i honestly understand toumas and not wanting to sing..i mean personally from my standpoint as a keyboardist (and playing this song and singing in front of people no less) not only is it incredibly uncomfortable if you don't like singing in the first place, but trying to do this and play a keyboard..seems harder than a guitarist singing :l. But he does sound good and i wish he would sing more often than he does, as annoying as it can be to do :)
too bad tuomas doesn't like to sing, he has a great voice! i love tarja's voice but i don't like how she almost shouted the last part in this song..... but she's still the best
I love how Tarja seems amused at how uncomfortable Tuomas is with singing....I bet that was what he meant in the letter about them not being close anymore :(
Tarja's not in the band because of her attitude it was a band decision not just Tuomas's. I really wish people would stop bickering about who's better, it's old.
@NightwishIsLove Her attitude? i think you have to see Tarja's letter and Marcelo's answers before you say that, I respect your comment, this is just my opinion. Sometimes love can make us take bad decisions...
@VladimirxGolshmidt indeed, there was no such thing as her attitude. THERE WERE ALL INVOLVED, already having some differences. and when Tarja told them she was gonna leave the band after the next album... they decided to kick her ass out first :) so all the stuff with money and no respect for fans were just fairytaled excuses :))
If you can't tell the difference between Tarja and Anette, you are either deaf, ignorant or retarded... Anette will never be able to perform this well. The guys made the biggest mistake of their lives when they decided to fire Tarja.
Sorry, I'm writing the same stuff again, but how could someone think this is Annette? OMG! When you don't SEE it's Tarja you have to HEAR! At least Annette is never dressed like that. She always wears short dresses and skirts. this MUST be Tarja! And it is Tarja!
Uh, wow. Just wow. Anette has never sang Beauty and the Beast live for one thing. Another, as pointed out, this video was from 2000. Anette was hired 2007. Also, an idiot could tell this is Tarja, especially with how high she is singing. Anette belts, she doesn't sing classically. A Nightwish fan would know that. And look at 1:38 if you aren't convinced: you would have to be BLIND, completely BLIND and stupid not to see that that is Tarja Turunen, not Anette Olzon.
I think that person is a retard, wasdoomed. I have only been a Nightwish fan for a year and a half, and I even know the difference between Anette and Tarja.
just wondering, is Tuomas the one singing in the recorded version, or is it a guest singer? sorry if this seems like a dumb question. But like my mom always says, there are no stupid questions. Only stupid people.
There are two recorded versions, one on Angels Fall First, where Tuomas sings and one on From Wishes to Eternity, where Tony Kakko from Sonata Arctica sings.
TUOMAS was born to do what he is doing now...........nothing more nothing less!!!!!! I don't care if he sings good or not.................in my ears he sounds perfect!!!!!!!!:D
sei un vecchio cafone dico davvero :) che minchia vieni a sentirti questa band qundo non ne capisci un cazzo... you're so stupid... with love ovviamente <3
Ho nice!! So great memories!!! I was just in front of the stage this night!! :)
MissVilaine 1 month ago
i honestly understand toumas and not wanting to sing..i mean personally from my standpoint as a keyboardist (and playing this song and singing in front of people no less) not only is it incredibly uncomfortable if you don't like singing in the first place, but trying to do this and play a keyboard..seems harder than a guitarist singing :l. But he does sound good and i wish he would sing more often than he does, as annoying as it can be to do :)
evilass334 1 month ago 2
I don't think the people watching Tuomas sing actually realize they've encountered one of the rarest things to happen in the history of Nightwish.
nintendude7cubed 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos 3
too bad tuomas doesn't like to sing, he has a great voice! i love tarja's voice but i don't like how she almost shouted the last part in this song..... but she's still the best
HerrVarg92 2 months ago
Comment removed
theixxfactor 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I absolutely don't agree with what tuomas said about how he sings. He actually sings pretty good :)))
AliceHolopainen 5 months ago
I absolutely don't agree with what Tuomas said about how he sings. He actually sings pretty good :)))
AliceHolopainen 5 months ago
que buenaas epocas!
AyeeMorgenstern 5 months ago
OHHHHHH My GODDD!!!!!!!::::::.....
Darknessfall88 6 months ago
Is there an MP3 for the live version? I would love to have it.
TOTTW 6 months ago
@TOTTW Youtube converter....
