Don't get me wrong I love Garbage I love Shirley. But this cover is GARBAGE. Sky is rolling in his grave over this one. There are much better covers of this great rock and roll ditty and this one has got to go. I hope Garbage drops this from their repetoire.. please for all that's holy in rock.
Imho a soulful rendition by the band, the vid is entertaining, & the singer is ooh-la,la -smooth as butter. Regards, The '62 Mathew St. Band (1 Man-Full Group Retro)
i actually thought this was a great cover of the original, i prefer the seeds version but garbage have done a great take of this song in they're own style
I love the original by the Seeds, which remains the best, but this is a much more creditable version than some of the Seeds diehards would have. Shirley Manson and Garbage feel the languid sexuality of the song that The Ramones miss.
mmmm I got thumbs down for my previous comment, and though I dont give a fuck Id just like to know WHY. SO if you guys could tell me what's wrong... Do you idolize garbage so much that you cant take a simple suggestion? Or do you hate this song so much that the idea of it being appreciated is more that you can bear? No serioulsy, I'd really like to know... No kidding. xD
the mixing and the production are bad. I'm sure they would sound fabulous live, playing it with a lore raw sound, and well with shirley's voice, not touched by those effects
for real man im pissed off of dickheads like you keep posting shit comment you dont like it than stay the fuck away from my video is that easy dont need to bitch about bitch
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
you are right- she wants you to think shes a slut so other stupid lil sluts will wanna be like her image but she hasn't the guts to do what she promotes herself wont do it herself
I Luvved the badass puppies & kitties,I called them cats N Dofs LOL,Hay Meat Cannon Doofis,This verson iz way better then the Romone's,And Shirley Manson iz not a slut U stuped meateater!
I can't seem to make you mine,Kissin' all around all the time, Flyin' around like a bee,Hurtin' everything you see. Tried everything I know, oh...To make you want to love me so,oh...The only thing you do, oh...Is try to put the hurt on me, oh... I can't go on like this,A little bit of love, and not a kiss.I gotta have your love every day,one that'll really stay, oh...
I actually like this, a lot. More than the original. I'm sorry.
wovenv2 1 month ago
this is a great cover :D
tallyhoman911 5 months ago
I quite like this cover... it's not THAT bad... really. Not brilliant, but yeh, not horrendous either...
nickthelick 6 months ago
too drunk to watch these cats. lmfao
foreverfaeriejoy 6 months ago 2
shirley
acidbathgirl01 7 months ago
try out the version from johnny thunders, maybe the best one of this song !!!
MrDorianstone 7 months ago
I for one, like the cats XD. ty for uploading, love garbage !
xxcityescape 8 months ago
I don't like the way it's recorded.. honestly
666Xandia666 9 months ago
Don't get me wrong I love Garbage I love Shirley. But this cover is GARBAGE. Sky is rolling in his grave over this one. There are much better covers of this great rock and roll ditty and this one has got to go. I hope Garbage drops this from their repetoire.. please for all that's holy in rock.
jojojoely484 1 year ago
@jojojoely484 I disagree but hey, that is my opinion. CB
TheRandomamp 6 months ago
Very very BAD. Completely wrong copy of a great and endless wonderful song!
hsmonterey67 1 year ago
@hsmonterey67 Its not a copy its a cover
Totalmachine09 1 year ago
I actually chuckled at the cats.
waronsuck2178 1 year ago
Sounds like a hoe
DunOrie 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@DunOrie - and yet you keep coming back!!?? you even fail as a hater..
zweenguyen 1 year ago 4
Ёбаные каты ваще не тему. в топку!
ser4ton 1 year ago
Imho a soulful rendition by the band, the vid is entertaining, & the singer is ooh-la,la -smooth as butter. Regards, The '62 Mathew St. Band (1 Man-Full Group Retro)
OlRetro 1 year ago
why the voice and all song keep like shaking
mariselafanful 1 year ago
fantastic song!
revolverproducciones 1 year ago
i love it!!!
cosasquediran 1 year ago
Wtf is w/ the Anti-fascist action thing?
PanoplyCabaret 2 years ago
:D :D I cannot get enough Shirley.
sexyjefflynne72 2 years ago
R.I.P sky!!!
evaldez1407 2 years ago 4
True, I seem to remember When I grow up having two BSides, Cant seem to make you mine and Tornado...
So im not sure which song counts as its BSide, because Cant seem to make you mine was also on The trick is to keep breathing.
BladeRunner21577 2 years ago
Nice effort on the vid, good to see it up on the tube, might not have made it here otherwise, it was "only" the Bside of When I grow up single.
BladeRunner21577 2 years ago
Also The Trick Is To Keep Breathing B-side
andrea111292 2 years ago
I love this version. Garbage is fantastic!
