I don't really care if she had dysphonia or if she didn't sing it as well as the original. This is sheer emotion, and a great rendition. Kudos for all of you, guys.
What is everyone crying about? This is as good a rendition as you can get. Like the other version better? Fair enough, but judge this version for what it is, not what you expected it to be.
i think she sounds fine. she's definitely not terrible. actually, her voice is quite lovely. but, she's so quiet, it's distracting! it's such a beautiful piece, and she's supposed to be the melody! :\
The beauty of having multiple renditions of songs is that you slowly learn to appreciate the subtle differences in voices that you never did before.
The original's voice and style appears to be more powerful and/or practised but I wouldn't count this singer out. If she gets the opportunity to sing this song a few more times, I wouldn't be surprised to see a lot of the negative comments become positive ones.
Huh? Her voice was a little rough for the first few seconds but after that it sounded perfect. I could have been convinced that that it was the original voice, it's extremely close.
@Cainmak While I agree that she's very engaged in her singing, the problem there is that her voice is not a match for Noriko Mitose. She still did a great job singing, but for a lot of people something like this is very iconic, and no one will care for it if it's not as close to perfect as can be.
This is one of the most favorable songs of all time. Radical dreamers, a song meant to touch... Sorry, but the one's who commented negatively are wrong. The way you guys played it was as if I was there. So cozy, warm, heartfelt, and felt like I was in a living room with my friends just chilling to the song. Nothing wrong with it whatsoever. LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVED it!
Before she started singing I was already reading the comments, and you guys made me worry that this would be epically disappointing, and YouTube comments are usually right or at least sway my opinion, but I don't know just WTF you guys are talking about this time. She's fine. Definitely not at the same level as the original, but far from atrocious.
@XTruth I admit the beginning was not as great, but she recovered quite well. She has a vocal ability clearly. Her lows might not be as great, as she doesn't get enough air, but her highs are good to excellent. This is a very difficult song to sing though.
@AWDracer Guitar was amazing and I was expecting amazing-to-match Vocals only to be trolled by this lady. Recovered quite well? Where? The only part she was ok was when her voice gained some strength at 2:40. 3:15 wtfisthisshit.jpg
@IchinShek I don't know the lady but I think you guys are being really harsh. If you're a trained guitar player, the guitar (or trained with any other instrument), the result would always be amazing. As long as you don't forget any notes, you're safe.
On the other hand, singing requires many many dimensions, and thus, is harder to do.
I'm not completely defending her singing, as it wasn't the best at all. But the people harshly criticizing her on Youtube probably couldn't do much better.
watch?v=BplklkjjkO8&feature=related
This is much better!!
poo10357 1 month ago
oh my god, she ruined it like a truck hitting a bus full of school children
katharn 1 month ago
LIKE ครับผม WCG_TH_BOMZ
WCGTHBOMZ 1 month ago
I don't really care if she had dysphonia or if she didn't sing it as well as the original. This is sheer emotion, and a great rendition. Kudos for all of you, guys.
cerberus112261 1 month ago in playlist Favorite videos
She was amazing
personagc 2 months ago
*sounds woops, and i bet you couldnt do any better
equestrianforever1 2 months ago
This souds wonderful guys shut up with the hating!
equestrianforever1 2 months ago
What is everyone crying about? This is as good a rendition as you can get. Like the other version better? Fair enough, but judge this version for what it is, not what you expected it to be.
roja88 2 months ago
Beautiful...
ccordell1111 2 months ago
i think she sounds fine. she's definitely not terrible. actually, her voice is quite lovely. but, she's so quiet, it's distracting! it's such a beautiful piece, and she's supposed to be the melody! :\
TheGreatMattao 3 months ago
I dunno what these here moon speakers is sayin! Crazy non-Merican jibbrish!
elimccl 3 months ago
nice cover... the guitarist could've done better though
nsac91 3 months ago
shota nakama very funny name, who knows portuguese will understand
maylesoki 3 months ago
@maylesoki pussy in bed,lol.
bladerj 3 months ago
@maylesoki I loled XD
MrRafemisora 3 months ago
RIP Squaresoft ☹
Squallar1 3 months ago 2
I think her voice has a nice maturity to it actually, which is a nice contrast to the younger-sounding original version. I like both very much. ^^
Chrissii1985 3 months ago 2
Absolutely beautiful, great version, loved it.
MatthewAvello 4 months ago
The beauty of having multiple renditions of songs is that you slowly learn to appreciate the subtle differences in voices that you never did before.
The original's voice and style appears to be more powerful and/or practised but I wouldn't count this singer out. If she gets the opportunity to sing this song a few more times, I wouldn't be surprised to see a lot of the negative comments become positive ones.
DarkestKNIGHTCJH 4 months ago
@DarkestKNIGHTCJH I couldn't have put it better, myself. Thank you for showing rare signs of intelligence on zeh internetz.
