Also, in the hadith in which the Prophet tells his daughter that a women should cover everything but her face and hands he simply points to her face and hands. When a person points to your face, how do you know he is not pointing to your entire head?
@fopower Thanks for this thoughtful comment also. What you seem to be saying is that Asma didnt not understand what was being said to her and then she conveyed it with this misunderstanding. This is problematic as this makes explainer/clarifier of the Quran (Muhammad - saw) unable to portray the meaning of the Quran and all the people of Asmas' time unable to understand the "true" meaning of whatever the Messenger said to them?
@thefotfoundation Sir, Muslims claim, that Allah is the God of the Bible and Islam arose from the religion of the prophets and apostles, but this is refuted by solid, overwhelming archeological evidence. Idol statues are in hand proving Allah was a pagan 'moon-god' in pre-Islamic times. Islam symbol is the crescent moon! Why is the crescent moon atop mosques and minarets, and on the flags of Islam? Why do Muslims fast during the month that begins and ends with the crescent moon in the sky?
as a muslim sister I respect your opinion on this. However I do not appreciate that this is the only opinion that islamic scholars and imams have decided to listen to and convey.
The fact the women already were wearing the "khimars" on their heads indicates that this was a cultural practice- the passage in the Quran simply tells them to cover their breasts- the importance of covering their heads is not discussed.
You say that the Quran "simply tells them [women] to cover their breasts".
This is inaccurate. The Quran says "walyadribna" the khimar to cover the chest. "walyadribna " means to draw, this of course can not be interpreted as you have, as first the khimar must be removed from the head.
Also, that the khimar IS a head-covering means that when the Quran is using the word "khimar" then head-covering is actually being discussed.
I've really come to appreciate the methodological and educated way you present Islam. I'm a hijab-wearer personally and many Muslims I know do say that it is not mandatory. I'll forward your video to them.
salam alikum brother , thank you very much about your hijab viedio , it is really perfectly expl. you are the first who really give me an exlelent explanation about the hijab matter . Im quite shockt about some comments at youtube about your vidio. Question is face cover niquab good or bad ? I wish to wear niqab to cover my face . But people say this is haram and just causes me problems in australia, i just want know for shure do i need niquab or not ? Thanks Tanya (convert muslimah)
JazakhumAllahKhairun for you comment. The issue regarding the Hijab is quite clear as you saw.
The niqaab is a disputed issue and although there are differing views most Scholars say that it is not obligatory (no sin if you dont wear it) but it definitely is good (reward if you do wear it).
That said my wife doesnt wear it but does on occasions e.g. wearing make-up and is on her way to a Sisters party.
Whether Khimr = headscarf or veil is not the point Quran says use this garment to cover CHEST (& not HEAD.)
Consider statement ;Use your toothbrush to clean your shoes. I am not asking you to brush your teeth but to clean your shoes despite using a "toothbrush".
Allah will judge us on what we dispute. Let us all sincerely seek and ask to be shown the TRUTH. Allah knows best
Peace, Thanks for the thoughtful comment. However there is an issue in your analysis.
The Quran doesnt say "use the Khimar" to cover your chest it says "walyadribna the khimar" to cover the chest. "walyadribna " means to draw, this of course can not be interpreted as you have, as removed from the head.
The Khimar (head scarf) is to be drawn over (walyadribna ) the chest, not removed from the head and used to cover the chest instead.
As salamu aleykum; barakaLLah feek...I don't think I could stay so cool and friendly about it (I've tried reasoning with her too) This kind of misguidance has to be fought cause it's all together dangerous as they (quranites: wich of course she denied to be) try and distort so many aspects of the deen. Keep it up for the sake of those who might fall into that trap.
This video try to proof the invented hijab as head covering which is not in Quran because prophet was given the book to explain their differences with the book and not other than book like arabwoman etc...24:31 allah is asking to cover up lady, starting over shoulder which was supprted by 33:59 jilbab mean gown over shoulder...
text41, your points are a little vague. Aside from denying the hadith, accusing me of trying to mislead people, mis-using the Quran and slandering Aisha (RA), the rest of your points arent clear. Please clarify. Peace, fot
interesting video, in my last comment i ahve told that you could not bring head covering over the chest where as allah is asking in the same aya over juyubehinna....
and you had to show other verse 33:59 which is again a cloth over shoulder...finally you had to combine these two ayats to stablish your interpretation...
in this video it has been said that " i am going to use quran and not said going to show from Quran...ofcourse you have used very well the quran to tell your concept which is of arabwoman's concept and not based on anyquranic ayat....how can it be, while u said u r going to use quran to show hijab of arab woman and not of quranic ayat based .
secondly in video is said about denying hadeece of prophet saw, i dont know which book he is reffering as "prophet hadeese" where as i have heard about hadeese of bukhari muslim and etc....but this is new for me that prophet or anyone of his companion has written any book in the name of haqdeece of prophet saw used to explain quran.....would u plz tell which is the hadith book of prophet saw?
interesting video in it discussed many points so i take one by one 1-quoted 16:44, 64
16:64 here Allah has sent book only to explain the differences...meaning difference are made clear with books i.e with ayats of books. and not written that one part is written some where else in books other than quran which he called hadeese....anyway this is your interpritation and not written in the aya and seems that realy trying to misguide people ...
Muslm girl here, don't wear Hijab never will ;-))All i'm gonna say is that if you feel the need to accept hadiths then do so,but do know that God knows what is inside of each of us.hadiths are extremely chauvinistic and biased and downright stupid,i wonder what motivates people,specifically men,to embrace them as inspired by God?why eh? Well,Hijab is clearly not in Quran for me.
You dont have to do anything you dont want to. I dont "feel the need", the Quran itself teaches Muslims to follow the Messengers explanation of the Quran = Hadith. This is your answer to why Muslims accept hadith as inspired.
"what motivates people,specifically men"? By far the largest teacher of Hadith from the Messenger was a woman, Aisha (ra)?!
