie is bengali and dance from south india...this is trying to show the mixed and diversed culture of india people
i think the tamil version is much better. Jyotika jus excelled in tat role.....Jus watch Raa Raa song from Chandramukhi movie( its the tamil version) am sure u gotta love it
@sivakasiberlin Malayalam film Manichitrazhu, was firstly remade in Tamil. Shobana's acting from the original is simply brilliant, neither Jothika nor Vidya did much justice to the original performance. However the song from the Tamil version Chandramukhi's the best. When it comes to dancing, again Jothika and Vidya were not as good as Shobana from the Malayalam version. But then again Shobana is a professional dancer. Vineeth the male dancer was in both the tamil version and this.Be objective!
Many years ago I studied Kathak, but since 3 years I have decided to teach because in my country nobody know Indian dance. Of course I teach Bollywood style to the guirls and this is my favorite video, because, the couple are excellents dancers. She is a wonderful actress so like him and the choreography is very beauty. It is one of the better of Bollywood history. And the scene is complete in its argument. Thanks a lot for upload this marveloux video.
Oh my gosh! At 3:45 they look sooooooo cute together! Vidya Balan really showed off her true bengali dancing skills!I am practicing this dance day and night! One day i hope i get it.
But one thing. In this hindi version song length is more. All other versions, starting to ending dance dance only dance. But this hindi version 2nd half only peak dance started. But that equal infact beated all other version perfection. This vineeth prove & submited his GURU DAKSHANA to his Bharatha natya Guru. Ms. PADMA SUBRAMANIAN founder of NIRUTHODYA. WoooooW! what a fastest beat dance? Class. Other than nothing.
I would say this is the second best in all the songs. Shobana was, of course, the best! In this one, they didn't make Vidya do stuff that she really couldn't, even after taking some kathak classes, whereas in the other 2, Jyotika and Soundarya were doing things that they couldn't. But then again, I am slightly biased -- I danced to the original version (Oru Murai) and I'm totally in love with Vineeth's and Shobana's dancing :P
Shobhana, soundarya, jyotika and vidya all ending with "a" have done a fantastic job in Manichithrathazhu, apthamitra, chandramukhi and bhool bhulaiya.
This is the worst of the versions i have seen in all. i.e., Manichitrathazhu in Malayalam, Aapthamitra in Kannada, Chandramukhi in Tamil.
However the Original Script in Malayalam is the best simply because Shobhana is a Professional Dancer and also she suits the Character because herself being a Tamilian, whereas Jothika and Soundarya are not Telugu. Jothika is Urdu, Soundarya is Kannada, and i have No idea of Vidya Balan.
she actually did the whole film for just 50 lakh, it was first offered to aishwarya rai, but she asked 4 crore for it and priyadarshan chose vidaya then.
I'm Bengali myself, so when I heard the beginning, I fell in love with it. Anwesha sings it so professionally. I've been trying to sing it, but it's so hard. There's so many vibrations that you have to do. I have to give props to Anwesha for rockin it and the singer who sang this song.
does anyone know where i can find this song in its bengali form? I've looked everywhere and i can only find it as Mere Dholna. I know Mere Dholna is the Hindi version but I want it as Ami Je Tomar. So anyone know where I can find it?
u knw the part where akshay mimics the bengali song..lol like ami je tomar , ami je tomar..lol watch the movie.ull see...mind blowing acting i tell u ! LOL
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I wish ASHA BHOSLE should have sung this song..would hav taken it to another level. she sings million times better than shreya anytime. although shreya has done a good job.
It is so heart warming that in this modern day with rif raf music like singh is king, we have such a masterpiece song like this from same MD, my heart just melts when I listen to this, beautiful Cinematography, Lyrics, vocals and the music, juts felt on the screen, the male vocals would have sounded better in sonu's voice, he would have surely taken this song to the next level. What a beautiful Movie, this is the first Bollywood movie I have watched in Ages....SUPERB!!! Who needs western Music!
wow i cant believe that in this movie and the tamil version,the main actor and couple other actors dont show sympathy or any kind feelings to the sick character..Soundarya seems to have the character well enough :) but man, the original is something else..all the actors in the movie were sooo good!!hindi is better of all the remakes but all the actresses, Shobhana, vidya, jo and soundarya did amazing performances..
