i have the naked pallette, but my makeup never turns out that great ): your extremely talented & your videos are so professional! :D thanks for the tutorials so people like me can at least TRY to get our makeup lik e that lol.
I would love it if you guys would check out my new beauty channel and subscribe! I promise I will have loads of videos up soon! My channel is everything girly and beauty related:)
Your technique with your brushes and how you apply the makeup is so good and precise! I feel like professional makeup artists do it the same way you do. How do you get that good? Do you just practice a lot?
@treehugger137 Thank you! I definitely try my best when I'm doing my makeup. :) I think it's just because I'm doing my makeup so often I just leant the best ways to hold the brushes and that's what works for me.
I did this look for New Years! I got SOOO many compliments on it and the dress came just in time! :) Thank you Ashley, this makeup and dress boosted my confidence about 20+ points. <3 Happy New Year love! (By the way, I'd LOVE to have you as a big sister, Carly is lucky!)
yess thankyou for zooming in when you put on ur eye makeup! some beauty gurus do such lovely makeup tutorials but they sit so far away from the screen so its hard 2 see
Honestly guys, it shouldn't matter how the videos are made, it should matter what the videos are about. Ashley is great with all things beauty and health, and I just enjoy watching her videos, no matter what they look like.
hey ashley can you please do a video about how to shop at makeup counters? i went to mac the other day but had no idea what i was doing. with sephora you just grab what you want but at mac i couldn't even find the lipsticks that weren't testers. i'm sure you have a lot of younger viewers that this would be helpful to as well and not just me. thanks!
You're absolutely stunning in this video! :) I love your dress (placed an order for it) as well as I'm purchasing the benefit mascara so I can completely remake this look! Such an amazing gorgeous role model. <3 I like your new editing too! Wish I was pretty as you though... :/
i personally like how you edit your videos. it's very professional and to the point. please don't change it because people are saying that your copying the bigger gurus.
Does anyone else think, "XOXO, Gossip Girl." at the end, or is that just me? If 'A' from Pretty Little Liars and Gossip Girl came together, that would be awesome. Lol. Too much tv, clearly.
I'm with you on the I wouldn't kiss anyone! When you said it at the end I was thinking "Aww, I don't have anyone to kiss this year." LOL, oh well! Beautiful tutorial, and I was trying to find a look to wear this New Year's, thanks Ashley! You're still absolutely beautiful! I was wondering what is on your nails, Chanel Graphite? ;)
Stop leaving rude comments!! Shes the sane Ashley as before nothings changed! I didn't even notice one difference in this video from her others! And if your gonna unsub her just cause you think she's copying Michelle Phan or is trying to be to sexy than unsub cause yiy wasn't a true subbie in the first place. Her videos aren't gonna be the same for ever. Everyone takes change so bad, she's just experimenting with different styles of videos! There's no need to tell her over and over how she's ch
Just cuz someone poses and does voice overs in videos..doesn't mean they are COPYING or TRYING to be like michelle phan.....honestly its stupid and annoying how u think she had changed.
UGhh peoples constant criticism of how this girl does her videos is just down right rude and annoying. If you dont like a she making her videos than simply dont watch them its easy as that. So what if she does poses or analogies or whatever it HER videos if you dont like the way she conducting them DONT WATCH thats why you hace a back button and a close button! Ashley I love your videos anyway you do them POWER to you girl. You are not like Michelle phan who basically advertises makeup brands.
I loved the look but i wish you would do more of your regular makeup tutorials, lately its just been voice over, i know you may be busy but its a lot more personable i feel. Thanks for the new years look, this definitely looks like a nice look to do with the naked palette. (= Have a happy new year!
Even with your brilliant tutorial, I doubt I can replicate it as beautifully as yours came out ;p However, I'll try my best to leave a picture on your twitter before I leave for my new year's party!
@gagaglam1 shes not trying to be like other gurus? have you ever heard of changing? her videos arent gonna be the same forever! if you dont like her no videos theres no need to leave a comment complaning. shes just trying out new styles of videos...
Ashley, what kind of camera do you use when filming and taking pictures? Is it the same thing?? & you should do a FAQ video or a video answering our questions about you! :)
I don't often leave compliments on makeup tutorials, but I really like this one! I think I'm going to use it on new years eve. Also you have amazing natural lashes :)
If people keep telling her she is "trying to be like Michelle Phan" she will either not reply at all or say that not only one certain person can film videos this way.
