this has 2 be the dopest breakdown ever. me being a kanye fan, i had all my friends from school asking me what this song meant but never could i give a straight forward answer. this had me crakin up from the metaphors this dude used. and never would i think that the whole shoot stars and the shovel line would cath me by suprise like it did. great job.
"She don't believe in shooting stars, But she believes in shoes and cars" I think it describes a girl who isn't into real romance or love (Shooting stars) but would rather have a man for materialistic reasons (Shoes and cars)
Just a thought
Oh and a metaphore is when something is said with a double or hidden meaning
The lack of belief in real romance was my original interpretation, as well. However, I believe that line was the inspiration for the use of the shovel.
I'm pretty sure there's no blood cuz if they showed the blood, the vid would probably never get airtime on MTV, fuse and the sorts :P Great breakdown though, i never understood the Florida part of the lyrics!
I'm an English teacher....the interpretation here was right on target!!! Excellent job!!! I actually teach a unit on hip-hop culture and lyrics. This is such fun to do, but you have to open your mind...that is why they call music "art".
omg i agree the concept of this vid is genius! love all the hidden meanins that u dnt get bt this explains it all that its a deeper vid than u think at 1st!
Its like she doesn't believe in miracles or doesn't believe in anything like shooting stars granting wishes but she does believe in spending money on shoes and cars
This is f'ing hilarious, the fact you felt compelled to even put this together. Everything in the text is so f'ing obvious. What has America come to that you need to state the obvious. What a joke. lmao
What the f***k is wrong with her??? She had to kill him??!!! She needs to go to a mental house. Kanye has a very.......interesting mind to make this vid..........
to da person undr me i agree 100 percent wit u cuz if u watch all three u kind of can add da peices together cuz kanye has sample all types of music into his n other ppl he produce for
that was pretty good but this songs premise is not based around a "relationship" at all per say at least not in the man woman sense the whole song is a metaphor for his relationship with hip-hop much like homecoming hence hip-hop (the girl) in this video killing him, the 2nd video portrays the hip-hop lifestyle(the girl) and the 3rd video shows hip-hop killing other genres of music (people) as to say kanye was cheating on hip-hop by incorporating other styles of music in his own
ok i knew all of that but the thing i dont understand is the part of the chorus that is cut out wut does he mean when he says "as u recall u know i love to show off but u never thought that i would take it this far wut do u know"
Good job with the interpretation but I was never confused about what he was saying in the song I just think the video leaves too much out. It seems as if we are watching an ending throughout the whole video...I think a lot of people wanted to see the imagery before it got the the point of her revenge!
There are so many ways to interrupt this video and the lyrics, but I think you did a fabulous job of it. Some things I thought of differently, some things I think you missed, and some you found that I definitely missed. But overall, I'd said you did one hell of a job. Two thumbs up to ya.
Man gooooood job on this lol I was thinking all the same things good to see I wasant the only one. the one part I didint know was the shooting stars part that part wass hot how you broke down
her ethnicity is black italian, not white.
a12356ut 2 years ago
this has 2 be the dopest breakdown ever. me being a kanye fan, i had all my friends from school asking me what this song meant but never could i give a straight forward answer. this had me crakin up from the metaphors this dude used. and never would i think that the whole shoot stars and the shovel line would cath me by suprise like it did. great job.
ZONEdaTAGGER 2 years ago
i dont get the shovel bit? so what she doesnt belive in shooting stars...wats the shovel have to do with it?
ExoticKiwiFruit 2 years ago
since she doesn't belive in shootin' the star(kanye) she decides to use a shovel instead...maybe she'll use it to bury him as well.
nomo1980 2 years ago
how did i never notice taht?
"she don't believe in shooting stars"
duh, i'm usually on top on these things.
appleJUICEomg 2 years ago
Ohh now i see
clever lyrics now dat i think about it
Tigght
ChickenButtEddy 3 years ago 2
I never realized that last line... very clever
samBomeo 3 years ago 2
"she don't believe in shootin stars, but she believe in shoes and cars"
she keeps the car and shoes he gave her, but burns the mink
"you more like love to start shit, im more of the trips to florida..."
when times get hard she fights, and he just cheats
jihanimani 3 years ago
ooooh now I see
ladigirl 3 years ago
OOOOOOOOOOO i get now...*feels retarded*
ditsylilme 3 years ago
"She don't believe in shooting stars, But she believes in shoes and cars" I think it describes a girl who isn't into real romance or love (Shooting stars) but would rather have a man for materialistic reasons (Shoes and cars)
Just a thought
Oh and a metaphore is when something is said with a double or hidden meaning
:-)
Blu2f 3 years ago
The lack of belief in real romance was my original interpretation, as well. However, I believe that line was the inspiration for the use of the shovel.
tclark108 3 years ago
pfft i knew that..
i thought this video would answer why there is not blood on the shovel after the first stab..
y901 3 years ago
I'm pretty sure there's no blood cuz if they showed the blood, the vid would probably never get airtime on MTV, fuse and the sorts :P Great breakdown though, i never understood the Florida part of the lyrics!
jac0bm 2 years ago
hollly shit i hella get it now. thank you. kanyes the fucking best.
jassass1n 3 years ago 2
OMG! your explanation left me speechless. i'm artistically numb to music thanks to most hip-hop. this video is why Kanye is great.
tyrone70 3 years ago
Someone finally broke it down, I got it when I first saw the video, did you see the prequel to the video?