Queenteam 2 years ago 2
R.I.P. Sky Saxon from The Seeds...
dalegrett 2 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
HELL NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Khultan 2 years ago
the lead singer is hawt
vonshtoyven 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
la the seeds mejorr
JahAle92 2 years ago
i actually thought this was a great cover of the original, i prefer the seeds version but garbage have done a great take of this song in they're own style
chrisyh5647 2 years ago 9
This comment has received too many negative votes show
how could she ruin an amazing song ...cringe....
weirdomaget 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'll stick to The Seeds 60's superior
merseymain 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is such garbage compared to The Seeds version. why do bands cover songs if they only make a lousier version??
kipbfc 2 years ago
good question! and I think that all those people who push the bad comment button never did hear the original version!
lemonsqueezermunich 2 years ago 3
fav song of them
anak0009 2 years ago
anti-fascist action !!! 1:12
subtilstudio 2 years ago 3
strange vid, good performance of this song
bloodybitch111 3 years ago
This is my new theme song.
XtehXchortX 3 years ago 2
1:25
sixasix6 3 years ago
she looks very very insaine-beautyful!!!! in 125
sixasix6 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
way to kill a great song by the Seeds..
CFilmsInc 3 years ago
i like it :s
panasiviri 3 years ago 3
Was there was a reason for the cats?
XtehXchortX 3 years ago 12
Comment removed
andrea111292 3 years ago
run out good pic
NoMONKEYS 3 years ago 9
@XtehXchortX WTF WITH CATS????!!!!!!!!!!!!
anthiD 2 months ago
i dont like the video, its really bad
adictiva 3 years ago 13
is not about the vid is about the song
NoMONKEYS 3 years ago 11
@NoMONKEYS Yeah but the video still sucks ass. The LEAST they could have done was upload Garbage pics to go with the Garbage cover.
Gaeilgeoir 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
im sure ill get thumbs downed for this, but that chick sounds like she's high off her ass on something
punchamime 3 years ago
I love the original by the Seeds, which remains the best, but this is a much more creditable version than some of the Seeds diehards would have. Shirley Manson and Garbage feel the languid sexuality of the song that The Ramones miss.
dkfrey 3 years ago 2
mmmm I got thumbs down for my previous comment, and though I dont give a fuck Id just like to know WHY. SO if you guys could tell me what's wrong... Do you idolize garbage so much that you cant take a simple suggestion? Or do you hate this song so much that the idea of it being appreciated is more that you can bear? No serioulsy, I'd really like to know... No kidding. xD
KalikaInLeather 3 years ago
the seeds from 1965! also the ramones did a good cover but this is great! garbage but great!
salvadorsalvona 3 years ago 2
the mixing and the production are bad. I'm sure they would sound fabulous live, playing it with a lore raw sound, and well with shirley's voice, not touched by those effects
KalikaInLeather 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ahw sonds like a cat cay geiting stept on and the ramones do it way beter
DunOrie 3 years ago
Who cares what you say you can't even spell you noob.
NoMONKEYS 3 years ago 4
@DunOrie dont ever speak that way about Shirley Mansons voice you bastard!
Ladypurpulhair 1 year ago
Nm...ANTI-FASCIST ACTION. Nice! PeacexXx!!!11:11
milofire 3 years ago 2
yep yep :)
NoMONKEYS 3 years ago
1:12???
milofire 3 years ago
I'm not sure about it- I love the song so much I'd listen to it if Madonna sang it- the only good thing I've said about Madonna.
pataphysician66 3 years ago
I LUV THIS SONG,I WANT THIS ALBOM & i LUV THIS BAND! 5 STARZ!
ZHardKoreGroovyJulz 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
They screwed up this great song. Chicks suck
DT11969 3 years ago
This version is terrible.
Ramones did a good cover.
Andrew301 3 years ago
i love the voice of shirley and the cats lol
xdrownedworldx 3 years ago
holy shit! head banging kitties!
wednsdays0evil0twin 3 years ago 3
"I can't seem to pay my re-ent....
Oh sorry! That was MY version of the
song, little Freudian Slip I suppose...
gpx44 3 years ago
Oh I Luv this song 4 starz!
ZHardKoreGroovyJulz 3 years ago
Song is very nice, but video - sleazy
JusDiz 3 years ago
i kinda like it....it reminds me of crimson and clover...lil' differnt....I'm a big seeds fan
:)
agirlnamedmel 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
don't like it
axlinscotland 3 years ago
Shut up ANDY go hump your boyfriend LOU
NoMONKEYS 3 years ago
Those cats are the start are trippy
d33dr0 3 years ago
interesting how two completely different genres can perform the same song. Psychedelic rock to electric emo.
stratkiller86 3 years ago
I think this versions conveys the feeling the best.
Satan316 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this sucks why make covers if your gonna make them suck
gabyroxs109 3 years ago
is an B side you jackass
NoMONKEYS 3 years ago
yeah piss off you woman-hating freak!(probably jealous)this version is fantastic! so there.
