On TOTP everyone mimed apart from whoever was number 1 that week 'I think'. They would be the only one's to play live. Also sometimes they used to have 'special guests' on the show. The 'special guests' would also play live. But everyone else pretty much had to use playback. This is not playback. Well the vocals definitely are not playback. I'm not too sure about the instruments.
ok, i love oasis as much as the next guy, but i think the instruments might be mimed. noel's solo on supersonic is note for note the same as on the album and the hand claps during the coda of supersonic arent appearing to be coming from anywhere. dont give me a bunch of crap for saying that. i love oasis too, but its just what it looks like to me
i guess this came from a show called "Something for the weekend"... there's another video on youtube of rock n roll star from this same 'gig' and there they show you what the title of this show is. if that's the case this would have been at: The Warehouse, Leeds, England... 1 July 1994
here you can't have a go at oasis for miming on TV, everyone has to mime on tv, you don't have a choice on most shows, Liam actually refuses to do it often and purposefully makes a mess of it to embarrass shows that ask him to do it, actual gigs they never mime
they re not mimed cos they re playin, the guitars re not conected or something, but they play....... =)
de todas maneras me chupa un huevo, si estoy ahi y los veo haciendo mimica , me cuelgo del pogo de una, para que me voy a quedar parado diciendo: no, miro como hacen mimica.... me voy chau...... pffffffffffft
You're right , in fact they've mimed many times 'cos of stupid TV shows unable to let them play live.
Each time they've seem to really HATE IT and always try to screw the record .
(Check out "Roll with it " on TOTP (with LIAM pretending to be noel on guitar, or "Stop crying your heat out" on Hit machine(french tv show)with Alan and Gem laughing at Noel hilarious moves)
i ment live ... liams voice is live but the music is exactly the same on the album have a listen then youll notice... yeh when they play proper gigs they dont mime but they have done on tv shows in the past ...
I love how shit it sounds when they fade out supersonic. Ive been on totp and its hard not to laugh when you finish the song. Oasis in my opinion were the best thing to come out of britain in the 90's.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
if oasis are about true ROCK then why in the world would they fucking agree to mime their hit songs??? sounds to me like they needed attention in their first year of jumping around and they basically listened to what they were told and where to play...
Liam isnt miming on this one (see other comments). and when they mime like on TOTP, its cos every artist on there is doing it, so do all the bands need attention then?
Afcourse gsbreath2, Liam is miming ... euhm, especially at 41seconds for example ... but yeah, afcourse its TOTP :D. like we wouldnt ave figured that one out ... they only played "Whatever (mimed)" in 1994 @ TOTP
this is not their first tv appearance... they do sing supersonic on their first but this is not it... their first TV appearance was on The Word, on march 18th 1994.. this is not it
you misunderstood me... I was naming THREE videos I've seen where he holds the mike like that.. this video..... the video of their first live performance of supersonic.... AND most of the songs they do from Gleneagles.
On TOTP everyone mimed apart from whoever was number 1 that week 'I think'. They would be the only one's to play live. Also sometimes they used to have 'special guests' on the show. The 'special guests' would also play live. But everyone else pretty much had to use playback. This is not playback. Well the vocals definitely are not playback. I'm not too sure about the instruments.
TheLukaraptor 6 months ago
ok, i love oasis as much as the next guy, but i think the instruments might be mimed. noel's solo on supersonic is note for note the same as on the album and the hand claps during the coda of supersonic arent appearing to be coming from anywhere. dont give me a bunch of crap for saying that. i love oasis too, but its just what it looks like to me
memgrizz1132225033 7 months ago
the vocals are live, but they seem to be using a backing track aswell
jonqdrum 10 months ago
Im not being funny but If you cant tell that this is a live performance then your a fucking idiot
LukaRaPtoR 1 year ago
its live ffs
LukaRaPtoR 1 year ago
awesome they sung the coke verse!!
roman798 1 year ago
Yeah, Liam is singing 'live' here.
li4m 1 year ago
i guess this came from a show called "Something for the weekend"... there's another video on youtube of rock n roll star from this same 'gig' and there they show you what the title of this show is. if that's the case this would have been at: The Warehouse, Leeds, England... 1 July 1994
TheBede003 2 years ago
@TheBede003 thanks mate
frjdoasis3 9 months ago
hands on the mic???????? WTF?
sebfynn 2 years ago
liam is singing. cmon u can tell
taNiboyy 2 years ago
here you can't have a go at oasis for miming on TV, everyone has to mime on tv, you don't have a choice on most shows, Liam actually refuses to do it often and purposefully makes a mess of it to embarrass shows that ask him to do it, actual gigs they never mime
Richie1989A 2 years ago 4
@Richie1989A robbie williams introduced them.! thats problem no.1
IDyNaMiCkzZx 1 year ago
@Richie1989A Even AC/DC has mime on TV
Jato97 8 months ago
Liam touching the mic,can you believe it?
nachotubea 3 years ago
what epiphone is noel playing here, not seen this one before. He has had soooooooooooo many
SirHuckenden 3 years ago
it looks like it is the epiphone es-335 dot. could be wrong but it looks like the one i've got.
blakeguitar94 2 years ago
they re not mimed cos they re playin, the guitars re not conected or something, but they play....... =)
de todas maneras me chupa un huevo, si estoy ahi y los veo haciendo mimica , me cuelgo del pogo de una, para que me voy a quedar parado diciendo: no, miro como hacen mimica.... me voy chau...... pffffffffffft
yotwats 3 years ago
oasis have never mimed thats a complete lie
mcfcbanno 3 years ago
Your actually wrong,
mcfcbanno, Oasis have mimed on EVERY "Let there be love" live performance, apart from 1 when it was acoustic and Noel was singing.