StarlightFreak 2 months ago
Awww Tuomas singing <3
GlitterAndMetal 6 months ago 3
Comment removed
andreeaa90 7 months ago
old song, but good song, Nightwish is amazing
ghostwish990 7 months ago
AHAHAHAHA TUOMMY XD
IrisTheOceanSoul 7 months ago
I like tuomas' voice.Its cool
milla387 9 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Search online Asian women # oneman4u.info #
droceaso 9 months ago
It´s so great to see the band happy together ,when Tarja und Tuomas loved each other. Ther´s so much emotion in the music.Sooo sad that it ended!!
fuckcommercialmusic1 9 months ago 3
6 people are idiots
milla387 9 months ago 2
Chilling
nolifeftw123 10 months ago
He sounds better live than on the album, in my opinion. I like the way he "shouts" the lyrics
lulalely 10 months ago
he can sing anytime he's fabulous! This is the first time I actually see him sing :D!!!
Veritostitos 11 months ago
Tuomas should really sing! hes the best vocal!
IHFSC 11 months ago
Tuomas !! Tuomas !! Tuomas !! Tuomas !! Tuomas !!
tieuthujulio 1 year ago 5
great!
DjMagnificien 1 year ago
tuomas has a nice voice, he shouldn't feel like he shouldn't sing :D
nightwishwolf999 1 year ago 5
wow, this performance is stunning. Tuo sang in a splendid way :)
pearlanddiamond06 1 year ago 5
i laughed so hard at tuomas's face XD
evilass334 1 year ago 6
Wow! this was incerdible! =O
GonNightwisher 1 year ago 4
my fav part is 0:00 to 6:57
HalloweenFaerysMagik 1 year ago 3
I love Tuomas!!!!! YOU ROCK!!!
finckelberry223uv 1 year ago 6
6:20-6:40
destroyallhaha 1 year ago
1:38 is my fav part of the song
Bigjoker1990 1 year ago
I like toumas when he sings, he is not bad
Bigjoker1990 1 year ago 15
The REAL Nightwish
XTremeDiva1828 1 year ago 7
Tuomas is a HUGE disney nut, you'd really think he'd be more into this.
nothingtolookat 1 year ago
haha this is so awesome... and actully Tuomas isn't the worst singer i've heard XD
emil9412 1 year ago
:O i had NO idea that tuomas sang the male part of this song O_O
GrowingObsession 1 year ago
Wow, how fast the time pass, this concert was 10 years ago
R.I.P. the real nightwish miss you tarja :(
sorry 4 my english
edgeofseventeen17 1 year ago
lol at Tuomas singing xD.He looks like hes gunna cry xD
JoseGabrielDiazPerez 1 year ago 14
TUOMAS ROCKS!!!!!!!!!
LOLZ THIS MADE ME LAUGH SO HARD!!!!
MissAnimeLover1 1 year ago
OH!
Tuooooooooooomas singing! LOVE IT!!!
NightwishFanGreece 1 year ago 5
tarja is very crazy lol!!!!
dgal91 1 year ago
Sweet Duett... =)
Tarja...
The good old times....
LadyOrajatar 1 year ago 7
Tuomas is so cute :DD cool, i didnt know that he can sing :DD lol
domiukas1 1 year ago
@domiukas1 he can't.
waylonsmithers68 1 year ago
@waylonsmithers68 Goshh.. why are u so serious..
domiukas1 1 year ago
@domiukas1 cos he just can't sing
waylonsmithers68 1 year ago
@waylonsmithers68 Using your vocal cords to hold a note is singing. He did that. He can sing. Whether you like it or not is opinion.
harrawrson 1 year ago
@harrawrson 99% of the people on earth can do that...
Allard88 1 year ago
I love how Tarja seems amused at how uncomfortable Tuomas is with singing....I bet that was what he meant in the letter about them not being close anymore :(
xXAsylumArmyXx 1 year ago
tuomas is so sweet :DD
polandgirl2008 1 year ago 2
Tarja's not in the band because of her attitude it was a band decision not just Tuomas's. I really wish people would stop bickering about who's better, it's old.
NightwishIsLove 1 year ago 2
@NightwishIsLove fianlly someone who get's it!! thank you!!! ;)
Raven2589 1 year ago 2
@NightwishIsLove Her attitude? i think you have to see Tarja's letter and Marcelo's answers before you say that, I respect your comment, this is just my opinion. Sometimes love can make us take bad decisions...
