Is India really a Democracy?You (Americans) be the Judge.# 5

[SuperPaki4lyfe]

Yes india is a democratic country of its own kind.

where millions of kashmiris have no right to vote for thier freedom.

sikhs. muslims and christians are often attacked, HIndus are dominant in every aspect.

And IF some politcian gives a great leader as jinnah a compliment he is highly criticised and immediatly sacked from his position for doing so..

[ThinkSmartThinkFree]

Racist MF

[koldergut]

i want to know who that old ignorant old fool was.

[pravicpu]

India were ruled by Mughals for almost 700 years and British for 250 years. Both of them didn't do anything to the eradicate bad customs in the society,even though they had many benefits from India. Whereas Independent India for the last 60 (just 60 years of independence) years is trying hard to bring up minorities and uplift the status of people, and these west instead of praising such effort they use their mouth to show their Ignorance without knowing their history or facts.

[jitu911]

The indian upper house does not have any powers!!! just like our president, they are more of a nominal head

India has the freedom of everything, this guy is juts stupid!!

[karlbenny]

you say minorities in india are not safe..... i am an indian christian and i feel the safest here in my homeland.....

[jenin1383]

Me too

[shetgold]

first watch your country ther is shia sunny fights killings and america killing muslims in afganistan iraq and now trying iran and in pakistan wot is happening all know and killing and raping kashmiri padits ...dont blam only on hindus blam yourself its natural in humans...... and one thing some killed cristians why ? coz they are forcing to covert hindu to cristion .. thats it

[brandyjaxx]

A hindu country with a muslim president, a sikh prime minister,party in majority congress led by an italian catholic lady, a dalit former prez,presently a female prez, where else can you find more unity in diverstiy... India rulz

[jammnjigga123]

Fuck your diversity brandyjaxx......what good is diversity in high government when all minorities in India all victims of rape, torture, mass killings. You Hindus have killed millions of Christians, Muslims, Sikhs, Dalits, even raped Dalit girls young as 4, you fucking sick bastards should all be put in Concentration camps! Its pay back time you fucking smelly Hindoos:D We all will take over your filthy country, jus like everyone else did in history:D You fuckn monkeys are only good to be slaves

[dumb2313]

You fucking muslim piece of shit go fuck muhammed the dog and his pigfucker allah the devil up the ass in hell faggot. and your mom is a muslim whore who was sucking my isreali dick last night.

[dimension117]

Ya right! Having a sikh prime minister and muslim president does not make a nation secular. It is when all are treated fairly.

Over 50000 sikhs killed. No justice f4 them. Over 200000 muslims killed since 1970 no justice f4 them either. Tthousands of christians murdered... This joke of largest democracy u play around with dus not fool the world.

[ak2479]

India's Prime Minister is Sikh. He took the office after a Roman Catholic woman of Italian birth was elected Prime Minister. He was sworn in by a Muslim President, who was preceded by a Dalit & succeeded by a woman.

America has only had white, male, Protestant presidents - save for the Catholic JFK. This is the first time that the House Speaker is female. People are amazed by the idea of black/female Presidential candidates. A good proportion of Americans are intolerant of blacks & Hispanics.

[Sikhballer84]

that doesn't prove that india is a democracy. so what if the pm is sikh? how many more minorities have to die w/o justice for ppl to realize that india is NOT a democracy.

[dumb2313]

Take you smelly turban off you fuck sikh faggot.

[brandyjaxx]

which era are u from u dick headed prick....

ppl like u should be hanged.. its a shame for u, ur mother, father, and ur country that your lack of education has made u speak this way... fag

[ak2479]

Actually, it does prove that India is a Democracy. Where's your proof that India is not, you moron?

[jammnjigga123]

to ak2479 fuck you hindoos, you guys will all be taken over by all minorities in India, We will all unite and tame you monkeys just like everyone else did in History haha:D

[kxar07]

Where do you live my friend jammjigga?

Frustrated as you are struck in stone ages, while India surpassed you? Poor baby. Stop whining and start studying. Or else some day, we will see you begging in the streets.

India is marching ahead, so we do not pay attention to barking dogs...

[ak2479]

haha :D Waiting for you to try sweetheart.

[brandyjaxx]

luv.. it has already been tried.. india is the 2nd fastest growin economy.. 4 of the 10 richest ppl on earth r indians.. india has the most no. of entrepreneurs in the world.. etc etc etc

[Bapi1993]

yeah but India should help the poor people thats the point of a democracy and majority of the politicians are corrupt as hell and that all needs to change. And I understand that its only 60 years old but they gotta improve fats otherwise the world will begin to make fun of u guys especially because all forign companys are opening up

[coolwaves4all]

infrastructure is starting by 2010, and due to N-deal , india can now make more electricity, more labour, Thanks to Mr. bush.