Go and check out watch?v=DkvpkAvgbDM
They are clearly miming there, so please get your facts right before you make a comment like that ;-)
Btw I like Oasis, I'm not knocking them or anything just you wrong with what you say, thats all :)
david181993 3 years ago 2
You're right , in fact they've mimed many times 'cos of stupid TV shows unable to let them play live.
Each time they've seem to really HATE IT and always try to screw the record .
(Check out "Roll with it " on TOTP (with LIAM pretending to be noel on guitar, or "Stop crying your heat out" on Hit machine(french tv show)with Alan and Gem laughing at Noel hilarious moves)
IGGYSOR 3 years ago 2
check out top of the pop , singing roll with it was also mimed some thing wrong wiht the video tho ,,,, can u notice? LOL
jukkaa123 3 years ago 3
funniest moment in totp history! only the gallaghers would switch positions to take the piss
joshie3212 1 year ago
i know i was wrong sorry but they dont mime that much :)
mcfcbanno 3 years ago
yeah their awesome live but this is mimed
md47bot 3 years ago
sound is, liam is actually singing ( at 42 secs for example youll hear ...)
andfookingaveit 3 years ago
oh yeah but the guitars not really playing
md47bot 3 years ago
Its LIVE!!
comeonfuckingcunt 3 years ago
Voice sounding absolutely amazing live - shame it's totally shot to f*** when he performs live now!
paulsawers 3 years ago
and you can tell when he sings shakermaker coz he sings the coca cola version and not the mister sifter one like on the album
FreaksOnALeash33 3 years ago
the voice is life but the music is mimed
FreaksOnALeash33 3 years ago
they dont mime u idiot
JordanE2 3 years ago
i ment live ... liams voice is live but the music is exactly the same on the album have a listen then youll notice... yeh when they play proper gigs they dont mime but they have done on tv shows in the past ...
FreaksOnALeash33 3 years ago
oh okay sorry thanks for clarifying.
JordanE2 3 years ago
They are miming here yeah. You can here the clapping that's only in the album, and guitar overdubs that Noel does.
brandonplaysguitar16 3 years ago
I love how shit it sounds when they fade out supersonic. Ive been on totp and its hard not to laugh when you finish the song. Oasis in my opinion were the best thing to come out of britain in the 90's.
jamescropley 4 years ago 2
fuck envisage they are shite
OasisLover2007 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
if oasis are about true ROCK then why in the world would they fucking agree to mime their hit songs??? sounds to me like they needed attention in their first year of jumping around and they basically listened to what they were told and where to play...
oasis1q 4 years ago
Liam isnt miming on this one (see other comments). and when they mime like on TOTP, its cos every artist on there is doing it, so do all the bands need attention then?
andfookingaveit 4 years ago 2
Actually they mime on TOTP cause the live sound there sucks. They tried a couple of times live but they never liked the overall sound
megas9084562 4 years ago
nah, every one who is on TOTP mimes, not just Oasis
andfookingaveit 4 years ago
thats a complimemt cause hes not miming
micoh369 4 years ago
@oasis1q roll with it 'live' in TOTP liam and noel change rolles, making a joke about the playback
Jato97 8 months ago
It's Top of the pops. Can't you guys tell there miming?
gsbreath2 4 years ago
Afcourse gsbreath2, Liam is miming ... euhm, especially at 41seconds for example ... but yeah, afcourse its TOTP :D. like we wouldnt ave figured that one out ... they only played "Whatever (mimed)" in 1994 @ TOTP
andfookingaveit 4 years ago
i thought on tofp they have live vocals over studio instruments.
gsbreath2 4 years ago
Correct. This is a live vocal over backing track.
boblondon76 4 years ago 2
Liam isn't miming! This is live vocal over backing track.
boblondon76 4 years ago
primera vez que lo veo en esa epoca tocando sin su les paul!!
superrsonico 4 years ago
'Something For The Weekend' broadcast on (I think) ITV Granada on 1st July 1994. Oasis also performed Rock 'n' Roll Star on this programme.
waynecarr949 4 years ago
we have an Epiphone guitar like the one Noel is playing the price is about US$300 but Noel make it sound amazing
clemsband 4 years ago
Liam is singing live but the rest of the band are miming !!!
chrisP3081 4 years ago 2
its cause its totp lol haha
peden200 4 years ago
Wow the 2nd show in existence [that I know of] where Liam touches the mic :) Odd to see, still sounds fantastic.
hrhadam 4 years ago
Ive seen three
Brolle88 4 years ago
Name em then? gleneagles, this, ?
hrhadam 4 years ago
This one, their first live television performance of supersonic.. and most of the songs from Gleneagles... so three I know of.
Amused0782 4 years ago
this is not their first tv appearance... they do sing supersonic on their first but this is not it... their first TV appearance was on The Word, on march 18th 1994.. this is not it
zeppelinrain07 3 years ago
you misunderstood me... I was naming THREE videos I've seen where he holds the mike like that.. this video..... the video of their first live performance of supersonic.... AND most of the songs they do from Gleneagles.
Amused0782 3 years ago