it doesn`t matter if whitney can sing better than her when she was 17, because you can`t compare generations . and plus she`s from the US -____- if you can compare generations, everyone from the last generation will totally own the people nowadays .
We CAN compare generations as long as they are singing the same song and they are human beings... I didn't take the accent thing into account.... I just look at the sound, technics + emotion XD
erm gd job stating the obvious. u really cant compare anyone with whitney houston. but gem really freakin amazing. she's the only hk singer i actually listen to.
To be honest, among Lady Cantonese Singers in Hong Kong in this 10 years... I can say apart from Jeoy Yung, I can't see any good female singers. But G.E.M give me a big supprise! She is really really really fantasic. and don't forget how old is she?! She was just 15 but in this great voice. Yes maybe you are right Charice sing better than her but don't forget English is not our mother tongue. ..
Yup, comparing to Charice is unfair, she is just a level above the rest....
And one thing, apart from some singing mistakes, GEM does need to work on stage presence and audience interaction. Been to some of her live shows, quite poor in that department...
Being such a new and young star @HK, I am so proud of GEM that she is already being compared to one of the world top singers Charice in her 1st year of career.
To qrewqrewqrew: I follow your lead to this clip. I am disappointed,she need more practice on voice,English,stage. Please check "Charice,Star King" on Youtube. see how a tiny philippino girl conquer Korea in 2007.
Come on and deduct my points!Cus I am going to say this anyway.I totally agree with you aaalo2002.She should work hard on her English pronunciation and she has sooooo much to learn and to improve(even the Hong Kong singer Eason Chan said this according to Next Magazine).She is indeed much better than HK singers nowadays but definitely can't stand out in the world.Just a little Philippino girl Charice Pempengco BLEW THE WORLD AWAY.She will be the next Celine Dion or Whitney Housten.
GEM is performing a English song in Hk and she is only 16. Tell your Charice to sing a Cantonese song. And if Charice can sing the cantonese song half as good as GEM then talk more. English is one of the Offiicial language in Philipines. ppl enjoy music their own way.
Wow you really look up to Cantonese songs cuz I can bet on my life that if Charice could speak Cantonese,she could sing WAY BETTER THAN G.E.M. cuz you know what?? Her Cantonese songs are much easier than I Have Nothing or I Will Always Love You.
@VeryColdheart This is so irrelevant. Charice's singing skills is just worlds better than G.E.M. No question. It's very objective and there's nothing to do with language or nationality or even genes. They are singing the same song why can't people make comparison?
Don't take me wrong, I love her a lot too. She definitely sings better than other rubbish Hong Kong singers. Charice sings better doesn't make GEM bad.
Just a kind reminder, English is one of the official languageS in Hong Kong too.
@martin0322 People always jugde the others with different yard stick. I guess you must be either the best in your field (are you?) or you are comparing yourself with the best everyday. Charice is one in a million if not billion, GEM is already better than a lot of the top singers in HK,PRC or even Taiwan, why don't you name a Chinese singer who can sing this song better than Charice, if you can just shut it, learn to appreciate talent when you see them.
@happydays1698 The top singers in the PRC have amazing voices, but tend not to sing pop music. On the other hand, a lot of Taiwanese singers aren't very good at all. Don't confuse production values with vocal ability. Taiwanese music culture is borrowed a lot from Japan, which is not exactly known for its singing. If you don't count the Aboriginal Taiwanese singers, look at all the "good" singers in Taiwan, and see how many of them are actually from the US, China, or Malaysia and Singapore.
@martin0322 another thing, GEM wrote songs like Sleeping Beauty @13 and Mascara @ 15. She is not just a talented singer but a talented singer song writer, just learn to appreciate talent as I am sure you must have a talent that no one in the world can compare with.....that is criticism
Why do ppl have to critises? And say who is better then who? This is Art there is no Comparison. If you two above me dun undertsand Shakespear do i call you guys Barbaric? No. diff cultures have diff judgements. If you like Charice then go to the Charice website and comment. Pls dun compare them.
And I am not critising.I am G.E.M.'S fan too but I just think she has a lot of space for improvement and I am looking forward to it. And yes I do keep an eye on what's going on with Charice. But I will always come back to G.E.M. cus I love her alot.
Well, you could call that criticism, but you can also view it as advice, comparing to Charice is just one way of pointing out ways in which GEM could improve, cuz it is obvious GEM's skill set is incomplete and not that polished in this video...
