The Click Five - All I Need Is You [7/15/06]

[MaryU362]

ERIC's VERSION IS BETTER!!!

[sabrinadckhrbr]

the click five is great! But i personally think that kyle's version is better. just sayin'. eric is more to the "upbeated" songs. they're both great!!! i love tc5 either way..oh and i love kyle :D

[Horsecrazed117]

its different lyrics and the backing instrements are playing slightly differently too,and yes i know my spelling sucks.

[ClickerShayne]

Eric also sings it good...i miss him so much..hey guys..!!! you should not compare Eric and Kyle..cause they are really different..so please don't say such a thing that Kyle is better than Eric or Eric is better than Kyle..!!!!

[edmundred]

eric cant sing at all cant believe the girls can still scream their lungs out - eric sings so bad he can go suck cock now _|_

[BoredRUs]

Oh the memories this video brings back....

Well, I would like to bring to your attention that Eric was in the band at it's peak point, when The Click Five was actually popular. He is the reason why most of us have come to love the band so much. We should all just respect the decisions made by the band.

Kyle and Eric are both talented singers without a doubt. I don't know why any of you should bash on either of them. Just let them do their own thing.

[kourage87]

I have nothing against Eric, but this version is a little weird. Plus, he seems like he HATES that he has to sing it. I don't know if maybe he was having a bad day or what. He's just not that into it!

[wen771127]

it doesn't suit kyle better, it's just you heard his version first.

[crepusculuminfinitio]

Hm, I'm assuming Eric was still with them when it was written, so even though it's on Modern Minds and Pastimes...he already knew about it. And, when he left, kyle took over. I do, however, like Kyle's version better, but this is kind of surprising to find! =)

OMG. i just recently found out eric was punk'd by joe, joey, ethan, and ben!!! lol

[crepusculuminfinitio]

Actually, listening to it closely, some of the lyrics are even a bit different...just a couple though.

[xGingerxSnapsx]

yeah.. he sounds whacked out... :/ but i didn't know eric sung this? anyway him && kyle both sing it well ;)

[triiiish09]

eric sounds tired ..

[triiiish09]

wow , i never knew eric sang this song . i miss and love him so much though i like kyle singing this song better . It's only my opinion so please don't bash me out . I love them BOTH so much

[julia813]

i missss this

[TC5music1001]

both of them are great singers but i think this song suits kyle better... i'm not taking sides because both of them have their own style of singing...

[143musicfob]

Whoa. Didn't know Eric sang this. Kyle suits this song better. I'M NOT STARTING A FIGHT HERE. In my opinion. I like them both!

[xmcflyfanforever]

I think both of them are a great singer.. :*

[fluteplayer007]

Kyle is definately better singing this song but Eric is still good and he has an awesome stage presence, and knows how to work and play off the crowd

[iloovetheclickfive]

Eric

YOU SUCK!!!!!!

[mahrizyah]

You have no right to say that. If you think Eric sucks, you're not a real click five fan. A real click five fan was there with the band from the frickin beginning, You need to have some respect for someone so strong and powerful. He's gone to hell and back and his stupid band didn't even want him because he wanted to be his own person. So you know what? You can shut the hell up and get a life, because I'd like to see YOU try to live his life and still be as perfect, strong, and beautiful as him.

[blgatlc123]

waiiit what happened to eric? like why isnt he in the band anymore?

[crepusculuminfinitio]

he went solo

[yoshitinindhouse]

the songs in modern minds and pastimes just suits kyle better.. sadly...

[kenlemlinh]

agreed !

[maryjaneclick5]

I think kyle is more into this song and much batter at but i would marrie eric for my life

[NVMname]

eeer????nothing...

[mEntZheriCk]

miss eric dill a lot!

[xiaobin90]

i prefer eric :D

[myrockabyes]

ETHAN IS A KICK ASS BASS PLAYER MAN.

[mEntZheriCk]

yeah man....

[lishan7763]

i think kyle sing better in this song...

[janeair1234]

SO GOOD!

[BangMaxwellEdison]

kyles decent

eric was alot better, in my opinion.

Im looking for some of erics new stuff, if he made any..

So any eric dill fans out there that can lead me to some of the stuff hes currently making?

I'd appreciate it alot!

and hey, maybe by a devine miracle he will come back to the click five, if we could only wish...