VladimirxGolshmidt 1 year ago
@VladimirxGolshmidt indeed, there was no such thing as her attitude. THERE WERE ALL INVOLVED, already having some differences. and when Tarja told them she was gonna leave the band after the next album... they decided to kick her ass out first :) so all the stuff with money and no respect for fans were just fairytaled excuses :))
mishaBMP 1 year ago 3
@mishaBMP Agree :)
VladimirxGolshmidt 1 year ago
THERE SOOOO YOUNG IN THIIIIS!!!!
GeneralArrow 1 year ago
oh God! I knew Tarja has most beautiful voice, but i did not know Tuomas can sing as well! :D
satansgirlfriendxd 1 year ago
no money for two microphons ._. hard times...
G0NZAL0666 1 year ago 2
@G0NZAL0666 This made me laugh. But I guess it's sorta true.... Or maybe they just didn't know how to install a mic above the keyboard. :P
MrJabberzz 1 year ago
Just to think, we will never hear this song or Phantom of the Opera live again because Annette cant sing it...
gbanger666 1 year ago
And thats all Tuomas fault, because if he hadn't have fucked up, Tarja would still have been in the band.
halvarthered 1 year ago
wow tuomas's voices sounds so different from when he talks lol :)
TARJA XD
cher4995 2 years ago 5
you thought that was annette? haha you noob. annette can only be this good in her dreams
xDarkvalorspiritx 2 years ago
If you can't tell the difference between Tarja and Anette, you are either deaf, ignorant or retarded... Anette will never be able to perform this well. The guys made the biggest mistake of their lives when they decided to fire Tarja.
ylonenfeathers 2 years ago 4
I acctually liked the fact tarja let him sing. He acctually sounds good.
Bluemoonlight2 2 years ago 8
only a fucking stubid person would think this is annette ....!!!!
THIS IS TARJA
wolverineX88 2 years ago
Cute :-)
Tuomas can't really sing ;-)
But I love them anyway :-D
GreatestOfPains 2 years ago
For the one that thought this is Anette... you cant compare a Queen to a debutant... never ever!!!
Sailormoon1313 2 years ago
Sorry, I'm writing the same stuff again, but how could someone think this is Annette? OMG! When you don't SEE it's Tarja you have to HEAR! At least Annette is never dressed like that. She always wears short dresses and skirts. this MUST be Tarja! And it is Tarja!
And it's great! i really like Tuomas voice!
FriFroJones 2 years ago 8
Tuomas voice is different when he talk and when he sing
antonsdefrancua 2 years ago
this is why i love this album...haha :P
athinapainter 2 years ago
I love every album! Ha ha ha :D
antonsdefrancua 2 years ago
i mean i love this album bcause tuomas is singing in it :)
athinapainter 2 years ago
You are funny I like it!
antonsdefrancua 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Anette does a very good perfornmance here!
iblistarot 2 years ago
ahahahahaah xD ... no comment
Italy4ever92 2 years ago
Dude, that was Tarja, not Anette.
yazoochick 2 years ago 3
Hey.. Learn to tell the difference between Tarja and Anette..
Go Anette, you were awesome in this video, doing this great duette with Tuomas!
iblistarot 2 years ago
I know the difference between Anette and Tarja. Tarja was fired in 2005. This video was taken in 2000. You need to learn the difference between them.
yazoochick 2 years ago 2
Uh, wow. Just wow. Anette has never sang Beauty and the Beast live for one thing. Another, as pointed out, this video was from 2000. Anette was hired 2007. Also, an idiot could tell this is Tarja, especially with how high she is singing. Anette belts, she doesn't sing classically. A Nightwish fan would know that. And look at 1:38 if you aren't convinced: you would have to be BLIND, completely BLIND and stupid not to see that that is Tarja Turunen, not Anette Olzon.
inu4kagfan4eva 2 years ago 6
Stop being a troll. That's Tarja.
snozzbatt 2 years ago 3
what are you a fucking retard or something? Annette in 2000? Does that sound like Annette to you?
wasdoomed 2 years ago 5
I think that person is a retard, wasdoomed. I have only been a Nightwish fan for a year and a half, and I even know the difference between Anette and Tarja.
yazoochick 2 years ago 2
Ah, this got boring quick.. Was interesting to see how emotional some people got though :) yazoochick, did you read my comment on your channel?
iblistarot 2 years ago
i dont want to monster to change to a human at last
lovekibainuzuka 2 years ago
I didn't know that Tuomas is singing, but he sang very good
antonsdefrancua 2 years ago 3
Tuomas is singing all the male vocals on Angels Fall First =P
Doum92 2 years ago
Now I know that Tuomas singing on Angels Fall First
antonsdefrancua 2 years ago
0:33-0:36 is SO awesome!
