Added: 2 years ago
From: NostalgiaCriticFan4
Views: 70,548
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (569)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Stir. Whip. Whip. Stir. Stir. Whip. Whip. Stir. Stir. Stir. Whip. Stir.

  • I love die hard but i still would not call it a christmas

  • americans were the only ones who couldnt do a ceasefire because americans are violent and retarded, so during ww1&2 ceasefires no one told america and just let them have the day off because they knew amerifans wouod be fucking dumb and might blow everyone up or something. Btw he missed out only fools and horses.

  • what about SCROOGE (1970)???

  • NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!

    

  • Comment removed

  • How about "Love Actually?"

  • me: i am sorry but it is the truth young one

  • Critic, thank you so much for introducing me to 'Jojeux Noël'. Best movie I've watched last christmas.

  • Sorry, but the way he pronounces "Joyeux" made me burst out laughing. It was barely close! Type it into Google Translate to see for yourselves. Its kind of like "j-why-you" NOT "joy-uice".

  • im going 2 tell u guys my top 12 christmas specials #12 family guy road to the north pole #11 miracle on 34th street (1947) #10 twas the night before christmas (1974) #9 mickeys christmas carol #8 unaccompained minors #7 home alone 2 lost in new york #6 how the grinch stolne christmas (1966) #5 gift wrapped (a looney tunes cartoon) #4 the fright before christmas (a looney tunes cartoon) #3 AVGN bible games 2 #2 a charlie brown christmas and #1 its a wonderful life

  • to all of you who are complaing about nightmare before Christmas remember there are more then the 22 he has talked about in the show and it's his opinion and he might see nightmare before christmas as a halloween film, maybe this year in 2012 he will do another list including it but to me a see it more as a halloween movie because i think that's what tim burton was going for rather then a christmas movie

  • y u no include nightmare before christmas?

  • A NIGHTMARE BEFORE CHRISTMAS?!

    HELLOOO-O-OOO?!!

  • @13mungoman13 *cough HALLOWEEN cough*

  • @nightbane2 No. It's definitely a Christmas movie. Just look at the FRIGGIN' TITLE of the movie.

  • would you believe the events of Joyeux Noël was true............. no really it happened i learned it in school both sides decided to stop fighting for christmas and they was playing football, laughing, talking eating together, then after christmas one side wrote merry christmas on a white flag and the other side wrote merry christmas to you too and the war resumed.

  • im suprised its a wonderful life isnt on the list

  • @AaronWallace011 remember the list is the top 11 next best christmas spiecals so there is another list

  • @thelashers o ok

  • Probably wouldn't have picked Die Hard as No. 1, but it's definitely on my list, because...well, y'know... IT'S DIE HARD!

    Joyex Nöel sounds like a movie I need to see, but I don't know if I'm looking forward to it - I'm a very emotional person and don't like sad movies. And it's a WW1 movie... (which means you know all the characters you connect with will probably die sometime later in the war).

  • It's DIE HARD!

  • Bruce Willis was great in Die Hard.

  • i didn't care for the snowman

  • @Cornwiggle dude what is wrong with you? Sicko:(

  • The best Christmas special is BLACK CHRISTMAS (1974).

  • Tokyo Godfathers FTW

  • @Klonoa7H shit off with anie bull shit its christmas watch gremlins

  • @98Lubo learn how to spell "anime" -.-

  • @Eilae96 no 

  • Die hard 1 and 2 were the best die hard movies IMO

  • Lethal weapon isn't on here? Oh well....

  • I think Christmas Comes But Once a Year should have been on this list

  • if die hard is a christmas movie then batman returns should've been on here

  • If you want to have a scary little Christmas, you gotta watch Silent Night,Deadly Night, Christmas Evil, and Black Christmas!

  • @Leatherbubba There's also Santa's Slay, but that's more of a horror- comedy, with an emphasis on the comedy part.

  • @Adamguy2003 There's also the Jack Frost movies, Rare Exports, and Don't Open Til' Christmas.

  • @Leatherbubba If you're looking for chrimbo horror films, I'd advise you also check out "Don't Open Till Christmas" (a british horror film), tales from the crypt's "And All Through the House", "To All a Goodnight" and "Silent Night, Bloody Night" (NO, not the film you mentioned, this is a different one). Also, there's a couple of others but they're rather mediocre.

  • i did get a little teary eyed at the end of the pinky and the brain one

  • When I first saw this, I raised an eyebrow when he chose Die Hard, but when he defended his choice with "Fuck you, ITS DIE HARD!" You really can't argue against that.

