Added: 3 years ago
From: portablefilmfestival
Views: 328,603
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (621)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I feel ya martinmariboe. Try running, or walking if you don't run, while blaring MM in your headphones. Go along a scenic route like a park or someplace quiet and woodsy. Don't think, just run and jam. Sooo relaxing. It works, Modest Mouse and Cross Country are an excellent combination. :)

  • Every so often i get the feeling that i am not living life to it's fullest. You know that feeling? I mean, i'm only 16, but i still have the feeling that life is running a damn lot faster than me. I miss my old friends, i feel like i'm stuck in one place and i just feel i'm meant to do something more than what the near future seems to bring. :( I've got to listen to this song more often. Makes me wanna get off my ass and get out into life...

    Music is the cure, and this song is no exception ;')

  • More Cowbell !!!

  • reminds you where you're priorities should lie

  • this video was shot where i live! RENO

  • she is carrying around her dead kid

    WTF!

  • @Grantzilla1 Not dead, sick

  • @TyLeecircusfreak Nah at the end of the video you see the heart monitor go flat... the kid dies and she freaks out and takes her kid out of the hospital to the little motel.

  • Comment removed

  • I think I cried before I even saw the video.

  • if you know the lyrics and have seen the video.if you have a SOUL you will cry at this xD

    :')

  • if only the music were going in reverse as well. That would be great

  • Life's a bitch.

  • this is the first song i have ever cried listening to, i dont know why it just speaks to me on so many different levels, thanks modsest mouse :')

  • i dont understand cuz the boy in the hospital was alive then she took him an BOOM !! ' h died ..why?? why she didnt allow him t live ..??? answer that question??

  • @skap022 the video is going in reverse, so the end of the video is the beginning. i guess the boy was sick or had cancer or something, he flatlined and died. the mom was in shock and denial and she couldn't take it, so she snatched him up to be with him one more time. she took him to the diner to eat his favorite meal one more last time, then took him to the motel to spend time with him. you understand what im saying? at 3:40 is a flashback where the mom and the healthy son are happy.

  • @knobylob

    He didn't die. The monitor flat lined because she disconnected him from it. He's comatose and was soon to die so she took him to spend a last few moments with him that are not in a hospital.

  • @knobylob dud, thanks fo that helped me a lot i like wht u said about lst dinner and the last moment cuz i didnt realize of that :) thnks buddy

  • Modest Mouse never ceases to amaze how they can touch all a persons emotions through one song...

  • song says it all

  • saddest song of forever.

  • ohhhh shit!!! twist ending much

  • i dont think you're supposed to smoke smokes at the gas station

  • I LIKE HOW THE FIRST FUCKING COMMENT RUINS THIS WHOLE FUCKING VIDEO THANKS DICK FACE.

  • I think she didn't want the doctors and coroner to take him away from her

  • ouch in my heart and I can't see through my eyes. Too much water in them.

  • This song makes me happy :)

  • @McTasticle Why?

  • thats why im waiting for....

  • Fuck this made me cry :(

  • @GladysMrtnz i'm sitting here sobbing

  • I listen to this song when I'm going through bad times, day dreaming in class about my friends that I don't see often. It sucks, and 2:26 get's to me all sad. Remembering about blazing, having those friends who laugh with you and get written up referal's with you to even Family emergencies. X- girlfriend you miss a fuckload. If you wish you could go back in the past and live life with no regrets' thumbs' up this. :' (

  • @MrEneffalready enough said bro exactly how we all feel

  • @MrEneffalready "Regrets yield you nothing in life. It's a waste of energy." -Baaadbobby.

  • @MrEneffalready lmao how does 2:26 get you sad it just shows lights. stop being a pansy.

  • @tripod738 I mean the song not the video Dipshit, Damn just quit life Poser.

  • @MrEneffalready im sure they would love for you to be fighting about dumb shit instead of enjoying their music. god, his and your opinion doesnt mean shit to these people, just enjoy the fucking music, ignore others idiot remarks and dont make idiot remarks to others!

  • @tripod738 why you a dick. smoke some bud, drop some A or take some Malcolm and this song might appeal to you

  • @tripod738 Do you realize how much of an idiot you are? This song is all about love... Take a second and breath that in! Get on our level and try again!

  • I love this song so much...and the video is incredible

  • wait so did the mom kill him?

  • @whopassedthegas No, the entire video is in reverse, I mean MAYBE, but the kid was really sick, not getting better, and either he died or she took him off the machines to finally put him to sleep in a nice motel.

  • arent modest mouse music soft rock?

  • This video is too damn sad

  • oh pobre I really like this song she wanted ho be with her baby one more time

  • this is possibly the saddest song ive heard, but in such a good way

  • i love this song reminds me of my mom

  • it is an amazing way to portray the impact a childs death can have on a parent

  • Does the concept of negative time mean anything to any of you?

  • beautiful...and creepy....but more beautiful

  • OOOOOH HER SONS IN A COMA! Idk y but this song makes me wanna have kids...... I'm 14

  • @McTasticle for the love of god don't have kids.

  • @themdamnwheaties LOL, not now!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • @McTasticle LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL! No.

