Breakdown [[Amy Lee and Shaun Morgan]]

[Jannibean]

he says specifically in an interview stated this was not about amylee, it was about a relationship he currently ended, its on mtv interviews webpage.

[ThatCatstabber]

@Jannibean Shhhh too many Amy Lee fans here,They will rage now because they are ignorant,Meet me behind the pizza place for analse- I mean...The truth..Yes...Truth

[followfornothing]

FBINS = Amy Lee

[FireflyFanatic3]

To be honest none of us are really in any position to judge. CMWYS was about Shaun, and some people might think it was really cruel of her to write and release that song, but that's just what Amy does, same as any songwriter - they have something on their mind, or something happens to hurt them so they write about it. It's exactly what Shaun has done here.

Maybe she was a bitch, maybe he was an ass, maybe they were both in the wrong. We'll never know, because it was THEIR relationship, not ours.

[hulktrolle]

@FireflyFanatic3 Amy left Shaun because he had a drinking problem... it was BAD. but he went to rehab just for her. but then she got married to a therapist by the time Shaun's rehab was over... he gace everything for her, but she believed he would never change.

[FireflyFanatic3x]

@hulktrolle maybe she just got sick of him coming home drunk all the time. But it doesn't matter, it's not our relationship, we weren't in it, we can't really judge because he was an alcoholic and abusive, but maybe she was a bitch to leave him. It's never that straight-cut. Nobody but them know exactly what went on in the rooms of their house(s) and the conversations and arguments they had. They're personal lives should remain personal, not really any of our business.

[39Kookeez]

great song and i know it wasnt said to be "about amy lee" and it was "about someone else" because amy was "so much better" but come on shaun thats the rehab talkin, man up homie :P jk. amy lee didnt say sober was about shaun did she? i thought she said it was about the former evanescence guitarist or something...ive honestly had enough of this middle school bullshit. i dont like amy for her music mainly, the very idea of her hating on shaun at that time just cuts all ties for me. LONG COMMENT

[FireflyFanatic3]

@39Kookeez no Amy Lee has never said (to my knowledge) "Call Me When You're Sober is about Shaun Morgan" but it was pretty obvious and she's never denied it. She just says "it's pretty obvious who it's about". If it WASN'T about Shaun, then surely she'd say something to stop everyone thinking that it was, to protect both him and herself.

[seanaise]

this song is NOT about Amy Lee

[Raykosza]

No one is perfect that is what music teaches us if we were perfect we would be gods

[98abbygail]

Sigh... The song was NOT about Amy. Its about himself. He did this to Amy, and he felt bad. So, THIS WAS SUPPOSED TO BE BY AMY, not him, but she couldnt withstand to sing a a song about Shaun...

[tannerguitars]

@98abbygail then explain call me when your sober

[98abbygail]

@tannerguitars She sung that about Ben :/. The other song about Shaun is The last song i'm waisting on you. Listen to the part "Sickened in the sun. You dare tell me you love me. But you held me down, and screamed you wanted me to die"...

[OcnRckr]

@98abbygail ...Then explain the music video where he is being "Broken down" by some girl that just happens to look like Amy...

[NiNn4LGJ]

hey guys come on now.

amy is one of the most talented singers..

and shaun is good too..

their break up was of course very depressing but this is something that we can't change even though we say "amy is bitch" !

so please stop it.amy IS NOT A BITCH.!

Amy Lee is an amazing artist and a great human..you dont know what REALLY happened so shut up your motherfucking mouths.

btw seether and shaun are really cool.and this song is nice too.

thanks.!

[GarthVarnish]

@NiNn4LGJ but Amy is a chauvanistic bitch. about as bad as that Twilight bitch screwing around with a werewolf and vampire's minds. Now, I might be gay for knowing that, but that doesn't change the fact she's a bitch.

[se3ther4Lif3]

@NiNn4LGJ amy cant perform live... she sucks...

[EduardoBrundo]

@se3ther4Lif3 lol u gotta be joking... /watch?v=ahAQxFrEK3Y

if she sucks... than,mas,i don't know wtf rocks.