"Hijab is clearly not in Quran for me". The opposite is clearly demonstrable. The Hadith clarify this which is why you need to deny them. Peace, fot
thefotfoundation ..Quran has this word in 39:23 which reffered as the book of Allah and not books written by people after 200 years departure of messenger of Allah in the name of word hadith. that is why people are giving deifferent logics tp proove their books as prophet saying and giving name as hadith of prophet saw,as u tried to give for hijab which is not in quran,
which book do u have? written by Hazrat aisha? have ? plz tell ne too the name or u r also destorting her personality?
One thing that confuses and angers me is how some muslims can come to a conclusion about deen that is completely contrary to what has already been established in deen and run with it, while it never crosses their minds that how come they came to that conclusion when no one else has, even the prophet himself? I think they believe they understand deen better than rasulullah (saw) authu billah!
Did you know that you guys used to be praying facing Jerusalem instead of Mecca?And did you know that your religion was started by Jews that lived and befriended by Muhamad your imam since he wasn't educated whatsoever?
you r talking right but the deen in quran doesnot say that muslim of allah ever faced jerusalam because first hous of allah is kaaba having muqame ibrahim....
From the beginning for a longest time this facing towards Jerusalem was the traditional way but here was a dispute and anger towards the Jewish State then those Mullahs decided on their own that facing towards mecca was solving this problem.What came out of it was every non-muslims would be exterminated, according to your koran.
muslim of allah as per quran has never faced jerusalam because as per quran kaba exists since day one that is why there was no need to face jerusalam.
Fotofota...this facing is mentioned in history of such people who donot know quran and prophet through Quran..quran has 3:96 here awal the first house adress is given which is that which has muqame ibrahim and muqame ibrahim is in kaba...as per quran no muslim never faced jerusalam...
text41, Although fotofota has the historical reason behind the change of the Qiblah from Jerusalem to the Ka'ba entirely wrong (as I would expect) the event did actually occur. Read Quran 2:144-145. Peace, fot
lol cute mashaAllah jazak ALlah khyr for the demonstration! when u said u were gonna demonstrate i had in mind some really pink frilly sequined beaded girly looking hijab! hahahaha! but Alhamdulilah that was not the case or i might have fell of the chair laughing and not listen to the rest of th vid :-D
mashallah Brother, this video truly did help me in terms of understanding the hijab in the quran. May Allah keep you and bless us all to gain knowledge.
the camel analogy is an oversimplification, simply becoz it has nothing to do with making you a better or worse person, and is incomparable to the prophet's teachings of behaviour and conduct as a muslim, u might see some ppl who like to dress like the prophet for example just as a sign of love, but has nothing to do with hadith argument
the hadeeth was written by men though. God says he will guard the Koran and the wisdom of it. the wisdom of it is the traditions that are past down. but that doesn't mean that hadeeth is pure and is preserved. in the Koran it says that his example is left for us. this is for the people of that time. otherwise i would have to buy a camel instead of a car to follow the lifestyle of the prophet. God bless.
The qur'an has been written by men, does that make the qur'an human made ? Ofcourse not, because the words are god's words not the book as papers.. Exactly the Hadiths and Sunna, yes the life and teaching of prophet Muhammed (pbuh) has been written andf memorised by men, but it keeps what the prophet said, and we have to follow his teaching, because from the qiran alone we can't learn our religion, we have to understand it as the prophet explained it. peace.
bro qwerty, plz give yourself a chance to explore the issue of hadith further, your right, hadeeth is not all pure, that's why there are 4categories by which hadith is classified: sound,good,weak,and fabricated. personally i don't take any hadith into consideration except if it's sound or good. dismissing hadith all togher simply shows that one knows NOTHING about the meticulous process by which hadith is compiled and put together,
...for example if a person is cought lying even once and about the simplest of matters, the hadith he claims to have heard from the prophet whould simply not be accepted or it would go under the fabricated and weak categories, whereistruth & others just like to come here and mislead pple, everyone, plz don't listen to them and do your own homework
the camel analogy is an oversimplification, simply becoz it has nothing to do with making you a better or worse person, and is incomparable to the prophet's teachings of behaviour and conduct as a muslim, u might see some ppl who like to dress like the prophet for example just as a sign of love, but has nothing to do with hadith argument
I wanted to ask about how it can be ascertained whether some statement in the Qur'an is taken to be an order, and made mandatory, or just a guideline which would be good to follow, but still optional? An example that comes to mind would be the verse that refers to disciplining one's wife. I take it that that verse is not seen to be making the three steps outlined there mandatory.*
It wouldn't be a sin not to follow it, even though it seems to be put forward as an order (or perhaps "request" :S). The verses concerning hijab are similar in this regard, it seems. Or is there a difference in the way it is worded, differentiating between a guideline and an order.
Salaam Bro, Good question. Essentially the verse you mentioned is in regards women who are being unfaithful to her husband. This therefore is not mandatory on all women but those that are unfaithful, the method given to deal with this situation is from God. Whether this method is the only method can be determined by the context: "Tell the Believers..", or an explanation given by Muhammad (pbuh) in the Hadith. Hope that helps. Salaam, fot
I understand that the guideline spelled out is only under the condition of an unfaithful wife. But, say this condition was fulfilled for me, but I didn't follow through all the guidelines in the Qur'an. Instead, when talking to my wife didn't work, I just kept talking.*
*Would that be considered a sin then, not going to the next step as the Qur'an prescribes? I somehow find it strange that it would be a sin, if it indeed is. I believe WhereIsTruth is of a similar view concerning the "hijab verses," though one slightly harder to defend it seems, in WhereIsTruth's case.
This is exactly why the Messenger's explanation of the Message (16:44, 16:46) is essential, the Athentic Hadith. To deny that is to apply basically your own idea of what is or is not a sin, Or what is or is not needed to be followed from the Quran. Thats claiming to know what God wants better than the one given the Message to Explain. So WhereIsTruth ends up denying 5xPrayer, Wudu, Facing Kaba, that I believe is misguided as an approach. Peace, fot
Brother, WhereIsTruth isn't muslim, she is Yehwa Witness, she doesn't even believe in Qur'an, she fools us - muslims - to spread her devil ideas. Ofcourse she denies everything, just to confuse the new muslims.