Exactly! Beside GEM's skill is incomplete, Charice is probably the most gifted girl on earth. She has the deep voice that fit this kind of song perfectly which GEM does not have, and why do we have to compare them anyway?
Well, tell me how many singer in Hong Kong that can sing like her?
這裡有黑色的gem
search:Gloria Tang- I have nothing@ Hummingbird Press Conference
youtube.com/watch?v=Ud4vCwkVegE
gn01953588 11 months ago
she is born to be a singer.
zhouzhou4 1 year ago
was this before gem became famous?
fascista 1 year ago
係..佢真係好似徐子淇
hannahrobet 1 year ago
. . . . ^_^
O O
sityinyuk 1 year ago
Hi 我係Gloria.....她好可愛
gn01953588 1 year ago 3
D FANS 叫aR尖- -" 唔係ar GEM咩
gn01953588 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
she is really nervous at the beginning but the whole performance is really brilliant :)
samxsmile 2 years ago
Comment removed
samxsmile 2 years ago
-.-幾時有咪咀.....
12345pen 2 years ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
佢好姣.我覺得.
I always love you 又咪咀.
chaukwan199722 2 years ago
She's 15 here, not 17. She's 17 now.
whateverokayy 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
難聽過她唱Where did you go 果D,有雜音
TheLovelycat 2 years ago
agree.
chaukwan199722 2 years ago
Her name used to be Gloria?
Chungchile 2 years ago
gem is not her real name and gem stands for get everdybody moving
BarbieGirlsPurple 2 years ago 2
thats everyone moving
water0823 2 years ago
still is
IluvHKong 2 years ago
techniques could be improved but great and truly gifted voice:)
cairobaby 2 years ago 3
she's 15 here... not 17
joannating 2 years ago 3
I love this part 5:17
Kellcrizo13 2 years ago
rofl hella mess up with joey yung but i dont like it either u right loveavrilbecky ---- agree with u
nihoma1 2 years ago
Gem跟誰 學唱歌ga?
zzzooooo 2 years ago 4
she ain't bad at all. she's really good. she's only 17? O_O wow thats...only a year older than me.
myheart715 2 years ago 2
I can see GEM really got talent! It is surprise for me too!
ElsieT94 2 years ago 2
whitney is miles better than her!
brianfan1 2 years ago
well obviously ? you can`t compare whitney with her . compare their ages ... and experience .
yayyangela 2 years ago
Comment removed
brianfan1 2 years ago
of course not . but you can`t compare them both, G.E.M is an hk singer -___-
yayyangela 2 years ago 3
why?
etz182 2 years ago
@yayyangela an HK singer? Are you sure?
martin0322 1 year ago
@martin0322 What are you talking about? G.E.M? Yeah, she`s an HK singer.
yayyangela 1 year ago
whitney can sing better than her when she is 17
etz182 2 years ago
it doesn`t matter if whitney can sing better than her when she was 17, because you can`t compare generations . and plus she`s from the US -____- if you can compare generations, everyone from the last generation will totally own the people nowadays .
yayyangela 2 years ago
We CAN compare generations as long as they are singing the same song and they are human beings... I didn't take the accent thing into account.... I just look at the sound, technics + emotion XD
brianfan1 2 years ago 3
I can't agree with you more... XD
brianfan1 2 years ago
erm gd job stating the obvious. u really cant compare anyone with whitney houston. but gem really freakin amazing. she's the only hk singer i actually listen to.
sstargurl 2 years ago
15歲=]
iamchunXD 2 years ago 2
A cleaner version
Kellcrizo13 2 years ago
i like!! :)
Kellcrizo13 2 years ago
TVB版 睡公主 gem 真係有d似徐子琪
kmlau1986 2 years ago 6
To be honest, among Lady Cantonese Singers in Hong Kong in this 10 years... I can say apart from Jeoy Yung, I can't see any good female singers. But G.E.M give me a big supprise! She is really really really fantasic. and don't forget how old is she?! She was just 15 but in this great voice. Yes maybe you are right Charice sing better than her but don't forget English is not our mother tongue. ..
AlienbearGupte 2 years ago 23
She is now 17 but her Cantonese song really awesome! Who said that she can't sing 雄厚既歌? She is just new and need experience, more practice only.
Do you think that you can sing like this in your 15?!
Add oil G.E.M. I rarely buy album from Hong Kong singers but I bought yours! Best of wishes to you G.E.M. Looking forward to see your concert.