[EduardoBrundo]

@EduardoBrundo man*

[Thanks4TheClues]

he treated her like some plaything for when he was drunk... which was all the time.

[everyoneissleeping]

He said it's not about Amy, so it's not. Stop looking for something that is not there. It's insulting to him...

[titian1992]

this song is about amy i saw them live at rockfest 2010 and b4 this song he said " how many of you have heard the song call me when your sober?... ya FUCK THAT BITCH" then started this song.

[tannerguitars]

@titian1992 nice lol

[XBadgerOnPoppersX]

Simply to put things straight:

Fine again is about Amy Lee.

THIS song is about alcohol.

[Tomo619]

@XBadgerOnPoppersX How is Fine Again about Amy Lee? That song was from Fragile... the album they released as Saron Gas. And Then on the first Disclaimer album released as Seether. How would he write a break up song about someone before he was even with her?

[tannerguitars]

@XBadgerOnPoppersX your a dip shit

[wolfpup68]

fuck that bitch amy lee. i hope she dies

[dergru]

this song might not have been COMPLETELY written for amy lee but i guarantee u parts of it were

[TheShadowgirly]

cool

[squidgypup]

shaun even said himself, that this song is not about amy lee, it was about another relationship he had after amy lee.

god, do people think he's only had one girlfriend, being amy lee |-) ?

[snickerswirl]

your right, this isn't about her, but in some ways I just kinda wanna believe it is? She wrote Call Me When your Sober about him though... shocker right? lol

[3cn1ght]

i know.

eveyr song he writes they all think its about Amy Lee.

Im sure hes fucked more chicks than Amy Lee

I mean come on. This song was written about 3 years after the breakup

fuckin dumb

[disturbedprincess5]

when u live with or date marry whatever with someone who is constantly drinking it isnt easy at all there is no working it out unless the drinker themself wants help. u cant make someone get help if they truley dnt want to change. You dont know what its like till u live with someone who is an alcoholic. trust me. but either way the song is great :]

[XTapgirlX]

I guess you weren't smart enough to keep your mouth shut.. or in this case to stop your fingers typing..

Learn how to spell, dumbass.

[DigitalGhost94]

i love this song, very good imagery to go with it.

[amie2643]

You all keep saying that Shaun didn't want to stoop down to Amy's level but him writing this song, even if it is about a different person, is doing the same as what Amy did. How about for once we leave these artists to their own lives and let them decide what they do and don't do. If they wanna write a song about someone let them. You don't have to listen to it.

[DigitalGhost94]

the songs on finding beauty in negative spaces weren't about amy, it was another girl, ppl just think they are because they can be asked to research it.

[sweetsacrifice1000]

i think that maybe they were both in the wrong. i still like Amy AND Shaun, and Amy wasnt perfect but i guess it would hert when the one you love is being taken over by drugs. but from what i've heard Amy's never done drugs, so maybe she doesnt know how hard it is to be addicted. i think she had every right to be upset, but whatev. they've both moved on, and i still love them both. we dont know what went on, and never will. just shut up about it and enjoy the music.

[DigitalGhost94]

it was his alcohlisum, amy's never done drugs but she likes her drink.

[sweetsacrifice1000]

true, BUT, she doesnt let it take her over like he was doing. thats the difference.

[darkgoddess15]

there's a lee family video showing a b9ong in the lee household oh look shaun has a good song to but geuss what HE DOES NOT WRITE IT! why? because he actually did care about her and isn't completely bitter i feel sorry for that poor baby in her belly

[darkgoddess15]

The song isn't about her and her song was about him if you ask me amy's a fake! they always say she's so nice and sweet but somethimes you catch the real her on camera and her fans just ignore it well geuss what she's the one trying to "play the victum" this time not him! he was just trying to fix his life and she was in his face the whole time and being a bitch about it

[Emonkey105]

This song isn't about Amy Lee, he said he wasn't going to drop to her level and respond to Call Me When Your Sober. I admire him for that. Shaun said this was about his most recent ex, wich wasn't Amy.