  • I just finished The Nativity Story. He's completely right about the rushed spiritual aspect of the film. The angel's speech is cut off in the middle when he comes to Joseph in a dream!! There's also no choir of angels appearing to the shepherds so that's a little disappointing. That being said, it is a good movie, you should definitely check it out.

  • You know considering the choices, they were good, but sorry if im lime the billionth person saying this, why wouldint he add tim burtons nightmare before christmas? Its a vlassic movie, that as far as i can remember had been shown in both halloween AND christmas, also to add he added the 'this is halloween' song in his top 11 mind f@?k's, just makes me think, like why not? You know...... But lol fuck you, it's die heart :D

  • "Fuck you, it's die hard!!"

    Best quote evah!!!!

  • "FUCK YOU, IT'S DIE HARD!!!"

    Amen to that! XD

  • How can you go wrong with Pinky and the Brain? I'll tell you.

    ELMYRA

  • Well, If it does make you feel any better about 'The Snowman', there was a special made by the same guy called 'Father Christmas', which is set a Year later (I think) and at one part; he meets the Boy and the Snowman again and says "Glad you can make it again...The party I mean..."

    So, if it offers any happiness, we can safely say the Boy was able to rebuild him... ;3

    That's good to hear, eh? ;3

  • For all you Die Hard haters out there, "Yipie kai ay, mother f**ker".

  • @meatballguy1 I've always wanted to say that to someone.....

  • @meatballguy1 Yay!  XD

  • @meatballguy1 You mean "Fuck you! It's Die Hard!"?

  • Goblin please everyone knows the spirit of Chanukah is a zombie

  • The ending is priceless!

  • Hate reviewers like IGN to make some of these holiday films go underated!

  • Comment removed

  • Another good Christmas movie that I ADORE and not many people know about is a little gem called The Ref, with Denis Leary. Trading Places is another enjoyable Christmas movie. But, I agree with the Critic on #1. Fuck you, it's Die Hard!!!

  • I almost died laughing when he said "die hard"...such an awesome movie

  • the amazing thing is the Christmas truce of 1914 ACTUALLY HAPPENED

    two sides peacefully coexisting for one day, then mercilessly killing each other the next

    I will never understand human psychology

  • Where's Nightmare Before Christmas?!? Kidnap the Sandy Claws always puts me in the Holliday mood!

  • FUCK YOU ITS DIE HARD

  • So the Director of Nativity, a movie about our lord and savior is also the director of Twilight a movie about gay vampires.... God's not pleased with that.

  • So...the guy who did the Nativity...did Twilight?

    Okay, I'm never watching THAT film ever.

  • FUCK YOU IT'S DIE HARD!

  • If Christmas ever went back to that Jesus-loving retardation, I would literally stop celebrating it. I like it as a gift giving, fun time of year with family, not anything religious.

  • "BITCH YOU PREGNANT, BAI!"

  • Saying "FUCK YOU IT'S DIE HARD!" is about as solid a way to win an argument as merely saying "Because I'm Batman!"

  • Fuck you it's Die Hard!

  • Oh yeah. I ALWAYS break out Die Hard in December!

  • the Nostalgia Critic's "no" is more epic than Darth Vader's.

  • LOLZ ANTI SIMITES THE HANIKA GOBLIN !!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Joyeux Noël sounds like a great movie. I need to find it before Christmas comes.

  • @billruller It is a pretty good movie, if you don't mind reading subtitles.

  • @billruller it is

  • @billruller It IS a good movie. Just saw it and like the critic says, you're in for something special.

  • Many people consider Nightmare Before Christmas to be more so of a Halloween movie, due to the story, for the most part, taking place in Halloweentown and involving the creatures of Halloween. It IS a Christmas/Halloween crossover, but is typed as a 'Halloween' movie.

  • Isnt Joyeux Noël also called Merry Christmass? I saw the cover in a video store and the synopsis was the same as the nostalgia critic says but the name is Merry Christmass

  • @srnefe It's French for 'Merry Christmas', and also I think the critic pronounced the name wrong, then again... it's a 'tomato/tomato' thing. But yeah, 'Joyeux Noel' is personally my number 1 favourite christmas film.

  • 7:31

    7:35

    7:41

    Sounds like questions Douchey Mcnitpick would ask

  • joyeux noel sounds like a really good story, defiently gonna watch it this christmas

  • i hate the snowman the song is one of the most annoying things you could ever hear

  • The Nativity Story? Seriously? I hate that movie. It gets alot of things wrong such as Joseph's character who would never stone Mary. He doubted whether she sinned or not and it BUTCHERS Mary's character. She isn't a whiny, sulky, unbelieving bitch, She has total faith in God, knows He loves her, is very devout, spent her childhood studying in the temple of Jerusalem and is an all round sweet, kind and lovable woman. You need a person who at least knows about Christianity to direct such a film.

