Evanescence not only has a title to a song in common with Nirvana, but the record label "Wind-up Records" has ties back to the grunge and punk era of the '80s including Sub-pop, Steve Albini, White Flag (band), GG Allin, Sonic Youth, The Buzzcocks, Butthole Surfers. All people and bands Kurt Cobain mentions in his published journal. (see Dutch East India Trading and sub-labels Grass, Homestead, Giant, Touch and Go Records). I am Amy Lee which the lead singer of EV uses my name as stage name.
I've loved Nirvana for 15 yrs or so and I gotta say that it's different but good. Nirvana and leadbelly don't sound the same either but thank got nirvana covered him
Being a die hard Nirvana fan, and not feeling like she desecrated this song by doing a cover, that says a lot. Nirvana is almost impossible to cover and not just completely blow it, this is pretty good,
Amy Lee sounds so great when she sings with a higher pitched voice!! So to some this my not meet their expectations, I personally enjoyed this cover!!
Her voice doesn't fit the song well. Not that it's bad, just her voice has a unique style to it and this is to far off. Nobody can sing her songs as well as she sings them, same thing for nirvana, nobody can sing Kurts songs as good as himself.
She's an amazing singer and all but she should really stay away from covering grunge, it just doesn't work at all. Maybe it'd be a different story if they would've put their own little style into it like The Fray did with Heartless but, as you can see, they didn't & it's just... *sigh smh
She has an amazing voice, but this song isn't for her. Only Kurt could sing it, simply because only him had that feeling of sadness and loneliness at the time of singing... He definitely was the owner of this song.
It would be better if it was all rocked out, like Nirvana's. That's the beauty of Evanescence; rock hard music and an angelic voice. It's beautiful. Love it.
Dudes this is cover.... When u make a cover u make on your style . If everyone tried to copy exactly everything would suck. Stop complaining and just listen to it or else go fuck your self.
Kurt Cobain used "paper flower" poppies in Heart Shaped Box music vid, which is Joe Elliott of Def Leppard's birth flower. This is where the pseudonym Poppy Z-Brite who wrote Courtney Love's bio came from. The paper flowers were from the song "Imaginary" which I wrote and performed by Evanescence. When I met Kurt in May '83 he was on roadcrew for Def Leppard's Rock Till You Drop Tour promoting Pyromania. Def Lep had been opening for Billy Squier which ended in Seattle & Oregon in April '83
"The only sad thing about a great night in the theater, is its EVANESCENCE. When it's over, it's over. You can remember the performance forever of course, but you can't recreate that VIRGIN SENSATION -- that almost numbing exhilaration -- of witnessing something NEW and different FOR THE VERY FIRST TIME." review titled A Chorus of Love by Frank Rich of The New York Times Oct 1, 1983 was inspiration for me to name Evanescence, to write Like A Virgin for Madonna and New Sensation for INXS
Best Nirvana song. Not a bad cover but I think she could have made it sound more Amy Leei-sh. The whole point of a cover is to make it sound like your version of a song and not imitate the original. Nothing will ever beat the original :)
The idea to write Heart Shaped Box came from the character Blanche in Tennessee William's play A Street Car Named Desire. Blanche had a heart shaped box with a seahorse pin. This is also why Kurt Cobain drew a seahorse in his journal.
good attempt but when you try to cover the likes of nirvana, chances are you are gonna fall short. although i will always love amy lee. call me baby ;)
Ah lo siento pero no me gusta. Amy Lee llegó a su techo con este tema, tiene una voz preciosa pero... Parece que las chicas tienen algo en contra de Nirvana.
@TheBritasaurus Personally man, you gotta admit for as soft and Gay Amy Lee's music is.. she did a GREAT cover of Nirvana. I tried to cover "In Bloom" at a high school talent show, and I've gotta say, Curt's tones are HARD to hit because of his unique voice. I think she did GREAT on this song. I could never song like this.... could you?