[suthrnbell0105]

I've seen interviews with amy (here on youtube, in fact) where she says her stunt double in 'Bring Me to Life' had an ugly ass, and then call Americans illiterate and stupid. I don't know what all went down in their relationship (as do none of you) but Amy definitely started throwing rocks NOT when she released CMWYS...but when she decided to air out Shaun's dirty laundry to the world during interviews. She was way out of line for that.

[haydeee31]

EN ESTA cancion no canta amy lee yo pense que por el titulo cantava otra cancion mas con shaun aparte de broken!..bahh amy lee es mejor ! yeah!

[bloekdasschaf]

this song isnt about amy for christs sake!!! shaun said so, he didnt want to lower himself to that level and hes damn right about that, not like amy. cause thats basically what amy does, write commercial songs to talk shit about people and make money with it, then having the fans say that that was soo unique. its ridiculus! the last song im wasting on you, call me when our sober,sorry amy fans, but great s something else.

[idget222]

w.e amy duz wat she duz but who fukn cares u dnt kno y she duz it the only1 who will really kno is amy she duz it 4 her own dam reasons nt 2 fukn make money nd i mean u r sooo much better than her rite cuz ur tlkn shit on pll 2 smart 1 dam if ur nt guna say anything good bout her or shaun then dnt comment got dam

[bloekdasschaf]

calm down dude. yeah amy does it for her own reasons, but she offends and openly attacks people with it, shes no angel herself (as she shows with CMWYS, shes definetly out of line with it)and if my comments bother you dont pay attention, i respect amy for who she was and what she did, just nowadays i see how self-possesed shes become... i have a brain and dont cheerish an action from whoever if my head comes to the conclusion that it wasnt so great. im as free to speak my mind as you are, moron.

[amy4evur]

self-possessed? what amy lee are you talking about ass hole?

[bloekdasschaf]

come down your trip nerd. shes quite self-possessed now, shes bitchy towards her band, the members keep switching through, and she of course is always the angel of every argument. completley innocent cause its always the others causing trouble all alone. she talks about herslf as EV, the rests equipment, she thinks shes somethig better. shes too sure to be irreplacable. for EV that might work, but look at other bands, they act with eachother, amy keeps pushing everybody else aside. its sad,realy

[amy4evur]

blah, blah, blah, he DID say so. and he's lower than amy lee by a LONG shot. amy lee rocks!!! ev fans, let me hear ya' holler!!!

[09TEXAG]

big seether fan ...really who gives a fuck wether or not this was about amy or not! this is a kick ass song!

[KristinaLovesSeether]

Who gives a fuck if it WAS about Amy?

Just enjoy the mother fucking song.

[ellanroxy]

@KristinaLovesSeether lmao so true

[SDK2584]

@KristinaLovesSeether But was it???? :P

[campcayugaa]

its about amy lee , think about it, maybe he doesnt want to admit it but use your motherfucking brain.

[lephuocsanh]

He said it was about his most recent ex, which wasn't Amy

[bluebell091]

ok what is wrong with everyone amy lee is awesome as is shaun if you haven't got anything nice to say don't bother opening your mouth

[idget222]

i agree with u cuz thats jus a bunch of trash ur sayn bout her nd him u guys say o well all they do is rite songs nd tlk shit bout ppl well so r u smart 1s

[52mrv]

Belo Video!!!! Adorei!!! Grandes bandas!!!!

[lena5039]

I was really disappointed when Amy wrote the call me when your sober song. it was poor and wrong on her part. she said it was something that needed to be said but it didn't its something that needed to be said when she was in the relationship with Shaun but not after. she wrote the album out of hate and anger and that makes her look as bed she tried to make Shaun look. it's sad. she's an adult act like one.

[Cheesypoof389]

Shaun said it's about not letting people affect you or hurt you when they say or do things to really try to stab you in the back, he never said it's about Amy but probably a bit about her. Shaun also didn't do this to stab her in the back because he said he wouldn't go down to her level. great song altogether though GO SEETHER!!!