Shobhana is hte best though..what a figure, expressions, acting and dance!!!
Take Shankarabharanam - it was remade in Hindi and the song "Dhanyavaad se Paaya" is good (Sung by Bhimsen Joshi - frm Karnataka though he is a Hindustani classical legend himself) But SPB did a great job in Telugu the original movie. They possibly here should have used Kathak or Manipuri style instead of Odissi and a mix of Bharatanatyam in Hindi But I like the song either ways.
SPOILS the song? That's a bit drastic. Adds a bit of a distinctive flavour to the song but spoil it? The singer would have to be someone like Shahrukh or Sanjay Dutt being made to sing classical for it be spoilt. Even so, it's a Malayalam/Tamil/Kannada movie that was remade into Hindi by a Malyali director who assisted the making of the original Malayalam movie. I would think he'd want to retain the original flavour somewhere in the movie.
Ok.. maybe I was a bit drastic in saying that it "spoils" the song.. but the mallu accent seems a bit odd.. the tamil song in malayalam version and the telugu song in the tamil version were perfect..and anyway all ere south indian languages.but the mallu accent with a hindi/bengali song does not sound smooth. a northie could have done the male voice.Listen closely to the "sa ni dha." part.and the way the "ab raat din" is sung u will realise what i mean.The"spoils the song" comment is withdrawn
I understand what you're trying to say, that the pronunciation of certain words is slight jarring. But if sa ni dha sounded "mallu" to you, well who is to say that the way you or I say Sa Ni Dha is more correct than the way the singer said it. Furthermore, the characters of Sridhar and Manjulika are Bengalis. Maybe the accent served well. The song still flows well though. It wouldn't had one of the singers gone off key.
In addition, some of the remarkable singers in Bollywood had accents e.g. S.P. Balasubramaniam (the male singer for Hum Aapke Hain Koun), Yesudas (who sang the songs of Chitchor and still won a National Award), Chitra K.S. (Mere Dil Ka Tumse Hai Kehna), Maryam Toller (Maiyya Maiyya), Lata Mangeshkar (the way she pronounces "Aetebaar" and other Urdu words), Mohammed Rafi (a lot of the times he pronounced the Q sound in Urdu as K). Try listening to the dialog in Bhool Bhulaiya. It's worse.
Final Arguments:-) Yes,no voice can suit Salman Khan as perfectly as SPB..Saajan, patthar ke phool..maine pyaar kiya..HAHK..And there were some wonderful songs by Yesudass in a movie called Meera ka Mohan ( im stll searching for those songs) BUT. emotions and music are expressed better in a known language since ther is lesser strain. And that is the case with this song. The textbook pronounciation is jarring. Maybe I noticed more cos I am a southie and my hindi is really bad and heavily accented
I think Malayalam is the best of the lot Malayalam also has real dancers-Shobana and Sridhar have done a great job (hardcore Bharathanatyam). In Kannada the Male dancer and Soundarya are good too - I have not watched the tamil version so cant comment. Hindi song is very catchy I guess if you listen to Shreya singing this song too she sounds southy :) because the original song was carnatic style it becomes hard to make it Hindustani unless they put in full effort.
And also.. one more thing. In Malayalam the climax song is entirely in Tamil and in the Tamil and Kannada versins the song is entirely in telugu. But only the hindi version has most of the song in hindi..thats not good. The malayalam version was the best...and the tamil version was rubbish because it gave importance to Rajnikanth... but on the whole a good concept of the movie and great climax songs in all versions of the movies.
Hello!! IT fits. Because the male dancer in the movie is Malayalee. You can't have Sonu Nigam singing for a guy that distinctively looks South INdia. And even though the story is Bengali, the dance is Bharatanatyam, which is NOT Bengali at all.
