Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (42)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Robin is the best loop man because he dance with it

  • robin looks so disgusted at 1:58

  • The thing i hate about this version compared to the "and all that could have been" version i the ending. As much as i love the "The only time" breakdown, its not as good as simply playing the song as it originally was on the album. That is, with the keyboard outro (also see the woodstock version of this song for how its supposed to sound).

  • Saw NIN in Clarkston last year--they didn't have this on the set-list, the show itself was missing quite a bit, didn't bring all that they could have, but still a good show

  • I saw NIN perform in Mexico City in 2008, it was one of the greatest shows I've ever been in...... the sound was amazing, and the lights were incredible!!!

  • The close ups on JMJ are pretty sick 2:51 and 2:56

  • robin doesnt have bad days

  • LOLLLL

    <3 ROBIN!!!

    he jus rolls his eyes

  • I looooooooooove closer live

  • lol @ Robin.

  • About 2:00 Robin looked so

    Annoyed, bored or both

  • yeah i know....maybe he was having a bad day?

  • @elfpuck69V2

    Yeah I noticed that, Robin rolling his eyes back as if he didn't want to be there. Strange.

  • @Westwoodisapleb

    He's probably making his own fun. My bet is that he gets pretty bored playing this song.

  • @Asciipanda & everyone else:

    My personal take on it is that he's simply acting

  • @Asciipanda

    Would you get 'pretty bored' of playing in NIN?

  • I thought he was just trying to pull a sleazy look (given the song's content)

  • fucking masterpiece!!!!

  • This video makes me furious with myself that I didn't hit the NIN show while I could last year. Oh well.. they're fantastic captured live, as well. [:

    Goddamn amazing song.

  • Had the same feeling today, could have gone to Rock Werchter but decided to go to another festival somewhere else, shame on me

  • Beautiful love song. Makes me feel all warm and fuzzy.

  • Cool how robin continues aaron north's guitar fill in in the between bits, though the best performance of this song was probably on All that could been live where he molests robin's face and pretends to jack off with a water bottle onto danny lohner at the end.

  • @jesusonectasy

    ...............I haven't seen And All That Could Have Been, I think I need to now.

  • @jesusonectasy agreed, this one is great but AATCHB was EPIC

  • @jesusonectasy I dunno, Woodstock performance was pretty rad.

  • The look on robin's face at 1:59 is awesome!

  • OMG I literally ROFL'd. What the fuck!? Did he pass out or something when the camera switched?

  • wow, best live performance of this song i've ever seen----way to go ThisOneIsOnUs!

  • I so love this version w/the break down..can't sit still!!

  • this is the best 3d light show I have seen so far on earth!

  • ehh i didnt know he did that effect for Closer, I loved it when he did it with The Greater Good though.

  • Lol, he sticks out his tongue at 0:27.

  • Thats fucking weird

  • Love the video FX!

  • its not

  • @starstruckstarfuck i think your ears are shit

  • incredible

  • This looks even sexier than I imagined. And I'm not talking about Closer...

  • Ugh. Awesome.

  • :) niceeeE

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more