You just have to tell her you're not really liking the "new thing" she's got going on and like her old ways better so maybe she'll listen and take your comments into consideration.
After all, she IS making videos for her subscribers.
You're so beautiful, Ashley! And I love your videos <3 (like I've said before), you make such an inspiration to a ton of girls, including myself I can't think of another role model and I'm so glad I found you on Youtube! Keep being amazing and beautiful I love you so much! XOXO!
I wear this look everyday. :)
SamanthaJeanGarcia 1 week ago
so who did u kiss ???????????
susulove22 2 weeks ago
i love the lipstick, what brand and colour is it? :)
triciaanddanielax 3 weeks ago
where can i buy the highlighter you used in this video?
t13ish 1 month ago
your eyes are so beautiful
Msmik220290 1 month ago in playlist Uploaded videos
What's the name of that highlighter?? I have been looking for one and you look really amazing with it on?? Plz respond
taylorswiftfan2626 1 month ago
@taylorswiftfan2626 it's called watts up and it's by benefit
MakeupandAllThat 1 month ago
You're so beautiful ♥ I love your videos, and your makeup and hair are always flawless. :)
XxhaleycutxX 1 month ago in playlist Uploaded videos
I love that dresss!
faythhhhhx22 1 month ago
i dont think your skin could get any more perfect .. honestly. loll. luccky gall.
whatev5140 1 month ago in playlist More videos from AshleysBeautyCorner
i have the naked pallette, but my makeup never turns out that great ): your extremely talented & your videos are so professional! :D thanks for the tutorials so people like me can at least TRY to get our makeup lik e that lol.
shitzilovehim 2 months ago
Omg you do makeup SOOOO amazingly I wish I was as good as you:) flawless...-3
addicted2beauty1000 2 months ago
Can you do a review on benefits watts up! Highlighter ? :)
losersyogo 2 months ago
Can you do a video on how you stay fit?
ilikepurple456 2 months ago
you remind me of selena gomez
MarieTiffanii 2 months ago in playlist Uploaded videos
She looks like my bestfriend kayla!
TheNerd474 2 months ago
you look like you could be a kardashian
vietprideee 2 months ago in playlist More videos from AshleysBeautyCorner
are you italian? you're so gorgeous<3
dancingdaises1 2 months ago in playlist Uploaded videos
This has been flagged as spam show
I would love it if you guys would check out my new beauty channel and subscribe! I promise I will have loads of videos up soon! My channel is everything girly and beauty related:)
Beloveely 2 months ago
can you please do a whats in purse video :)
qahilla 2 months ago in playlist Uploaded videos 5
Ashley, is Carly Cristman really your sister? I thought it was just a joke! :P
MJFAN3457 2 months ago in playlist Uploaded videos
Your technique with your brushes and how you apply the makeup is so good and precise! I feel like professional makeup artists do it the same way you do. How do you get that good? Do you just practice a lot?
treehugger137 2 months ago 13
@treehugger137 Thank you! I definitely try my best when I'm doing my makeup. :) I think it's just because I'm doing my makeup so often I just leant the best ways to hold the brushes and that's what works for me.
AshleysBeautyCorner 2 months ago 8
I did this look for New Years! I got SOOO many compliments on it and the dress came just in time! :) Thank you Ashley, this makeup and dress boosted my confidence about 20+ points. <3 Happy New Year love! (By the way, I'd LOVE to have you as a big sister, Carly is lucky!)
MakeupByM5 2 months ago in playlist Uploaded videos
DID YOU GET THE NAKED 2 PALLETTE? just wondering, please answer!