Vidya Balan did a good job in this film. Vidya is an actress who is a tradtional type of Indian woman, unlike some of the overly westernised lot we see these days. Reminds me of all the olden actresses like Madhubala, Vijayantimala, Nutan, more recent Smita Patil, Jaya Prada, Sridevi, Madhuri.
fantastic song
iamharsh007 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Really heart touching song. and the dance is awesome. love this song. Thanks a lot for uploading this song. Thanks again to the uploader.She is the best actress in Bollywood. She deserves the best actress award in India.
naim2610 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Really heart touching song. and the dance is awsome. love this song. Thanks a lot for upload this song. Thanks again to the uploader.She is the best actress in Bollywood. She deserve the best actress award in India.
naim2610 3 months ago
well,I only listen to the song and I dare not to watch the video.
angelaserpa100 3 months ago
This Song Iz Juz Awesome ... I LOVE IT sooo SoOo Sooo Much ... !!
It Drenched Into My SOul & Veins ...
&
Shreya Goshal & Anwesha ....
Ur Voices ... Too Great ... Love U
GoD BlEsS YoU TwO ...
BReddyAryan16 3 months ago in playlist rabindra sangeet
i didn't know Vydia dances like that she is incredibly good
aluxenawal 5 months ago
I love this movie, and especially this song & dance scene (but I 'pause' it right when the king pulls his sword...:) - thanks for posting it
punzelle 9 months ago
watch out the first version manichitrathazhu'' shobhana's amazing perfomance
parvathivijayan400 10 months ago
bangladesssshh,
ami tomake ballobashi!
Yasminchoudhury 1 year ago
i seriously never knew Vidya Balan was SUCHA AWSOM dancer... love it just love it... AMAZING ob
desiigal16 1 year ago
@desiigal16: watch out the first version "manichithrathazhu" shobhana's rocking performance
sreedev712 1 year ago
@desiigal16: watch out the first version "manichithrathazhu" shobhana's rocking performance
sreedev712 1 year ago
Whyd that wierdo prince/king guy slash Vidya on her face?
spottopia 1 year ago
@spottopia dude he didnt slash vidya on the face. he cut off the head of the male dancer, and his blood fell on her cheeks.
ank950301 11 months ago
/watch?v=5GQca51FlQ0
its the real one
Gjay512 1 year ago
It iz such a BEAUTIFUL composition that i cannot believe that it iz been composed by COPY CAT yes PREETAM and i still believe that it must be adopted from the another versions of SOUTH If any body knows kindly let me know Salute to UNKOWN composer HATS off to SHERYA GHOSHAL and I AM PAKISTANI 03332604292
nawabshaukat 1 year ago
@nawabshaukat
this is the real and first version :)
Gjay512 1 year ago
@nawabshaukat nonsense. pritam has copied only 3% of his songs (PROVEN FACT)
ank950301 11 months ago
This is not Bengali.
hardupooju 1 year ago
Comment removed
hardupooju 1 year ago
its not at all brillian as d malayalam version..... her performance is so damn not gud as shobana's n those u who think dat dis is brilliant/... u r wrong.. once if u see d malayalam version u will change ur ur words.....
sameera14289 1 year ago
her performance is so weak compared to t original ...shobana
apnafavorite 1 year ago
see vidya balan widout make over she ll be more scary then this scene
lol..............
mariamax99 1 year ago
thank you. i've been looking for this song everywhere.
thisistass 1 year ago
Holy shit it's scary
XxCuteAna 1 year ago
remake of malayalam movie and tamil movie : chandarmukhi and manichitrazhu! shobana was the best .. no one can beat her....
dosti45 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i think watchin this is STUPIDITYYYYYYYYYY...... :-p
8270689 2 years ago
what kind of indian classical dance was she performing??
Usagiiiiiiii 2 years ago
lol at time of watching this movie her dancing like this was scary. :|
DieHardsBegins 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
who said this is bengali version this is hindi version all the words of this song is in hindi not in bengoli. fuck you all....
honeyyou12 2 years ago
any bengoli here? plz tell me da meaning of da 2 lines aami je tomar.....
swapnilsalkar 2 years ago
it means "i'm yours, only yours"
ihatesowhat 2 years ago 3
@swapnilsalkar the two lines mean "I am yours...and only yours...."
drunkandangry 2 years ago
ami je tomar = i am yours
joshua00023 1 year ago
quit fighting overr art folks....enjoy it. does sit really matter what it is .....its beautiful
rajansabitha 2 years ago 3
wow people r fighting over dance?? who cares man jus listen to the damn song. why do we always fight over stupid shits. the people who choreographed this song know wht they've done..
xxn3rdie90xx 2 years ago
this is not the whole bengali version and one more thing
we are all indians it doesn't matter that if the movie is bengali and dance from south india...this is trying to show the mixed and diversed culture of india people
BE PROUD OF IT not mad
maumitasgreat 2 years ago 3
:-)
Regards.
trulytito 2 years ago
bad print......
madhulimamukherjee 2 years ago
Where can I find an audio recording of the Bengali version?