[sareuhisme]

this devine miracle I NEED IT

[BangMaxwellEdison]

hahaha yes we all do

even the ones who are pro-kyle..they need it too, they just dont know it

[nimblechic07]

yep..I WANT him BACK!! X)

[mEntZheriCk]

u should check out eric's myspace account...there's bunch of his new songs =)

[maryjaneclick5]

Are you eric dill? please replay i love you if you are

[xvanessa93x]

if you go on his myspace page he has new amazinggg songs!

[AnnGlamour]

Kyle's voice suits this song, not Eric. but hey! they're both amazing singers.

[dthewlisrocks]

I don't recognize the lead vocals guy.

[supermen20793]

I love Eric ! I wish he 'll come back to Click 5

[KlutzyGymnast]

ERIC

[dumboe8899]

Kyle's so much better at this song. It's kind of painful to watch, not because Eric sucks (he doesn't) but because his vocal range is about an octave too high for this song.

[FramberAmbank]

I know whatcha mean

[iidolizeclickfive]

oh my! kyle's voice is way better! im telling you guys!!!! eric's voice is not appropriate for this song.... kyle is the best!!!!!!

[redzagalah]

eric merosakkan lagu dohh !

[steze49]

i gota be honest .. kyle's voice sounds better with this song.

eric was a great singer, though.

[Marcus4president]

biggest bunch of fags ever

[hellokitty7401]

oh my gosh kyle does such a better job singing this than eric!!

[EllieAnne]

Eric Dill is a better live singer, Kyle doesn't sound that great here, but he'll probably get better. I miss Erics, but Kyle's ok too.

[MiyakoSawada]

Actually, I think that's Eric singing, not Kyle.

[luvlycarla101]

yeah this is eric. lolzzz kyle's voice is deeper. gah eric is sooo hott. so is kyle. lolzzz

[SHELTERfromTOMORROW]

I believe in the freedom of speech. But I do not believe that anybody has the right to bash another person. Appreciate what we have and if you don't like that, suck it up or deal with it. Nobody is forcing you to like anything.

[jhecee0308]

yeAh u'rE riGht...

it doesn't maTTer if its eric or kylE is the one to sinG the songs of click five,,, it just that......

they ROCK~!!!!!!!!

eRic and kyLe were both g0od....

i reaLLy aPPreciAte aLL their s0ngs.....

I LOVE CLICK FIVE~!!!!!!!

[thatssotina]

god this song is by eric, and they have it on their new album! GOD! kyle stop trying to take eric's place! you will never take his place in my (and lots of other fans) heart!

[luvlycarla101]

omg kyle is not trying to freaking take eric's place. he isnt trying to take anybody's place. he doesnt care if he wont take the place in your heart. the important thing is that he is the new lead singer. accept that. eric wanted to go solo. and that is his choice. kyle is merely the new lead of the click five. omg get that through your head

[clarnce19]

so u lyk kyLe???

[luvlycarla101]

i like both of them. i think they are both great singers. and we should not diss on either one of them

[thatssotina]

UR annoying

[shmileysheep]

stupid freakin screaming girls i wanna hear da music like omg !!!!1 grrrr

I ♥ THE CLICK FIVE !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[laahgirl]

I hate Eric; kyle is hoooot ♥

[crazyhead16]

I luv eric more !!

[poplol2007]

both kyle and eric are great

[sensitive19751975]

nice.. i love Eric's voice..

[athinluvspurple]

i prefer kyle's version becoz his voice suit the song more...but eric is GREAT!!!!!!

[angelofury88]

now eric's planning a record sounding emo like 30seconds to mars..he wanna be more rock n roll, check out his new black hair..can he really do it with that harmonious & soft voice? we'll wait&see..

[LucasGrabeelFan1]

So hes gonna have an ALBUM? Sweet! When is it gonna be out?

[normal33]

different lyrics

[LucasGrabeelFan1]

So this is Eric?

[madhatterrocks]

don't forget eric is singing live and that kyle's version is recorded in a studio

[nikslopez91]

i like kyle's version..eric's voice is tooo high.. but i like it when he sang just the girl

[hoonie08]

tayylin, no, Eric was not the one who formed the Click Five, actually he was the last one to join the band.. :D

[mia22jul94]

i like kyle's version ♥

[tayylin]

Both are nice ! Remember , it was Eric who formed the click five , if it wasn't for him , we wouldn't even know kyle by now !!