Petdaisy101 2 months ago
just did this makeup for new years:) lovvvinngg it!! thanks so so so much for making this:)
xoxobeautybarbiexoxo 2 months ago in playlist Uploaded videos
please please please make eyebrows tutorial and face routine please ashley.your videos are amazing,your so beautiful!
enny9991 2 months ago
you're eyelashes are amazing!
soniaosian 2 months ago in playlist More videos from AshleysBeautyCorner
I loved that you used the naked palette! i just got mine and it seems other gurus are over the hype.
dustfinger213 2 months ago
omg i want every single revlon lip butters they have out, they seem soo moisturising and the color isnt to pigmented and cakey
FashionWidATwist 2 months ago in playlist More videos from AshleysBeautyCorner
yess thankyou for zooming in when you put on ur eye makeup! some beauty gurus do such lovely makeup tutorials but they sit so far away from the screen so its hard 2 see
FashionWidATwist 2 months ago in playlist More videos from AshleysBeautyCorner
This is really beautiful ! Thank you. xx
Emma261233 2 months ago
i think you look younger than your actual age. do you get that a lot?
jennaleeforu 2 months ago
Ur so pretty!!
luv2thinkpinknpurple 2 months ago
you kinda look like a kardashian !
nickipoo101 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey Ashley Happy New Year to u good to see u back i was missing ur vids....:)
Lovelybeautyluver 2 months ago in playlist Uploaded videos
Comment removed
Lovelybeautyluver 2 months ago in playlist Uploaded videos
Honestly guys, it shouldn't matter how the videos are made, it should matter what the videos are about. Ashley is great with all things beauty and health, and I just enjoy watching her videos, no matter what they look like.
MargaretClaire1 2 months ago
You are so pretty!
dynamite101100 2 months ago
WOW this is the prettiest look i have seen so far for NYE
PinkStar349 2 months ago
this is soo pretty! wil def be trying this look with my UDNP! :)
xlovemissvegetar 2 months ago
oohhhaaiii thuurr music lover? zeppelin floyd hendrix? combined into one?
what kind of idea does my music bring forth? JUST THAT...see for yourself!
AbsoluteZeroMusic 2 months ago
is it just me or does she look a little like melanie iglesias?
Trendyguns 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hey ashley can you please do a video about how to shop at makeup counters? i went to mac the other day but had no idea what i was doing. with sephora you just grab what you want but at mac i couldn't even find the lipsticks that weren't testers. i'm sure you have a lot of younger viewers that this would be helpful to as well and not just me. thanks!
justAlittleNobody 2 months ago in playlist Uploaded videos
<3
Fablousangel100 2 months ago
Can you PLEASE do a what i got for christmas video ?????
BooskieBae 2 months ago 4
I really love this makeup look!
One quick question - what color is your nail polish? Thank you!!
kc4424 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I love your videos! Please check out my channel its new !
XOXO LILLY
932blondie 2 months ago in playlist Uploaded videos
Wow your drop dead gorgeous
chrisferrari 2 months ago
can you do an updated foundation routine? :) thumbs up if you want her too!
dAiSyMaRiExOxo 2 months ago
You're absolutely stunning in this video! :) I love your dress (placed an order for it) as well as I'm purchasing the benefit mascara so I can completely remake this look! Such an amazing gorgeous role model. <3 I like your new editing too! Wish I was pretty as you though... :/
MakeupByM5 2 months ago
beautiful look! (: I am gonna try this :D
MsBiancaWonka 2 months ago
FABULOUS look indeed :D ! great job !
Tropical8D 2 months ago
i personally like how you edit your videos. it's very professional and to the point. please don't change it because people are saying that your copying the bigger gurus.
sydneysmiles13 2 months ago 57
@sydneysmiles13 Well thank you! I personally don't agree with those people anyways! These are my videos and this is how I am. :)
AshleysBeautyCorner 2 months ago 35
@AshleysBeautyCorner Please tell me how u are making ur edits i thing u wont say right ?
Roladesigns 2 months ago
ashley you look like melinda ademi:) xxx
MiaStrikes 2 months ago in playlist Uploaded videos
This has been flagged as spam show
WONT MAKE YOUR DICK GROW...BUT MIGHT MAKE YOUR MIND BLOW...CHECK US OUT @MegaSixmillion
MegaSixmillion 2 months ago
Nice:) Check me out - Joel Luyt - on YouTube:)
Joelluyt 2 months ago
U are so pretty<3
itgoesmyway 2 months ago
Does anyone else but me hate when people your own age call you sweetie or hun?
melonalove1 2 months ago
Comment removed
melonalove1 2 months ago
@fl4less ... a lot of makeup
melonalove1 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i bet half of the people disliked it are the lil weenies that are sad they dont have a naked palette..