Iam sure that WhereIsTruth sdoesn't even believe in Quran as God's word, she just claim that front Muslims, to spread her ugly ideas and to lead the new muslims to doubts about Islam, ofcourse she can't do that because Muslims aren't retarded like her (as her daughter said) ,
I responded to her video about denying Hijab, and she deleted them after I gave her proofs from Qur'an itself about obeying the prophet and what he says is as what God says, but she is "Yehwa Witness" who tried to hide his/her ugly face.
i just wanted you to know...when my daughter says "we are still retarded" she doesn't mean we are retarded...she was saying it is retarded to fight. ;)~ she is spunky. as you can tell, she is not really in special-ed classes. lol
I hadnt realised that PseudoCloud was your daughter. I didnt take it personally, I just assumed she was someone who taught in special ed classes. A sincere discussion means facing all the points of view, in facing these views and disagreeing or agreeing, one never has to fight. Talking is enough. Peace, fot
First and foremost, I would like to compliment you on wonderful video. Secondly I will say my mother WhereIsTruth has made fair points too. It is of my opinion though that this seems endless. Hijab or not, it really seems to hold no difference to me. I may be presumptuous in saying this, but I honestly doubt I am the only one with far greater things to repent for than whether I wore a hijab or I prayed the exact right amount of times each day.
I know, when judgment comes He will not look upon me and ask "Micayla why on the 21st of April 2007 did you not pray to me five times, at the specified times?" I also find it hard to believe His first question to me will consist of something such as "Where's your hijab?"
All and all this really is just cultural difference. In all due respect really rather pointless. Take notice, it is mentioned twice in the Qur'an whereas everything else...time and time again.
I agree with you in that there are greater things, but WhereIsTruth has also denied the wudu, the formal prayer and facing the Kaba when praying, according to her understanding. This issue is simply the beginning of the slippery slope to a doityourself Islam. Hence the need for a response. Peace, fot
Who knows what God will ask us That Day and what little thing will swing the balance. We pray for Forgiveness. That the covering is mentioned twice specifically in the Quran does not mean that you can pick and choose as to it being a requirement from God. I understand that Sisters need to decide when they feel ready to adopt the Hijab but to deny it is another thing entirely. Peace, fot
All prayer should be earnest and from the heart. The outward manifestation of your inner belief is required by God, in manners, dress and conduct. I respect and love all of My Sisters, and their right to feel ready or not to wear Hijab. I also love All of my Sisters enough to tell them what God has told them in the Quran. No-one, least of all me has ever said "Wheres your hijab". Peace, fot
thank you so much for being thoughtful and explaining things so nicely. yes i do agree that Allah wants us to cover...but i have translations that don't say use your headcovering...the ones i quoted in the video. it seems to be up for debate even amongst the translators. i will have to continue....one moment.
so anyway, i'm sure that since the women of that time and place wore headcovering to protect them from the sun of the desert, Allah asked them to use this headcovering to cover their bosom. however, for those who live in a time or place where there is no need for this type of headcovering...we can dress modestly for our era and be pleasing to the Most Merciful. one moment...
If covering your hair was an issue, and it was important to Allah, he would have been more specific since this would be a Holy Writing for all times and places and cultures. i do not think there is anything wrong with a woman wearing a hijab, i also don't think their is anything wrong with not wearing one either. my belief, although i respectfully know it is not yours, is that the real issue is dressing modestly. one more moment please
As regard to prayer. the Quran does say five times a day at one scripture but just mentions the two ends of the day at another. one time he mentions that the mid day prayer is important...Allah mentions different amounts of prayer because it is not a ritual...he is just reminding us to pray more often. one more moment...thank you for your patience
also, the God of Abraham made it clear in the First Revelation...which the Quran verifies to be true...that he does not like repiticious prayers...nor should you be just mentioning Muhammad in your prayers since the Quran makes it quite clear one prophet should not be put above another. the type of praying done in the religion called Islam, according to my understanding of the True God's Revelations, and my belief, is not correct. but you can certainly worship Allah as you like.
i have to say, some of those who are the nicest to me our my Muslim friend...but also, some of those who are the harshest and most unkind are those claiming to be Muslims too. it seems as if i'm dealing with people from two different religions sometimes. ;) i'm sorry to be taking up so much space but i have just a little more to say...i am quite long winded sometimes...lol
anyway, the Quran and the Bible belong to Allah, not to any particular religion. i have the same right to worship Allah and talk about Him and spread my beliefs as any other. i do feel strongly though that Allah has told us to spread the Truth to others...and i truly believe the things i am saying...it's alright if you don't believe as i do...and it's alright if i don't believe as you do...Allah will sort it out in the end :)
So, i want to thank you for your concern for me...and also explaining things to me in such a kind way. May Allah bless you and your family with nothing but peace dear friend. The Most Merciful is our Great God...All praise to Allah.
i thought it was very sweet how you were humble enough to demonstrate how to wear a hijab...may Allah bless you, and reward you and your family with the inheritance of Bliss. :)
JazakhumAllahKhairun. I feel totally humbled by my Sisters when they strive to obey God by wearing the Hijab. May God guide us always closer to His Truth. Ameen. Salaam, fot
If God says in Quran 2:2 "This is the Book; in it is guidance sure, without doubt, to those who fear Allah." How can you be "sure" that the Hijab verses were for the women of that time? What are you basing that sureness upon? What and Who's criteria are you using to determine modesty? I dont understand. Peace, fot
The term Khimar is specific. There is no other understanding for that term. The Hijab is not a cultural requirement but a religious one that the Quran specifically mentions. I agree, the issue is to dress modestly but according to God's criteria and not our own culturally determined (and therefore changing) criteria. Peace, fot
The OT & NT all refer to the method (bowing and prostrating) that has been used in the formal prayer. This has been continued with Islam as the Prophet has shown us. The Salah/Prayer is the 2nd pillar of Islam and almost no-one ever has understood it to be other than 5x a day in the manner that the Prophet prayed. Muslims supplicate every second, the formal prayer is to make time to physically submit as well as in the heart. Peace, fot
The Quran is the Criteron so corrects the errors that have come into the older scriptures, it does not require Muslims to acccept them. No Muslim prays to Muhammad (pbuh) in the prayer but prays FOR Muhammad and Ibrahim (pbut) and their families as we pray for our parents and other Muslims. We can only Worship God as he revealed to us to worship Him. Not by any other method i.e drum-banging, dancing, human-sacrifice are not valid as forms of worship. Peace, fot
I agree that people can be harsh or gentle, dont blame their understanding of the religion, but pray for them. I am enjoying our conversation. peace, fot
I agree that the Scripture belongs to God. I agree that you may believe what you do and that you should then tell others. I also believe that you are mistaken in some of your ideas (especially regarding the Hadith) and I also wish to help others get the fuller picture. God will sort it out in the end, but we have a responsibility now to give the Truth to others. Peace, fot
The guy who calls himself "WhereIsTruth" is just a coward like any other Yehwa witneses... I responded to his comments on his video about Hijab, then he deleted them because he just can't response on them. He deny the Sunna although I quoted from Qur'an that we have to follow Muhammed and not only the quran. Then he claimed that Muhammed has to be followed while he was alive, but not anymore after his death Lol, he claims Muhammed has been sent only to recite the qur'an
and all what he did in his life just nothing, anything the prophet said is nothing and meanless, only what we find in the quran we suppose to take, and the sunna is just human made, he is very ignorant, beside he is fabricating a religion by taking bible and quran, he doesn't really believe in quran but he just claim that front muslims to spread his ugly ideas and let the new muslims have doubt about Islam.