The real Amy Lee was discovered by Joe Elliott of Def Leppard along with unknown Kurt Cobain in '83 at age 15. Not only does the lead singer use her name, but Amy Lynn for Pres Jimmy Carter's daughter. Kurt's friend Kathleen Hanna's band Amy Carter. Heart Shaped Box came from character Blanche in A Street Car Named Desire with a seahorse pin. See Kurts seahorse drawing. It had nothing to do with Courtney but Amy who is from the south. "at peace ami, youre a good one" Kurts Journal
Not going to lie, I was big into evanescence when they first came out... but now? Shes starting to bore me... sure she has a great voice but very little expression. Sure she can belt out notes on a crazy register and has power enough to shatter windows, but lacks in emotion. I think Amy lee is one of those artists that peaked way too early and now all she does is re hash the same song with different lyrics. Technically her range and pitch and power are flawless, but for me thats not enough.
@Falenir Give it a little time man, ignore her for like months maybe years, then start to listen to some of her stuff again and see if it fills a hole. If not than you're quite right to be dissapointed.
I must take time to confess my life long boner for Amy Lees voice =3, ever since I was little watching Dere Devil (they were on the sound track, the movies ok.. ) ive had a bit of a secret obsession. For years evernesence was my guilty plessure. NOT ANNY MORE! currently blearing this out of my window as loud as I can!
@ArmyMech63B I love this cover! But they're different bands and styles, you can't possibly compare it that way. Nirvana were VERY good. One of the best bands in the entire world.
Amy is great. But listening to these kind of cover versions makes me understand that Kurt was the soul of Grunge. Maybe Kurt would have made Grunge even the Ave Maria.
1:45 wow.... one of the most amazing pictures of her eyes I have ever seen! They looks so deep and they are impossible to look away from! They suck me and I can't get out... This is quite funny because my favorite band is Nirvana, and my second favorite band is Evanescence! Not coincidence, is it?
@gunner525 Have you ever jumped around and sweated then tried singing? Most likely anyone will sound shakey. She's like that in concerts. Not in her live acoustic sessions. And even mentioning Beyonce on a Evanesence video makes no sense because they are completely different. Amy has a beautiful voice. Sure she has her voice malfunctions sometimes but I'd like to see you get on stade in front of hundreds. Possibly thousands and not mess up. Untill then leave Amy alone.
Her voice is way too shaky. I mean it's not Beyonce bad, but she still can't solidily hold the notes when she sings live. Plus she's always an eighth count behind the music. I expect a lot better live performing from a girl who went to school for music. Stage fright should have been scared out of her years ago.
@gunner525 She didn't go to school for music. She's a self-taught singer, mostly. The most she had was being in a high school choir - not exactly professional-grade music schooling. She does have breath control issues, especially on stage, but for a self-taught singer, she's pretty great.
@crimrose She went to Middle Tennessee State University to study music theory and composition. She's just a studio artist and nothing more. What she needs to do is just work on composing works for soundtracks. She'd make a lot more money doing that than trying to preform live.
@gunner525 She never finished though, because Fallen went big right after. She's a self-taught singer. She does have issues live though. But I don't think she needs to make more money, with how many records Evanescence have sold. Nah, I don't think she needs to worry about money for the rest of her life, really.
even if she was ugly her voice well makes up for it... close your eyes for godsake and just listen to her if you think she is fat who gives a damn she has the most beautiful voice i have ever heard
P.S. for my safety i think i should also mention she is beautiful herself she doesnt need to starve herself
i think she is stunning....good song...good cover! :) good voice...very very pretty woman, what more could one ask for? the perfect woman, forever in my dreams. i would be a happy guy if i was burried with her photo and a blue rose.
well if she's "fat" (???) she can be fat in my bedroom anytime... sit on the edge of my bed and sing. i wouldn't want a woman with a friggin' six-pack.
Her weight doesn't change anything. She is still talented. Even if you don't like her voice, it doesn't mean she isn't talented. It just means she isn't your preference.
