Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (291)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • yeah yeah try more bitch to be a gothic rock singer!!!U still need a lot...Though gj all the other band's members!

  • Make FAQ

  • still need the official like a prayer performance on here too

  • follower =P LMBO

  • Good cover and performance and can we move past the whole ridiculous Evanescence VS We Are The Fallen Debate. Both bands are good.

  • Comment removed

  • Im ashamed to be from the same country as her.....

  • I love your songs we are the fallen

  • CANNOT STOP LISTENING. This is such an amazing cover. She rocked it.

  • wow

    

  • This is absolutely terrible..

  • STEEEEEEEEEEEVE PERRY(Shameless Baseketball reference)

  • Now that's a REAL singer, she sounds amazing live unlike other crap pop singers that can't sing without auto-tune. More people should listen to this band.

  • Comment removed

  • i like this song should be a studio song

  • I Seriously Love her Irish Accent but it seemed to go away as she sang Love Carly!

  • OHH I LOVE HERRRRRRR PERFORMENCE

  • thumbs up if you keep coming back to watch the same video all the time. lol. they fucking kicked ass didn't they?

  • awesome cover journey

  • @t9993 omg ur right i never noticed that before

  • I've uploaded the Carly Smithson vocal range video.. now theres finally one on youtube.

  • I love how i can go to a amy lee video and no one talks about carly but if you go to a carly video fucking every one is being a ass hole to her....wow just because you heard of amy first doesnt mean that carlys a copy...cuz shes not ....shes from fucking ireland...she never even heard of amy till we are the fallen....(for the info which was in 2009)

  • They are so keel love it!

  • Kudos to Ben and John for the great guitar play, has to be said!

  • VERY RESPECTED!!!

  • they totally rocked it!!

  • I actuall watched American Idol when she was on it, and then stopped when she was kicked off.

  • crap! 

  • Awesome cover!!!)

  • :) amazing cover! Love it!

  • :) amazing cover! Love it!

  • I have to admit this is a great cover.

  • Original is still better.

  • amazing!!!!!

  • Is a very nice song and group , with coordinate musics ,and a result: of a so good song with power and force in your message . Congratulations : "WE ARE THE FALLEN" . ..and our best Regards , from Catalonia-in the /Coast Brave / Spain

  • @codialbert jajja nunca había visto eso de Catalonia-in the /Coast Brave/ Spain

    Saludos desde Valencia

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @karlass88

    -Hay muchas cosas que no has visto aùn, querida "Karlass88." - Pero no tengas miedo cariño! Not fear! Yo te las mostraré!= por partes y por tiempos ! ..y con el punto de ternura justo , necesario y preciso..si ..los amigos son para eso! .-Y no me dés las gracias :- són 50 euros y en paz.. !..jaja... Saludos desde la Coast Brava / Catalonia / Spain,dedicated :ERASMUS -NOT FEAR! GirL

  • i just saw her shorts .lol

  • I really think Rock fits her voice i couldn't imagine her doing a solo album.

  • fantastic!!! x

  • I love Carly

  • she's hot! :P

  • love this song! my breakup song...still love you steve<3 though we touched and went our separate ways.

  • Better than the original!!!!

  • Damn, she nailed it 

  • awesome!! cooL...

  • fucking love it.

  • I FORGOT SHE WAS IRISH!!!!! I loved her on American Idol because she reminded me of Amy Lee, and then I found out about WATF and kinda hated her. But then I bought their CD for the hell of it, LOVED IT, and now this is probably one of my fav bands.

    Can't believe I ever disliked them. Seriously. LOVE THIS COVER. Ohmygod. My fav Journey song ever and I think she did a GREAT JOB on it! I wanna see 'em live. So bad.

  • @SnowWhiteQueen29 THEY ARE AWESOME LIVE.. and she is soo sweet

  • Really asome cover from journey. It's as good as the original version. Asome ^^

  • "let me hear you mother fuckers, come on" hahaha epic

    she's amazing, like, really amazing.