It would also appear that video responses are the way to go too since they cannot be deleted (you have no idea how many comments of mine she actually deleted, the majority of which had Quranic ayats!). Selaam.
JIP...you know the real reason i deleted your comments...you slammed me with 12 comments. i told you that you were welcome to repost one or two at a time and give me a chance to respond. you are trying to make me look bad to everyone...Allah does not like that. you should not present a situation that is not true. not telling the whole story is similar to lying. you can respond to this if you want...but i will ignore it...i do not wish to fight.
People can post and you can respond as time allows. To delete a response that is not abusive only serves to make the person deleting the message seem to have something to hide. Just an opinion. Peace, fot
as i was trying to explain without going into details...there was more to it. i usually try to respond to everyone...but sometimes it just gets to be an argument. Allah doesn't want us fighting. and if some are reading who haven't read the Quran...it could stumble them into not reading it...if those who have are fighting. peace
I might actually buy that becky if you didn't also delete the comments on your part 4 video.
I know they were there for a couple of weeks before you finally deleted them. You also responded to them.
The ones I remember for sure are the ayat 16:98 about seeking refuge with shaytan before reading Quran, and 4:65 about the sunnah. I also know there were others.
Why did you delete those, there was absolutely no reason and no insult.
Also, in the hadith in which the Prophet tells his daughter that a women should cover everything but her face and hands he simply points to her face and hands. When a person points to your face, how do you know he is not pointing to your entire head?
fopower 1 year ago
@fopower Thanks for this thoughtful comment also. What you seem to be saying is that Asma didnt not understand what was being said to her and then she conveyed it with this misunderstanding. This is problematic as this makes explainer/clarifier of the Quran (Muhammad - saw) unable to portray the meaning of the Quran and all the people of Asmas' time unable to understand the "true" meaning of whatever the Messenger said to them?
See: 16:44, 16:64, 5:92, 4:59, 59:7, 4:65, 3:31, 4:80 etc etc etc.
thefotfoundation 1 year ago
@fopower
I believe that Muhammad (pbuh) was clear in his explanation of the Quran and he was understood by the people of his time (especially the great women).
To imply that 'Asma maybe didnt know what her Father meant so I dont know what he meant' is not to say anything at all.
"He who obeys the Messenger, obeys Allah; but if any turn away, We have not sent thee to watch over their (evil deeds)." Quran 4: 80.
May God guide us all always closer to His Truth. Ameen.
fot
thefotfoundation 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@thefotfoundation Sir, Muslims claim, that Allah is the God of the Bible and Islam arose from the religion of the prophets and apostles, but this is refuted by solid, overwhelming archeological evidence. Idol statues are in hand proving Allah was a pagan 'moon-god' in pre-Islamic times. Islam symbol is the crescent moon! Why is the crescent moon atop mosques and minarets, and on the flags of Islam? Why do Muslims fast during the month that begins and ends with the crescent moon in the sky?
kevinmelvillesimpson 1 year ago
as a muslim sister I respect your opinion on this. However I do not appreciate that this is the only opinion that islamic scholars and imams have decided to listen to and convey.
The fact the women already were wearing the "khimars" on their heads indicates that this was a cultural practice- the passage in the Quran simply tells them to cover their breasts- the importance of covering their heads is not discussed.
fopower 1 year ago
@fopower Thank you for your comment Sister.
You say that the Quran "simply tells them [women] to cover their breasts".
This is inaccurate. The Quran says "walyadribna" the khimar to cover the chest. "walyadribna " means to draw, this of course can not be interpreted as you have, as first the khimar must be removed from the head.
Also, that the khimar IS a head-covering means that when the Quran is using the word "khimar" then head-covering is actually being discussed.
thefotfoundation 1 year ago
Haha forgot to mention a Muslim brother in hijab is sorta amusing
SumayahsIslam 2 years ago
;-P
thefotfoundation 2 years ago
I've really come to appreciate the methodological and educated way you present Islam. I'm a hijab-wearer personally and many Muslims I know do say that it is not mandatory. I'll forward your video to them.
SumayahsIslam 2 years ago
JazakhumAllahuKhairun Ukhti, for your kind words.
Salaam, fot
thefotfoundation 2 years ago
salam alikum brother , thank you very much about your hijab viedio , it is really perfectly expl. you are the first who really give me an exlelent explanation about the hijab matter . Im quite shockt about some comments at youtube about your vidio. Question is face cover niquab good or bad ? I wish to wear niqab to cover my face . But people say this is haram and just causes me problems in australia, i just want know for shure do i need niquab or not ? Thanks Tanya (convert muslimah)
widdigroemerstrasse 2 years ago
WaAlaykumAsSalaam Ukhti,
JazakhumAllahKhairun for you comment. The issue regarding the Hijab is quite clear as you saw.