1minalgabail 2 years ago
balls watch the mal version....
sonuwawa 2 years ago
jyothika did a better job
fuzzyfaced 2 years ago
jyothika looked the part amazing and did a very good performance but her dancing was nothing compared to vidya's. very good job on both parts though
:)
hiddentears14 2 years ago
i think the tamil version is much better. Jyotika jus excelled in tat role.....Jus watch Raa Raa song from Chandramukhi movie( its the tamil version) am sure u gotta love it
dillihyd 2 years ago
i love vidya balan's performance
MsDesigirl2009 2 years ago
it sucks, the tamil version is better "raa raa" , coz this shit is not spoooky man
sivakasiberlin 2 years ago
The Malayalam version is the besssttttttt 100%
underpressure16 2 years ago
u hail from us TAMILS, u r our kidz :D
sivakasiberlin 2 years ago
i suppose u could say that
nashk2tamzin 2 years ago
@sivakasiberlin Malayalam film Manichitrazhu, was firstly remade in Tamil. Shobana's acting from the original is simply brilliant, neither Jothika nor Vidya did much justice to the original performance. However the song from the Tamil version Chandramukhi's the best. When it comes to dancing, again Jothika and Vidya were not as good as Shobana from the Malayalam version. But then again Shobana is a professional dancer. Vineeth the male dancer was in both the tamil version and this.Be objective!
MsVoice88 2 months ago
brilliant song
reckoner24 2 years ago
shreya ... u r the best !!!
The male classical singer (i feel he is from Kerala, pepl told me, he only sang in the Malayalam version also) has also done justice to the song...
farjiid200701 2 years ago
The male singer is M. G. Sreekumar. Yes, he is from Kerala. :)
littleangel50us 2 years ago 2
abuelkamsa
hii
u r from which country ??
wordspark 2 years ago
this is the best dance sequence i have ever seen in ,y life ... Hollywood included !!
bigbromiss 2 years ago
very nice song and great dance by vidya balan
sameeryurs 2 years ago
Comment removed
ahmedstamfordahmed 2 years ago
God damn, this is so fucking good...
DoriRomantic 2 years ago 7
Everybody forgets about M.G Shree Kumar...... the classical part is sung by him.............which adds colour to the song............
gandhiji00 2 years ago 2
awesome song! love shreya's voice in this and vidya's dancing and acting was really good.
FaiyazKolia 2 years ago
malyalam is the best
priyaiyer2007 2 years ago
Many years ago I studied Kathak, but since 3 years I have decided to teach because in my country nobody know Indian dance. Of course I teach Bollywood style to the guirls and this is my favorite video, because, the couple are excellents dancers. She is a wonderful actress so like him and the choreography is very beauty. It is one of the better of Bollywood history. And the scene is complete in its argument. Thanks a lot for upload this marveloux video.
Sahadi
abuelkamsa 2 years ago 3
i lv sp, superb voice
srimanfuntosh 2 years ago
Comment removed
15mayankgoyal 2 years ago
Vidya Balan is amazing! She is an awesome dancer!
emilypsinghlove 2 years ago 3
love d song..for all its sargams..shreya's lovely voice..d rendition is simply awesome.....with all traditional ragas...wooow!!
JaneAnn88 2 years ago
Comment removed
JaneAnn88 2 years ago
Luv shreya ghoshal big time!
