Shinobi's Commentaries 20: How To Lose All Your Fans In One Video (Trailer)

[Indigodelta383]

its look like he was having breakdown

[AuraMasterFox]

...Well, that's one way to kill a review show...

This was, in fact, the worst thing you've ever had to commentate on. Congratulations, good sir.

[shinobiflare]

@AuraMasterFox Why thank you. But don't say that just yet.

[mickeys12]

Just finished this commentary and I agree with everything you said about this guy. He was annoying I couldn't even make it through his so called review when he posted on That Guy With The Glasses forums. I can see how painful watching this video must have been because just seeing the review portion of this commentary was painful.

[DrQuagsire]

I know he was being sarcatic, no wait I mean troll, but that was terrible. I've seen troll videos before,better one I'd say and I can get that, but this guy just...... *shrugs*

Couden't he be negative and sarcastic at the same time (saying its shit but complimenting on how well M. night did a scene that was poorly executed), that could have made it a bit better.

[MSkull01]

I'm sorry, Shinobi, but I actually found his review to be funny. It's painfully obvious that he's being sarcastic and that he really doesn't like "The Last Airbender". This sort of review reminded me of the Nostalgia Critic's "Surf Ninjas" review where people can see that he REALLY doesn't like that movie.

Sorry, Shinobi, but didn't really like this commentary. I just felt that you were getting way to offended with something that was quite obviously a joke.

[MSkull01]

@MSkull01 Also, there's a difference between being sarcastic and being a troll.

Sarcasm is meant to ridicule something/someone by saying one thing but meaning the opposite.

Trolling is to purposely antagonize others (through the internet) for an often negative reaction.

He's saying that the movie is good yet he's obviously trying to show us that the movie is bad. That's not trolling; that's sarcasm.

[shinobiflare]

@MSkull01 You are obviously entitled to your opinion, and I'm not saying you have to agree with me. That said...there's a difference between The Nostalgia Critic's review of Surf Ninjas and this...whatever this is. In that NC's review was FUNNY. This...was just infuriating on all possible levels. The jokes weren't funny, even if I did take them as sarcasm they were still offensive. And the main reason I did this was that this guy reacted so negatively when people called him out on it.

[shinobiflare]

@shinobiflare I can understand a video made for a joke--the problem is, the review itself has to be funny in order for that to work, and to me, this review was--to use your terms--not funny. Also, how is "Fuck Mako" or inserting the "Leeroy Jenkins" clip randomly even a joke? It's impossible to take THOSE parts of this review as sarcasm. Now granted, some of it DID feel like he was being sarcastic, but to me, most of the review did feel like one giant fail-troll review.

[shinobiflare]

@shinobiflare What's worse--he had absolutely NO BUILDUP and/or reason to do this--if this was a review done as an April Fool's joke, or given some justification in-universe like NC's video, I wouldn't have commentated on it--but he did this for what can at best be described as "shits and giggles." And even if he WAS being sarcastic, this video was too offensive for me to find it funny. That's why I commented on it, and if given the choice, would do so again.

[Headbanger142]

@MSkull01 And yet he makes pedophile and gay jokes over and over again throughout his review? You know some of the people on TGWTG are gay right?

[MSkull01]

@Headbanger142 And making gay jokes is bad, why? I don't recall the entire review consisting of nothing but gay jokes.

[AntonyBlalock]

@Headbanger142 ...they are?

[shinobiflare]

@AntonyBlalock Some people on the forums are--Diamanda Hagan, Mogwaicub, Cin Wicked...

[AntonyBlalock]

@shinobiflare really? That's cool actually

[gusgriz]

Why does it give me a 1 minute video of some guy eating a cookie on bliptv

[shinobiflare]

@gusgriz No idea...other people don't seem to be having any trouble, though.

[Headbanger142]

Ah yes. Waited patiently for this one. Gonna watch it now.

[AntonyBlalock]

@Headbanger142 why is your comment flagged as spam?

[IsaacTales2]

...what? Screw character development as it drags out the movie? ...People WANT TO HAVE CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT SO WE CAN HAVE A REASON TO LIKE THESE CHARACTERS!

God...whatever logic this guy has, it's not good.

[shinobiflare]

@IsaacTales2 He meant it to turn out that way, even if he won't admit it.

[AkatsukiMario]

That guy just sounded so [painfully sarcastic...

[shinobiflare]

@AkatsukiMario He was trolling. Even if he didn't admit it.

[AkatsukiMario]

@shinobiflare He's very bad at it then. Everything in his video felt like it had this sarcastic tone.