  • nice performance, but Journey's original is untouchable

  • Beautiful!! I prefer her singing more of THIS kind of music...

  • She rocks \m/

  • carly rocks!!!!

    

  • I think Youtube needs a 'Love' button amongst the 'Like' button.

  • these band rocks!

  • love love love this song but I cant help but to feel that she for got she had on a dress I mean n one part I seen her black underwere lol

  • FINALLY A PERFORMANCE I WANT STUCK IN MY HEAD :)

  • fuck that was awesome

  • I wan't more!!!!

  • Wow she's great and Ben is great too)))

  • Amazing cover! :]

  • I love how carly smithson sings. She sounds better live than in studio. When she sings live, she has so much presence, and she has so much emotion behind her voice. It's far beyond any singer I've ever heard.

  • wooow

  • great cover...ROCK ON!!!

  • I am in awe O_O

  • I loved this song, it is the best performance of Carly Smithson to date in my opinion ;D

  • I like both bands. EVANESCENCE better bring it in OCTOBER! TEAR DOWN THE WORLD is a better album than OPEN DOOR, but not as good as the first one.

  • Comment removed

  • @Ceallachain100 I am a band of both bands, but in my opinion, TTWD is not as good as The Open Door.

  • Upskirt at 1:56! =)

  • great perormance, cant wait to see the DVD!!

  • it seems like Amy and her voices have both improved like at the rock am ring performance with Watf she wasn't that great and now she's awesome. Then Amy was already good (at some performances) but at the maquirana festival and nyc concert she was amzing

  • Happy 2nd anniversary to We Are The Fallen

  • @kittiikatze I have ther album and realy like it my face has to b burn but I dnt think they r as good or will ever b as good as evanescence and as ben left to go solo and only had 1 song that was not all that and now turns up in a new band with the rest of evanescence it's odd. But then agen the rest in an iterveiw sed they left to spend more time at home so I ges they already new that we r the fallen would never do as well

  • @Shakiramad It's important to realize that Ben left not to go solo, but because he didn't like the direction Evanescence was taking. As much as people talk up Amy, he cofounded it with her, and it's just as much his baby as it is hers. But she became the face of it, and changed it. I dig Ev, but watching this video and seeing how happy all the guys are really puts into perspective how much more enjoyable this experience is for them.

  • @silverchyld Well said! It is also time that people realised that their name really has nothing to do with EV. I like EV as well and will be going to see them next month. The Fallen in their name comes from the fact that all members had at one time reached a high level in their careers and had Fallen back down! Some member had fallen from EV, Carley from her position in Idol etc. It is possible to like more than one band people so either get with it or stay with YOUR single band

  • Great cover.  Check out their original work. There's some amazing songs on the debut album. Hopefully they get their record label issues worked out soon.

  • Amy you rock and will always b best in my eyes

  • I was like omg the whole band left amy for that just to do cover songs but at the same time I am ashamed to say I like them but then agen it just evanescence with a new lead singer and a new name

  • @Shakiramad They don't do just covers. Buy their album. It's awesome!

  • I was like "omg what an awesome song written by WATF, finally"!!! And then I was like "0hh it's a cover?" And I was like :/

    excellent cover anyways.

  • Is she Irish? Or from the South East or something?

  • @DuskAndHerEmbrace13 She is Irish

  • @DuskAndHerEmbrace13 She's Irish

  • Posted this on the wrong video, but I'm posting it here too. We Are The Fallen + Journey = PURE AMAZING.

  • best live vocals in a long time. shes so awesome

  • uuuuuuuu q bueno suena esto :)

  • That was insane!!! why do you think she can sing???? D:

  • that was INSANELY good , keep up the good work guys :) 

  • Love this version, though I still think that Carly might very well be straining her voice a bit too much.. It just doesn't sound like it's easy for her to sing like this

  • @lovemoody

    Disagree i think she sounds mega, perhalps of the best live vocals I have ever heard

  • This is amazing. Rock on!