TheAdorabelle 2 years ago 12
Yeah))))))
Oomka 2 years ago
Tuomas sings very good live though he seems to be a little drunk ;p He must be awesome singing in studio.
LegenJCdary 2 years ago 2
i think...he should sing more often
he's an good singer, maybe not the best, but very good
polandgirl2008 2 years ago 7
i love tuomas singing i know is not the perfect voice but when he is speaking he is so cute !
nightwish231 2 years ago 2
2:33 like if tarja were saying "LOUDER LOUDER YOU CAN C'MON!" hahaha
<3
GbyOriordan 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
GbyOriordan 2 years ago
lol i never heard Sami Vanska's voice :|
Daudiu 2 years ago 3
I don't see them doing this song with Anette. Marco's voice just doesn't seem right for it.
yazoochick 2 years ago 2
Theyve got to do this with anette
AustralianAtheist92 2 years ago
lol i've never heard tuomas sing this live!! :D
Xx6DeathofSeasons6xX 2 years ago 24
@Xx6DeathofSeasons6xX You probably won't hear it again either. xD
FireRagnarok 1 year ago 2
Tarja's Dancing :D
She's great ;)
TheTarjaTurunen 2 years ago 7
I love this song. And that's why i remixed it yesterday :D
MrAsylar 2 years ago
E eh, not bad, tuomas !!!
niahaa 2 years ago 4
Tuomas's face! xD xD xD Oh wow he really doesn't wanna sing :D
LordPhoenix1707 2 years ago 62
Haha yes xD
Your fuckin right :D
NiGHTWiSHx4xEVER 2 years ago 3
But we all LOVE his voice. We should make him a big sign that says "WE LOVE YOUR SINGING!"
hjpaddock 2 years ago 6
@LordPhoenix1707 One of the things he will never do again in his whole life, he said xD
XTremeDiva1828 1 year ago
@LordPhoenix1707 lolz
AyreonsDimension 1 year ago
azért Tadeusz a Dalriadából se semmi; dobol, meg hörög egyszerre!
Binczet 2 years ago
Marc was not here, then the band was: Tarja, Emppu, Tuomas, Jukka and Sami Vanska (bassist)
scorpy03 2 years ago 2
just wondering, is Tuomas the one singing in the recorded version, or is it a guest singer? sorry if this seems like a dumb question. But like my mom always says, there are no stupid questions. Only stupid people.
hiddenxleafxninja 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
altariaapple 2 years ago
It's Tuomas. He sings on 'The Carpenter', 'Astral Romance' and 'Once Upon a Troubadour' as well.
oswaldo732 2 years ago 3
There are two recorded versions, one on Angels Fall First, where Tuomas sings and one on From Wishes to Eternity, where Tony Kakko from Sonata Arctica sings.
Glady210 2 years ago
Tuomas sings in the recorded version.
A guest singer sang in a live performance that's on the "from wishes to eternity" dvd (and maybe some other concerts, I don't know)
and since Marco joined, he had been singing the male parts in this song
Allard88 2 years ago
Yeash, Tony kakko (from Sonata Arctica) sang the part of the beast in a nightwish live :)
RainStillnight 2 years ago 4
Who rated this bad? XD
hjpaddock 2 years ago 4
Tuomas is singing on angels fall first, and Tony kakko is singing on over the hills and far away
Melissaamorx 2 years ago
yes, It´s toumas in the studio version, he´s powerfull!! too bad he dislikes to sing live...
Daworldendswithyou 2 years ago 3
WOAH i've never heard tuomas sing lol! not bad voice aswell they look so cute in the early years aswell
angelofdarkness49 2 years ago 4
if tarja and tuomas did this more singing together they would still be together
senchsucht 2 years ago
toumas singing :D
Amazing
KittyCore99 2 years ago
lmao Tuomas singing, holy shat! That's funny stuff =)
DdragonforceF 2 years ago 3
man empuu and thomas is first members in NW and whit bass is sami vanska
scorpy03 2 years ago
Hey!!! What the heck happened the bass & guitar player when they did phantom of the opera?! That was an awesome song by the way!
juggler420 2 years ago
this video is an old one, and has the very first band members..
Emppu, and Marco weren't yet with NW..