[amy4evur]

GO EVANESCENCE!!!!

Shaun lied, he stooped "down to her level." as if that drunk bastard was ever above her in the first place...

[Cheesypoof389]

I guess we'll never know because he never just decided to go public on practically everything, I'm not trying to start a fight but ts a matter of opinion, I still like Evanescence I'm just on Seether's side. its all a matter of opinion.

[DigitalGhost94]

she left because of his constant alcoholisium & arguements i think they could have worked thru it.

[palominharock]

um belo casal..amy and shaun forever!!!

[deaathbutterfly]

1:10 ...where was this show ?

[Dwarfyy666]

I love amy lee SHES FTW!!!

[amy4evur]

yeah, amy lee ROCKS!!!!

[nestle268]

seether rules!!! ITS NOT ABOUT AMY LEE DUMBASSES!!

[himura502]

shaun said it wasnt about amy lee it was about some girl he was going out with and every day was bad he said amy lee and him on their worst days were better then him and this womans best days

[vickynescence]

eventhough shaun said it isn't about amy, i guess that somewhere deep inside of him it acutually is..

she hurt him a lot with call me when you're sober and...i don't think he would confess that it is about her to keep his pride, but actulally it partly is..

[freakoffherleash300]

vickynescence, I agree with you completely, he's not going to say it is about Amy obviously, but we all know that it is. Anyways, Amy was out of line with Call Me When You're Sober, there's a saying that goes "keep the dirty laundry at home" or something like that lol.

I'm glad Shaun made this song, it's awesome, it's our song to those people who sing us call me when you're sober. Rock On Seether!

[Thanks4TheClues]

@vickynescence

theres some new vid of him live saying he wrote this for someone who wrote call me when youre sober for me.

[ironmaiden530]

dudes this song isnt about amy lee its about a girl liking himand trying to get only her thoughts in his head hence the music video of here taking out all the other thoughts in his head and putting in one about her and thats not amy lee becuase he clearly said in a interveiw on mtv hes not stuping down to her level and writing songs about there broken relationship the only song he ever wrote aobut her was broken that was with her she wrote call me when your sober about him cause shes a bitch

[maqto]

its sad indeed, cause he had feelings for her a while after they broke up i read some interview how he feel after fact she sang about him in"call me when.." and he didn't attacked her while he could, he even said he had worse relationship before he was with amy so he behaved like gentleman,pity amy did such a shit to him after time they spent together...

[prozzak2006]

i wonder if they ever had sex, like im curious how far their sexual relations go. just making out? 2nd base? 3rd base?

[ilikesmoothies1]

yeah if at 3rd hes lucky shes hot... oh instead of 1st, 2nd, 3rd... I use the A, B, C chart

[InesGivenToFly]

this song's not about amy . Shaun clearly said it on an interview .

[Seether2769]

lol dude shaun said it numorous amount of times that this is the only song off the album that is about amy n that he took the high road instead of calling her mean things.. Maybe learn ur history b4 u say anything

[gocuathotmail]

wrong he has never said it about amy

[gu1tarister]

Seether's beast

[Busaridermazz]

No matter what you all say- Shaun's heart ,is gotta still feel somethin, for Amy,and its that lil bit of emotion ,that had to have a lil, impact on him writing this:Musician to Musician-

[wareagle5inarow]

ok i hate to say what everybody else has said but shaun didn't write this because of amy lee he doesn't need her to write like she needs him.

[grungerocks5055]

omfg nerd, this song isnt about amy lee, shaun didn't want to go down to her level of acting .. you should know wth u are talking about

[ibridgebulldog]

i am so jealous of you helljason ! i wanna goto one of their concerts ! crisscreations just seems like a fag ! :D

[helljason]

amy got engaged to terry about 6 month ago... she said it in one of her gigs when people were asking questions... she said that terry has asked to marry her n she said yes....

n if you have a look at all the song they both write... it does a bit seem like they are pulling and pushing eachother somehow...

i lovem both anyway.. bt ibridgebulldog i agree with you... amy does kick ass... the consert evanescence had in sydney was 1000 better than the one seether had..