GrandAngel8000 4 months ago
She did some of then notes really good.
princessmarthajandio 4 months ago
Eso fue algo horrible, quien la dejo subir al escenario y cantar asi?
Gatopzu 4 months ago
@Gatopzu si es verdad.. es horrible... arruino el temazo T.T
AbelxHaroldxDermont 4 months ago
Huh? Her voice was a little rough for the first few seconds but after that it sounded perfect. I could have been convinced that that it was the original voice, it's extremely close.
Phenomenal piece right here either way.
LoefflerDouglas 5 months ago 2
What is the problems with her voice?
khuongducduy 5 months ago
i dont like that husky voice
yurikoYumei 5 months ago
She sounds like she's breathless all the time...in a bad way. >.<
TearsOfSnow 5 months ago
I love it. She sings from the heart.
alainisgeek 5 months ago
F*ck the inflection... guys look at her face. She's engaged in what she is singing.
Cainmak 6 months ago 11
@Cainmak While I agree that she's very engaged in her singing, the problem there is that her voice is not a match for Noriko Mitose. She still did a great job singing, but for a lot of people something like this is very iconic, and no one will care for it if it's not as close to perfect as can be.
t3hlogster 5 months ago
No...no...this is wrong...I guess it HAS to be Noriko Mitose.
zaviusfirerave 6 months ago
Sorry but I can't stand a song that I like so much being sung with .. that voice. It ruins it.
I mean saying she's that bad bad.. nothing compared to the original.
GuillaumeDrolet 6 months ago 2
@GuillaumeDrolet But she sing it perfectly.
Ttinaa90 6 months ago
@Ttinaa90 Right, notes...wrong inflection, wrong feeling. I agree with him. This ruins the hell out of it.
EyeLickChildren 6 months ago
I am trying to find an arangement of this song for my little brother's highschool band. Does anyone know where I could find one?
SerothTalon1 7 months ago
Chrono Cross is probably my favorite game when it comes to music.. its just beautiful
akeenobumatsu 8 months ago
@akeenobumatsu Chrono cross is the best game from everything, it doesnt have a speech and its perfect!!
Victor7Ayres 7 months ago
beautiful song...
RebornGalaxy 8 months ago
One of my favorites
Una muy bella cancion, de mis favoritas
Outstanding instrumental and voice perform
Arigato
Davidalfa69 8 months ago
beautiful,beautiful
beautiful voice, excelent instrumental
pablodelson 9 months ago
wow excellent video and chrono cross too
rora7rora7 10 months ago
her face is shining and so smooth lol its not a mannequin right?
simpatic14 10 months ago
they needed to make the mic a little more sensitive and let us here her breathing; imo.
Ratseeker 10 months ago
This is one of the most favorable songs of all time. Radical dreamers, a song meant to touch... Sorry, but the one's who commented negatively are wrong. The way you guys played it was as if I was there. So cozy, warm, heartfelt, and felt like I was in a living room with my friends just chilling to the song. Nothing wrong with it whatsoever. LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVED it!
matttheviolinist 11 months ago
Before she started singing I was already reading the comments, and you guys made me worry that this would be epically disappointing, and YouTube comments are usually right or at least sway my opinion, but I don't know just WTF you guys are talking about this time. She's fine. Definitely not at the same level as the original, but far from atrocious.
W/ that said, still prefer the original vocalist.
JapanForSale 11 months ago 24
@JapanForSale Definitely the way her voice sounds is she had dysphonia or something like that in that performance.
But she sang anyway, is admirable in my opinion.
MizukiClover 2 months ago
ewwwww omg the guitar sounded so beautiful and when she started singing omg sooo ugly
XTruth 1 year ago
@XTruth I admit the beginning was not as great, but she recovered quite well. She has a vocal ability clearly. Her lows might not be as great, as she doesn't get enough air, but her highs are good to excellent. This is a very difficult song to sing though.
AWDracer 11 months ago
@AWDracer Guitar was amazing and I was expecting amazing-to-match Vocals only to be trolled by this lady. Recovered quite well? Where? The only part she was ok was when her voice gained some strength at 2:40. 3:15 wtfisthisshit.jpg
IchinShek 11 months ago
@IchinShek I don't know the lady but I think you guys are being really harsh. If you're a trained guitar player, the guitar (or trained with any other instrument), the result would always be amazing. As long as you don't forget any notes, you're safe.
On the other hand, singing requires many many dimensions, and thus, is harder to do.
I'm not completely defending her singing, as it wasn't the best at all. But the people harshly criticizing her on Youtube probably couldn't do much better.
AWDracer 11 months ago
She is not that good as Noriko in OST of Chrono Cross, but still very good.
Since 3:15 disappointed me a bit. An amazing moment in the original version.
batatshi 1 year ago
great performance....
ivancebe 1 year ago
Liked it then, like it now.
Jeatkid 1 year ago