[silvesterronald]

bjp govt made all bad thinks angnist minorties. now we have secular govt (indian union is all gods nation)

[utubecrazyharish]

all Indians in da house....stop accusing pakistan and calling her names man! chill out....we wdnt like it when someone calls us "rundia" wd we? lets all relax...lets see how we cd prosper together.....and pakistanis......you guys have really gone overboard with this one...im sure your ability to punch in key automatically bestows a certain responsibility on your shoulders.

[utubecrazyharish]

Im sure Islam stands for the wonderful virtues that most muslims so beautifuly demonstrate. and as a hindu...im sure hinduism equally believes in peace and love for all....so why this needless pointless anger? seriously guys....lighten up...if we cant talk good...lay off gettin on a verbal onslaught...because neither of us would ever know the absolute truth as much as we all claim we do. lets refuse to be biased and put our ability to judge for sale! peace out my friends!

[utubecrazyharish]

Ok.,...im tired of hate mongers...seriously...thats all we cd do online ain? goto some random pages and vent out our frustration? indians and pakistanis alike man! gimme a break.....why should we feel so happy about eachother's demise? wd u in pakistan feel better if the milllions in india starved to death? is that what islam is? im sure not.

[mnai10]

i realyl dont understand your point. India is really a country of mixed people with many not literate. Its easy agiatate a group aganist others my mentioing issues. It doesnt mean the country in pandemonium.Things like these happens but controlled.

[PashtunKhyber]

hahahaha porkis are following the jews by destroying indias reputation jus because its a soon to be member of the SCO which makes porkistan veyr jealous becos that wud mean the asian union wud wiped that shit hole son of a honky yank ass hole slave country

[Imwhereursoulis]

Gandustan is a gandu country. The video speaks the truth. And those who want to defend by sayin that RUNDIA has a muslim president and a sikh prime minister, they are the dumbest fucks on the planet. They just sit in their offices and do wat the hindus tell them to do. Wat a political propaganda just to show the world. But i guess the world is lot more educated than ur dirty tricks.

[kkaimal]

is america really a democracy?

[ckhw2]

Here's something to shut you guys up about anti-sikh shit... Times have changed and we have moved on... For God's sake, our very own Prime Minister is Sikh!

[naceem82]

Inida is so Clever anda corrupt country its fact and these Hindus r pigs just want our(Americans) help to progress

[janfree99]

hindu,s are very clever dude look at shilpa wot she done to poor jade ruined her career

[aswin1205]

dude, dun be such a dumbass. Its intolerant and just rude comments like "Hindus are pagans and lets drink cow piss" that causes such tension amonsgt people. Ever religion has dirt on it if you look closely enuff. And you know sumin, I'd be happy if all you crazy bastards left india, you're the reason that tension is caused among otherwise peaceful people.

[ninjadude666]

india will forever be a corrupt country, 1984 anti-sikh riots proves, this, thousands of sikhs raped, murdered, massacred, butchered, killed and humiliated and yet to this day still no justice, and even after one of the sikh gurus sacrificed him self for the hindu faith! and after all, it's all the stupid little hindu villages who'd make a big scene about richard gere pecking shilpa on the cheek, wake up and advance into the 21st century!

[singh214]

idol worship?  what of sikh's reverence of the guru granth as a living guru?

[twelveswords]

the safest place for sikhs is outside of india...thank God that loads have emigrated...india is dominated by idol worshiping fools..i.e hindus...but if sikhs wanted to have a homeland...it cud only happen after a nuclear war when the majority hindus were wiped out and sikhs would rise and cleanse their land of the demon-worshippers

[wiseguy1111]

HINDU = PAGAN COWARDS AND LIARS

let us now have a moment of silence and drink the piss from the holy cow and pray 2 half elephant and half monkey gods or better yet worship gods with 20 arms and blue men, if that aint pagan then i dont know what else is, this is the reason muslims hate them with a passion

[monk666666]

Has anyone given a thought that wiseguy1111 could actually be a muslim, trying to create tension between Hindus & Sikhs? I am neither a Hindu, nor a Muslim, but I am glad to say that I have expereinced the good sides in people of both faiths. I have some great friends who are Christians, Sikhs, Hindus & Muslims.

[wiseguy1111]

hinduism is the most retarted religion in the world next to islam...hindus are pussys us sikhs had to get the muslim invaders out of india while the hindus pussys did jack shit..if it wasnt for us hindusim wud not exsist..our ninth guru gave his life for thses fools i dunno why he did...u hindus shud all bow down

[theboy01]

Sikh sacrifice speaks for itself,its 2nd 2 none, it doesnt need your retarded glorification. And our 9th Guru ji Sacraficed his life for hindu's as an example for freedom of religion in general under Islamic oppression. No one shud bow to 2 any1 except God. U really are a fucking fool.