[jaynelei]

I like both version, I think Eric is a great singer as well. I'd choose both.

[FranklinCrew]

ERIC IS UGLY. HE CAN'T SING LIVE. VOICE TOO HIGH.

KYLE IS HANDSOME,ENTERTAINING,HIS VERSION OF THIS SONG IS BETTER AND HE HAS A UNIQUE VOICE AND CAN SING SOO MUCH BETTER.

sorry to eric fans,but kyle is sooo much beautiful.

[Edgard1203]

what is it like if Eric Dill sings "Jenny"

[madelrigonan07]

like what kyle said, he's got lower register. but i absolutely agree with the majority, kyle's version is better.

[Edgard1203]

So this is the original version of the "All I need is you" song I think both versions have a great sence of Music in my ears when Eric and Kyle sang it. yeah

[oxDonghaeWifeyxo]

he reminds me of jesse mccartney with that head flick thing...like theyre both so conceited...

[alyannaforever]

he is so ugly and boasting,, Kyle patrick is cooler,, he sucks

[reehxtarded]

erik`ss like overconfident :))

[LEAHUROCK]

eric has a boner lol :)

i like both versions of d song,

i spose every1s entitled to der own opinion!

bt d part wer eriv goes 'hld on tight il hold on too, cos all i need is you'!

he cant reach the high vocals whereas kyle can!i am in luv with eric and alll! bt personally if i had to pick between eric and kyles version id actuallym pick kyles version :)

personal opinion though :) <3

[sheeplovem]

i love eric

[weisheee9]

different voices. one higher.one lower. he cant sing live though.. either tt or hes outta breath.. ha

[face177]

kyle is better!

[hurricanecat]

no offence to eric's fans but i seriously like th version in the album , in other words , the one that kyle sings . you have to agree , his voice is so much better (:

[xxtalamariexx]

I agree with the person who posted before me.

This song is better when Kyle sings it. :]

[TheclickfiveLover]

I like this song better when kyle sings it..

[luv4chocolate]

i personally think erik is hotter and i just like his voice more!!!

[lamchop7]

C'mon man, stop all the "hoos better singer" debate thing. We all have different opinions and at the end of the day it's gonna be a pretty equal vote. Personally, I think Eric is better, he made what tc5 wat they are and he has a very unique voice. Some people agree. Some people don't. What does it matter? All that's important is that they both continue to make good music for us.

[Roon3yFan123]

could eric kill it anymore?

kyle is wayyyy better!

wayyyyyyyyyyy

[upisd0wn]

i agree kyle's a lot better!

[SkyLeon]

nah eric's better maybe u forgot how eric looked like

[dumboe8899]

Kyle's much much much better.

[reddevildeb]

This video has made me come to a conclusion on the whole Kyle/Eric debate.

Kyle wins! Not sure yet if he can pull off their older stuff but he certainly does better on the new stuff than Eric! And Eric seems to be too much of a show off!

[gori078]

ei...both eric and kyle are good.....

[smileysinc]

eew. kyle sounds way better..

[poy321]

i luv the bass in this song

[hellokitty7401]

he stinks in this song

[thatssotina]

YOU stink at LIFE

[hellokitty7401]

look wierd girl, i can have my own opinion and u can have urs. ur just jealous! ohhh

n i actually have a life and dont keep coming back and commenting this one dissin on kyle

[dsaunts3]

KYLE IS BETTER!!!!!!!

[tottikaka]

hey, both vocalists are great. and they're both goodlucking, too, so what's all the fuss about? the important thing is that the band hasn't disbanded yet like all the bands out there... we should support click five not because of the changing of the vocalist but because of their songs and the band itself :)

[chrisyukie]

KYLE is better than eric!!!!!

[frOstZonE]

hu cares hu the singer..I LOVE THE BAND IN ALL

[whoalikeetotally]

eric was okay. i kind of liked tc5 then.

but when kyle came. i kind of got hooked on them then.

cause i think their new songs have a different element to them.

:)

plus. kyle is amazing.

[knchen]

Don't know how they're gonna sing their older hits with the new singer. They're not gonna sound the same.