No, she isn't skinny, and no, she isn't fat. I think sometimes people forget what 'fat' stands for. Even if she isn't BANG on her healthy weight, she isn't more than 4 or 5 kilos over. That still doesn't make one "fat". Please focus on her singing, because you're missing out while arguing.
im a girl and amy lee has the perfect shape skinny chicks have tiny boobs bugs me lol flat cheasted surfboard im not fat a average size 125 pounds what im saying she has great boobs
@jaykay204 Not true with the perfect in shape skinny chicks have tiny boobs. I am not 'perfect' shape and far from big boobs but yet i am not flat. BUT unlike many girls..I am Italian and a pear shape. My waist 26", my boobs are just b's but i am blessed with naturally large hips(39"). Which I prefer anyday :) Plus my bf is happy with. :)
flyleaf's lacey whatever the fuck her last name is, needs to take some lessons from amy here. amys version actually sounds AWESOME, flyleaf just made a stupid wanna-be version of it.
while im sucking up to amy lee here, is it just me or is she just like GODDESS beautiful???
amy is not fat her body is perfect & dont forget that the camer put on the original weight 5 or 8 k so maybe the ppl who say that she is fat because of the camera
ilove your video 5 star
im new here need friends please but girls only sorry bec of my parents
im from egypt & i wish she make concer their specily in alexandria
This has been flagged as spam show
Evanescence not only has a title to a song in common with Nirvana, but the record label "Wind-up Records" has ties back to the grunge and punk era of the '80s including Sub-pop, Steve Albini, White Flag (band), GG Allin, Sonic Youth, The Buzzcocks, Butthole Surfers. All people and bands Kurt Cobain mentions in his published journal. (see Dutch East India Trading and sub-labels Grass, Homestead, Giant, Touch and Go Records). I am Amy Lee which the lead singer of EV uses my name as stage name.
Boddahism 2 days ago
I've loved Nirvana for 15 yrs or so and I gotta say that it's different but good. Nirvana and leadbelly don't sound the same either but thank got nirvana covered him
26RonnieG 2 weeks ago
She is amazing :)
Raichu234 2 weeks ago
I love this cover. I can't believe I never listened to this more. I forgot how much I love it!
MusicIsLove2812 2 weeks ago
Heart Shaped Box Cover by Chris & Aine ..
zaharagrace123 2 weeks ago
i never liked this song but now i do
maggie12345ism 2 weeks ago
Never cared for Nirvava, but slap Amy Lee on it and I'll love it.
GuitarGirl4ever 2 weeks ago
@GuitarGirl4ever ummm no. this cover is mediocre at best. there aren't many songs that can't be covered but i think nirvana's songs qualify.
still, nobody could manage to make it better so amy gets props there i guess.
romaggot 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
youtube.com/user/Boddahism i just dont understand some of these comments on here... really dont..check me out.....
mar235 2 weeks ago
amy lee sounds cool singing this song...
skywick1 3 weeks ago
I just noticed that if you look at the black from above the screen it has words at 1:17.
floweringplains 3 weeks ago
Being a die hard Nirvana fan, and not feeling like she desecrated this song by doing a cover, that says a lot. Nirvana is almost impossible to cover and not just completely blow it, this is pretty good,
Jeli818 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
Jeli818 3 weeks ago
The Nirvana original is best but this version is amazing! better than any other cover would be!
MsQueenoftheshadows 3 weeks ago
amazing cover :) Amy is amazing ...
iMusicMelody 1 month ago
Kurt was a legend, and amy lee is a goddess. be greatfull.
Haleyfieldofcans 1 month ago 3
i just dont understand some of these comments on here... really dont
MrLabbunny 1 month ago
Love Amy but this one, not so much.
1focusedGirl 1 month ago
kurt you wrote this , great song ......but 1602 people would rather ride the arse off amy lee dude
bugz1974 1 month ago
i love this song nice cover
pimphstrong1 1 month ago
Amy Lee sounds so great when she sings with a higher pitched voice!! So to some this my not meet their expectations, I personally enjoyed this cover!!
IIIIIGunzIIIII 1 month ago
Her voice doesn't fit the song well. Not that it's bad, just her voice has a unique style to it and this is to far off. Nobody can sing her songs as well as she sings them, same thing for nirvana, nobody can sing Kurts songs as good as himself.
ShamuNtheHomies 1 month ago 2
I love this cover! Amy did a nice job! :D
EvanescenceXKISS 1 month ago
is enough nice i like it but i prefer the Nirvana...
xDarkGirl999x 1 month ago
FAIL!!!
