U2 With Or Without You - New York 2005-10-07 - Vertigo Tour

[1mediator1]

Ohh...It's so sad :'(( This video (with the story of Mary) is more than another such videos

[ranilaiya]

gayyyyyyy

[kaylee1321]

I worked with Mary in 2005 in Seattle WA. I didnt know she passed away until now. I found this video that she sent me when we were working. So sorry to hear that she passed away. I cant believe it. Please can anybody email me and tell me why she died?

RIP Mary!!!!

[Broadwayboundgirlz]

Mary..you still remain in our thoughts...we think of you often, and not a month goes by without my three little girls that you cared for mentioning your name. We miss you!

[Megazoup]

Elle est magnifique cette fille et tous les 2 ont l'air de vivre un grand moment, c'est horrible de savoir quelle n'est plus de ce monde. So sorry

[jukeboxhero844]

AWWWWE!!!!! How did she die? I wonder if bono knows? :( sadness!! RIP

[feltonsnooks]

blip.tv/file/1384179

Remembering Mary K. Walker link here will play video with sound. youtube red flagged because of music. much love, b

[feltonsnooks]

kelleywhildenfans.blogspot.com­/2010/10/u2-with-or-without-yo­u-new-york-2005-10.html

[feltonsnooks]

kelleywhildenfans.blogspot.com

Actress Kelley Whilden posted video on her fan blog

[feltonsnooks]

kelleywhildenfans.blogspot.com­/2010/10/u2-with-or-without-yo­u-new-york-2005-10.html

[sf0808]

Mary (the girl in the vid) was my best friend's brother's fiance. RIP Mary.

[baird007]

She is beautiful! She looks like a ray a sunshine on Bono's shoulders.

[jacobekelundarbast]

The best song by U2. Sorry about Marry. :/

[woutu2]

i know its 2 years she s died but i fiel sorry for her friends family and everybody who knows her may she rest in peace now i dont know the girl iam sorry wout from the netherlands

[gustavoesg]

rest in peace, Mary, descansa en paz....

[Dandacook]

Mary rests with us and will live on forever in our hearts, and our memories All of those at the Palmers family that worked with her miss her still Drift not down, in remorse Be lifted upwards by Angel's face Give her rest ever onwards Let her in our hearts, embrace Quiet in the Shadows awash by sun & moon Taken by those who watch over though it feels to soon Poe said: I tonight, my heart is light No Dirge will I upraise But waft the Angel on her flight With a Paen of old days

[Stealth259]

In these few minutes its like he gives her the feeling to let all her worries go...It also looks like he fights to hold his composure with this sweet girl. I don't know the story but Im sure she is okay where she is now.

[ispymarz]

HOW DID MARY DIE??? WE all want to know...May she rest in peace..so young,so sad...What happened to her..I was at that concert in 2005..Bono looks like he's going to cry a few times while he's singing..unusual for him to do that..

[TheSeasBreeze]

@ispymarz Her dad had unexpectedly passed (I believe from a heart attack.) Mary was devastated and I believe she had been taking some medication to deal with it. A friend, one day, gave Mary some of her own prescription medications for a headache and unfortunately it reacted with what Mary was taking. This was a very tragic accident and Mary's loss is felt by many even all these years later. May she be at peace.

[MrBZmk]

wow... this is one great video ...unfortunately with a sad end... condolence to her family..

[U2drummergirl]

this is so sad! At least she had an experience she will never forget! i am in tears now...

[thedarkflowkiller]

Well, she have experienced on of her dreams before dying, it's great.

[AjxxTHEbunny]

omg. this is like so beautiful. the girl & Bono & everything. she was the luckiest girl.

Rip Mary.

[marcos66990]

Querida Mary, é triste vê-la partir tão cedo,mas God sabe o que faz certo? pelo menos vc teve a honra de desfrutar aquilo que milhares de garotas do planeta que é cantar ao lado do Bonovox, descanse em paz minha querida!!!

[flynpony]

My condolences to Mary her family and friends. God Bless!

[RicardoRuna2008]

Such a beautiful girl. Rest in Peace! U2 Forever!

[endbeat]

It's unbelievable...this song...this girl...god bless her. 'll never forget this moment. Peace.

[patziela]

she is so beautiful girl...

[u2Queen14]

im so sorry, how did mary die?

[manifestoN]

rip Mary :(

[Rezlogic]

Miss ya Mary

[feltonsnooks]

This is Mary's brother.  Thank you for your comments. they mean the world. She was the most giving person and amazing sister. I miss her everyday and am doing my best to make her proud. If you have time please forward this out to as many people as possible. it was one of her favorite moments in her life. Much Love, Bryan Walker

[JesseEley07]

Hi Bryan! I was so saddened to hear of Mary's loss. I am a U2 fan and love this song and came across this. I was shocked to hear that she has gone and my condolences go out to you and your family. How did she pass away? Jesse

[crossieblue]

How did Mary die?

[grantsmorales]

bonita mujer

[camozfa]

hi mary..!!

[bushregmike]

Beautiful girl. Sorry to hear she passed. May her star in heaven shine in the summer night may it shine as the brightest star in the winter light. One heart, one hope, one blood. With her always.

[mastermindxyz1]

what happened to her? well if she did passed...she will be missed

[sonidid]

Copy And Paste If Shaun Smith Brought You Here!!!!!