[wiseguy1111]

im the fool eh

i agree u should only bow down 2 god but hindus owe us everything forever indebted 2 us for the sacrifices we made and how do they repay us? by commiting genocide and tryin 2 ethnically cleanse india of its sikh populations.hindus are legendary for there cowardice and backstabbing and they wont stop until every sikh is dead so my friend it is not I who is the fool it is u who is the fuckin fool!!!

[theboy01]

lol, I think you just need to stop talking for you own health! The Sikh relgion was established in chaotic times, weve always defended our selves even when it was 40 against 125,000. Theres not even a 1% chance Sikhi will die,. If you refereing to the 1984 incident, did you know Hindu neighbours of the Sikhs hid them from the mobs to help us? Listen, like i said Sikh sacrafice will speak for it self when it is time, You represent Sikhs in the worst way.

[wiseguy1111]

ya there were sympathetic hindus who helped but the majority were killing us and sterilizing us my momah was a freedom fighter and gave his life so that sikhs could be free of persecution and oppression u talk of things u cant even relate 2 or understand so keep ur love preaching 2urself.

[theboy01]

When you want somthing out of people, you have to appeal to thier self intrest, never to thier mercy or gratitude, becuase they will find a way to ignore you. So by you bringing up past sacrafices is not going to help 1 bit. The killings have made us a million times stronger, and will never happen again believe me. We have to politically pimp them to get what we want. Change your Screen name to Fool of a guy.

[dixitpd]

It is interesting to note that the introduction claims that sikhs are unsafe while the prime minister himself is a sikh

[theboy01]

lol, nothing will happen to the prime minister. He is a honest man & has everyones best intrests at heart, which is much more than I can say for that wanna be Hitler, indira Ghandi. Sikhs are not unsafe.

[dixitpd]

that happened 25 years ago, wake up dude. BTW, the president of India is from the other unsafe community that was mentioned (the muslims). Let america worry about their shit, India is good enough to take care of herself

[wiseguy1111]

buddy we arent safe at all punjab is shrinking by the day the government is taking all our land even chandigardh is no longer in punjab. if u cant see what the tru motives and goals of the government is then u are truly blind and the greatest fool of them all. makin a puppet sikh prime minister was done 2 make the sikhs think that they truly live in a democratic and tolerant country. so far from the truth

[wiseguy1111]

u should change ur name 2 optimistic dumb ass

theres a war goin on what do u know manmohan singh is a puppet he takes oreders from the same government that tried 2 whipe out sikhs and are still doin so by flooding punjab with drugs and killing innocent sikhs. research rrs shiv sana then talk until u know the facts keep ur stupid hindu loving mouth shut

[rvindk]

Hindus have a history of violence be it against sikhs, muslims, buddhists or more recently against christians. Hindus murder and rape untouchables and other lower castes with impunity. Historically buddhist monks were murdered and their monasteries destroyed and buddhism eventually driven out of India by hindus and yet these morons call their religion peaceful. 2000+ years of hindu caste violence against untouchables and its not getting better.

[neerajsoman]

Heh. Retards...The eldest son of Hindu Punjabi families traditionally became sikhs, hence warriors. Paks on thsi forum can go shove it. The point of Sikhism was that it was a warrior religion, creating a protective barrier against the barbaric Islamic invaders. I say this with no prejudice towards today's Muslims, but it is true that Sikhism evolved out of fear of attack by Muslims.

[romeygoraya]

Mr.secondaryhonour is an asshole i am sikh and india is united and its always going to be united and i proud to be an indian

[sakredfire]

If you look at most publications analyzing the socioeconomic situation in india, and trying to figure out ways to stop violence, they are written by indians. For the most part, there is free speech in India. As far as the indian government, of course the prime minister was appointed! It's a parliamentary democracy, stupid...just like canada, the uk, and a host of other democratic countries. That's how they work!

[sakredfire]

your average, middle-class Indian is not an extremist, no matter what his religion. There are problems with rabble-rousing politicians that try to mobilize voters through unethical means, but that is changing. Just look at the current government. Manmohan Singh is a sikh, but is universally respected by most Indians. He rules because of his own merit, not for any other reason. Christians have done their own fair share of oppression, but your average hindu believes all roads lead to God.

[MirBadshah]

Hindu extremists are burning Christain Churches almost every day, killing and raping the helpless Christains and forcing them to convert to Hinduism,

What a shame and our great president Bush can not see that all.

[iensoong]

A hell of a lot less than the Hindutva movement, that's for sure. The KKK doesn't control huge chunks of the government, unlike the RSS-BJP axis in India, as I already mentioned in my previous post but you mysteriously sidestepped. Sheesh, whenever you talk about religion, the fanatics come out of the woodwork. This conversation is over a week old and here the weirdo is dragging it up again.