Krizue 2 years ago
wow the original Nightwish is Emppu, Marco, Jukka and Tarja. Yes that is Emppu.
JrockFTW22 2 years ago
Äh, there isn't any Marco :D
NightwishTimmi 2 years ago 2
oh my GODDDDDDDD TOUMAS ????????????????????? very great voice I Think that must sing other song soon after the Passion play
ziporcoipa 2 years ago 2
hahaha
i don't think he will, he said that one of his worst nightmares is to sing... you can see this on NW website
Krizue 2 years ago
OH MY GOD!!! Toumas holopainen!!! you are awsome man!!!
Daworldendswithyou 2 years ago 31
@Daworldendswithyou he is the god of music :)
jinzsexslave 1 year ago 5
jajaja god!! toumas XD i do the same mmmmand is so difficulyt sing and play and an instrument!! waoU!! good for him!
KravenDix 2 years ago 3
tnx, i dont know how did you understood my text lol song on cd song Lol. ty :)
Ljuba95 2 years ago
9 years, and still rocks! :P
Ljuba95 2 years ago
and who sing this song on CD song?
Ljuba95 2 years ago
tuomas
clintdiamante99 2 years ago
tuomas..
Winterhe4rt 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
not.
NightwishTimmi 2 years ago
yes... ;)
Winterhe4rt 2 years ago
tuomas in angel fall first and tony kakko in from wishes to eternity
manumadmar 2 years ago
wow.. 9 years ago already...
krili0 2 years ago
his voice sounds like somewhat an aristocrat.
clintdiamante99 2 years ago
Tuomas!:X i wanna sing and play the keyboard like him <3 Tuomas is a god of music!
amaranthflavius 2 years ago 10
Yes he is! And not forgetting Yoshiki of X-Japan!
Archergod 2 years ago
omg i just love love love love this video,man i love him ,specially when he sings :D awesome,pitty he doesnt do it more..
Lapsellinen 2 years ago 2
awesome tuomas!!!!!! =)
Winterhe4rt 2 years ago
lol, tuomas forgets the lyrics at one stage.
VladGLX 2 years ago
I am so in love with that dark haired fellow to the left.
THolopainenAddict 2 years ago
me toooo <33333
Lapsellinen 2 years ago
Actually Tuomas sounds good live but on the CD ''Angels fall first'' sounds horrible.
Lovemetal96 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
horrible. I like it. :o
NightwishTimmi 2 years ago
omg! i knew tuomas sung on a few of their songs but i have never actually seen it!!
charmed4sure16 2 years ago
YEAH YEAH YEAH!! I LOVE IT
VAMPMEROT 2 years ago
ha tuomas sings really bad on the recorded version of this but he sounds kinda good here! :D
XxxmariacullenxxX 2 years ago
TUOMAS was born to do what he is doing now...........nothing more nothing less!!!!!! I don't care if he sings good or not.................in my ears he sounds perfect!!!!!!!!:D
tstmp 2 years ago 3
WOOOW, i didn't know that Tuomas sang the mail part of this song in the past..
Thats Awesome!!! REALLY!! =)
And Emppu with his nice Washburn!! =)
Winterhe4rt 2 years ago
this was the real nightwish....
it would never come back... snif
detractordeimbeciles 2 years ago 10
Sadly I agree with you...
I've given Annette a lot of chances, but she deceives me time after time...
isildur9999 2 years ago
yeah. bye tarja and sami :(
clintdiamante99 2 years ago
2:12
O dear Friend I remember the night...
Tuomas` face xD
hahaha maybe He remembered something
CountessKuseka 2 years ago 4
hahaa something like
"of course i remember that night! ^^ and oh i do..^^" XD
R2ROrancid 2 years ago
Tuomas singed in the Angel Fall First ^^
he sings so good, i don`t know why he didn`t sing more...
CountessKuseka 2 years ago 3
He says, that he can't sing...Liar !
xD
cath2204 2 years ago 3
Hehehe. Tuomas singing! It makes me giggle. I love it!
Saimeren 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
ew this band is gay
BabyEater9000 2 years ago
aussi toi ^^
you too ^^
brunoristian 2 years ago 2
ta gueule ^^
BabyEater9000 2 years ago
sei un vecchio cafone dico davvero :) che minchia vieni a sentirti questa band qundo non ne capisci un cazzo... you're so stupid... with love ovviamente <3
brunoristian 2 years ago
PRF
And your are an idiot :)
fairyxcorpse 2 years ago