Added: 3 years ago
From: RealIdolFans
Views: 107,028
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (235)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Close, but it's Bob Dylan

  • Bob Dillon ?

  • hes soo preety!

  • Of all lines to mess up in this song how could he mess up part of the chorus...

  • And the NA NA NA NA NA NAA NA NA NA, BATMAN!

  • I love him too . hes just a beautifull soul . What has happened lately to his career I hope all is well with him . Hes a demigod incarnate

  • @mumsworry1 Jason Castro is a Born-Again Christian and he recently released a CD called, "Who I Am". Its really good! You can check out one of the songs on my channel in the uploads section, its called"That's What I'm here For".

  • he sounded like river phoenix in the movie the thing called love

  • even after being told hes going home basicly, he was STILL smiling and laughing, thats a true man having a truely ggood time

  • He Mr Jason .....You are totally sleepy and there is a place you are going to :) home

  • @Palladino200 hey,try joining American Idol and make to top 4..okay? =)

  • @yt0n1234

    tell this to Simon

  • Butchered.

  • diesb't sound so bad

  • jason i love you! and this performance! even the part you messed up! :)

  • not as good as the original but i love him still

  • JASON YOU ARE THE BEST !!!

  • :D he forgot the words!

    oh my god i wanna marry him.

  • jjjj

  • i dont understand why people are watching videos of people and things that they hate not trying to bee mean but seriuosly save us all some time and dont watch them at all

  • really? he really forgot the lyrics? how clumsy ;P it´s a nice guy with a nice voice and nice rastas!!!

  • Awful, in my opinion.

    Shame he wrecked a really good song. I'm going to go away now and listen to the real thing just to correct this situation.

  • ha this fool don't even know the words i dont care ....i'm better!

  • I have a version where Bob himself forgot his own words!!!!

  • the song is great but everyone can sing it... in a singing contest this song counts for nothing

  • this boy smokes! he happy all the time! haha

  • If he would have not forgotten the words he would have nailed this performance, he sounded amazing!!

  • heh wolfmotha 77.....if you fuckin quit posting all that JEWISH "office" bullshit and actually posted a comment of any signifigance you would understand why he left out those words......ya fuckin goof

  • hes amazing, should'a wonn :}

  • I think the words thing was a accidently on purpose thing. I think it was stick it to the judges time. He was over it. Between Paula criticizing a song he hadn't sung yet in front of the live audience, and the garbage he took about his Bob Marley song...he was just done.

  • @wolfmotha77 No harsh feelings, I am just stating my opinion. And I understand that he made the top 12. All though I personally think that Tim Urban, Amanda Overmyer, and Jason Castro are the least talented (I understand that you're a fan, and I don't mind that. We can all have our opinions, but could we be polite to one another.)

  • @AnnieTigerChucky jason castro has a great voice so if he missed a few words that makes him a bad singer?

  • It's good he took out the words..

    American Idol is a fake,

    They try to choose one person they can make money off of for 5 years, then choose crappy singers to compete against them.

  • yes he did do that on purpose..because he wanted to leave

  • im pretty sure he blazed before every performance

    and thats why he was so fuckin happy all the time

    my hero :)

    haha

    hes sucha cutie

  • like eye said before he did not forget those words...if you listen to the original version from the byrds you will understand....lets see he sang a marley song than this song and left out key sentences on purpose...am i right or am i right.....damn lambs

  • He forgot words in ONE song. Several other idols from S7 also forgot words at one point too (or substituted wrong words) Archie, Carly, Brooke, and David Cook. Jason's self-titled debut album is out on April 13th.

  • cmon you guys your not that stupid are you....he left those words out on purpose....do you people understand anything.....damn lambs

  • He, Tim Urban, and Amanda Overmyer were the worst singers EVER to make top 12.

  • @AnnieTigerChucky I agree with you on Tim Urban, he sucked. Amanda and Jason were good.

  • I love him tons- I have heard this many times and still love it:)

  • I mean cute kid!:)

  • Who cares if he made a mistake! He has such a cute personality and handles things so good, he has a good spirit about him!!! He is such a good singer!!! what a cut kid!!!

  • I bet he smokes pot

  • @chadiushobby Really? Ya think?

  • That was a train wreck :) I didn't realize that American Idol was a comedy.

  • rly funny (no offense to jason) and you (RealIdolFans) spelled Dylan wrong...

  • he*

  • hes handled it well, he just kept on going (:

  • Jasonn can make mistakes he still sounds awesome and has such a presence noone can take away!

  • good singer ;) haha i think he would've gotten to the top 2 if he hasn't forgotten the words.