  • How sad, she probably realised he would die so she decided to take him away.

  • This song reminds me of jail and how lonely it is

  • oh geez.:'c

  • HEs ALIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIVEE!

    

  • @theodessa5 its all backwards at the start the kid dies and she carrys him out to pretend hes not cause shes in shock

  • hey can someone please explain what happens in this music video? thanks

  • Comment removed

  • either he is died or he is one hell of a sleeper

  • Yes, he was alive at 4:32, but because it is backwards, she pulls the cords after the boy goes into V-Tach and dies...

  • @321321ash Chronologically in the video the screen shows a flatline, and then you see her pull the chords. so logically if you reverse the situation she pulls the chords, then the screen shows a flatline.

  • "i hope that you like it in your little motel" (more than a hospital)

  • the boy is alive, shes trying to let him die in peace with her, rather than at a hospital

  • So I'm a freshman at dobie highschool and we had to analyze the lyrics behind the song. and omg you don't understand how deep this song is. the video itself is deep, let alone the lyrics.. I cried so hard when i got home. I never knew how important it is to let the people you love, know you love them.

  • @SKATE9959 It's about friends and them dying. Isaac and the band had a couple of significant friends that had died and songwriting was the way to deal with it.

  • Disturbungly beautiful! Thumbs up(:

  • so beautiful

  • the kid is alive..if you see carefuly..she unplug the thing

  • @xXTHE18Xx She unplugged it because he died.

  • oh my god i balled and sobbed like a baby.

  • Such a great song Probley one of the deepest bands ive heard.

  • wow i hardly ever cry since im like a guy but that video made me tear up at the end :.(

  • great song but it makes me cry every time i see and ear the song

  • To those of you who argue whether he is dead or not. The video is going backwards. He is shown flatlined at 4:32, he is ripped off the monitor at 4:30. So since the video is going backwards, he flatlined before she ripped the cords off. The brief moment where the heart monitor is shown fluctuating is most likely due to the cords being taken off and giving a misreading.

  • The only scene with a heartbeat flatline is 4:25. then she pulls the chords out at 4:29. The machine at 4:32 is NOT the same as the one on 4:25, which shows his heartbeat. the machine at 4:32 shows his blood pressure, and blood oxygen levels, which indicate him as alive.

  • @criket527 I'm still going to disagree because the heartbeat monitor updates left to right (new on left old on right) that would suggest he'd been flat-lined for a bit before she pulled the cords. But at any rate. I think we can all agree that the answer to the question is a confusing one and it is sad nonetheless.

  • @joeseatat I agree, it does not change the message or meaning

  • nick and norahs infinite playlist was a shit movie, get over it. this is a modest mouse video

  • I have been singing this song to myself for the past week, and tonight I watched Nick & Norah's infinite playlist for the first time. I cant believe I heard this song in the movie.

  • nick and norah's infinite playlist. when nick was whistling in the car when tris was trying to get back nick lol

    

  • Why does 3:32 make me feel sad??? :c

  • i guess i'm the only person that this song makes me feel twice as stoned

  • when i first listened to this, i had never felt so sad in my life but i a good way. Best moment of my life so far <3

  • @TheDarklord45 wait until you have kids.you will feel worst.

    that will be your better moment in life.

  • Oh shit done got me sad now

  • but in reallity i cant go nowhere my life is a long shit man

  • if you got a road map from the damned you'd know just where to go.

  • Yea she wasn't dragging her dead child around, it flatlined cause she ripped the chords off him...

  • Comment removed

  • Currently trying to play this..;D

  • Ok, so I was playing this song in Guitar Center on the piano and you entered the room and pretended to fiddle on another keyboard.. when I was done, you got up and said "Thank you. That was probably the best concert I've ever been to", and I said, "Really?" You nodded and walked away. I've been ruminating my head into the ground for the past 12 hours about you. At the risk of sounding creepy, you should definitely return to Guitar Center tomorrow so we can grab some yogurt and loiter at teavana.

  • @TedEdFred21 Loitering at teavana is the best

  • @TedEdFred21 Teavana was a big part in my early romantic relationships.

  • @TedEdFred21 It was me im actually a man!

  • @TedEdFred21 I dont get it

  • @TedEdFred21 DID SHE SHOW?

  • @TickleMePurplee no :(

  • @TedEdFred21 Aww. Poor dude. 

  • @TedEdFred21 And??? What happened? Tell me you saw him/her again!.

  • 108

    god, i miss U

  • This song is beautiful. and the video just adds so much to it.

  • why is it that every song that has a video going backwards it ends up being extremly depresing

  • nobody can make you feel more than modest mouse

  • Good video

  • Jesus, why is the audio on this video so quiet? It's a quiet song, I know, but this is a bit unnecessary..

  • @PhoneHomeProduction wow. the person took the time to put this awesome song on youtube so you can listen to it, and your complaining about the low volume? just turn it up and enjoy the music!

  • @rgl3ma57 I really don't have a problem with audio, ever. But I sincerely turned my speakers up to the highest they could go, and it was still pretty quiet.