[flamingox16]

i don't udrstd why the fans have to bicker over the change of vocals in tc5, they're perfectly fine with it, (i mean the band) still on good terms with each otr, so let's all act like adults here and accept things the way it is. seriously, there's no point.

fyi, i'm a fan too.

[Vsnap]

Kyle's 100% better.

I think Eric did the band a favor by leaving.

[cosmicbelt]

ohh well...give KYLE a break...he's good too...u kno u can't compare them...coz their voice is way different...I think KYLE is good, even tho Eric is better on the stage...but KYLE...I think he needs to go match up w/ the ret of the band members...like wearing skinny or straight pants...not the skinny skinny EMO...n he's good to go !!!

ain't that true ?

[SHELTERfromTOMORROW]

tbh, idgaf if you like eric more than kyle or vise versa. they both have qualities that the other doesn't, so they're both fantastic in their own ways

just depending on how you look at it.

and the suits were cute, but it's time for a change. plus, the uniformness started falling apart when eric was still there anyway.

[surfgirl94]

i luv eric dill!!!! gosh i miss him being in click 5. i don't mind kyle, but eric is the original. eric is a hottiee btw.

[Disneyfreak714]

Im a huuuggee fan of both Eric and the click five and kyle with the click five. Kyle however, i think has a smoother, deeper, better voice, and has improved the click five. i cant see how you can hate him since all hes doing is having talant.

[surfgirl94]

watever disneyfreak, i'm just stating my opinion in which every girl agrees with: we all want eric. kyle is not that bad bad. he turned tc5 from cool powerpop with eric to horrible "emo-style" vocals with his type of singing. kyle sucks, bottom line. if u don't agree then fine. your just too scared to face the truth. bring eric dill back. pleeaassee!!!

[caligirl1234567]

you're so right!

i totally agree!

[surfgirl94]

i hate kyle patrick, i love eric dill. he is original babe. not to mention, eric is a complete hottie.

[sushidude95]

who's the guy singing? i can't see anything!

[Disneyfreak714]

The guy singing is ERic Dill--original lead singer of the click five. eric left the band in november. the lead singer is now, the brilliant, and extremely talented. Kyle Patrick

[pirategurl50]

Kyle's version is better...Eric's is ok though.

[britanyisurfriend]

itz the other way around hunny

[pirategurl50]

Ah...Im entitled to my own opinion, britanyisurfriend, as are you. :)

I sound nerdy.

...Well, of course the ORIGINAL singer of All I need is you is better than kyle (for most fans, anyways) because eric's the one who made the click five the click five so.....

But I like kyle's version better because of his deep voice that makes me melt everytime i hear it....so...yeah..

[surfgirl94]

yes, eric did make the click five what they are. and we want to keep it that way. i just don see why you people like kyle. kyle's deep voice is so not the click 5. they went from matching suits(which were cute), cute lead singer, good vocals,and tight pants, to emo kyle patrick, skinny emo-gothic pants, and they don't even wear the same outfits. that's it. we remember tc5 when they had eric, and cute matching suits. i'm just saying...forget kyle....it's all about eric.

[pirategurl50]

I personally think that Kyle isnt emo...what made you think he's emo anyway? and Kyle IS cute...when you think about it. of course his hair MAY seem like a girl's but still...

I didnt like their old matching suits. They werent at all cute. so old and boring. And of course, eric was cute as well but still...I like the new tc5...theyre much more...mature and less girlish..

[surfgirl94]

i still agree on having eric. kyle is emo in a way by the way his vocals are. it's so deep. kinda like a "pirate". kYLe looks like a bird with beak.

they're matching SUITS are cute. they don't make the click 5 look like crap, like the new singer. anyways, the click 5 debut wearing suits, and agreed on WEARING suits, why, wHAT's wrong with being girlish??? from your username, it's 'PIRATEGURL" OR SHOULD "BOY"?

[pirategurl50]

Um...girlish is wrong because..well...theyre GUYS, remember? And i am a girl but im not THOSE girlie girls...*shudders*...

Wearing matching is just plain weird. Seriously. Matching suits are just...Weird.

Kyle doesnt look like a bird with a beak, btw. Hes definitely much more than that.