Qady2209 3 years ago
I'm an English teacher....the interpretation here was right on target!!! Excellent job!!! I actually teach a unit on hip-hop culture and lyrics. This is such fun to do, but you have to open your mind...that is why they call music "art".
msmartinelli 3 years ago 2
okay, okay, this video is awesome.
dreamcrusher5 3 years ago
omg i agree the concept of this vid is genius! love all the hidden meanins that u dnt get bt this explains it all that its a deeper vid than u think at 1st!
princesspink1981 3 years ago
Oh shxx....as much as ive listened to this song.. i never grasped the concept... thought it was about a materialistic chick at first..
Sch00Lb0Y 3 years ago 2
NOW I get it. xD
ashley0195 3 years ago
damn who ever did this is smart great video
brownaztecpride 3 years ago 2
great explination
aznrapsta 3 years ago
Nice
beckoleco 3 years ago 2
"she dont bbelieve in shooting stars"
that was deep as hell !
emjaymoggs 3 years ago 5
yeah i thought the same!
princesspink1981 3 years ago
i dont want she mean she dont belive in shooting stars does she mean ... she dont believe in shooing celebrites?
DahboMusik 3 years ago 2
i cnt be arsed to explain to u what a metephore is lol. . . .maybe its coz im not entirely sure myself.
sorry man
emjaymoggs 3 years ago 2
Oh well..
DahboMusik 3 years ago
its a pun, a play on a word that has two meanings
DEF454 3 years ago
Its like she doesn't believe in miracles or doesn't believe in anything like shooting stars granting wishes but she does believe in spending money on shoes and cars
mousehound 3 years ago 2
thats whats up i give u mad props 4 this i neva really understood what was happening
FNS87 3 years ago 2
awesome work man
Seagerash 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
kanyes fuckin retarded poser...
good voice but hes wasting his time with rap..
willium47 3 years ago
kanye is a genius!!!!
studven 3 years ago
Yeah I felt the same way as Brysof92, they should re-release this YouTube version so that more people would understand.
I just love this shit and there's not much more to say.
tsndav 3 years ago
music shouldnt be this damn complicated
d0llipop 3 years ago
ur a fckin idiot, music is supposed to be complicated.
thats why its so great, and kanye west is a genius
123Numbers456 3 years ago 6
lol. it has to be.
RickGabeSound 3 years ago
don't listen to dess haters...good explanation ma friend....now i understand da video...
tintedeyez 3 years ago
wat the fuk man...my 6 year old sis cud have explained that to me more sufficiently
YOWATTDAHELL 3 years ago
that was very helpful...i kind of knew about 75% of the song but this cleared up the other 25%
Brysof92 3 years ago
NOTE: This music video is best described as abstract, and can be anything you want it to be. However you want to interpret it, is what it is.
slodere 3 years ago
thanks now i get it
bryan8885 3 years ago
Did an ex really try to kill him?
pdink 3 years ago
This is f'ing hilarious, the fact you felt compelled to even put this together. Everything in the text is so f'ing obvious. What has America come to that you need to state the obvious. What a joke. lmao
kili5896 3 years ago
What the f***k is wrong with her??? She had to kill him??!!! She needs to go to a mental house. Kanye has a very.......interesting mind to make this vid..........
edah238 3 years ago
Dang. Thats good. "She doesn't believe in shooting stars" Thats deep
ManUPhil8 3 years ago 2
Ooh
now i get it
but i still dont get the whole beginning pt. of this video and why was that one thing "censored" and all pixely?? what was it?
NickKnackDance 3 years ago
That pixelated object was the lighter fluid.
Search4Forever 3 years ago
but why would they feel the need to block it out?
NickKnackDance 3 years ago
it was likur
Doomsaibot 3 years ago
great job to whoever made this video too..
dpotvin92 3 years ago
1:15 in this movie is great :D
fr3dd3 3 years ago
search for "Theory of a Deadman-So Happy"
It's basically the prelude to this video. Viral marketing at it's best
TheDashMan26 3 years ago
holy shit thats crazy "so happy" is the prelude with the car, shovel, tape, and shit...kanyee the man
dpotvin92 3 years ago
yep.