Who gave her dat voice???
eesharc 2 years ago
Oh my gosh! At 3:45 they look sooooooo cute together! Vidya Balan really showed off her true bengali dancing skills!I am practicing this dance day and night! One day i hope i get it.
sinfulangel2013 2 years ago
You will. Good luck.
sabbirsa 2 years ago
Thanks! By the way i finally got it!
sinfulangel2013 2 years ago
will it be possible for u to email this song to me? or tell me where i can get the mp3 version of this bengali version...
thanks
fida05 2 years ago
love the song
weejayR9 2 years ago
i loveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee this song...
kakontania 2 years ago 3
the msuic 4 this is propper fab !
xoxoshgirlxoxo 2 years ago
this is still the hindi version... pretty much. except for some verses.
beedizzyroy 2 years ago
what is this movie title..
amizamoasis 2 years ago
bhool bulayiaa
lesseve 2 years ago
bhool bhulaiya
xoxoshgirlxoxo 2 years ago
how is this the full bengali version u idiot???
kdubz321 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Get a life and calm down you complete idiot.
KingPunde 2 years ago
lol who said i dont have a life???
as far as the idiocy thing goes......well ur a typical example
kdubz321 2 years ago
the story is really interesting but the film direction made it ugly, the quality for 2007 -> -.-
oOShqiptarOo 2 years ago
go please too the year 3000 !!!! go away from this timeline please ok?
weejayR9 2 years ago
wow she cann dancee..
coooooooool
ConcreteAngel22222 2 years ago
yenna koduma saravanan idhu!!!!
harinikeshsaarang 2 years ago
But one thing. In this hindi version song length is more. All other versions, starting to ending dance dance only dance. But this hindi version 2nd half only peak dance started. But that equal infact beated all other version perfection. This vineeth prove & submited his GURU DAKSHANA to his Bharatha natya Guru. Ms. PADMA SUBRAMANIAN founder of NIRUTHODYA. WoooooW! what a fastest beat dance? Class. Other than nothing.
thirumalairaghavan 2 years ago
/* me encantaaa esta cancionnnnnnnnnnnnn es super wena weee
thebabyjanet 2 years ago
ew i hated Akshay Kumar except for in Jaanwar thats like the only movie that I thought that he could dance to
I <3333 THIS SONG 4EVA SHABAASH KAMAAL KYA BAAT HAI
Hbthe101 2 years ago
Un dans spiritual faimos.
dinahanastasia 2 years ago
who is the singer of this song?
AKKInHSYKlover 2 years ago
Shreya Ghoshal<3
my fav singer : )
Bengali21gal 2 years ago
The male is Sreekumar ...
CaptainPicquard 2 years ago
I would say this is the second best in all the songs. Shobana was, of course, the best! In this one, they didn't make Vidya do stuff that she really couldn't, even after taking some kathak classes, whereas in the other 2, Jyotika and Soundarya were doing things that they couldn't. But then again, I am slightly biased -- I danced to the original version (Oru Murai) and I'm totally in love with Vineeth's and Shobana's dancing :P
littleangel50us 3 years ago 2
Shobhana, soundarya, jyotika and vidya all ending with "a" have done a fantastic job in Manichithrathazhu, apthamitra, chandramukhi and bhool bhulaiya.
Action11Heroine 3 years ago
first of all mr.avharprasad..this song is beautiful..and second of all..get your stupid facts right...jyothika is not urdu, she's punjabi muslim!!
shenal10 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is the worst of the versions i have seen in all. i.e., Manichitrathazhu in Malayalam, Aapthamitra in Kannada, Chandramukhi in Tamil.
However the Original Script in Malayalam is the best simply because Shobhana is a Professional Dancer and also she suits the Character because herself being a Tamilian, whereas Jothika and Soundarya are not Telugu. Jothika is Urdu, Soundarya is Kannada, and i have No idea of Vidya Balan.
avhariprasad 3 years ago
u ppl c this potrion in malayalam , then u can feel the differance in presentation of this scene, shobhana did a great work in malayalam...
krishnapriya1 3 years ago
the original film was in malyalam named manichitrathazhu then it came in tamil named chandramukhi and now in hindi named bhool bhulaiya
its an excellant movie and love............. this song
its soooooo..........nice
pooja123cool 3 years ago
the video iz nt dat gud as da song..buh i luvv da song
deadlyteen13 3 years ago 2
the video of the song depends upon the situations and this sond is just like that and i agree with u on saying the song is good
pooja123cool 3 years ago 2
they all are stupid... m telling u dis is gr888888888... mah fav....