  • I looooooved him singing this. Wish he hadn't forgotten the words, haha :)

  • Jason Castro made American idol cool with his chill songs and his careless attitude in the competition.

  • agreed.

  • wow...wonder if fox is partnered with this company...doubt it.

  • he forgot some lines

  • @vannahspark i think he wanted to get off this week lol

  • roflcopter

  • i love jason castro!!! my gosh he is fineeeee! he did an amazing job!

  • as if no one in the world has ever forgotten the lyrics while singing a song they know by heart. i forget lyrics when singing in my car all the time to songs i have known since i was a young kid. shit happens leave him alone he's great.

  • Sure shit happens, its not the end of the world... but the fact still remains that this is a *talent* competition... Singing songs- remembering lyrics- it's what they're there to do, and be judged on... So obviously he's going to get flak for messing up. Why be so protective? Any typical producer/manager/venue owner would have torn him to pieces for this performance...

  • i'm not being protective i'm just saying it's not a big deal at all and it's old to talk about it since it happened like 2 years ago lmao.

  • you cant sing like bob dylan he has a very unique voice i always stuggle to play dylan songs even thou the chords are easy i always find it hard singing hes songs

  • actually bob dylan's voice isn't really as unique as you think he actually copied his voice from woody guthrey's voice so it's not really an organic voice.

  • yeah i think he was done in the performance before this when he did "I shot the sheriff" he laughs everythime simon starts talking

  • ROTFL @ :22

  • Comment removed

  • Big deal, he forgot some Bob Dylan lyrics. Only the most difficult songs (lyric wise) the world will ever see.

  • He totally did that on purpose. Look how happy he was when he left...

  • @OfficialTheresaCrall why would he do it on purpose? he was happy for one of two reasons. 1. he was high. 2. he didnt care

  • Big deal. He forgot some lyrics. He's still humble and adorable,has a huge fan base and landed a deal with Atlantic Records. Gotta give him credit for his belief in himself and for his perseverance...

  • LOOK ITS POOPLOCKS LOLZ.

  • jokerwalrusmusic i agree with u haha

  • lol he didnt know the lyrics but i love him =D

  • no shit

    did you notice jason was singing that song

    oh and did it say jason wrote this song?

  • in your description it said it was bob dillon. way to not know anything about music.

  • its called a typo

    get a fucking life

  • it wasn't even a dig at you, man. you oughta chill. if someone spelled jason castro's name wrong people would be all over them, so why can't i be all over somebody for misspelling the name of the greatest songwriter in history?

  • it's just a typo

    and dylan is the greatest songwriter, I've played many dylan tributes

  • david archuleta, david cook... like... each 60 times better... he had no chance of winning against them both... plus he forgot the words through the middle

  • fuck you

  • He did that INTENTIONALLY. TPTB never wanted him in the Finale in the first place, so the best thing to do for him was to throw in the towel, phone in his performances and act chill about it. Never have I seen a person with such a cool attitude towards his pre-destined fate...

  • yea i can agree with u tht he is an incredibly nice guy although... maybe he did do it intentionaly... just i thought it didnt sound extremely good... good singer but i wasnt sure about his performance

  • He did that as an FU to the judges for Paula's gaffe the week before. It pretty much affected him from the second perfie during that week up to the time he got eliminated.

  • i love his hair back like that

  • Simon is an ass for telling Jason to 'pack his suitcase'. Jason's too good for American Idol anyway! He was the most original and unique and that, people, is an idol! Can't wait for his CD =)

  • i totally agree i loved him and he is the one i come back to listen too i forget half of the david cook songs

  • AT 9:10 SOMEONE WILL CALL YOU OR TALK TO YOU ONLINE AND SAY I LOVE YOU OR ASK YOU OUT BUT HERES THE CATCH Send To 3 vids

  • Its a bar band style cover even if he had remembered the words. I think Simon once said if a performer is going to take old songs which were written for a different generation then he should update them somewhat or make them his own. I have a feeling when this song first came out there were thousands of performers singing that song pretty much like a duller version of Bob Dylan, which I think everyone is in agreement is what Jason did. Kind of the type of thing done when learning guitar.

  • well, i don't think that SImon is

    THAT bad...though yeah, inevitably

    he should be...that's the reason why

    AI stood out...coz there's a meaninie

    willing t help you immprove...

    yeah, jason's good bot noone would improve

    if everyone lies to him and tells him that he's

    automatically a god...yo've got to accept the

    truth...and improve!

  • Comment removed

  • God I hate American Idol. I love the participants but i HATE the judges! Simon Cowell is a bitch! he has crushed so many peoples dreams, for no reason other than to be mean. and they so obviously script this. they don't even care how good the person sings. Fuck this shit!