The niqaab is a disputed issue and although there are differing views most Scholars say that it is not obligatory (no sin if you dont wear it) but it definitely is good (reward if you do wear it).
That said my wife doesnt wear it but does on occasions e.g. wearing make-up and is on her way to a Sisters party.
Best to ask a Scholar for specific advice.
Salaam, fot
thefotfoundation 2 years ago
Peace
Whether Khimr = headscarf or veil is not the point Quran says use this garment to cover CHEST (& not HEAD.)
Consider statement ;Use your toothbrush to clean your shoes. I am not asking you to brush your teeth but to clean your shoes despite using a "toothbrush".
Allah will judge us on what we dispute. Let us all sincerely seek and ask to be shown the TRUTH. Allah knows best
timetothink01 2 years ago 2
Peace, Thanks for the thoughtful comment. However there is an issue in your analysis.
The Quran doesnt say "use the Khimar" to cover your chest it says "walyadribna the khimar" to cover the chest. "walyadribna " means to draw, this of course can not be interpreted as you have, as removed from the head.
The Khimar (head scarf) is to be drawn over (walyadribna ) the chest, not removed from the head and used to cover the chest instead.
thefotfoundation 2 years ago
this guy is a liar, the quran clearly states everything including prayers and zakah and sawm
the quran also repeats that it is sufficient as a guide
jigglyfidda125 2 years ago
Aha u are mohammadian ?
GA937 2 years ago
Is that a statement or a question? That you knowingly use derogatory terms to describe others is to your detriment.
thefotfoundation 2 years ago
As salamu aleykum; barakaLLah feek...I don't think I could stay so cool and friendly about it (I've tried reasoning with her too) This kind of misguidance has to be fought cause it's all together dangerous as they (quranites: wich of course she denied to be) try and distort so many aspects of the deen. Keep it up for the sake of those who might fall into that trap.
ummubasma 3 years ago 4
good job brother!i feel better and more beauty in Hijab.
diekaNr 3 years ago
JazakhumAllahKahirun. Salaam, fot
thefotfoundation 3 years ago
This video try to proof the invented hijab as head covering which is not in Quran because prophet was given the book to explain their differences with the book and not other than book like arabwoman etc...24:31 allah is asking to cover up lady, starting over shoulder which was supprted by 33:59 jilbab mean gown over shoulder...
text41 4 years ago
text41, your points are a little vague. Aside from denying the hadith, accusing me of trying to mislead people, mis-using the Quran and slandering Aisha (RA), the rest of your points arent clear. Please clarify. Peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
interesting video, in my last comment i ahve told that you could not bring head covering over the chest where as allah is asking in the same aya over juyubehinna....
and you had to show other verse 33:59 which is again a cloth over shoulder...finally you had to combine these two ayats to stablish your interpretation...
text41 4 years ago
in this video it has been said that " i am going to use quran and not said going to show from Quran...ofcourse you have used very well the quran to tell your concept which is of arabwoman's concept and not based on anyquranic ayat....how can it be, while u said u r going to use quran to show hijab of arab woman and not of quranic ayat based .
text41 4 years ago
secondly in video is said about denying hadeece of prophet saw, i dont know which book he is reffering as "prophet hadeese" where as i have heard about hadeese of bukhari muslim and etc....but this is new for me that prophet or anyone of his companion has written any book in the name of haqdeece of prophet saw used to explain quran.....would u plz tell which is the hadith book of prophet saw?
text41 4 years ago
interesting video in it discussed many points so i take one by one 1-quoted 16:44, 64
16:64 here Allah has sent book only to explain the differences...meaning difference are made clear with books i.e with ayats of books. and not written that one part is written some where else in books other than quran which he called hadeese....anyway this is your interpritation and not written in the aya and seems that realy trying to misguide people ...
text41 4 years ago
Muslm girl here, don't wear Hijab never will ;-))All i'm gonna say is that if you feel the need to accept hadiths then do so,but do know that God knows what is inside of each of us.hadiths are extremely chauvinistic and biased and downright stupid,i wonder what motivates people,specifically men,to embrace them as inspired by God?why eh? Well,Hijab is clearly not in Quran for me.
cinemanerd 4 years ago
You dont have to do anything you dont want to. I dont "feel the need", the Quran itself teaches Muslims to follow the Messengers explanation of the Quran = Hadith. This is your answer to why Muslims accept hadith as inspired.
"what motivates people,specifically men"? By far the largest teacher of Hadith from the Messenger was a woman, Aisha (ra)?!
"Hijab is clearly not in Quran for me". The opposite is clearly demonstrable. The Hadith clarify this which is why you need to deny them. Peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
thefotfoundation ..Quran has this word in 39:23 which reffered as the book of Allah and not books written by people after 200 years departure of messenger of Allah in the name of word hadith. that is why people are giving deifferent logics tp proove their books as prophet saying and giving name as hadith of prophet saw,as u tried to give for hijab which is not in quran,
which book do u have? written by Hazrat aisha? have ? plz tell ne too the name or u r also destorting her personality?
text41 4 years ago
One thing that confuses and angers me is how some muslims can come to a conclusion about deen that is completely contrary to what has already been established in deen and run with it, while it never crosses their minds that how come they came to that conclusion when no one else has, even the prophet himself? I think they believe they understand deen better than rasulullah (saw) authu billah!
orenishii28 4 years ago
slaghfirullah there are many of these ignorant people, it's a shame :(
inshaAllah they will be forgiven.
psf1busta 4 years ago
Did you know that you guys used to be praying facing Jerusalem instead of Mecca?And did you know that your religion was started by Jews that lived and befriended by Muhamad your imam since he wasn't educated whatsoever?
FOTOFOTA 4 years ago
you r talking right but the deen in quran doesnot say that muslim of allah ever faced jerusalam because first hous of allah is kaaba having muqame ibrahim....
text41 4 years ago
From the beginning for a longest time this facing towards Jerusalem was the traditional way but here was a dispute and anger towards the Jewish State then those Mullahs decided on their own that facing towards mecca was solving this problem.What came out of it was every non-muslims would be exterminated, according to your koran.