  • I love WATF ---but I think I agree with Will Hunt of Ev.....this seems more like a revenge band against Amy. Carly is looking way too much like Amy.

  • @WickedDragon86 nobody is taking revenge

  • @WickedDragon86

    Nah, I think they are a better act than Ev, I can see why a member of Ev would say that though as TTWD was a better albumn than any EV album (including Fallen though fallen had the better singles) so therefore he'd be somewhat insecure that Moody being the better writer out of al of them was coming back to reclaim his fans.

  • @WickedDragon86 Carly looks NOTHING like Amy!

  • I liked this as soon as I heard the first note, did anyone else? =P

  • Three words: Oh. My. God. This has to be the best cover of the song that I've ever heard. <3 I heard you guys are gonna release an EP with a bunch of covers from the 80's, a studio version of this had better be on it. xD

  • 1:00

    

  • almost reaching 10K play times! :)

  • Comment removed

  • the music is awesome, but i just can't bring myself to like the lead singer

  • this would be such a great song for WATF, loved it!

  • Truly Very Good! I enjoyed watching and listening. Carly has an amazing voice!

  • I want more....mooOOAAARRRR!!!!!!!

  • Audio download soon please? :D

  • amazing!!! these song is epic!!!! LOVE IT!

  • Carly RockZ ... Hard!!! So excited for their new Album comming EARLY 2012 !!!! Are you excited,too ? ... THUMPS UP!.. Want to know somethin more about Mr. Moody? .. Go read his new "Blog" on his MYspace PAGE! .. Awesome!

  • @JeanLucPolier WTF is recording another albun???

  • @PatrickKortKamp yes it will b released next year

  • @PatrickKortKamp Is WATF, and the new album will be released early in 2012

  • @Sele2punto0 I know I just wrote it wrong. But I'm happy now. We Are The Fallen is an awesome band.

  • @JeanLucPolier Where did you hear about their new album coming out in early 2012? I haven't been able to find anything.

  • @TheSingingSongman i saw an interview where she talked about new WATF Stuff and the thing she had going on with "Viva Elivs" she mentioned that she expect an early 2012 release..

    It was an interview related to Idol... Idoleenis? or something like that? ;)

    i forgot how to spell it ...now i can´t find it, too... if i find something .. i´ll tell you... i think the "interview" was with someone who always interviews former Idol contestants... i think ..

  • @JeanLucPolier

    thanks for info I really like them. I'm so excited.

  • @JeanLucPolier They're coming out with a new album!!!?? :D

  • Wow that was great!

  • Evanescence is good, We are the Fallen is good. Amy is good. Carly is good. I love both <3

  • @xBrokenxPaperxDollsx No... Amy is good and Ben Moody is good!

  • Maybe she has a good voice , but she is not THE AMAZING AMY LEE <3

  • @EvRocksMySox

    You are right, she isnt Amy.. she's better! *runs from the Ev fans* ... lol

  • @EvRocksMySox And we give thanks for that, ha!

  • what an amazing voice! It goes so well with the boys rock

  • they covered it so great it sounds like its their song carly will always rock

  • I really like it and that was cool wished I could have that song on my mp3 player lol.. Love it.

  • Carly Smithson >>>>> Lady Gaga, Britney, or any of the other "popular" female vocalists out right now!

  • great

    

  • I've replayed that "Thank you for opening my eyes" and the hand gesture a bunch of times. It's funny for some reason.

  • IM SO GNNA BUY THIS

  • upload an HD version

  • I love this! I hope to see We Are The Fallen live someday. :)

  • Comment removed

  • Ya know, do certain people have nothing better to do than try to criticize every little thing from this band? It really doesn't do much in your favor or for that "other" band you supposedly support. If you don't like the music or the people, fine - DON'T LISTEN TO IT. But have the intelligence to shut the fuck up in regards to people who DO LOVE THIS BAND & CARLY HERSELF. Oh, and just for the record, Carly you can call me a motherfucker anytime you want.