BrettLank101 1 month ago
She's an amazing singer and all but she should really stay away from covering grunge, it just doesn't work at all. Maybe it'd be a different story if they would've put their own little style into it like The Fray did with Heartless but, as you can see, they didn't & it's just... *sigh smh
Phoenix0IIV 1 month ago
She has an amazing voice, but this song isn't for her. Only Kurt could sing it, simply because only him had that feeling of sadness and loneliness at the time of singing... He definitely was the owner of this song.
MisheeKaintz 1 month ago
No, no, no! She-does-not sing well. Just horrible.
sincapfare 1 month ago
It would be better if it was all rocked out, like Nirvana's. That's the beauty of Evanescence; rock hard music and an angelic voice. It's beautiful. Love it.
23snowwhitequeen 1 month ago
Never cared for Nirvana in truth. But Amy Lee does a good cover to only song I ever liked from the group.
daishou13 1 month ago
Comment removed
daishou13 1 month ago
beautiful <3
rockpunkqueen201 1 month ago
i like this song better by nirvana but i really like this to but it kinda makes me wants to kill myself
joeeks 1 month ago
The original version by Kurt Cobain is much better, but this version is very good too.
Mygogtube 1 month ago 2
@Mygogtube Really. Amy Lee is amazing but original version by Kurt Cobain is much better.
DanielaOliveira08 1 month ago
@DanielaOliveira08 Are you brazilian? Your name seems to be from Brazil...
Mygogtube 1 month ago
@Mygogtube Yes, I am Brazilian, but I hate most bands of Brazil.
DanielaOliveira08 1 month ago
@DanielaOliveira08 Me too. .-. Restart, Cine... is terrible D: ... But thank God we have Legião Urbana, Paralamas do Sucesso, Titãs... *-*
Mygogtube 1 month ago
I love this version <3
FreaksLee 1 month ago
Love <3
Sw33nEtt 1 month ago
Prefer this version :D
Love Kurt too
Hate the fact Miley Cyrus covered smells like teen spirit... That's like Justin bieber trying to cover 2Pac :\
Nagina33 1 month ago 2
Dudes this is cover.... When u make a cover u make on your style . If everyone tried to copy exactly everything would suck. Stop complaining and just listen to it or else go fuck your self.
ZuluToadStool 1 month ago
She has a beautiful voice, and I admire her attempt at covering this song, but obviously nothing is ever going to be better than the original.
CastinCouchnCatwalk 2 months ago
the original was better but its still amazing
Ashely28 2 months ago
WTF!! F#cK This "Cover" they ruined the song... >.>
claussen666 2 months ago
This version is better, I think :)
Anahit1709 2 months ago
I really like this version :)
LazzurusMan 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she sounds like a shitty ass dying turd.
kylieeatstoast 2 months ago
Ahh the first line put me in a trance
SheLivesInAFairytail 2 months ago
it is awesome but no offence i think seether cover version is better
buzzard511 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Kurt Cobain used "paper flower" poppies in Heart Shaped Box music vid, which is Joe Elliott of Def Leppard's birth flower. This is where the pseudonym Poppy Z-Brite who wrote Courtney Love's bio came from. The paper flowers were from the song "Imaginary" which I wrote and performed by Evanescence. When I met Kurt in May '83 he was on roadcrew for Def Leppard's Rock Till You Drop Tour promoting Pyromania. Def Lep had been opening for Billy Squier which ended in Seattle & Oregon in April '83
Boddahism 2 months ago
she is like a vampire. a sexy beautiful magical talented vampire goddess.
beastboixxx 2 months ago
Amy !!! ur an amazing
Dolbezian 2 months ago
Her voice is good. But Kurt knew how to feel during this song. No one else will ever have that.
Ddgolem12 2 months ago
I love amy, no matter what. So instead of saying "eh idk" LISTEN TO THE DANG SONG AND SHUT IT.