kayturedollxo 2 months ago
i bet half of the people disliked it are the lil weenies that are sad they dont have a naked palette..
kayturedollxo 2 months ago 2
i love your videos you shuld update more =)
TheBarbieTamez 2 months ago
i'm so doing this for new years:) thanks so much!!
xoxobeautybarbiexoxo 2 months ago in playlist Uploaded videos
ur GORGEOUS!!!!
freesyria96 2 months ago
Can you do a victoria justice look
MarielizKuky 2 months ago
Ashley I have long lashes like yours but I have a problem with my lashes constantly falling out even without mascara. Any advice?
jasmineandsilvia 2 months ago
Your gorgeous
KITKATNUT13 2 months ago
i love this look :)
very pretty
Starr08131 2 months ago
are you really gonna wear this dress for new years or do you have something else in mind? haha
pinkfroyo 2 months ago
Omg i love your lashes !!! Your such a beaut ashley :)
shaynanabayna 2 months ago
Darn. I don't have anyone to kiss. I'll be away from my boyfriend for new years:'(
lykLaMaZiNg 2 months ago
Does anyone else think, "XOXO, Gossip Girl." at the end, or is that just me? If 'A' from Pretty Little Liars and Gossip Girl came together, that would be awesome. Lol. Too much tv, clearly.
ashleyhasOJD 2 months ago 2
@ashleyhasOJD LOOLL omg i totally did too!!
smissyb 2 months ago
HAIR TUTORIAL PLEASEEEEEEE!
gottaloovesara 2 months ago
Did the camera quality change>!>!>>!?!?!?!!
emilysstar13 2 months ago
I'm with you on the I wouldn't kiss anyone! When you said it at the end I was thinking "Aww, I don't have anyone to kiss this year." LOL, oh well! Beautiful tutorial, and I was trying to find a look to wear this New Year's, thanks Ashley! You're still absolutely beautiful! I was wondering what is on your nails, Chanel Graphite? ;)
MakeupByM5 2 months ago
that 'xo -A' reminded me of pretty little liars :0 LOVE THE TUTORIAL THOUGH xx
xDFashionGalsxD 2 months ago
I love that you used the NAKED pallete in this, and I love this look! I can't wait to try it out :) You're gorgeous. Thanks for all you do
madiirist 2 months ago
Ugh, I wish I was half as pretty as you! haha
LoveeIsMyWeapon15 2 months ago
@dAiSyMaRiExOxo Yeah you tell them !! (;
Hannnnahx0x 2 months ago
you're really good, and your videos too, the 89 people who disliked this are just jealos, not everyone is as pretty as you !
MaisTV2 2 months ago
Same**
mileycyrus743 2 months ago
Stop leaving rude comments!! Shes the sane Ashley as before nothings changed! I didn't even notice one difference in this video from her others! And if your gonna unsub her just cause you think she's copying Michelle Phan or is trying to be to sexy than unsub cause yiy wasn't a true subbie in the first place. Her videos aren't gonna be the same for ever. Everyone takes change so bad, she's just experimenting with different styles of videos! There's no need to tell her over and over how she's ch
mileycyrus743 2 months ago
Comment removed
mangolimestrawberry 2 months ago
Yay for using the naked palette! I can replicate this, can't wait :D
ILoveRain10 2 months ago
Dang girl! Your lashes are LONG!
ILoveRain10 2 months ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
@angelica1560 Shuddup
dAiSyMaRiExOxo 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@kikachatterjee Shuddup
dAiSyMaRiExOxo 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@PinkGlitter873 Shuddup
dAiSyMaRiExOxo 2 months ago
@1497nessa Shuddup
dAiSyMaRiExOxo 2 months ago
i love your eyebrows!
how do you get them that perfect ?
paulihere 2 months ago
My birthday is new years eve and I happen to have all of the same products so i'll definitely be wearing this!I'm so excited! haha
JellyBeanz93 2 months ago
I love your videos Ashley (: the look is amazing!
Macxkitty 2 months ago
Nah no midnight kiss. Yay for the forever alone team
tnktpot97 2 months ago
No one's perfect but you seem to be close to it! You are beautiful! Keep it up! :)
ferreelzzsedra 2 months ago
Love love love the dress, you always have such perfect outfits!