[surfgirl94]

again, prefferably, eric. kyle can't sing. his voice is so emo. he sucks. i just don't see why all u girls are blind. we want eric.

[bostonmayo]

they are the best band in the world..

i love this song soo much..thanks for posting this..its awesome!!

[slickcross]

These guys are fags. Can't even keep a note. Man, These dudes look like chicks. If these guys would ever go to prison, they would get raped so fast they wouldn't know what stuffed them! SCREW CLICK FIVE! They're not even a rock band. They're a Wuss Band!

[runz4life23]

kyle is not as good as eric. eric made the group sound more pop but kyle makes it sound more rock like. i guess thats a good thing.....

[HMeiz]

Eric is SOO CUTE!! His voice is one of a kind. ;)

[cuttiepie12345678910]

HES FUCKIN HOTT!!!!

[tealeaf06]

sounds better wiv eric... :(

[x3senselesswreck]

both of it sounds good though.

[x3senselesswreck]

the band just posted this song on myspace.

you guys should go listen to it.

does it sound better with eric or kyle?

i think it sounds better with eric.

both it both sounds good.

[robwat123]

Yea Eric was better. Why did he leave?

[CarCrashHearts1]

aw cute. I miss Eric. But I like Kyle-new singer. Alot! Eric is still soooo good though.

[amicxxx]

the bass was loud but Ethan's still cute

XD

i miss Eric's voice

it was just so pretty..

:[

[MattMedlin]

i miss eric sooooo much! he was so much better than kyle!!!

[lilyhorse]

I wanna hear the new guy on another song. He was alright singing "Jenny" but I think Eric was still a better vocalist. oh well. life goes on...

[emilynur]

*sob* yeah i miss Eric...

[Mood8]

eric is still the best man! i dunno whether tis is eric..but eric IS THE BEST!

[pinkprincess123654]

this lead singer suxz i like eric

[ektelonrep]

dude..this is eric

[fireblain]

dang.....he was having a hard time hitting those high notes, wtf, that guy was like my vocal hero...

[x3juicyygirliix3]

i hate the new lead singer.. i love eriiccc!

[Mikisthatchick]

eric left... :(

but the new singer has an amazing voice!

[thegirlilookingfor]

wow.. wat a music

[SandyTimNUT]

omg...its true, i really did talk to steve and he told me Eric left....get over it!

[muck4luckluvsmcfly]

dang thats depressing i would like buy a ton of copies haha well not really just one but i'd watch it all the time!!!! love them much. and thank god he didn't leave haha

thanks!

[muck4luckluvsmcfly]

so he left or he didn't :( and what movie??? lol it better just be a rumor. or i might just be depressed for like ever.

lol

[xobittersweet51]

No he didnt leave. "Taking 5" is a movie they just finished filming nobody bought it yet though so it cant come out in theaters=[

but Eric's name is Ritchie=]

[SandyTimNUT]

is he still in the band?

[hotpinkblondexo]

i was there...eric gave me his guitar pick : ) and joey winked at me haha

[xobittersweet51]

Yes Eric is in the band. They guys didnt say anything about him leaving so he didnt. Ben just posted they are recording right now. And if you think about it, they just got done filming a movie and recording an album. Unless he is really really stupid he wouldnt leave. In conclusion..dont believe everything you hear on message boards. Im not trying to be rude believe me =] I just wanted to inform you.

<3

x0ashley

[SandyTimNUT]

actually XO...Eric DID leave the band....I don't think Steve would lie

[xobittersweet51]

Steve Duchardt?

I didnt hear anything about that...did he post on the boards?

or on their myspace?

Umm..but yeah I still think its aa rumor. But we can both believe differnt things.

[SandyTimNUT]

actually, Steve told me in person that he left!

[xobittersweet51]

mhh Eric<3 such a silly booy

Thank god that rumor is finally D-E-A-D

[eminemzz]

wish i was there...haha...oh well there's always next year?

[smiling20]

I LOVE THIS SONG ALOT!((x

[justthegirl4eric]

wow, I love this song x32409238. thanks=]

[xoAshleyox1424]

i love this song so much. <3

[justwine]

ahh all i need is u eric ! :D love the vid btw, thanks for posting

[TC5FAN]

i love this song. eric can dance. =]

[OHHHHEEYYY]

hahah yup. eric's got some sweet dance moves. =)