  • @PhoneHomeProduction hate to break it to you, but your speakers must be junk. I can hear every word crystal clear at quarter volume.

  • Only intelligent people listen to Modest Mouse. This song is great.

  • How do you spell melancholy, Thats how the song makes me fell

  • I think she was in denial if u look at the screen his heart stops so she must of been holding sum1 dead

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Seriously this song is like slowly twisting a knife in my stomach, makes me think of all i should have ¸done/said but didnt.

  • I just bawled my eyes out

  • I cried so epically hard after seeing this video :( booo

  • the boy is not dead, hes just sleeping. i think, cause he was fine until she ripped him off the chords.

  • @MasterFreaks1 I think it doesn't matter if the boy is dead yet or not. He's clearly in the process of and that's why the mother takes him off the chords. She wants the last memories of her child to be of things they enjoyed doing together and not of a cold hospital room. So even if he's not dead by the end of the video he's about to be.

  • I AM SO SAD RIGHT NOW DAMNIT........

  • was she carrying that dead kid around the whole time or what?

  • This video is every parents nightmare.

  • Filmed in my hometown, Reno NV. :) Love it.

  • I really did not think that was what was going on 8 •

  • cried.

  • goddamnit man every time i see this video i just fuckin bawl.

  • I hate saying "8 people etc". But, I think if 8 people honestly and whole-heartedly disliked this video, they can go die.

  • I LOVE AT

  • I'm pretty CPS would take the kid if they knew she was driving backwards like that.

  • my god this video gives me the chills

  • Comment removed

  • this music video reminds me a little bit of the scientist by coldplay's music video.

  • wow, that's kindof a chilling music video. in a good way, though.

  • This video gives me shivers everytime I watch it. And I've watched it alot. Even when I listen to this on Itunes I think about this video and how sad yet beautiful it is

  • @noobish2331 youre a dumbass the band is modest mouse

  • @noobish2331 LMAOOOOOO WHAT!!!

  • @noobish2331 What? The bands name is Modest Mouse....

  • cant here SHIIIIITTTT!!!!!!!!

  • I really just want to give that mom a hug..

  • Whoa wait...So she was dragging a corpse around that whole time?!? Yea that seems like Modest Mouse.

  • I looked into the screen crying for five mintues after the video was over.

  • only reno could represent the shit hole in this song. welcome home!

  • Soooo sad!) :

  • shes pretty good at doing everything in reverse.

  • My friend showed me this yesterday and i was sad :'(

  • my dad has been slowly dying throughout my life from Huntington's disease. He has only a couple years left, we put him in a Nursing home because we couldn't look after him and he's at the hospital now.

    This isn't going anywhere, but i always connect with this song as it connects with me :]

    <3 Modest Mouse

  • I just watched the movie "Suckerpunch" and for some reason, during the whole movie I had this song stuck in my head.

  • @Grrx8 Me too lol

  • this song makes me feel so sad... but in a beautiful way

  • @CalypsoU2fan you mean meloncoly?

  • @TheFrankiebaby3 No dude! A Melon Collie :D (A dog that herds cantaloupes)

  • @CalypsoU2fan I mean melancholy

  • @TheFrankiebaby3 I suppose it coud be, yes..

  • @CalypsoU2fan I Know exactly what you mean , I live to this song twice a day , once in the morning and before i go to bed . My favourite part is at the bridge

  • @CalypsoU2fan stfu

  • @CalypsoU2fan thats gay yet extremely hetero

  • He didn't die, the monitor went flat because she tore off his sensors. She just wanted to go back to the pristine times, when he was well. It is not definate he is dead... I really hope he isn't or else I would feel even worse.

  • @Nirvanasmile731 No, that's the same thing I got out of it too. She didn't carry around the kid's dead body.

  • Wait so is this the way the video is suppose to be or did the poster reverse it on purpose??

  • Comment removed

  • @tyuiop747 thats how it is

  • @tyuiop747 well, you said the same thing twice: if the poster reversed it on purpose, then thats how the video is supposed to be...

    and it would be a much less powerful video had it been played forwards.

  • @keziski Lol, i just totally saw that i repeated myself, ha. And i agree. :p

  • Awesome I love it

  • this song is the TITS!

  • such a beautiful song .:')

  • This song made me fall in love with modest mouse

  • Everytime I see this music video, I burst out laughing, because she effectivly made sure that he would die, and he had a hope for life in the hospital, but niow, due to his own mother, his death is inevitable, lol

  • Comment removed

  • @jamesphilip911 the point was he died in the hospital and she couldn't handle it so she ran away. I feel like that was pretty clear.

  • @jamesphilip911 His heart beat stopped in the hospital (made evident at the end of the video) so she freaked out and took him and ran away. He died in the hospital.

  • The music video is in reverse. No members of the band are shown, just a mother with her son, who in the end we find was dying. Before he dies however, she removes the monitors from him and takes him, leaving the hospital. She drives and takes him to a diner and eventually to a motel. This is where the video starts, going backwards, ending at the hospital. Presumably the mother could not bear to watch her son die in such a cold place and wanted him surrounded by comfort.