And you should do a room tour!
ronnieeeex3 2 months ago
How do you do your eyebrows?
pinklovescanada 2 months ago
THIS IS SO GORGEOUS ! love you ashley <3
drizzyweezybiebs 2 months ago
This is soooo pretty!!!!! I love the eyes! And you have amazing lashes too :)
Lafalot54 2 months ago
your amazing at makeup! love this look!:) can you do another new years eve look? maybe a blue smokey with glitter? love your tutorials!
beautybella01 2 months ago
whos michelle phan?
bibi141489 2 months ago in playlist More videos from AshleysBeautyCorner
wow after all the effort she puts in her videos for you guys you thank her by criticizing her?
beautybella01 2 months ago
You are seriously the most gorgeous person I have ever seen!
ilovecheerxxx 2 months ago
this look really suites you Ashley, and it matches the dress perfectly! you will def rock this look on new years :D
Kookiez72 2 months ago
Comment removed
MikaelaSchultz 2 months ago
Comment removed
MikaelaSchultz 2 months ago
Just cuz someone poses and does voice overs in videos..doesn't mean they are COPYING or TRYING to be like michelle phan.....honestly its stupid and annoying how u think she had changed.
Keellyy12 2 months ago
UGhh peoples constant criticism of how this girl does her videos is just down right rude and annoying. If you dont like a she making her videos than simply dont watch them its easy as that. So what if she does poses or analogies or whatever it HER videos if you dont like the way she conducting them DONT WATCH thats why you hace a back button and a close button! Ashley I love your videos anyway you do them POWER to you girl. You are not like Michelle phan who basically advertises makeup brands.
sorcraw95 2 months ago 31
@sorcraw95 I can't take your rant seriously because of all of your grammar/spelling mistakes.
twirlerrx3 2 months ago 7
where do you get your eyebrows done? there so pretty
Mrstwilightsagalover 2 months ago
I miss youuuuuu! :(
grlzluvshoes 2 months ago
Love this look but I miss hearing your sweet personality shine through on your video's! :(
xpeekabooqtx 2 months ago
your lashes are sooo long and pretty!!
talkingtoalison 2 months ago
You are gorgeous!!!!!
PianoMan53100 2 months ago
you always look so pretty in your videos!
talkingtoalison 2 months ago
you're gorgeous, im so jealous!
beautyfanatic100 2 months ago
pretty girl! Truly an inspiration to all girls of all ages. I look up to your confidence and i'm 18! lol
vballpenguin003 2 months ago
I loved the look but i wish you would do more of your regular makeup tutorials, lately its just been voice over, i know you may be busy but its a lot more personable i feel. Thanks for the new years look, this definitely looks like a nice look to do with the naked palette. (= Have a happy new year!
missantuna2 2 months ago
lol what kiss
i'm forever alone :D
ohsnapitsenna 2 months ago 69
@ohsnapitsenna Haha, that makes two of us... :P
AshleysBeautyCorner 2 months ago 65
@ohsnapitsenna same girl (:
Mittenzzs 2 months ago
Great tutorial:) cannot wait to try it out!
Cjlove66 2 months ago
YES. i just bought the Naked pallette yesterday & i didn't know what to do with it, thanks for doing this! :D
LinaisaRonster 2 months ago
YOU ARE THE EPIDIMY OF BEAUTIFUL ! ILY AND YOUR VIDOES.PLEASE CHECK MY CHANNEL EVERYONE
honeysweetstuff67 2 months ago
So pretty!! xo!
cdiorme 2 months ago
i loved this makeup look :) also you look stunning and i hope you have a fantastic new years !
lovemusicfashionn 2 months ago
XO - A reminds me of pretty little liars!
itsmaybelline17 2 months ago
where have you been ashley?
itsmaybelline17 2 months ago
I'd love to do this for new years :D
Chaantelx 2 months ago
can u do an updated eyebrow video??