AlienbearGupte 2 years ago 8
execuse me, Jeoy Yung can't sing 海豚音 but gem can
LoveAvrilBecky 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
AMAZING TEEN SINGER!
"I have nothing" cover!
WATCH IT AND SUBB NOW!
on my channel
Charlottafan 2 years ago
把聲唔錯 , 但唱歌技巧有待改善
tennrainooto 2 years ago 3
wow.. i now see how much talent she has=))
iamabelle 2 years ago
Go G.E.M ur always the best i'll support you....
azntenshiangel 2 years ago
She has the kind of voice I love!
LittlePenguin89 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
英文咬字好
但無感情..無外國feel
ausze618 2 years ago
外國feel ??on9.要外國feel做物
cdrom199 2 years ago
佢係靚過除子琪喎
Doey20081103 2 years ago 7
ben 好誇.... 靚過徐子琪 =3=
but Gem都算靚:) 又唱得... great!!!!!!!!!!
Elsieification 2 years ago 6
唱得好!!香港好少歌手可以令我咁欣賞,而且你仲咁後生, 如果專注唱歌一定前途無可張量!!!
doramingka 2 years ago 13
超好聽,支持你G.E.M.
MarySin1314 2 years ago 7
好勁!!!
ying0325 2 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
声に芯がないような・・・。
banayato8810 2 years ago
can you sing better than her?if can't , then you should shut up
wujonathan1994 2 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
on99食屎!!!
coolyininlove2with 2 years ago
I LUV GEM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
xJanaRoxDaWorldx 2 years ago
Gloria??
eunice61120062006 2 years ago
sure!
yinkinglui 2 years ago 2
Her trills sound poor.Charice is much better,even though I can say Charice is the best.
Cynthiaxd1989 2 years ago
Yup, comparing to Charice is unfair, she is just a level above the rest....
And one thing, apart from some singing mistakes, GEM does need to work on stage presence and audience interaction. Been to some of her live shows, quite poor in that department...
chakyz 2 years ago
charice is philippino. phillipinos are generally better singers than chinese ones.
she's pretty damn fucking good for a chinese chik- better than anyone else i've heard so far.
stickyriver87 2 years ago
Being such a new and young star @HK, I am so proud of GEM that she is already being compared to one of the world top singers Charice in her 1st year of career.
+oil GEM!
quiche71 3 years ago 4
同 CHARICE 差好遠
tywong2004 3 years ago 6
yes I agree...... Charice is much better
bbsen 3 years ago 3
15 已經咁勁...
compuwong 3 years ago 13
To qrewqrewqrew: I follow your lead to this clip. I am disappointed,she need more practice on voice,English,stage. Please check "Charice,Star King" on Youtube. see how a tiny philippino girl conquer Korea in 2007.
aaalo2002 3 years ago
Come on and deduct my points!Cus I am going to say this anyway.I totally agree with you aaalo2002.She should work hard on her English pronunciation and she has sooooo much to learn and to improve(even the Hong Kong singer Eason Chan said this according to Next Magazine).She is indeed much better than HK singers nowadays but definitely can't stand out in the world.Just a little Philippino girl Charice Pempengco BLEW THE WORLD AWAY.She will be the next Celine Dion or Whitney Housten.
lazyisa 3 years ago 8
GEM is performing a English song in Hk and she is only 16. Tell your Charice to sing a Cantonese song. And if Charice can sing the cantonese song half as good as GEM then talk more. English is one of the Offiicial language in Philipines. ppl enjoy music their own way.
VeryColdheart 3 years ago
Wow you really look up to Cantonese songs cuz I can bet on my life that if Charice could speak Cantonese,she could sing WAY BETTER THAN G.E.M. cuz you know what?? Her Cantonese songs are much easier than I Have Nothing or I Will Always Love You.
lazyisa 3 years ago 4
@VeryColdheart This is so irrelevant. Charice's singing skills is just worlds better than G.E.M. No question. It's very objective and there's nothing to do with language or nationality or even genes. They are singing the same song why can't people make comparison?
Don't take me wrong, I love her a lot too. She definitely sings better than other rubbish Hong Kong singers. Charice sings better doesn't make GEM bad.