XD yea lol
SuperMysticAlchemist 2 months ago 7
Hyah.....
superhill08 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
"The only sad thing about a great night in the theater, is its EVANESCENCE. When it's over, it's over. You can remember the performance forever of course, but you can't recreate that VIRGIN SENSATION -- that almost numbing exhilaration -- of witnessing something NEW and different FOR THE VERY FIRST TIME." review titled A Chorus of Love by Frank Rich of The New York Times Oct 1, 1983 was inspiration for me to name Evanescence, to write Like A Virgin for Madonna and New Sensation for INXS
Boddahism 2 months ago
Amy is amazing but Kurt rolled over in his grave when she sang this....
6sweet6satan6 2 months ago
Best Nirvana song. Not a bad cover but I think she could have made it sound more Amy Leei-sh. The whole point of a cover is to make it sound like your version of a song and not imitate the original. Nothing will ever beat the original :)
muzikpr0 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The idea to write Heart Shaped Box came from the character Blanche in Tennessee William's play A Street Car Named Desire. Blanche had a heart shaped box with a seahorse pin. This is also why Kurt Cobain drew a seahorse in his journal.
Boddahism 2 months ago
GREAT VERSION.......
delapipanegra 2 months ago
good attempt but when you try to cover the likes of nirvana, chances are you are gonna fall short. although i will always love amy lee. call me baby ;)
sciflinebacker 3 months ago
Ah lo siento pero no me gusta. Amy Lee llegó a su techo con este tema, tiene una voz preciosa pero... Parece que las chicas tienen algo en contra de Nirvana.
Kitkatklub04 3 months ago
Nothing will ever beat the original.
albertbamp 3 months ago
Yo estoy enamorado de esa mujer.....Dios que mujer que canta bien!!!
jls0883 3 months ago
How did you come to the conclusion that Amy Lee is fat??? She looks perfectly healthy, what about u guys, huh?
henj38 3 months ago in playlist Jorja's music 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Eww.....you can not cover nirvanna I hate this....
TheBritasaurus 3 months ago
@TheBritasaurus Personally man, you gotta admit for as soft and Gay Amy Lee's music is.. she did a GREAT cover of Nirvana. I tried to cover "In Bloom" at a high school talent show, and I've gotta say, Curt's tones are HARD to hit because of his unique voice. I think she did GREAT on this song. I could never song like this.... could you?
MuddMadosh 3 months ago
:(
xtasox33 3 months ago
Comment removed
xtasox33 3 months ago
Love her, but this cover, meh. And trust me, I wanted to love it. But reality is, it's so-so.
guitardds 3 months ago 26
The real Amy Lee was discovered by Joe Elliott of Def Leppard along with unknown Kurt Cobain in '83 at age 15. Not only does the lead singer use her name, but Amy Lynn for Pres Jimmy Carter's daughter. Kurt's friend Kathleen Hanna's band Amy Carter. Heart Shaped Box came from character Blanche in A Street Car Named Desire with a seahorse pin. See Kurts seahorse drawing. It had nothing to do with Courtney but Amy who is from the south. "at peace ami, youre a good one" Kurts Journal
Boddahism 3 months ago 2
@Boddahism your fucking insain
sTapleEVA 3 months ago
Amy lee = all round awesome
Nagina33 3 months ago 2
This is fucking terrible.
hippymonkmon 3 months ago
Not going to lie, I was big into evanescence when they first came out... but now? Shes starting to bore me... sure she has a great voice but very little expression. Sure she can belt out notes on a crazy register and has power enough to shatter windows, but lacks in emotion. I think Amy lee is one of those artists that peaked way too early and now all she does is re hash the same song with different lyrics. Technically her range and pitch and power are flawless, but for me thats not enough.
Falenir 3 months ago
@Falenir Give it a little time man, ignore her for like months maybe years, then start to listen to some of her stuff again and see if it fills a hole. If not than you're quite right to be dissapointed.
JT164STL 3 months ago
@Falenir She needs a tragedy to happen, something to wake up her emotions again
arkayen666123 3 months ago
Comment removed
Falenir 3 months ago
Her voice gosh:)
Paisleighsroom 3 months ago
Why label this as Amy Lee. It's her AND Ben Moody doing a radio promo...as Evanescence.....
danimal97520 3 months ago
it seems like she just covers songs shes good but only covers songs
The50feetdeep 3 months ago
full of talent
201011221 3 months ago
amazing
Nirvanakid776 3 months ago
huh wtf? hmmmmmm not bad!