FOTOFOTA 4 years ago
muslim of allah as per quran has never faced jerusalam because as per quran kaba exists since day one that is why there was no need to face jerusalam.
text41 4 years ago
I quess that you got a very limited knowledge your own history my friend!
FOTOFOTA 4 years ago
Fotofota...this facing is mentioned in history of such people who donot know quran and prophet through Quran..quran has 3:96 here awal the first house adress is given which is that which has muqame ibrahim and muqame ibrahim is in kaba...as per quran no muslim never faced jerusalam...
text41 4 years ago
text41, Although fotofota has the historical reason behind the change of the Qiblah from Jerusalem to the Ka'ba entirely wrong (as I would expect) the event did actually occur. Read Quran 2:144-145. Peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
lol cute mashaAllah jazak ALlah khyr for the demonstration! when u said u were gonna demonstrate i had in mind some really pink frilly sequined beaded girly looking hijab! hahahaha! but Alhamdulilah that was not the case or i might have fell of the chair laughing and not listen to the rest of th vid :-D
RabiaAhmed 4 years ago
lol, barakhAllahFi My Sister. Salaam, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
mashallah Brother, this video truly did help me in terms of understanding the hijab in the quran. May Allah keep you and bless us all to gain knowledge.
ali
blkhatpersian 4 years ago
SALAMU ALAIKUM BROTHER
I am so glad Ive found ur channel
thanx to brother swordfishabe
GREAT VIDEO BY THE WAY
JAALIUS 4 years ago
Wa'AlaykumAsalaam. JazakhumAllahKhairun Bro. Salaam, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
the camel analogy is an oversimplification, simply becoz it has nothing to do with making you a better or worse person, and is incomparable to the prophet's teachings of behaviour and conduct as a muslim, u might see some ppl who like to dress like the prophet for example just as a sign of love, but has nothing to do with hadith argument
predental 4 years ago
the hadeeth was written by men though. God says he will guard the Koran and the wisdom of it. the wisdom of it is the traditions that are past down. but that doesn't mean that hadeeth is pure and is preserved. in the Koran it says that his example is left for us. this is for the people of that time. otherwise i would have to buy a camel instead of a car to follow the lifestyle of the prophet. God bless.
qwertyfshag 4 years ago
The qur'an has been written by men, does that make the qur'an human made ? Ofcourse not, because the words are god's words not the book as papers.. Exactly the Hadiths and Sunna, yes the life and teaching of prophet Muhammed (pbuh) has been written andf memorised by men, but it keeps what the prophet said, and we have to follow his teaching, because from the qiran alone we can't learn our religion, we have to understand it as the prophet explained it. peace.
TomiTom1234 4 years ago
bro qwerty, plz give yourself a chance to explore the issue of hadith further, your right, hadeeth is not all pure, that's why there are 4categories by which hadith is classified: sound,good,weak,and fabricated. personally i don't take any hadith into consideration except if it's sound or good. dismissing hadith all togher simply shows that one knows NOTHING about the meticulous process by which hadith is compiled and put together,
predental 4 years ago
...for example if a person is cought lying even once and about the simplest of matters, the hadith he claims to have heard from the prophet whould simply not be accepted or it would go under the fabricated and weak categories, whereistruth & others just like to come here and mislead pple, everyone, plz don't listen to them and do your own homework
predental 4 years ago
the camel analogy is an oversimplification, simply becoz it has nothing to do with making you a better or worse person, and is incomparable to the prophet's teachings of behaviour and conduct as a muslim, u might see some ppl who like to dress like the prophet for example just as a sign of love, but has nothing to do with hadith argument
predental 4 years ago
Hey fot, great video.
I wanted to ask about how it can be ascertained whether some statement in the Qur'an is taken to be an order, and made mandatory, or just a guideline which would be good to follow, but still optional? An example that comes to mind would be the verse that refers to disciplining one's wife. I take it that that verse is not seen to be making the three steps outlined there mandatory.*
ehsanul 4 years ago
It wouldn't be a sin not to follow it, even though it seems to be put forward as an order (or perhaps "request" :S). The verses concerning hijab are similar in this regard, it seems. Or is there a difference in the way it is worded, differentiating between a guideline and an order.
ehsanul 4 years ago
Salaam Bro, Good question. Essentially the verse you mentioned is in regards women who are being unfaithful to her husband. This therefore is not mandatory on all women but those that are unfaithful, the method given to deal with this situation is from God. Whether this method is the only method can be determined by the context: "Tell the Believers..", or an explanation given by Muhammad (pbuh) in the Hadith. Hope that helps. Salaam, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
I understand that the guideline spelled out is only under the condition of an unfaithful wife. But, say this condition was fulfilled for me, but I didn't follow through all the guidelines in the Qur'an. Instead, when talking to my wife didn't work, I just kept talking.*
ehsanul 4 years ago
*Would that be considered a sin then, not going to the next step as the Qur'an prescribes? I somehow find it strange that it would be a sin, if it indeed is. I believe WhereIsTruth is of a similar view concerning the "hijab verses," though one slightly harder to defend it seems, in WhereIsTruth's case.
ehsanul 4 years ago
This is exactly why the Messenger's explanation of the Message (16:44, 16:46) is essential, the Athentic Hadith. To deny that is to apply basically your own idea of what is or is not a sin, Or what is or is not needed to be followed from the Quran. Thats claiming to know what God wants better than the one given the Message to Explain. So WhereIsTruth ends up denying 5xPrayer, Wudu, Facing Kaba, that I believe is misguided as an approach. Peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
Brother, WhereIsTruth isn't muslim, she is Yehwa Witness, she doesn't even believe in Qur'an, she fools us - muslims - to spread her devil ideas. Ofcourse she denies everything, just to confuse the new muslims.
TomiTom1234 4 years ago
Wow, you did very good job on this. Keep up the good work bro.
MuslimKid786 4 years ago 2
haha..deleted my coments too, just wanted to let everyone know, don't challenge whereistruth's views
predental 4 years ago
lol thats so funny.
I saw your comments (before they were deleted). They were positively brilliant and logical.
If Allah SWT ever asks us, I bear witness there was nothing insulting in your comments and you were not throwing "sand" in her face. Selaam.