[XxSternchenxX8]

Why did she die? Love the song <3

[bodonnavox]

i was 13 when that happened

[MfromFrance]

ABSOLUT BLISS :-)

It's the first time I see Bono touched dancing on stage with a girl.

Beauty Mary so happy. God keeps her in that bliss.

[Revtheresalister]

BEAUIFUL

[chest002]

If you liked the Boston performance it is available on DVD. I found it on ebay. Just punch in u2 2001 dvd. That will bring it up. Cheers.

[Pepilotaaa]

that such a pitty! :( what has happend to this girl? this is a great video and I can't stop listening for this song over and over again.. love lyrics a lot! and it's really very sad about this girl:(

[Aleancelo]

I wonder if Bono knows that she's already dead.

[bader58]

every time he sings this song live, he grabs a lucky female from the crowd and she dances with him the whole song.

[kocevje26]

hm me to!

[jpjames1]

gorgeous girl Bono liked her for real u could see

[dannymartin80]

rip 2 mary and her dad, may they both be safe lookin down on us all

[sbhdawn]

do you know what happened to Mary and her dad? I would like to know if you could tell me.

[tamara246zes]

It's so sad Mary passed away.. I'm sorry for her family and friends. This video is so nice, she looks so happy..

[bizkit34]

sorry to hear of her passing. does anyone know how she passed?

[eltimbomofo]

theultimatedaddysgirl is her website.

[aurelienmillec]

are they serious ??? cant be possible, its like the saddest morning... i first watch the video and enjoy it and then i read the comments... i dont know that girl but i ll do a cover of this song for her... on my profile.

[U2fan4life]

I'm sorry for her family's great loss, and I give my condolences

[BrianO11]

It is true

[Aleancelo]

What's the cause of her death?

[eltimbomofo]

3 years ago today. I'm very sorry to hear about Mary's passing.

[kaylee1321]

@eltimbomofo

Hi I was a friend of Mary back in 2007 we worked together in seattle. I would want to know how she passed away. Can you please reply.

[ragzc17]

RIP Mary, you are beautiful.

[eltimbomofo]

Did something happen to Mary?

[wwmyamk]

I am sorry to say that Mary passed away last week.  Those who love her thank you for your video. We miss you and love you Mary.

[firime]

what was the cause of her death?

[sbhdawn]

What happened to Mary? Please, we would like to know. Was she killed in an accident? Waiting to hear.

[pranana]

OH MY GOD... that's sad...

[ClassicSunrise]

@eltimbomofo Thank you so much for posting this. It's hard not to cry while watching... years later and I still can't believe it. Not only was Mary incredibly beautiful but she was incredibly kind too. I went to elementary school with her and I can tell you that she was a really special person. Everyone loved her. It's great having this clip to remind us of better days. She stays alive in our hearts.

[slavegrind]

Bull shit,man. That guy must be kidding about the death of the girl.

[bizkit34]

i was right behind this girl and her boyfriend

@ the concert. they had the ultimate u2 daily double. she danced with bono and bono used their American flag during "sunday blood sunday".

[STONEDAR1978]

ok the video is great, but that girl is just a goddess!!!

[Nsemest182]

I bet her bf was bummed hahah or really pumped cuz bono liked his gf

[r3dluca]

GREAT BLONDE...FANTASTIC!

[bijibadness]

hah, thats so fucking close man, crazy.

[rafalweb]

I bet he got a Bono Boner while holding this girl.

[belgianwolfie]

awesome video , and I agree with the remark on the grace in which you handled this. Must be an overwhelming experience.

[eltimbomofo]

Mary please send me a private message. I'd like to get you the pictures as well.  Tim

[loli714]

Thanks for the video. It is awesome. Your boyfriends family is very lucky to have you too. We Love you Mary! Love your NC family...

[seamus2204]

wow - your boyfriend is one lucky guy Mary  Mike

[Dizzied8869]

Mary, wow !! What an amazing video !! I am speechless, totally awesome - I LOVE YOU !!

[redroqr]

I will have to say this is very cool ......... one is she isnt acting like a moronic fan & two is she is into the vibe of the song ........ very cool stuff !!!!! cabo wabo

[solittle40]

that's exactly what i thought. i also noticed that he kept her up there longer than some other girls, probably because she was being respectful and appropriate.

[marykarrie]

Hi Tim! It's me, Mary, the girl from the video. My boyfriend got sent this clip randomly today by a u2 fan. We couldn't believe it! It's such an amazing clip. Thank you! If you have any other footage I would love to see it. ...What a night.

[eltimbomofo]

Mary! I'm so happy you saw the video. You handled the whole experience with such grace. I felt bad that I couldn't get it to you. I also have 4 pictures that I took before the video started. One of them is very good. I can try to get them to you. That was an awesome night!

Tim

[oasiszildjian07]

I know that girl! I work with her! Her desk is about 15 feet from mine. She's new with us, but she's awesome and we all love her!

[eltimbomofo]

Please tell her the vid is up. She gave me her email when I took this, but I lost it in the frenzy of the concert. I believe her boyfriend also gave an American flag to Bono to carry around the elipse.

Tim

[ljkm1015]

Wow !  excellent close up. thanks for posting.

[bencroft]

amazing video. I love U2.

[mikeisi]

Amazing video eltimbomofo! This is probably the best fan video of a "with or without you" dance. congrats to the lucky girl whoever you are.

God bless

-Michael Mitchell (piano guy at Honolulu show)