2501ShirowsGhost 3 months ago
I must take time to confess my life long boner for Amy Lees voice =3, ever since I was little watching Dere Devil (they were on the sound track, the movies ok.. ) ive had a bit of a secret obsession. For years evernesence was my guilty plessure. NOT ANNY MORE! currently blearing this out of my window as loud as I can!
Growing up is fun like that xP
ZACY29 3 months ago
She has a beautiful voice :)
FreakWithBoots 3 months ago 41
Amy Lee>Nirvana
ArmyMech63B 3 months ago
@ArmyMech63B I love this cover! But they're different bands and styles, you can't possibly compare it that way. Nirvana were VERY good. One of the best bands in the entire world.
DevilPt9 3 months ago
This is nothing, I heard Seether do this one in person which was awesome. If they ever made a Nirvana movie the Seether guy could do the singing.
pffreese 3 months ago
She looks like liz vicious lol
Nice and respectfull cover. Good.
Motohazard 3 months ago
her voice is to classic. doesnt fitt to hsb
lostandwounded 3 months ago
This is a great song and Amy Lee is a wonderful vocalist. However...
Nirvana + Amy Lee = sounds like Sonic Youth. Ew.
randaroo413 3 months ago
i cud cuss some of yall that bad tlkin this version. Amy Lee is jus amazing all around. Loves IT!
WorldlyHappiness 3 months ago
She did a piece of great work in here, I can hear and feel that she's putting her heart into it...
Pat9695 3 months ago
No one can ever be better than Kurt but Amy lee did a wonderful job here I love it
rockisdead25 4 months ago
she covered it. but very good. but i still would rather listen to nirvana than this :)
luitenant22 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Yup this is the sparkle in the eyes
atennnant01 4 months ago
Love this.. It's not Kurt.. but it is beautiful :)
liagibba90 4 months ago
Amy is great. But listening to these kind of cover versions makes me understand that Kurt was the soul of Grunge. Maybe Kurt would have made Grunge even the Ave Maria.
Diege29 4 months ago
Neh. Doesnt do it for me...
LOWD2091 4 months ago
@LOWD2091 You are not alone there.
lcsmwiley 4 months ago
As if this song didn't suck enough in the first place~
mikeflanagan1130 4 months ago
I think she totally does this song, and Kurt justice. <3
xCreepieXCutiex 4 months ago
It's not Kurt, but I still likes.
jesusofsuburbia911 4 months ago
ew
jasperwoods 4 months ago
Nice cover. Nirvana will always rule, but Evanescence is not a bad band, love them too (to a lesser degree)
Life4bombs 4 months ago
my opinion Nirvana butt love evenescence too
musicoreinstein 4 months ago
@musicoreinstein O RLY? I love Amy Lee's butt too.
iluvedward12243 4 months ago
@iluvedward12243 you know what i mean
musicoreinstein 4 months ago
@musicoreinstein I know, but I couldn't help it XD
iluvedward12243 4 months ago
It's good,but Nirvana better than this! Some emos say '' Amy Lee better than Nirvana '' what the hell? Nirvana forever,Evanescence for emos.
Sickpuppiesmusic1 4 months ago
@Sickpuppiesmusic1 everones emo if you have any emotions at all >_>
snoweatsbabies 4 months ago
@Sickpuppiesmusic1 I really like Evanescence, and I'm not emo. Far from it. So bad logic on your part.
KittyzKatterz 4 months ago
@Sickpuppiesmusic1
Excuse me, who's the lead singer who killed themselves again?
xAshlyy 4 months ago
@AnthonyDingemanse you should hear her live when she's sitting on the piano.