JesusIsAProphet 4 years ago
well brother, i am just glad that she describes herself as "not a muslim" cuz denying all these things is obviously denying Islam as a whole
predental 4 years ago
Iam sure that WhereIsTruth sdoesn't even believe in Quran as God's word, she just claim that front Muslims, to spread her ugly ideas and to lead the new muslims to doubts about Islam, ofcourse she can't do that because Muslims aren't retarded like her (as her daughter said) ,
TomiTom1234 4 years ago
I responded to her video about denying Hijab, and she deleted them after I gave her proofs from Qur'an itself about obeying the prophet and what he says is as what God says, but she is "Yehwa Witness" who tried to hide his/her ugly face.
TomiTom1234 4 years ago
To lighten this all up, and put it simply.
'Arguing on the internet is kinda like competing in the special Olympics, even if you win, your still retarded.'
hehehehehe.
seriously...your fighting about...well...a scarf.
haha. no offense.
especially to retards, I really quite enjoy your company in my special ed classes.
hehe.
Peace and Love homie.
PseudoCloud 4 years ago
This is not a fight but an exchange of views. I hope you continue to enjoy your special ed classes. Peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
i just wanted you to know...when my daughter says "we are still retarded" she doesn't mean we are retarded...she was saying it is retarded to fight. ;)~ she is spunky. as you can tell, she is not really in special-ed classes. lol
WhereIsTruth 4 years ago
I hadnt realised that PseudoCloud was your daughter. I didnt take it personally, I just assumed she was someone who taught in special ed classes. A sincere discussion means facing all the points of view, in facing these views and disagreeing or agreeing, one never has to fight. Talking is enough. Peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
I agree :)
WhereIsTruth 4 years ago
First and foremost, I would like to compliment you on wonderful video. Secondly I will say my mother WhereIsTruth has made fair points too. It is of my opinion though that this seems endless. Hijab or not, it really seems to hold no difference to me. I may be presumptuous in saying this, but I honestly doubt I am the only one with far greater things to repent for than whether I wore a hijab or I prayed the exact right amount of times each day.
PseudoCloud 4 years ago
I know, when judgment comes He will not look upon me and ask "Micayla why on the 21st of April 2007 did you not pray to me five times, at the specified times?" I also find it hard to believe His first question to me will consist of something such as "Where's your hijab?"
All and all this really is just cultural difference. In all due respect really rather pointless. Take notice, it is mentioned twice in the Qur'an whereas everything else...time and time again.
Am I wrong?
PseudoCloud 4 years ago
I feel, you should pray, earnestly from the heart. At all times, when you are happy, sad, or scared. That should be enough.
I respect completely whomever chooses to take the hijab. I ask only for the same respect for choosing not to.
I mean honestly..."Wheres your hijab?"...come on folks.
Peace and Love.
PseudoCloud 4 years ago
I agree with you in that there are greater things, but WhereIsTruth has also denied the wudu, the formal prayer and facing the Kaba when praying, according to her understanding. This issue is simply the beginning of the slippery slope to a doityourself Islam. Hence the need for a response. Peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
Who knows what God will ask us That Day and what little thing will swing the balance. We pray for Forgiveness. That the covering is mentioned twice specifically in the Quran does not mean that you can pick and choose as to it being a requirement from God. I understand that Sisters need to decide when they feel ready to adopt the Hijab but to deny it is another thing entirely. Peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
All prayer should be earnest and from the heart. The outward manifestation of your inner belief is required by God, in manners, dress and conduct. I respect and love all of My Sisters, and their right to feel ready or not to wear Hijab. I also love All of my Sisters enough to tell them what God has told them in the Quran. No-one, least of all me has ever said "Wheres your hijab". Peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
dear brother,
thank you so much for being thoughtful and explaining things so nicely. yes i do agree that Allah wants us to cover...but i have translations that don't say use your headcovering...the ones i quoted in the video. it seems to be up for debate even amongst the translators. i will have to continue....one moment.
WhereIsTruth 4 years ago
so anyway, i'm sure that since the women of that time and place wore headcovering to protect them from the sun of the desert, Allah asked them to use this headcovering to cover their bosom. however, for those who live in a time or place where there is no need for this type of headcovering...we can dress modestly for our era and be pleasing to the Most Merciful. one moment...
WhereIsTruth 4 years ago
If covering your hair was an issue, and it was important to Allah, he would have been more specific since this would be a Holy Writing for all times and places and cultures. i do not think there is anything wrong with a woman wearing a hijab, i also don't think their is anything wrong with not wearing one either. my belief, although i respectfully know it is not yours, is that the real issue is dressing modestly. one more moment please
WhereIsTruth 4 years ago
As regard to prayer. the Quran does say five times a day at one scripture but just mentions the two ends of the day at another. one time he mentions that the mid day prayer is important...Allah mentions different amounts of prayer because it is not a ritual...he is just reminding us to pray more often. one more moment...thank you for your patience
WhereIsTruth 4 years ago
also, the God of Abraham made it clear in the First Revelation...which the Quran verifies to be true...that he does not like repiticious prayers...nor should you be just mentioning Muhammad in your prayers since the Quran makes it quite clear one prophet should not be put above another. the type of praying done in the religion called Islam, according to my understanding of the True God's Revelations, and my belief, is not correct. but you can certainly worship Allah as you like.
WhereIsTruth 4 years ago
i have to say, some of those who are the nicest to me our my Muslim friend...but also, some of those who are the harshest and most unkind are those claiming to be Muslims too. it seems as if i'm dealing with people from two different religions sometimes. ;) i'm sorry to be taking up so much space but i have just a little more to say...i am quite long winded sometimes...lol
WhereIsTruth 4 years ago
anyway, the Quran and the Bible belong to Allah, not to any particular religion. i have the same right to worship Allah and talk about Him and spread my beliefs as any other. i do feel strongly though that Allah has told us to spread the Truth to others...and i truly believe the things i am saying...it's alright if you don't believe as i do...and it's alright if i don't believe as you do...Allah will sort it out in the end :)
WhereIsTruth 4 years ago
So, i want to thank you for your concern for me...and also explaining things to me in such a kind way. May Allah bless you and your family with nothing but peace dear friend. The Most Merciful is our Great God...All praise to Allah.