Just a kind reminder, English is one of the official languageS in Hong Kong too.
martin0322 1 year ago
@martin0322 People always jugde the others with different yard stick. I guess you must be either the best in your field (are you?) or you are comparing yourself with the best everyday. Charice is one in a million if not billion, GEM is already better than a lot of the top singers in HK,PRC or even Taiwan, why don't you name a Chinese singer who can sing this song better than Charice, if you can just shut it, learn to appreciate talent when you see them.
happydays1698 1 year ago
@happydays1698 The top singers in the PRC have amazing voices, but tend not to sing pop music. On the other hand, a lot of Taiwanese singers aren't very good at all. Don't confuse production values with vocal ability. Taiwanese music culture is borrowed a lot from Japan, which is not exactly known for its singing. If you don't count the Aboriginal Taiwanese singers, look at all the "good" singers in Taiwan, and see how many of them are actually from the US, China, or Malaysia and Singapore.
dark14 11 months ago
@martin0322 another thing, GEM wrote songs like Sleeping Beauty @13 and Mascara @ 15. She is not just a talented singer but a talented singer song writer, just learn to appreciate talent as I am sure you must have a talent that no one in the world can compare with.....that is criticism
happydays1698 1 year ago
Why do ppl have to critises? And say who is better then who? This is Art there is no Comparison. If you two above me dun undertsand Shakespear do i call you guys Barbaric? No. diff cultures have diff judgements. If you like Charice then go to the Charice website and comment. Pls dun compare them.
VeryColdheart 3 years ago 5
And I am not critising.I am G.E.M.'S fan too but I just think she has a lot of space for improvement and I am looking forward to it. And yes I do keep an eye on what's going on with Charice. But I will always come back to G.E.M. cus I love her alot.
lazyisa 3 years ago 4
Well, you could call that criticism, but you can also view it as advice, comparing to Charice is just one way of pointing out ways in which GEM could improve, cuz it is obvious GEM's skill set is incomplete and not that polished in this video...
chakyz 2 years ago 4
Exactly! Beside GEM's skill is incomplete, Charice is probably the most gifted girl on earth. She has the deep voice that fit this kind of song perfectly which GEM does not have, and why do we have to compare them anyway?
Well, tell me how many singer in Hong Kong that can sing like her?
afungkam 2 years ago 2
佢把聲好靚,但係佢把聲唔係好適合唱d咁雄厚既歌,佢翻向d柔和,抒情歌
chrishi 3 years ago 3
I thought I heard them said she was only 15yrs old at that moment?.?
elchardo 3 years ago 2
okay la. she's only 17 . sup : )
dayybe 3 years ago
she only 15!
guwamu 3 years ago
by then she was only 15, but it was 2 years ago.. so she's now 17, still young 0.o
askcy 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
pitch唔準
eddie04291 3 years ago 3
又係d扯氣聲入晒咪...
konkkk 3 years ago 2
始終把聲唔夠厚,有待磨練
macross7ra 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
依家咁唱法似雞叫
macross7ra 3 years ago
我都係比個意見o者...唔係踩佢...
macross7ra 3 years ago 4
首歌係Whitney Houston............
乜野christina上身??
做到資料搜集先.....
tai1229 3 years ago 2
樣唔錯 ; 腔口明顯偏鬼婆自然唱得順d (好多ABC都係咁既聲), 假如可以,寧願佢聲線再柔點、再天賴點 、再神聖點 ,咁就真的如假包換技驚4方
harry12340063 3 years ago 6
excellent!!
wai1899 3 years ago
超勁 i love her 幾時出cd?好耐冇買hk singer cd的衝動
ahfung33 3 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
我覺得佢太刻意賣弄唱功..
有點兒模仿了他人既唱法
埋沒了自己既風格...
不過聲底唔錯...搵個好d既唱歌老師可有一番作為
kill106 3 years ago
要在香港找到可以賣弄唱功的女歌手也很少吧
她只是新人起碼贏了一半人了
hszuhsuan 3 years ago 34
This has been flagged as spam show
八婆番歸啦~~
gn01363680 3 years ago
超勁呀gloria!!!
SweetieAshely 3 years ago 4
add oil!
rockestal 3 years ago
awesome
support u
wayne22ho 3 years ago 3
christina 上身!
kansze 3 years ago 7
咩christina上身je...完全唔同聲調唔同風格囉~好母!?
sanesenas 3 years ago
超勁呀gloria!!!
l01208 3 years ago 5
young but great
Jadehelam 3 years ago 3
wow such a sweet voice.. GEM rocks!!
Mandiiez 3 years ago 11