RickGabeSound 3 years ago
damn man...you are totally right...could be the other new version of the clips prelude of other clips as well?
noenam 3 years ago
to da person undr me i agree 100 percent wit u cuz if u watch all three u kind of can add da peices together cuz kanye has sample all types of music into his n other ppl he produce for
hood8787 3 years ago
that was pretty good but this songs premise is not based around a "relationship" at all per say at least not in the man woman sense the whole song is a metaphor for his relationship with hip-hop much like homecoming hence hip-hop (the girl) in this video killing him, the 2nd video portrays the hip-hop lifestyle(the girl) and the 3rd video shows hip-hop killing other genres of music (people) as to say kanye was cheating on hip-hop by incorporating other styles of music in his own
realmillions 3 years ago
i dont get it though, how is hip-hop "killing" him?
yunboyfresh 3 years ago
i really want all those people who left comments on the video like "man wtf was ye thinking...that video made no sense at all" to see this video...
djGILES10 3 years ago
i love yuu
yuu jus made me luv kanye 10 times more
msoclassychik 3 years ago
Thanks so much 4 this. Damn Kanye is a genious
STANDARDDDDDD 3 years ago
i think this song is a continuation to drunk &hot girls (guy doing a bunch of sh*t jus to get sex) then he gets caught by his gf by th paparazzi
krazikris93 3 years ago
i understood most of it but i get it now thanks
krazikris93 3 years ago
man i liked this song but i did not kno it was this deep thanks for breakin it down
jeralchris 3 years ago
ok i knew all of that but the thing i dont understand is the part of the chorus that is cut out wut does he mean when he says "as u recall u know i love to show off but u never thought that i would take it this far wut do u know"
kurama125 3 years ago
its the girl talking, basicially saying he didnt know she could go that far(as to kill him), what do he knows?
yunboyfresh 3 years ago
oh ok that makes sense thank you
kurama125 3 years ago
as u recall was him quoting Biggie "who ever thought hip hop would make it this far now im in the limelight....."
dthesatisfier 3 years ago
Good job with the interpretation but I was never confused about what he was saying in the song I just think the video leaves too much out. It seems as if we are watching an ending throughout the whole video...I think a lot of people wanted to see the imagery before it got the the point of her revenge!
crypto229 3 years ago 3
yea i thnk he's gonna do tht
he's gonna have more then one version 2 the video
msoclassychik 3 years ago
I finally understand now. Kanye is really good with his metaphors. Thanks for the breakdown.
jgetum 3 years ago
wow..now i undastand what he is trying to say
jazzybooo09 3 years ago
very resourceful
heymaria123 3 years ago
I get it now, thanks!
JJW48002 3 years ago
good job, nice explanation x
apollo112 3 years ago
Is there people out there that didn't get this?? What's wrong with the world.
GheBreBeats 3 years ago
yeah, that was awesome. i agree with the whole, "she don't believe in shooting stars" so she uses a shovel...genius.
wavygurl 3 years ago
Well i must say that is the best explanation of this song and video.
It goes to show that artists still feel the songs they make.
JusThatGurlMon 3 years ago
wow
shaastarr 3 years ago
dat was a very good ezplanation actually.dat was koo.i think dats wat kanye meant too
Barry822JerryB 3 years ago
lmao... i understood the video... but i thought the "shooting stars" connection was great... nice work
juandellsays 3 years ago
that...was...the supidest reason of murder i've EVER seen EVER
smil3y04 3 years ago
She didn't murder him, watch where she aims the shovel....down by his crotch area. He can live, but he won't ever be cheating again...lol.
mnc51 3 years ago
i got it, u a deep brother
BrezzEasyy 3 years ago
deep! well dne man
dgreatestofalltimes1 3 years ago
There are so many ways to interrupt this video and the lyrics, but I think you did a fabulous job of it. Some things I thought of differently, some things I think you missed, and some you found that I definitely missed. But overall, I'd said you did one hell of a job. Two thumbs up to ya.
mezzantino359 3 years ago
you don't have any idea how many times i've tried to explain why the video is genius.
good job b.
article7 3 years ago 2
i didnt get to read the words or hear the music... i was mesmerized by that fat ass she has on her. WOW
osas1n 3 years ago
Didnt think people really listened to lyrics these days, Thumbs Up.
mrvizcarrondo 3 years ago 6
I just got hole different respect for kanye on this video, that shit is deep
BUGSY010 3 years ago 4
Man gooooood job on this lol I was thinking all the same things good to see I wasant the only one. the one part I didint know was the shooting stars part that part wass hot how you broke down
dangerboy123 3 years ago 2
gooooood shit...you really did a good job with this
illanig 3 years ago 2
im scared of gurlz now
jr602az41 3 years ago
Bravo! thanks to u all those idiots will finally get the genius behind all the hidden messages :D
check out my video too!
Ubootedmee 3 years ago 3
wow, thanks for this response. i always loved flashing lights and i knew there was a concept to the video but i didn't understand. thanks
nbr18 3 years ago 3
Thanks for breaking it down for all those that have no insight. I think the song and the video is nothing less than pure genius...
senseiemjay 3 years ago 4
good job dude!
jimmyjohns123 3 years ago 3
Good job, thanks for posting that response to my vid, you need to send this around with my video. Very entertaining!!
Majesty
Street Knowledge Media
umajesty 3 years ago
Thanks!
Search4Forever 3 years ago