  • Ooooo, someone got rejected on x-factor!

  • ATLANTIC RECORDS!! yahooo

  • I still listen to this because I like the way he sang it.

  • Jason Castro performs "Mr. Tamborine Man" by Bob Dillon during the Final Four American Idol Episode on May 6th 2008.

    It's Dylan. Bob Dylan

    Yes and the trtrtrtrm part?!he should read the lyrics twice if he cant remember it -.-

  • i couldn't belive he forgot

    its like the main part its

    "Hey Mr. Tambourine man play a song for me in the jingle jangle mornin i'll come following you"

  • :24 cant even remember the words

  • its a wig.. still like him?

  • you're an idiot.

  • Bob Dylan is the man cool song choice

  • Its not that he CANT sing, I think it was the songs in particular that he chose.

  • Jason should have won just based on his face. not to mention, his voice is new and fresh.

  • i dont think this was that bad pf a performance, its just at this point he was the odd man out compared to the other contestants

  • Well there was Jason Castro, David Archuleta, David Cook, and who else?

  • Syesha Mercado was the fourth

  • Syesha Mercado was the hottest.

  • Jason is soo good i adore him he was my favourite :D

  • The original by Bob Dylan is much much much better...

  • You cant compare ANYBODY to Bob Dylan dude just no

  • lol no duh, bob dylan is a legend... of course you cant compare a cover of that song to the actual one.. just like bob marley. hes still amazing.. as long as he doesnt forget the words and.. try to do bob marley lol, that just cant work out unless you have that sort of voice.

  • haha. is it bad that i even think him forgetting the words is adorable?

    jason castro is amazing. sorry if you can't see that, because you are truly missing out.

    i'll love him forever!

    <3

  • @julielovesjason  dude i feel the same way.

  • thank you!

  • it's funny he just goes munununu come following you but it sucked when he got voted off

  • That was cute.

  • u do

  • You know what? Lay off people. Jason is like anyother normal person. He has a girlfriend and a real talent.

    Sure, he messed up, but so what? We all mess up. He'll be a famous love song artist soon and the people who love him will respect that.

    He's not gay, he does not do drugs so leave him alone. He's an awsome guy so just lay off him.

    Nice try, Jason Castro.

    I can't wait to see him on his tour.

  • Thank you plus the guy si a giant Christian an even in Idol went to Church everyday and my brother knew him in collage and he was always like that laid back

  • I love him Jason! He's a hottie! MARRY ME PLEASE!!!

  • then y r u watching the vid if u hav no reason 2?

  • he's horrible

  • he really does sound like bob dylan here..got the nasal thing going on lol

  • This song suits him fine, i thought that the umm part was part of the song, till the judges mentioned it.

    Look on the bright side - it is ORIGINAL mumbling.haha

  • hes so shmexay

  • I hated that. :( It stunk

  • when he did tht uhnunhu part did he 4get the words?

  • yeah.

  • 0:22 to 0:25

  • YOU BLOW ME AWAYYY

  • he totally suits this kind of music! and i didn't even know he messed up the words i thought it was all part of the song ;)

    this boy is toooo good for wordsss way to good for this stupid show.

  • i know, alot of people just thought he was doing a "scat" thing when he did that. He handled it like a pro and kept going. He didnt make a big thing of it like a couple of contestants i can think of that forgot lryics *cough* Brooke and archeleta

  • A few words missing, still brilliant! Unique, fresh, raw, love it! One of my top songs for you!

  • woooooooooh im still a fan of this guy jason castro u rule

  • cristaevandamme you are so right!

    go jason..!!XD

    ♥

  • and he sang this good overall

  • "You're an Idiot babe. It's a wonder you still remember how to breathe" -Bob Dylan

  • Oh my God, I love Jason Castro. He truely is an amazing singer, drummer and guitarist. I find it funny, that none of you people have made it as far in life as he has and yet you criticize from behind your computers. Oh wait, you all dont have a life.

    peace out! ;]]

  • it was SO funny ina good way when he mest up

  • :O Woah.

  • paula gets on my nerves

  • I could see this guy becoming famous....I don't think american idol was the proper venue for him...he's not exactly what they look for on the show but he definately has the potential to do something with his music. As for forgetting the words, I hear it happen all the time of live stages..it took a lot of courage to keep going afterward and that's what makes a great performer....Good Run Jason !!

  • Finally, justice has been served, at least three weeks late. We now only have to hear Jason at the county fair.

  • hes high as ufck

  • jason castro is a hottie.

    and i actually liked this song quite a bit, and i think he mite have done a really good job w/ it if he wasnt so nervous.

    i mean obviously like all of his pride had been like taken down a few minutes before.

    i don't blame him fer bein nervous.

    he's really talented..

    i just think he didn't think he belonged.