No difference.
pannenkoekensmurf 4 months ago
love how they're both are so unique and beautiful.
pannenkoekensmurf 4 months ago
1:45 wow.... one of the most amazing pictures of her eyes I have ever seen! They looks so deep and they are impossible to look away from! They suck me and I can't get out... This is quite funny because my favorite band is Nirvana, and my second favorite band is Evanescence! Not coincidence, is it?
coheedandcambria100 4 months ago 2
I can't get how they call amy lee fat..I mean she was with shaun morgan who is a fucking giant..and I've never seen anyone calling him fat o_o
darklampard 4 months ago
good
0509613009 5 months ago
@gunner525 Have you ever jumped around and sweated then tried singing? Most likely anyone will sound shakey. She's like that in concerts. Not in her live acoustic sessions. And even mentioning Beyonce on a Evanesence video makes no sense because they are completely different. Amy has a beautiful voice. Sure she has her voice malfunctions sometimes but I'd like to see you get on stade in front of hundreds. Possibly thousands and not mess up. Untill then leave Amy alone.
MissFek 5 months ago
Her voice is way too shaky. I mean it's not Beyonce bad, but she still can't solidily hold the notes when she sings live. Plus she's always an eighth count behind the music. I expect a lot better live performing from a girl who went to school for music. Stage fright should have been scared out of her years ago.
gunner525 5 months ago
@gunner525 She didn't go to school for music. She's a self-taught singer, mostly. The most she had was being in a high school choir - not exactly professional-grade music schooling. She does have breath control issues, especially on stage, but for a self-taught singer, she's pretty great.
crimrose 4 months ago
@crimrose She went to Middle Tennessee State University to study music theory and composition. She's just a studio artist and nothing more. What she needs to do is just work on composing works for soundtracks. She'd make a lot more money doing that than trying to preform live.
gunner525 4 months ago
@gunner525 She never finished though, because Fallen went big right after. She's a self-taught singer. She does have issues live though. But I don't think she needs to make more money, with how many records Evanescence have sold. Nah, I don't think she needs to worry about money for the rest of her life, really.
crimrose 4 months ago
Comment removed
mar235 4 months ago
..l..
smellslikejulian0100 5 months ago
even if she was ugly her voice well makes up for it... close your eyes for godsake and just listen to her if you think she is fat who gives a damn she has the most beautiful voice i have ever heard
P.S. for my safety i think i should also mention she is beautiful herself she doesnt need to starve herself
sparkyr1 5 months ago
i think she is stunning....good song...good cover! :) good voice...very very pretty woman, what more could one ask for? the perfect woman, forever in my dreams. i would be a happy guy if i was burried with her photo and a blue rose.
maccaBable 5 months ago
She's so pretty it's almost scary...
hi5tutu 5 months ago
No No No deffinitly not the right voice for this song! Amy lee does have a great voice but NO! BUTCHERD!
PRCdammit 5 months ago
nice cover..
clisk35 5 months ago
que tia tan fea!!!
cascorao 5 months ago
i like this cover and the singer too
Haettrickmusic 5 months ago
well if she's "fat" (???) she can be fat in my bedroom anytime... sit on the edge of my bed and sing. i wouldn't want a woman with a friggin' six-pack.
deepcreep98 5 months ago 19
she sounds amazing<3
pleasesuckmychode 5 months ago
i do not like this cover at all.
GuitarRockGod951 5 months ago
But amy lee is not fat. I will agree to that.
ItaliaPolskaQT85 5 months ago
i just watched ergo proxy and now i cant look at amy lee without seeing re-l
suki1615 5 months ago
@suki1615 I KNOW RIGHT?! XD
DarkFlame345 5 months ago
Let the haters hate! Dont be mad cuz she is amazing and your not!
briaunarechichar 5 months ago
Amy lee is gorgeous....she is not at all fat...I don't understand assholes like that...
hellokitty4040 5 months ago
Wow. I'm Blown away, like really. Nothing will ever be better then Kurt Cobain, But this...this is damn close.
SheLiedAboutAge 5 months ago
Her weight doesn't change anything. She is still talented. Even if you don't like her voice, it doesn't mean she isn't talented. It just means she isn't your preference.