[MinimizeMyself]

um, terry?

oh no, no no.

she got married to some therapist.

[XoSnOwWHiTeQuEEnoX]

josh hartzler =]

[yunagirl1249]

She married her long time friend Josh Hartzler

[ibridgebulldog]

you know what crisscreations don't dis amy lee she kicks ass

[XoSnOwWHiTeQuEEnoX]

true that! amy is AMAZING!!!

[tom36450]

This song is not about amy lee. saun has said over and over again that none of his songs are about amy lee. JESUS!

[jetz1976]

By the sound of it, shaun has been through alot, he just wanted to have something good in his life and to be loved, Amy obviously was incapable of doing such a thing, what a lovely lady hey? not

[kornmaggot73]

Yea this song came out way before his bro died and he never actually came out and said its about amy he actually said he is letting ppl take it how they want so im assuming its about amy leaving him instead of helping him through his drug problems and saying shell always be there for him but the video comes out soon will see what it means to him. P.S. Seether is way more musically talented them amy lee.

[xoxoEvanescence]

did she cheat on him? i heard that but idk.

[FFXSoul91]

No.

[AllYouNeedIsRock1]

very good songI love it!! But dude... Rise Above This is NOT about Amy... it's about his brother... If there's one song for Amy in FBINS it's this one.

BTW I also love Call Me When You're Sober.

[crisscreations]

CallM e When Your Sober is better than this song....Rise Above This however may make Shaun Rise Above Amy

[countryboy23054]

I agree with fakinghellissweet the bitch made an unfair move and for what reason? Just because of a bad breakup? He just lost his brother for peets sake.

[redbaby88]

this might be the only one of his songs about her, but no one is sure, shaun won't say who the songs are really about, he wants the fan to think for themselves

[frenzicffion]

no, no.

he said himself that none of the album had anything to do with amy lee, and he said if any of the song had any thought about her it was breakdown (breakdown isn't entirely about amy by the way)

[colemusic90]

no.

[fakinghellissweet]

Amy's a BITCH,the guy lost his brother and to deal with the pain he started drinking alot and she breaks up with him becoz hes drinking,he checks into rehab and she goes and brings out call me when your sober the same day he enters rehab.

Talk about someone kicking you when your down

[redbaby88]

his bro didn't die until 2007, call me when your sober came out in 2006, he went into rehab because of drugs, n that was in 2006, b4 his brother's death

[3DGIsLife]

shaun didn't write ANYTHING about amy, he's said himself. there's no songs about her on this record. he didn't lash out at her, like she did at him. he has these crazy things called morals.

[kalliehella]

I know as a song writer my self breakups and relationships are the best things to write about. So when he says that he didn't write one song about Amy after they broke up and it being a long relationship it is very hard to believe that none of the songs are about her.

[slipkris23]

please people this song it's about her ,from the same way the open door it's abouth him,in the part of this song when he says "hate me break me dowm" sound like "amy break me down"

[XlivingXtheXdreamX]

He's just saying that none of the new songs were about Amy because he claimed he wouldn't do that. But seriously what else could it be about?

[drums22gdrkelly]

i dont think fuck me like you hate me is toward amy lee

[evilkrikett]

This is not about Amy Lee!

No songs on this album are!

[idriss666]

R u sure he saud that there no songs about her but when we listen fmlyhm or breakdown

[evilkrikett]

are you kidding me fmlyhm?

[redbaby88]

fmlyhm is about a realitonship that is only about sex

[evilkrikett]

Yeah and not amy lee. The songs are not about her.

[yopeeps123123]

Go to the damn website and look at why he wrote fmlyhm!!

[yopeeps123123]

I just relized that me and shaun both have a mole on out necks in the same exact place. ODD!