WhereIsTruth 4 years ago
mashallah you have weird reasoning. :)
AsifEminem 4 years ago
i know Asif,
lollllllll
WhereIsTruth 4 years ago
one additional thing, dear brother.
i thought it was very sweet how you were humble enough to demonstrate how to wear a hijab...may Allah bless you, and reward you and your family with the inheritance of Bliss. :)
WhereIsTruth 4 years ago
JazakhumAllahKhairun. I feel totally humbled by my Sisters when they strive to obey God by wearing the Hijab. May God guide us always closer to His Truth. Ameen. Salaam, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
If God says in Quran 2:2 "This is the Book; in it is guidance sure, without doubt, to those who fear Allah." How can you be "sure" that the Hijab verses were for the women of that time? What are you basing that sureness upon? What and Who's criteria are you using to determine modesty? I dont understand. Peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
The term Khimar is specific. There is no other understanding for that term. The Hijab is not a cultural requirement but a religious one that the Quran specifically mentions. I agree, the issue is to dress modestly but according to God's criteria and not our own culturally determined (and therefore changing) criteria. Peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
The OT & NT all refer to the method (bowing and prostrating) that has been used in the formal prayer. This has been continued with Islam as the Prophet has shown us. The Salah/Prayer is the 2nd pillar of Islam and almost no-one ever has understood it to be other than 5x a day in the manner that the Prophet prayed. Muslims supplicate every second, the formal prayer is to make time to physically submit as well as in the heart. Peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
The Quran is the Criteron so corrects the errors that have come into the older scriptures, it does not require Muslims to acccept them. No Muslim prays to Muhammad (pbuh) in the prayer but prays FOR Muhammad and Ibrahim (pbut) and their families as we pray for our parents and other Muslims. We can only Worship God as he revealed to us to worship Him. Not by any other method i.e drum-banging, dancing, human-sacrifice are not valid as forms of worship. Peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
I agree that people can be harsh or gentle, dont blame their understanding of the religion, but pray for them. I am enjoying our conversation. peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
I agree that the Scripture belongs to God. I agree that you may believe what you do and that you should then tell others. I also believe that you are mistaken in some of your ideas (especially regarding the Hadith) and I also wish to help others get the fuller picture. God will sort it out in the end, but we have a responsibility now to give the Truth to others. Peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
Thank you for your kind words. May God guide us all always closer to His Truth. Ameen. Peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
The guy who calls himself "WhereIsTruth" is just a coward like any other Yehwa witneses... I responded to his comments on his video about Hijab, then he deleted them because he just can't response on them. He deny the Sunna although I quoted from Qur'an that we have to follow Muhammed and not only the quran. Then he claimed that Muhammed has to be followed while he was alive, but not anymore after his death Lol, he claims Muhammed has been sent only to recite the qur'an
TomiTom1234 4 years ago
and all what he did in his life just nothing, anything the prophet said is nothing and meanless, only what we find in the quran we suppose to take, and the sunna is just human made, he is very ignorant, beside he is fabricating a religion by taking bible and quran, he doesn't really believe in quran but he just claim that front muslims to spread his ugly ideas and let the new muslims have doubt about Islam.
TomiTom1234 4 years ago
I gave him many proofs to destroy his ideas and fabricated religion, but he deleted them just to not show himself as a defeated ugly Yehwa witness.
TomiTom1234 4 years ago
mash'Allah brother. Awesome response.
It would also appear that video responses are the way to go too since they cannot be deleted (you have no idea how many comments of mine she actually deleted, the majority of which had Quranic ayats!). Selaam.
JesusIsAProphet 4 years ago
did I forget to mention that it was fun to watch too? LOL.
It's nice to see a brother willing to don the hijab for a good cause
JesusIsAProphet 4 years ago
lol, I think I might have started a trend. Salaam, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
JIP...you know the real reason i deleted your comments...you slammed me with 12 comments. i told you that you were welcome to repost one or two at a time and give me a chance to respond. you are trying to make me look bad to everyone...Allah does not like that. you should not present a situation that is not true. not telling the whole story is similar to lying. you can respond to this if you want...but i will ignore it...i do not wish to fight.
WhereIsTruth 4 years ago
People can post and you can respond as time allows. To delete a response that is not abusive only serves to make the person deleting the message seem to have something to hide. Just an opinion. Peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
thanks for the advise fot,
as i was trying to explain without going into details...there was more to it. i usually try to respond to everyone...but sometimes it just gets to be an argument. Allah doesn't want us fighting. and if some are reading who haven't read the Quran...it could stumble them into not reading it...if those who have are fighting. peace
WhereIsTruth 4 years ago
I might actually buy that becky if you didn't also delete the comments on your part 4 video.
I know they were there for a couple of weeks before you finally deleted them. You also responded to them.
The ones I remember for sure are the ayat 16:98 about seeking refuge with shaytan before reading Quran, and 4:65 about the sunnah. I also know there were others.
Why did you delete those, there was absolutely no reason and no insult.
JesusIsAProphet 4 years ago
oops, i meant so say seeking refuge with Allah from shaytan!
authu billah!
JesusIsAProphet 4 years ago
excelent bro, i wouldn't have wrote my comment if i knew u were going to make that excellent response jaazak Allah khair, may Allah reward u
predental 4 years ago
i LOVE THIS VIDEO BROTHER 500 STARS
vittorio203 4 years ago
Salaam Bro. I saw your excellent response and then watched the video you responded to. I thoght I would join with you in video agreement. Salaam, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
aww now i want one of those hijabs!
AsifEminem 4 years ago
btw bro you looked like Monty Panesar ha ha!
AsifEminem 4 years ago
lol, Monttyyyy. JazakhuAllahKhairun Bro. Salaam, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
LOL, i was wondering why the icon for the video looked strange. Anyway good video and well explained.
OneMJDN 4 years ago
lol, JazakhumAllahKhairun Bro. Salaam, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
salam plz watch my video too to understand quranic hijab besides this other than quran hijab...salam
text41 4 years ago