Added: 4 years ago
From: rwjacks2
Views: 10,468
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (36)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • He is really good now!

  • a bit of work could help this boy, what a shame...

  • the kid forced his vibrado. It comes naturally. other than that, the kid has a great voice and I think he should stick with singing

  • too fast... sharp

  • so. sharp.

  • Vibrato comes naturally. Kid forced it. He would of sounded better if he had sung it without the vibrato.

  • 14 year old commenting: beautiful

  • so...you have a problem? my highschool, freshmen to seniors will sing this, im a junior but still...

  • when my high school chorus did this we had an alto singing the counter-tenors part.

  • contra*

  • i hate when people clap between movements

  • ROAR!

  • im singing this...and im a girl...in my opinion it would sound a lot better in a girls voice..and this boys voice sounded way to grown up

  • Leonard Bernstein wrote as a note in the score that the 2nd movement solo is never to be sang by a woman. Only counter tenor or boy soprano

  • Yes he did, & i completely agree.

    Only a boy shall sing this part

  • you can never sound too grown up.

    sounding juvinile is worse.

    and this is the way Bernstein wanted it.

    your director is obviously not that good if hes having you singing it, and not doing it the way it suppose ot be done.

  • picmeco's right (above)

    a girl alto or soprano could do a better job. that boy isn't so great.

  • I have sung the solo of the Chichesters Psalms this year at the "Stuttgarter Stiftsmusik-Fest" with the "Stuttgarter Kantorei" , the dirigent was Kay Johannsen. The boy ( I'm a boy too) don't hit the notes very good. It sounds a little bit dirty. And the harmonic don't works together!

  • wow. I like how the kid was in a complete different key, He is suposse to represent david as a child, innocent, the vibrato killed it.

    The choir is alright. I like the alto's

    and the basses are a little muddy.

  • Speaking as one of those altos.. thankee kindly :)

    I think this was his first gig...

  • wow. I like how the kid was in a complete different kye, He is suposse to represent david as a child, innocent, the vibrato killed it.

    The choir is alright. I like the alto's

    and the basses are a little muddy.

  • I agree. As much as I respect Bernstein, I think this boy or man thing had more to do with him liking them than it did anything else. If the soloist sounds bad, who cares that it's a boy singing? This kid is WAY sharp and overdoing the vibrato. A good young girl soprano can definitely do a better job than this.

  • You're wrong about the "man or boy thing." Bernstein specified that a boy (or countertenor) sing the solo because the soloist is supposed to represent King David as a boy. In movement II, David's first coming into those glorious poetic & musical gifts we all remember from the Book of Psalms. I agree with you, though, that this part would probably be easier for a young soprano to sing. However, doing so would fail to fulfill Bernstein's artistic intent. Party on Garth!

  • ugh, this guy is nice, but he made me feel like crap, now i'm really sad

  • The West Australian Symphony Orchestra is performing this work on the 24th and 26th of April 2008. The boy treble will be Liam Green. Remembrance Anzac Day Program 8pm, Thursday 24 & Saturday 26 April Perth Concert Hall BRITTEN Sinfonia da requiem ELGAR Cello Concerto SCULTHORPE Sun Music III BERNSTEIN Chichester Psalms Martyn Brabbins, conductor Natalie Clein, cello WASO Chorus
  • It would be nice if the boy soprano were in the same key as the orchestra. And where the vibrato came from is a mystery.

  • wow cole did really well and well done to the rest of the group

  • yeah well cole is my bestie and my bf, so ha kira :( someday when Cole is famous i'll be like, i dated that guy in middle school...unless he's my husband...but that seems really weird....nevermind...

  • yeah,kira? well cole is my bf and my bestie, so ha!!!!!!!!

  • not no mo bitch!!

  • you should add the other movements!!

  • this is my choir!

  • we're singing this in my highschool chorus. a few of us will be going into the NYC to sing it with 2 other choirs. =]

    i have to remember to ask my teacher for a copy of the songs or something. its just soo pretty

  • OMG! COLE IS MI BESTIE! He calls me B.P. at school! omg... i like need his autograph now, so when he becomes famouse in 2025, it'll cost $1,000,000,000.

    -Kira

  • Wow, tell Cole his cousin Gabe thinks he did a Great job!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more