fiona1500 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Its a sick video
anhossain 3 years ago
i thin he mean sick as in a good video
bellamits 3 years ago
this was such a creepy film man..
liby1234 3 years ago
Vidya Balan was probably payed a lot to play a crazy person. Sorry for people who haven't seen the movie, but it's kind of obvious.
youlovamuah 3 years ago 2
she actually did the whole film for just 50 lakh, it was first offered to aishwarya rai, but she asked 4 crore for it and priyadarshan chose vidaya then.
jesse0sheena 3 years ago 2
i loved it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
akudiv 3 years ago 2
its my best song, i love it!!!
sanam2403 3 years ago 2
Anvesha sings this song better than original.
ggg443 3 years ago
i am a fan of anwesha, but you cant say she is better than shreya ghoshal..
jesse0sheena 3 years ago 2
Hi sheena, i love shreya ghosha's trained voice.But anvesha's voice has ability to create romanace, love, kindness, energy. reply me. tanx
DU241955 3 years ago 2
i agree..anwesha is brilliant! she will be a great singer one day.
jesse0sheena 3 years ago 2
i agree
anwesha is really the best
i started crying when she sung
o meri jaan
Carlisles1affaire 3 years ago
nice song
tinavala55 3 years ago 2
LOVE IT!!!!
riffiazina 3 years ago 2
Looove dis sonq <3
M3ANDONLY 3 years ago
I'm Bengali myself, so when I heard the beginning, I fell in love with it. Anwesha sings it so professionally. I've been trying to sing it, but it's so hard. There's so many vibrations that you have to do. I have to give props to Anwesha for rockin it and the singer who sang this song.
youlovamuah 3 years ago 7
beautiful song...its such a tough song!!!
how do singers sing it...how does anwesha sing it!!!
im tryna sing it myself...ami je tomaaar shudhu je tomaar
Sylvanyicool 3 years ago 3
the dance sux...but what a fabulous song...by a divine singer
prashanth1405 3 years ago
Shreya did the job in this song & vidya did a great support.
TiloWolf02 3 years ago 2
HELLA LOVE DIS SONG...THNKS SO MUCH!
Crazy4you10 3 years ago
i dont know the difference betwenn ami je tomar and mere dholna what is the difference it sounds the same
bolanomi13 3 years ago
does anyone know where i can find this song in its bengali form? I've looked everywhere and i can only find it as Mere Dholna. I know Mere Dholna is the Hindi version but I want it as Ami Je Tomar. So anyone know where I can find it?
crazyagent013 3 years ago
god she looks so scary in the begining. lol.
sweetsalmin 3 years ago 2
vidya is not shobana, ya everyone knows that. Can people just comment on if Vidya did good or not instead of ALWAYS comparing her to sho-banana?
RaniTX08 3 years ago
lol i just love the way akshay kumar insults and mimics the song in one part .lol it was hesterical !!!!!
lifeisshortliveitup 3 years ago
he did can u tell me where
bolanomi13 3 years ago
u knw the part where akshay mimics the bengali song..lol like ami je tomar , ami je tomar..lol watch the movie.ull see...mind blowing acting i tell u ! LOL
lifeisshortliveitup 3 years ago
YEAH WERE CAN U GIVE ME THE SITE
bolanomi13 3 years ago
ya i agree... no one can beat shobana. but vidya did a good job too.
canadian4875 3 years ago 5
shobana was excellent
priyanka2001 3 years ago 3
vidya did good, but shobhana did the best in the original malyalam movie manichithrathazhu
NiMBuKun25 3 years ago 2
this is the best song i`ve eva heard i mean in the sense of dancing it`s best`s just thril us n vidya has done a fantastic job
siyaroy2 3 years ago 2
nice
princessabbz09 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
they got this song from a movie called chandramoki
SylhetSweety16 3 years ago
luv this sng
=)
smellysim 3 years ago 3
This is the Best song out of tghe movie Bhool Bhuliyia
Hbthe101 3 years ago 5
shit she scared me,lol.but nice song
ihfmdrg 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I wish ASHA BHOSLE should have sung this song..would hav taken it to another level. she sings million times better than shreya anytime. although shreya has done a good job.