  • Peace people... :D enjoy the music and leave all your fucking craps behind... if you want to abuse each other don't do it on this perfect live performance :)

    I love We Are The Fallen... I'm a crazy fan of We Are The Fallen but I also love Evanescence... People... ENJOY THE MUSIC :)

  • I'm sorry, but I actually don't appreciate being called a motherfucker when attending your concert Carly (3:48). I know I wasn't actually there, but why do bands think fans like that?

    I really like We Are the Fallen, one of my favourites, but Carly tries too hard to be bad ass and looks absolutely ridiculous. At the beginning when she is pointing and "clapping" her arm does anyone else cringe and chuckle a bit?

  • I'm pretty sure the use of the term motherfuckers or 'fuckers' from rockbands to their audience is basically a salute to the fact that they're performing to a crowd of misfits, and nodding to the fact that they're a whole crowd of motherfuckers all together having a good time. I really don't think it's as offensive as you think it is- harden the fuck up, motherfucker ;)

  • @TheKatIsBackAgain Haha, that actually made me laugh. I get what you mean, I just...I guess what I mean is, it seems so...like she is trying hard to impress or something. I don't know. I was also just trying to poke fun. It's not classy, not that they are supposed to be classy, but...I really can't articulate what I am trying to say hahaha. Anyway. It' not this big of a deal. I'm done with it. lol.

  • @VampSlayer13 I wasn't actually insulting you. I used the term motherfucker in jest in my statement- I used it casually to make my point. I'm glad you weren't offended.

  • @TheKatIsBackAgain No no I got that lol.

  • @VampSlayer13 lady gaga calls "monsters" to her fans and no one is offended ¬¬

    come on, is only to be with fans in a sarcastic way

  • @Sele2punto0 I've already responded to someone who commented on this. Feel free to read that. I'm not repeating myself. Good'ay.

  • Comment removed

  • @VampSlayer13 it was a term of endearment u moron

  • @SMDB82 You mad bro?

  • Comment removed

  • @SMDB82 If I may use your terms, how endearing of you. I hope you have a good day too motherfucker <- That was meant as a compliment...wasn't it?

  • @VampSlayer13 i didn't take any offense....even tho u intended it to be that way :)

  • @SMDB82 You know, to assume makes an ASS out of U and ME.

  • @VampSlayer13 clever. anything else?

  • @SMDB82 I wasn't trying to be clever. But no, I guess I am done. Are you done?

  • @VampSlayer13 i think we've clogged up the comment feed long enough

  • @VampSlayer13

    You need to get out more you motherfucker! serioulsy though I think the handclapping looks great, she seems very assured these days and it comes accross, so no I didnt find anything about the performance to "cringey" in fact I though it lookeed great, now if only amy Lee could pull that off!

  • @JonCantspell Dude, this thing is over with now. The clapping is cringe worthy in opinion, no one has to agree, I can't help that I cringed. Just happens. I like Amy Lee and Evanescence more, but there are times when I cringe during her performances too, I can admit that sometimes my favourite bands don't look and sound great all the time, although regretfully.

  • @VampSlayer13

    it's cool, you have your opinion. I sont think the audience mind so I guess it works for some, I think she cuts the mustard though!

  • what an energetic crowd...

  • ;_; Oh my god, how good this sounds after watching Anywhere But Home... Rock out forever!

  • @TheKatIsBackAgain You're an annoying troll. Get the fuck out of here. why did you have to insult Evanescence, you bitch? Get over your fucking self!

  • @eggEgg23 Actually, I was being completely honest. And JSYK- I was never under myself so I'm not sure how to be over myself. can you tell me how?

  • @TheKatIsBackAgain I don't care if you were being completely honest. If you hate Evanescence so much, why did you go and bother to watch Anywhere But Home you fucking idiot? Dumb ass. Go fuck yourself.

  • @eggEgg23 When did they say they hate evanescence?

  • @AnnelieseMoon She's been around every video randomly talking about Evanescence and how much they suck in other words. She basically just said Amy Lee's voice sucks live. Why they gotta bring that up and start up shit?