  • My mum's favourite Christmas movie is Four Rooms, but Die Hard's her second XD

  • Whats that song playing during die hard

  • the director of nativity also directed red riding hood does she want wolves in the bible?

  • Bitch your pregnant!!! Bye!!!

  • NOPE. Life sucks. Merry Christmas. :l

  • joyeux noel is the best and sadest story ive ever heard. im glade that more people now about it

  • @supernerdccs How can you spell "Joyeux Noel" and not saddest, I've, I'm, glad and know?

  • He should do a Top 11 Halloween specials...THEN he can add Nightmare Before Christmas!

    ...Call me crazy, though, but I didn't like that movie. The songs were great, however.

  • FUCK YOU! IT'S DIE HARD!

    That reason is as legit as BECAUSE I'M BATMAN!!!

  • I love the Nickelodeon Christmas specials, too. The Spongebob one is okay, the Rugrats ones are classic, but the one that always gets to everyone is the Hey Arnold! Christmas special. The "Merry Christmas, Arnold" at the end...*sniff*.

  • I've ah... never seen Die Hard...

  • 1:20 the long pause after that, lol

  • Die Hard is SO Christmasy! Theres red and twinkling lights everywhere! Red blood and the flashing lights of sub machine guns?! What else says christmas like that?

  • perssonaly i see this video every day again just for the ending with star wars special preview ....

  • oh no ! Twilight !!!! run for your lives !!!! XD oh and 6:37 i agree with NC stupid movie .

  • Comment removed

  • Die hard is fucking awesome. I agree a christma classic

  • All in the Family is the greatest sitcom ever made.

  • This list is well done and everything, but where the f*** is Nightmare Before Christmas? I don't expect it to be #1 or anything, but SOMEWHERE on the list would be nice.

    Also, DIE HARD!!!! :D

  • @SJTreeHugger I bet he will make a trilogy of this and maybe in the top 5.

  • @SJTreeHugger That's a Halloween movie, god damn you.

  • @Applemask It can be both a Halloween AND a Christmas movie. I mean, it DOES have the word CHRISTMAS in the title, you know.

  • @Indyfilms123 NO DAMN YOU I WILL NOT YIELD

  • @SJTreeHugger i think the reason it wasn't was because, like my self, NC probably saw it as more of a Halloween movie than a Christmas movie. I watch it on halloween every year, but never really find myself in the mood to watch it for christmas.

  • Twilight-NC: Aaaaaa.....

  • Won't Jesus be ashamed of the director who directed Twilight after he or she directed the Navitvity.

  • Freude schöner Götterfunken, Tochter aus Elysium, wir betreten feuertrunken Himmlische dein Heiligtum. Deine Zauber binden wieder, was die Mode streng geteilt. Ale Menschen werden Brüder wo dein sanfter Flügel weilt!

  • "anything but this" ok how about a bat credit card in your stocking?

  • IT'S DIE HARD BI*CHES!!!

  • Jôyeuss Nowel :D ! Strange french accent !

  • The red portion of the likes bar is the size of Justin Bieber's dick.

  • @FrozenKoolAidDude nooo the size of it is one of his testicles

  • @legopivotboy What testicles?

  • @FrozenKoolAidDude oh , i forgot about that. then it is the size of his vagina

  • @legopivotboy That's an insult to females.

  • @FrozenKoolAidDude sorry about that. it was ment as an insult to bieber though

  • @legopivotboy You see the headline that he was wearing women's pants? (or more like wearing a man's shirt)

  • @FrozenKoolAidDude ok, now youre con fusing me. lets end this discosion now

  • @legopivotboy I'm serious! He was! Check the Yahoo! headlines.

  • Joyeux (Jwie-ou)

  • The snowman looks like a creepy film.

  • @csbattlebot NO! It's not creepy! It's incredibly sweet....

  • "Joyeux Noel" is such a brilliant film. You really do get the emotional feeling when all sides agree to stop fighting and become friends. That is the true meaning of christmas :)

  • batman returns???

  • Why are people annoyed that NC missed a lot of specials? He can't mention them all, while many of them aren't even Nostalgic. A recent special I've seen was in Community, and while the series sort of bores me I LOVED the special. It had the meaning of Christmas with almost every perspective; even cynics got limelight. It was great, but certainly not Nostalgic.