raoalikhan 3 years ago
truly a beautiful flim. modern and and classical as well.
fab. musical arrangement & dance
samantarambharat 3 years ago
It is so heart warming that in this modern day with rif raf music like singh is king, we have such a masterpiece song like this from same MD, my heart just melts when I listen to this, beautiful Cinematography, Lyrics, vocals and the music, juts felt on the screen, the male vocals would have sounded better in sonu's voice, he would have surely taken this song to the next level. What a beautiful Movie, this is the first Bollywood movie I have watched in Ages....SUPERB!!! Who needs western Music!
AnwarFan 3 years ago
The male singer is very good... Sreekumar.. classical plus also playback in south...
hes sung absolutely fantastic! especially the sargam part.. he sang with great control...somehow i dont think Sonu would have managed it that well...
just that Sreekumar has a slight accent in hsi hindi i think...
astropurni 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
asha bhosle should hav sung this one..she can sing million times better than shreya.
raoalikhan 3 years ago
I loved the movie.
The song is amazing,
and i love when they flash back to when Manjulia was alive.
MissRiyaa5590 3 years ago 2
woops, i meant in the kannada and tamil movies, no sympathy from the actors..
sanrac007 3 years ago
wow i cant believe that in this movie and the tamil version,the main actor and couple other actors dont show sympathy or any kind feelings to the sick character..Soundarya seems to have the character well enough :) but man, the original is something else..all the actors in the movie were sooo good!!hindi is better of all the remakes but all the actresses, Shobhana, vidya, jo and soundarya did amazing performances..
Shobhana is hte best though..what a figure, expressions, acting and dance!!!
sanrac007 3 years ago 4
amaizing song
missdrspark 3 years ago 2
AMAZING BUT A BIT SCAREY
Strawbarella 3 years ago 3
Hahahhahh yeah thats what I was thinking the whole time.
luckydaanth 3 years ago
i love this song
trinibabyz0829 3 years ago 2
i saw this movie im gonna dance it the girl was posstsied and wel...see the movie i wouldnt give it away
trinibabyz0829 3 years ago
great song!!
trishnarocks 3 years ago
is she like in prison or something, she almost looks scary were are they?
sagebates 3 years ago
oh wait never mind i read up on the movie
sagebates 3 years ago
she has a mental disorder where she thinks she is a dead ghost.
MissRiyaa5590 3 years ago
Fantastic song....... and Its sung Beautifully.
tejashrijoshi 3 years ago 2
Take Shankarabharanam - it was remade in Hindi and the song "Dhanyavaad se Paaya" is good (Sung by Bhimsen Joshi - frm Karnataka though he is a Hindustani classical legend himself) But SPB did a great job in Telugu the original movie. They possibly here should have used Kathak or Manipuri style instead of Odissi and a mix of Bharatanatyam in Hindi But I like the song either ways.
santsub 3 years ago
somehow now whenever i hear goongroo ke awaaz it sends chills down my back even till today haha.
ash4ya86 3 years ago
the male voice has such a distinct mallu accent... spoils the song... who is the singer?
msindiaa 3 years ago
SPOILS the song? That's a bit drastic. Adds a bit of a distinctive flavour to the song but spoil it? The singer would have to be someone like Shahrukh or Sanjay Dutt being made to sing classical for it be spoilt. Even so, it's a Malayalam/Tamil/Kannada movie that was remade into Hindi by a Malyali director who assisted the making of the original Malayalam movie. I would think he'd want to retain the original flavour somewhere in the movie.
immu1981 3 years ago 2
Ok.. maybe I was a bit drastic in saying that it "spoils" the song.. but the mallu accent seems a bit odd.. the tamil song in malayalam version and the telugu song in the tamil version were perfect..and anyway all ere south indian languages.but the mallu accent with a hindi/bengali song does not sound smooth. a northie could have done the male voice.Listen closely to the "sa ni dha." part.and the way the "ab raat din" is sung u will realise what i mean.The"spoils the song" comment is withdrawn
msindiaa 3 years ago
I understand what you're trying to say, that the pronunciation of certain words is slight jarring. But if sa ni dha sounded "mallu" to you, well who is to say that the way you or I say Sa Ni Dha is more correct than the way the singer said it. Furthermore, the characters of Sridhar and Manjulika are Bengalis. Maybe the accent served well. The song still flows well though. It wouldn't had one of the singers gone off key.