No, she isn't skinny, and no, she isn't fat. I think sometimes people forget what 'fat' stands for. Even if she isn't BANG on her healthy weight, she isn't more than 4 or 5 kilos over. That still doesn't make one "fat". Please focus on her singing, because you're missing out while arguing.
deathcorerock 5 months ago
if still fuck her
pulsepunder 5 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Anyone notice Amy lee is kinda fat?
rico91stang 5 months ago
@rico91stang
uhmm who cares if she's fat she's amazing
just because she's not anorexic like some people out there
rawrfacelovesnoodles 5 months ago
@rawrfacelovesnoodles As long as you acknowledge that she is fat.
rico91stang 5 months ago
@rico91stang but you dont need to acknowledge it who really cares about it, your just shallow
rawrfacelovesnoodles 5 months ago
@rawrfacelovesnoodles Not shallow. Just stating facts.
rico91stang 5 months ago
@rico91stang lol seriously, if you call that fat you probably never seen anything else then a skeleton.
zimri19 3 months ago
@zimri19 fat.
rico91stang 3 months ago
@zimri19 LOLOLOLOL! agreed
SlightlyLostPixie 3 months ago
im a girl and amy lee has the perfect shape skinny chicks have tiny boobs bugs me lol flat cheasted surfboard im not fat a average size 125 pounds what im saying she has great boobs
jaykay204 5 months ago
@jaykay204 Not true with the perfect in shape skinny chicks have tiny boobs. I am not 'perfect' shape and far from big boobs but yet i am not flat. BUT unlike many girls..I am Italian and a pear shape. My waist 26", my boobs are just b's but i am blessed with naturally large hips(39"). Which I prefer anyday :) Plus my bf is happy with. :)
ItaliaPolskaQT85 5 months ago
I actually hate this version, don't get me wrong.. she's an amazing singer, just.. not for me..
Jinxedwithme 5 months ago
@Jinxedwithme i agree bud, amy lee is amazing, but i dont think she gets this song.
muklan1 5 months ago
I cant stand the original, but this is actually pretty damn good.
elfberserker 5 months ago
are you seriously hating on Lacey Mosely from Flyleaf? She can sing is amazing live as is amy lee. get off it.
silentchick18 5 months ago 2
marry me aimee
jerseybean23 6 months ago
Evanescence + Nirvana = Head implosion
loweydude220 6 months ago 71
@loweydude220 ha your so right, except heart shaped box was origonally Alice in chains but i get your point, and a good point you make!!
Dawnraider13 4 months ago
@loweydude220 Whoa, I never knew Nirvana did this song... Amy's version was the first one I heard.
n1g3ld34c0n 3 months ago
@loweydude220 Evanescene+Nirvana+seether = Killer track
linkinahmed 3 months ago
nasty faggots.... keep it to yourselves. -_-
dmi3011 6 months ago
love it
roydie46 6 months ago
I think this cover would make Kurt proud. congrats amy lee =P
voteformeforpres 6 months ago 37
@voteformeforpres
agreed, i think he would to and impressed :)
SakuraAvalonBleac25 3 months ago
flyleaf's lacey whatever the fuck her last name is, needs to take some lessons from amy here. amys version actually sounds AWESOME, flyleaf just made a stupid wanna-be version of it.
while im sucking up to amy lee here, is it just me or is she just like GODDESS beautiful???
nzephier 6 months ago 2
This is fucking awesome.
fckthisplanet 6 months ago
amy lee is amazing, i like that unlike most music stars today, she doesn't use Autotune or get tons of plastic surgery
ozzman123 6 months ago 2
perfect!
555songsong 6 months ago 3
Amy has those hauntingly beautiful eyes!!! They make me melt!! And Her voice is awesome!
lshinpaugh 6 months ago
I love her voice. She is just amazing.
XxLoveMeDreadfullyxX 6 months ago
just WOW
Sharmilka 6 months ago
@MsFashionBug
Crap! my sister was on my acount again. sorry about the stupid comment :P
AgeOfIntolerance 7 months ago
Me dieron ganas de escuchar nirvana.
now I want to listen to nirvana.
hfargon 7 months ago
shes really pretty but i like the nirvana version better
nikkilovesjrock09 7 months ago
amy is not fat her body is perfect & dont forget that the camer put on the original weight 5 or 8 k so maybe the ppl who say that she is fat because of the camera
ilove your video 5 star
im new here need friends please but girls only sorry bec of my parents
im from egypt & i wish she make concer their specily in alexandria
mennatarek2468 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i wanna fuck her!
506jimbob 7 months ago