  • Every year, my family gets together to watch the Nativity. My dad has a version with the innocent Massacre, and I was freak'n SEVEN! It was traumatizing to see a little kid, who was just sitting there, who had to be just a few years younger than I was, and see a roman on a horse ride up and impale the kid with his spear! And breaking into a house and killing a baby? I know that's how it literaly happened, but really? It was R-rated, and my dad could have had a little more sense!

  • okay i admit it,s DIE HARD but the gremlins should been number 1 diehard 2

  • Comment removed

  • Well since you like Die hard as a Christmas movie, then what about the Godfather? People always say that is a Holiday classic. Yea, nothing says Christmas like men beating their wives with belts, getting shot with Tommy Guns, and finding the severed head of your prized horse in bed with you.

  • @Dragon1813 Heh... Merry Christmas...

  • I hate the snow man! I hate it! Hate! Hate! Hate! Hate Hate!

  • I'm surprised that the ending of The Snowman didn't make it on the list of Saddest Nostalgic Moments. I can remember crying at the end of the film. But it's still incredibly beautiful!

  • HOW DARE YOU NOT SAY ARTHUR'S PERFECT CHRISTMAS!

  • i watched joyeux noel in history not long ago. pretty touching film

  • The Spongebob Christmas Special, "Christmas Who?"

    was made in 1999, 2000, or 2001.

  • Anything made in the 1999s are Nostalgic.

    SPONGEBOB CHRISTMAS SPECIAL!

  • No Batman Returns? 

  • Those Yoda interruptions are actually pretty creepy now that NC has already reviewed Star Wars Christmas. It's like we know what he's gonna have to endure. lol

  • I'm kind of surprised, no White Christmas? At all?

  • You have to be fucking kidding me...

    NIGHTMARE BEFORE FUCKING CHRISTMAS!!!! >:O

  • @XxusagibunnyxX A lot people really do debate this movie. Some consider it a Halloween movie while others consider it a Christmas Movie. I consider it both, I watch it around Halloween and Christmas.

  • @XxusagibunnyxX yeah, where's that at?! i watch it every year, halloween and christmas. what the hell NC, you even said it was good, so why not in this countdown?

  • Lethal Weapon is another great Christmas action movie.

  • When I first heard his choice of Die Hard I thought what? But when he argued "Fuck you. ITS DIE HARD!"  You really can't argue against that/

  • I can't BELIEVE that the same director who directed Nativity Story did Twilight.

    It really depresses me....

  • @BelovedCaptain I know, I thought that too.

    But that's okay. I still enjoyed the movie, and I love sitting around the fire with family on Christmas Eve to watch one of the few Christmas specials that actually shows children the true meaning of Christmas.

  • @GoldenFlither15 Oh I love it too... but I think the director should stop directing films like Twilight and do some wholesome movies..like Nativity Story.

    I think she directed Red Riding Hood and I heard that was just as bad as Twilight.

  • @BelovedCaptain Oh man, avoid 'Red Riding Hood' at all costs. It really does make the 'Twilight' movies look like 'Casablanca' (which is an exaggeration, but hopefully my point's clear).

    I totally agree. Wouldn't you say it's kind of ironic as well? From a story so holy and sacred as that of the Nativity, to a story so evil - in every sense of the word - as 'Twilight'? I thought that was kind of interesting. ;)

  • @GoldenFlither15 Interesting? You're too kind. :) It's pathetic.

  • @BelovedCaptain *laughs* Touche.

  • @BelovedCaptain Same here. How do you go from making something as amazing as the Nativity Story to Twilight? It's worst than Don Bluth.

  • Claymation Christmas? WTF.....

  • His reaction to the Star Wars Christmas Special is epic!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • I thought die hard was a joke... he's still right, though

  • "a package for me? well, eh, ok. thanks!"

    *Chewbacka rawr*

    "What a wierd looking mailman..."

    LOL!

  • BITCH YOU PREGNANT! BYE!

  • What's the song used when the Critic talks about the Nativity Story?

  • @BigDC100 It's from the Nativity Story soundtrack. It's a rendition of "O Come, O Come Emmanuel."

  • Mr. Krueger's Christmas, with Jimmy Stewart. That movie will bring you to your knees in tears.

  • 4 dislikes?!

    FUCK YOU IT'S DIE HARD!!!!!!!!!

  • Yippe kay yei madafaka!!!!

  • Merry Christmas Mother Fucker!

  • home alone 1 and 2?

  • @34RiverStone Top 12 Christmas Special

  • @Yami6692 oh.  he he

  • @34RiverStone home alone 1 was in the top 12 list

  • @UltimaGamer1 i know - i saw the top 12 list recently :)

  • @34RiverStone home alone 1 was on his top 12 christmas list (which predates this list)