Swimgirl6855 2 months ago
Love this tutorial and you make it look soo easy ... :D
mouthymichelle 2 months ago
Even with your brilliant tutorial, I doubt I can replicate it as beautifully as yours came out ;p However, I'll try my best to leave a picture on your twitter before I leave for my new year's party!
aussynes 2 months ago 3
@aussynes Please do! I'd love to see. :)
AshleysBeautyCorner 2 months ago 5
ashley as usall beatiful love yuh lotss<3'
PanDDAloVE43 2 months ago
Love it :)
pamk31 2 months ago
Gosh. So gorgeous
janicew9 2 months ago
@gagaglam1 shes not trying to be like other gurus? have you ever heard of changing? her videos arent gonna be the same forever! if you dont like her no videos theres no need to leave a comment complaning. shes just trying out new styles of videos...
mileycyrus743 2 months ago
Ashley, what kind of camera do you use when filming and taking pictures? Is it the same thing?? & you should do a FAQ video or a video answering our questions about you! :)
lustbydust 2 months ago
gorgeous makeup, love the editing of the video, so professional<3 and I love Florrie, music is so great <3
randomgenre 2 months ago
@randomgenre Ah, I love her music too :)
AshleysBeautyCorner 2 months ago
Girl did you go boxing day shopping yesterday!? It's crazy haha.
lustbydust 2 months ago
I don't often leave compliments on makeup tutorials, but I really like this one! I think I'm going to use it on new years eve. Also you have amazing natural lashes :)
WaterLilySPLASH 2 months ago
What's with all the haters?
I actully like the way you did this video, it seems so professional. :] BTW, your natural eyelashes are amazing! They are so long and curled. :]
rosesinsterling 2 months ago
I really like this make up! I will totally try it ;)
luissy7 2 months ago
If people keep telling her she is "trying to be like Michelle Phan" she will either not reply at all or say that not only one certain person can film videos this way.
You just have to tell her you're not really liking the "new thing" she's got going on and like her old ways better so maybe she'll listen and take your comments into consideration.
After all, she IS making videos for her subscribers.
LOLili69 2 months ago
what are your plans for new years ashley? (:
pinkfroyo 2 months ago in playlist Liked videos
What primer do you use :) if you dont mind me asking?
hanwillans 2 months ago
YOUR SO GORGEOUS seriously! Lol chritmas haul?(:
XXlaughoftenlovemore 2 months ago
good video!!! :)
jmpandzic 2 months ago
Very pretty!!
mailopez29 2 months ago
ur so gorgeous :/ and then theres me haha
Dancerbabe303107 2 months ago 2
you are so hot in this video!
TheBeautygurux3 2 months ago
Comment removed
PinkButterflyxo9 2 months ago
595 likes... 302 views. anyone confused?
secretsavvy 2 months ago
wow, you look like you could be a Kardashian, and that's not an insult!
Kayla13saphire 2 months ago
how old are you!?
xobailee 2 months ago
I'm from Ireland and i got like loads of people I know to start watching your videos and now they all lovee you :D
TheBeautyFashion1 2 months ago
@TheBeautyFashion1 That put such a huge smile on my face, thank you! <3
AshleysBeautyCorner 2 months ago
Can u plz use drugstore product more than high ends ?
Greenlime996 2 months ago
CHRISTMAS HAUL CHRISTMAS HAUL CHRISTMAS HAUL <3333 !!!!!!!!!
Petdaisy101 2 months ago 2
I dont understand how u can dislike this video??
coc0x68 2 months ago
how old are you? and great look:)
amysarah1996 2 months ago
You're so beautiful, Ashley! And I love your videos <3 (like I've said before), you make such an inspiration to a ton of girls, including myself I can't think of another role model and I'm so glad I found you on Youtube! Keep being amazing and beautiful I love you so much! XOXO!
MakeupByM5 2 months ago
YAAAY i can actually do this tutorial cause i got the naked pallette :)
MsAlekito 2 months ago
OMG what do you do to have so long eyelashes ??? i'm so jealous even if you don't have any mascara they're sooo long and curled!
JustMylinh 2 months ago
i just got this palette for christmas and im soo excited to try out this look!
xoxemily95 2 months ago
@xoxemily95 You're going to love it. It's so amazing. ;)
AshleysBeautyCorner 2 months ago
Did anyone ever tell you , you kindaa look like allison from teen wolf ? Because you really do :)
KrisLissette 2 months ago
SERIOUSLY,,,,,,,,I LOVE THIS:) so glamourous!!!!
glamourqueen33 2 months ago
a lot of backlash, people relax!!
shes still the same ashley!
ModishlyMystifying 2 months ago