[Amanb1001]

A bigger question to ask is America a democracy. People have this false notion that democracies are utopia's... Also people forget that Sihks killed innocent Hindu's as well... not justifying it in this way but just raising the point that many conveniantly forget.

[iensoong]

Riiiight...for every Hindu killed by a Sikh, maybe four or five hundred Sikhs killed by Hindus. People who still follow the caste system have nothing worthwhile to contribute. Give up the caste system slavery first and then Hindus can talk.

[Amanb1001]

1) Don't assume all Hindu's follow the caste system.

2) Death is death regardless of religion. Because there are more Hindu's obviously more Sihks got killed, if it were the other way around it'd be the same thing.

3) Sikhs have created their own caste system as well. I know your response "we're not suppose to in our religion" well neither is Hinduism but its still a social problem.

[iensoong]

Ummmmm...

1) Hindus have enormous diversity of practice but the one thing that unites them is belief in the caste system.

2) The conflict took place mostly in the Punjab where Sikhs are in the majority. Of course, Hindu terrorists entered the state through various means. Hindu terrorists cause a lot of problems, including Kashmir, Gujarat, even in other countries.

3) Who said I'm a Sikh? You say Hinduism isn't supposed to follow the caste system?! HAHAHAHAHA! ;-)

[Amanb1001]

1) Hinduism is never meant to be a religion first of all. Outisders coined the term Hindu. Caste system used in a discriminatory way is a social construct. Watch the Mahabharata and see for yourself how caste system should be used.

2) Sikh's also killed many innocent Hindu's, regardless of numbers. A terrorist is a terrorist in any religion.

3)I shouldn't have assumed you were a Sikh but Hinduism doesn't condone caste system in a discriminatory way.

[iensoong]

1)'Hindu' is a derogatory term, but if you say Hinduism has not used caste system discriminatively you are lying. Forget about mythological scripts and look at documented history of Hindustan. Only people to be treated worse than low castes and dogs by the Brahmans are women.

2)Jews killed many Germans but does not mean the Holocaust didn't happen. Holocaust happened and the Germans did it. Hindus commit many riots and holocausts using their superior might, just like fascist Germany.

3)See 1.

[Amanb1001]

I never said it hasn't been used in a derogatory way. I'm just saying it shouldn't be.

And i'm not saying because Sikhs killed Hindu's, the Hindu's killing them was okay. I still think that was fucked up. But don't generalize that too all Hindu's. Many Hindu's saved Sikhs as well by hiding them in their houses for exp. my family.

[iensoong]

I am sure Sikhs are thankful for being hidden in your house as you claim, but the need for doing it should make clear to you the systemic problem. Hindus have a problem not just with Sikhs but with all minority groups, including Christians, Muslims, Buddhists, who have I forgotten? They have murdered these groups from one time or another in overwhelmingly Hindu coordinated riots. Hindu RSS is the largest terrorist organization in the world. Not individual, it is a systemic problem of Hindustan.

[Amanb1001]

What makes you think the RSS represents contemporary Hinduism? And as for Hindu's wiping out minoroties, can you give me examples? Don't forget the Muslims who killed many innocent Hindu's in Kashmir. The Sikhs who bombed Air India airplane in 1985. Every society has extremists, stop your generalizations.

[iensoong]

You are pretty dumb if you cannot understand recognizing systemic problems is not making generalizations. Sikhs were acquitted of the Air India attack and several books have pointed to Indian intelligence services. For examples of Hindu-led massacres reference Encyclopedia of Stateless Nations to begin. BJP is a wing of RSS and is by far the major Hindu religious political party. If India is a democracy it should allow a vote on Kashmiri independence. It won't because it is not a real democracy.

[Amanb1001]

You are pretty dumb to make these "systemic problems" out to be generalizations. Just read it in your previous messages. Canada has the KKK, but how much influence does it really have on Canadian society?

[secondaryhonour]

sikh did not kill any hindu it was the hindus that killed 10 000 sikhs all over india in 1984

[Amanb1001]

You're in denial if you think that. Try doing some research, and it wasn't 10,000; last time I checked it was half of that... I could be wrong tho.

[secondaryhonour]

if anything it was more then 10 000 sikhs killed by hindus and people still think hindus r a peaceful race

[secondaryhonour]

india is not a democracy it is the dictatorship majority. If it was a democracy then it should pull out of the minority nation which it occupies such as punjab and Kashmir and many more

[amitaas]

Indian Muslims are much better than Pakistanis. They are very constructive, on the contray the world knows that Pakistan has all the militants.

[smarteddie21]

stop interfering in our matters only an indian can know the problems with muslims

[lxjilyfe]

I know all Indians wanna kill all Pakistani,that's what you mean only indian "KNOW" the problems.

[smarteddie21]

listen dude how come pakistan taking place of indian muslims is that u mean. then ur wrong. not all indian muslims are like you