[yopeeps123123]

Shaun claims that he didn't write this song about Amy and said that if he wrote it about someone it would be about his newest breakup. But it has a piano in it and I think he put that in there because it is about her.

[QuamAmoena]

The songs let me think about a similar song: The Last Song I'm Wasting On You of Amy lee

[Butterflie1617]

The Last Song I'm Wasting on You was about Ben Moody but Call Me When You're Sober is about Shaun

[QuamAmoena]

I know, but it just reminds me of it.

[yopeeps123123]

This video is better than mine

[disclaimer05]

Shaun made some bad choices, he even stated it was "lame that I was reduced to a slobbering drunk". However, for Amy to go out and tell everyone what went wrong and what happened between them wasnt right at all, you just dont do that! Not only that but I'm sure there was so much more going on between them than we'll ever know, so dont judge Amy nor Shaun for their very public break up.

[Goodenough12]

i don't know i think shaun morgan kinda of lose the game because he lost LOVE,TRUST,AND AMY...I can't belive he choose beer and drugs over her...i would of have never ever given up on her..

[frenzicffion]

Goodenough12 (4 months ago)

i don't know i think shaun morgan kinda of lose the game because he lost LOVE,TRUST,AND AMY...I can't belive he choose beer and drugs over her...i would of have never ever given up on her..

-x-

oh my god, he had an ADDICTION

what was he supposed to do or say?

"oh yeah, amy, i'm going to just drop my addiction in the next 5 minutes because i love you baby. not like it's hard or anything"

that shit takes time.

he went to rehab, if you didn't know.

[coledhein]

hey dumbass he didnt choose it his brother commited suicide he lost controll

[daysaliving]

aww his bro killed himself :(

[heart1612]

this is a great song, he is a very very amazing musician, but I don't blame Amy for putting him out there like that. He must've hurt her real bad to make her do that. She was truly in love with him.

[ffionluvstina]

He drank? Wow.

[yopeeps123123]

shaun too depressed to tell the world that the song his about Amy

[Homelys]

Agreeed

[SFErocker4life]

If this song was about Amy

i think shaun did a better job

of being mature about it.

and not telling the world her

problems everyone has problems

and she doesn't have the right

to write a song about it

thats real immature

[jazer426]

amy lees call me when your sober helped boost shuan it didnt hurt him in any way and hes said this song is more about his last girlfriend which wasnt amy lee plus call me when your sober is an amazing song if you ever been in a relationship with some one who no longer is capable of being in a relationship

[girlee1988]

hey i totally agree with u!!!

bout him sobering up cuz she kinda helped him with the song!!! he wouldn't go to the rehab if there wasn't amy!!and call me when u sober really is a great song!!! but breakdown is an amazing song 2!! i admit it!!!

[AnObscenity]

Actually, the song is more a response to Call me when you're sober.

Hence " Break me down if it makes you feel right, and hate me now if it keeps you alright"

Which is what she was doing with the song, Trying to break him down.

[jazer426]

i dont think so i think she was getting some bad pressure off her you know her music is letting out her feelings she had every right to do it. she did not break shaun down in any way. We know amys wrote songs about ben so why the big clash on her for making one about shaun. Shaun even said the songs were for his most recent ex which was not amy .

[yopeeps123123]

fmlyhm lol

[yopeeps123123]

agreed. He wrote broken for his ex wife. What if he wrote that one that goes fuck me like u hate me for her? XD

[zeemx]

lol he wrote broken for his ex wife and sung it with amy thats ironic

[S33TH3RRACH3L]

broken was about his daughter

[gathalion7]

hell no

broken is about his daughter

[AnObscenity]

Broken was for his daughter.

[eternalXdamnation]

its an absoultly beautiful song <3

and i know its about her

and i personally think its a way better song than call me when your sober

its just so beautifully writer and sung

shaun is an amazing musician

[goldberg107]

ya he just wanted this song to be less of an attack against her than her song was to show hes still better

[ytyga]

it is actually about her, but just not a retaliation to call me when you're sober