immu1981 3 years ago
In addition, some of the remarkable singers in Bollywood had accents e.g. S.P. Balasubramaniam (the male singer for Hum Aapke Hain Koun), Yesudas (who sang the songs of Chitchor and still won a National Award), Chitra K.S. (Mere Dil Ka Tumse Hai Kehna), Maryam Toller (Maiyya Maiyya), Lata Mangeshkar (the way she pronounces "Aetebaar" and other Urdu words), Mohammed Rafi (a lot of the times he pronounced the Q sound in Urdu as K). Try listening to the dialog in Bhool Bhulaiya. It's worse.
immu1981 3 years ago
Final Arguments:-) Yes,no voice can suit Salman Khan as perfectly as SPB..Saajan, patthar ke phool..maine pyaar kiya..HAHK..And there were some wonderful songs by Yesudass in a movie called Meera ka Mohan ( im stll searching for those songs) BUT. emotions and music are expressed better in a known language since ther is lesser strain. And that is the case with this song. The textbook pronounciation is jarring. Maybe I noticed more cos I am a southie and my hindi is really bad and heavily accented
msindiaa 3 years ago
I think Malayalam is the best of the lot Malayalam also has real dancers-Shobana and Sridhar have done a great job (hardcore Bharathanatyam). In Kannada the Male dancer and Soundarya are good too - I have not watched the tamil version so cant comment. Hindi song is very catchy I guess if you listen to Shreya singing this song too she sounds southy :) because the original song was carnatic style it becomes hard to make it Hindustani unless they put in full effort.
santsub 3 years ago
Vineeth (the male in Hindi and Tamil) is also a real dancer! hes pukka Bharatnatyam dancer! but Vidya isnt
astropurni 3 years ago
And also.. one more thing. In Malayalam the climax song is entirely in Tamil and in the Tamil and Kannada versins the song is entirely in telugu. But only the hindi version has most of the song in hindi..thats not good. The malayalam version was the best...and the tamil version was rubbish because it gave importance to Rajnikanth... but on the whole a good concept of the movie and great climax songs in all versions of the movies.
msindiaa 3 years ago 3
Hello!! IT fits. Because the male dancer in the movie is Malayalee. You can't have Sonu Nigam singing for a guy that distinctively looks South INdia. And even though the story is Bengali, the dance is Bharatanatyam, which is NOT Bengali at all.
vidyasundaram08 2 years ago
it's not proper bharatanatyam cause this is lighter and whats the difference, we all indian
nashk2tamzin 2 years ago
go Vidya Balan!! My favorite mallu kutty :)
underpressure16 3 years ago
btw shes tamil but from kerela
jade89uk 3 years ago
i love the song!!!!!!!!
tiadeb453 3 years ago
Vidya Balan did a good job in this film. Vidya is an actress who is a tradtional type of Indian woman, unlike some of the overly westernised lot we see these days. Reminds me of all the olden actresses like Madhubala, Vijayantimala, Nutan, more recent Smita Patil, Jaya Prada, Sridevi, Madhuri.
purplebutterfly15 3 years ago 2
Nice song. One criticism... its both Hindi and Bengali, bit disappointed it aint all Bengali:(
purplebutterfly15 3 years ago
Can you please translate the Bengali lyrics please it sounds sooo sweet, I really want to know I only speak Urdu. Thanks cute buttefly.
zaara217661 3 years ago
Sorry dont understand Bengali myself, only Hindi, Urdu. But it does sound real nice. Am sure someone will translate the song in Bengali.
purplebutterfly15 3 years ago 2
Okay no problem, I will wait for a bengali speaker to translate, thanks anyways..
zaara217661 3 years ago 2
ami je tomar shudhu je tomar....
this means i am yours only yours...
these are few words taken from a famous bengali song of earlier years.. :)
rio1803 3 years ago