RimmelLipstickLover 3 years ago
i likes it
paddie353535 3 years ago
Too mellow the seeds is better
hurraquio 3 years ago
Hmmmm, I dig it! I like it alot, actually.
BlkMagik 3 years ago
Mkay. That's a really good song. BUT some of the pictures were very......random?
VeryUniqueX 3 years ago
yeah i run out of pic on Soldier Through This video
NoMONKEYS 3 years ago
Not even close to the Ramones cover. And the original beats them both.
Drratburn 3 years ago
As a rule I hate covers... but I actually like all three versions I have heard. Garbage, The Ramones... and of course The Seeds.
Trotsky66 3 years ago 10
This is absolutely the best version of this song, LOVE IT
ChaosRocket 3 years ago 4
Thx u gd news 4 once
NoMONKEYS 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is fucking terrible
completely ruined the song
the effect on the voice is rediculous
abnormalx 3 years ago
just go fuck your own ass i know you do it you sick fag
NoMONKEYS 3 years ago
This version makes me sick. Absolutely terrible
Steveabc06 3 years ago
U,R,GAY piss off go get teabag u asshole
NoMONKEYS 3 years ago
Yeah I Luv Garbage 4 starz man!
ZHardKoreGroovyJulz 3 years ago
I love this track
And I liked the cats! for some unfathomable reason they really suit the song!
fairy52 3 years ago
lol :)
NoMONKEYS 3 years ago
wasn't really feeling the start but once it got going it's pretty good....... Hard to compete with the original though.
jimmyjam1985 3 years ago 2
i reall ylike the original but this isnt bad at all.
alejakababa 3 years ago 3
Yeah I Luv Garbage 4 starz man!
ZHardKoreGroovyJulz 3 years ago
I LOVE THIS SONG
chuwaka500 3 years ago
the cats ruin it
but thats what i think
xxx
its a good song though and the band are amazing
kurenia 3 years ago 7
All are good I think because they are different not one sounds the same. And guys gettin mad it's just music
JakeANowhereMan 3 years ago 3
true
NoMONKEYS 3 years ago
true...waazzuuup?!
Trivalis 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
dont fuck up the song you bitch
tijmand 4 years ago
for real man im pissed off of dickheads like you keep posting shit comment you dont like it than stay the fuck away from my video is that easy dont need to bitch about bitch
NoMONKEYS 4 years ago
I like woship Shirley MAnson!
ZHardKoreGroovyJulz 4 years ago 3
Shirley Masnon is not a slut. you're stupid
KeaneQueen11981 4 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you are right- she wants you to think shes a slut so other stupid lil sluts will wanna be like her image but she hasn't the guts to do what she promotes herself wont do it herself
markwasthere 4 years ago
What the...?
I refuse to let you screw with Manson like that! What'd she do to /you/?
Go tie yourself to a ceiling fan and jump. Play in traffic,something...
Ugh,please.
~ Midnight
MidnightsWrath 3 years ago 2
lol nice ;)
NoMONKEYS 3 years ago
Third version I hear. Ramones cover was splendid. This is cool too but check the 60's original by The Seeds.
VL1302 4 years ago
I Luvved the badass puppies & kitties,I called them cats N Dofs LOL,Hay Meat Cannon Doofis,This verson iz way better then the Romone's,And Shirley Manson iz not a slut U stuped meateater!
ZHardKoreGroovyJulz 4 years ago
lol thx 4 the comment :D
NoMONKEYS 4 years ago
Yeah Shirley Mansons so hot! 5 Stars! Funny badass cats N dofs!
ZHardKoreGroovyJulz 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ramones cover it the best, slut singing this fucks it up
meatcannon 4 years ago
get lost u gay ass mother fucker
NoMONKEYS 4 years ago
i think the pic @ 1:49 fits the song
garbageblahblah 4 years ago 2
yep & @ 2:45 :P
NoMONKEYS 4 years ago
Bruddy good cover.
AlbertMondback 4 years ago 2
Both versions rule, but I like this one better. Probably because it's by Garbage. Heck, Shirley could sing that "Umb(e)rella" song and I'd like it.
AllLuckySevens777 4 years ago
gotta agree with allluckysevens777 it doesnt matter what it is if shirleys singing it its gonna be fuckin wicked awsome
spiritregan 4 years ago
This song is cool, shirley manson is the sexiest chick ever.
MrZuchinni 4 years ago
huh what an interesting song.
shirleyshusband2008 4 years ago
I can't seem to make you mine,Kissin' all around all the time, Flyin' around like a bee,Hurtin' everything you see. Tried everything I know, oh...To make you want to love me so,oh...The only thing you do, oh...Is try to put the hurt on me, oh... I can't go on like this,A little bit of love, and not a kiss.I gotta have your love every day,one that'll really stay, oh...
Lilito27 4 years ago