  • I love jasoon!

    though his presentations werent too good..!!

    i just hope archuleta doesnt win!!

    i want cook to win!

    i love his voice its amazing1

  • definetly..i like jason and all..but i LOVE DAVID COOK..and HATE with a PASSION david a!!

    haha

    VOTE FOR DAVID COOK..

    p.s. i actually liked how he sand this song ALOT!!

    it gave me the chills :]

    finally, some1 other than david cook giving me goosebumps

  • hey, he;s still hott!!

  • I can't believe this guy got to the top 4. Wow. That is just EMBARRASING that he forgot the words. Seriously, NO PROFESSIONAL does that. He had a week to memorize this, and if he had really focused on it he would've gotten it. Too bad he's too much of an idiot to. I've hated this guy from the start. My opinion is he only got this far because of his looks. Thankfully people saw this and snapped to their senses.

  • there are some professionals that forget the words sometimes like at one of their concerts, no one's perfect, and i still think that girl, i forgot her name, should have gotten eliminated, jason is so much better than her

  • The fact is that those professionals have the right to forget the words (although I've never seen it happen personally), they've worked hard to build up their name and are already famous. If you forget the words to someone else's song when singing it on television IN a competition, that's just very unprofessional right there. I can tell you if he WAS in a professional vocal competition that wasn't up to the viewers, he would have gotten a lot of marks deducted for making that mistake.

  • yeah i agree about that, but still he just forgot a few words and at least it wasn't like that brooke girl where she started the song over, it was good that he kept on going even though he messed up

  • I have to say, that was embarrassing to watch. but I also have to say that for him to continue on without freaking out from forgetting the words took a lot of balls. he's definitely not American Idol material (not saying it's a good or bad thing -- he just doesn't fit what they're looking for), but he's found a niche he can do something with. assuming he doesn't forget his lines and all.

  • Wow, he sucked.

    He so wanted to get this week

    you can tell

    He'll get a recording contract- they all do.

  • david cook is an old man!

  • After his 1st peformance tuesday he mouthed the words "dont vote" & it was rumored he told his family to spread the word throughout his town not to vote for him. Seeing as how ryan said last night that the votes were so close, it makes me wonder, if jason hadnt done what he did (telling people not to vote) would he be in top 3 right now? We'll never know, but my guess is yes. He took control over his fate & he was clearly happy with the decision. All the best to him hes gained some amazing fans.

  • Jason was ready to go. He was tired of the BS of the show. That became clear after paulas little "slip up". Jason isnt dumb, he knew this show had an agenda. They tore him down, screwed him over, and all the while were still able to kiss the 2 david's asses!. He has more style and class than this show and deserves better. Now that he has his foot in the door he would accomplish amazing things. I'm happy that he was so much at peace with everything.

  • i wonder why!!he's still their performing.

  • he's got more style than the show...and as for the vocals...bob dylan himself wouldn't have made it in this stupid competition...go have an actual career Jason

  • So true

  • pack your suitcase to head off to singing camp

  • i hated him to death im glad he went home

  • aww.. haha

  • You could see yesterday he was relieved to go home. He made the show something worth watching.

  • thanks!i just saw the clip of the results,and sad to say that he's goin'home.well,i think that he was so good in his own way though.this is a very tough competition,and we really don't know what's comin'next!and who's gon'be the next AI!good luck to david a.!david c. and syesha!

  • LOL at the guy holding the fake head. he's just standing there in shock.

  • !yes!if you want jason to stay in this competition.....you must vote for him!true!one mistake could be forgiven.......second and third times mistakes!is forgettable...so,i guess he's safe!well,let's just wait and see then!after America finishes to vote!jason's fate is in the hands of the ppl who's gon'vote!prayin'for him to be safe though.....and be on that stage next week!!!

  • umm... he went home yesterday.

  • Jason ?!!! I will pack your suit case. LOoooooooooooolllllllll

  • You know there are actually a lot of very famous performers that don't have perfect voices. But it's the total package. Can you honestly tell me that Neil Young or Bob Dylan have great voices. They have a unique sound that appeals to a lot of people. Jason to me has a very appealing sound and as a bonus he is very easy on the eyes and has a great personality.

  • Very good vocals

    Great performance minus the missed words

  • um excuse me but the POPULARITY factor has worked in his favor thus far! he SHOULD go home!! he's not that good at all...honestly, it isn't stupid. everything the judges said was true.

  • He is my favorite I love him and does NOT deserve to go. This is a POPULARITY contest NOT a TALENT contest. It is so stupid some of the best have gone and the worst stayed