I just wanted to thank person that uploaded this video. I'm a sociology student and this really helped me conceptualize the visual manipulation of "what" and "who" is SUPPOSEDLY working class/middle class. It is nice to see the intertwining matrix of domination as it is not as it should be. Thanks again.
god, there are a lot of assholes posting comments on this video. If you are all so satisfied with our system then why bother watching. As they say, "strong words = weak cause
Poverty is everyones fault but the poor. Real nice. LOL I love it when people put a ton of energy into whining about being poor but no energy into getting out of poverty.
I am talking about poor people that whine and try to blame everyone but themselves for being poor. It is not like it is hard to get out of poverty in this country. You just have to put some effort into life.
the thing is that capitalist ideology relies on personal experience which it presents to the world as an adequate replacement for a systematic approach. it's a myth, just like smith's 'invisible hand'.
btw. what does an irish pirate song got to do with any of this?
and dont speak of Gráinne Ní Mháille (c. 1530 c. 1603), also known as Granuaile or Gráinne Mhaol, sometimes known in English as Grace O'Malley with such disreaspect bloody heathen
so you are unwilling to even define what socialism means to you?-Connotation is a subjective cultural and/or emotional coloration in addition to the explicit or denotative meaning of any specific word or phrase in a language, i.e. emotional association with a word.
though i've never said i was a socialist, i'm very sympathetic to the ideas of social equality and direct democracy, which i could identify with some of its fundamental principles. but i'm very unwilling to discuss it further with a person who advocates neoliberal capitalist values, even today when they've been discredited beyond any doubt. you are, my friend, what "we socialists" call, a reactionary. look it up on wikipedia. now if you'll excuse me, i have more important things to do
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
you cant articultae what you are,
and you think free market economics has been discredited?!
why? you have no sense of history do you? capitalism is cyclical there have always been recessions and boom and bust cycles, you really do need to study economics, i'm going to send you some videos on the indian economy and i want you to watch them, they explain
why the best way to eliminate poverty IS the free market.
We have not lived in an unfettered capitalist society! All economic problems that exist in this country are due to government policies that have been imposed on our economy. The federal reserve plays a big role in driving up the prices of goods and services due to inflation .
@TheWilliamcale Socialism has never been attempted authentically. Any time it has it has been destroyed from within or without by threatened power. If you had any understanding of what socialism is you wouldn't be attempting tired and antiquated "critiques"
@TheWilliamcale I also see that in your critiques you have no addressed any of the social issues addressed in this film and have again only thrown out tired critiques against socialism. So sad.
lol how are people bringing up socialism when this video is all about class portrayal in the media, especially television. idiots
lambeauleap66 11 months ago
OH NOES! black people!
This video is great, people show be more aware of the rise in prison numbers.
America has a form of fascism at work.
watch?v=s4-wicKsoi0
greenhell666 1 year ago
I just wanted to thank person that uploaded this video. I'm a sociology student and this really helped me conceptualize the visual manipulation of "what" and "who" is SUPPOSEDLY working class/middle class. It is nice to see the intertwining matrix of domination as it is not as it should be. Thanks again.
missaquaboogie 2 years ago
god, there are a lot of assholes posting comments on this video. If you are all so satisfied with our system then why bother watching. As they say, "strong words = weak cause
onedumbskank 2 years ago 11
@onedumbskank
Not sure about everyone else but I know I have to watch for a school assignment.
patch0482 11 months ago
Poverty is everyones fault but the poor. Real nice. LOL I love it when people put a ton of energy into whining about being poor but no energy into getting out of poverty.
shananagans5 2 years ago
Who are you talking about? the people in this video?
thejakeman16 2 years ago
I am talking about poor people that whine and try to blame everyone but themselves for being poor. It is not like it is hard to get out of poverty in this country. You just have to put some effort into life.
shananagans5 2 years ago
zzzzzzzz....
Adraell 2 years ago
thank god for the police
TheWilliamcale 2 years ago
please stop spamming
bifutake 2 years ago
do you know what you are?
a typical leftist who can not tolerate dissent because you are too stupid to defend wht you believe, say what you have to say, no one is stopping you
but do NOT censor rational center right dissent
TheWilliamcale 2 years ago
yeah, by calmly asking you not to spam
bifutake 2 years ago
explain why my comments are spam
i dont get it seriously
TheWilliamcale 2 years ago
"thank god for the police"
rewind 2:58-3:15
either you didn't understand it, or you chose to ignore the argument(s)
bifutake 2 years ago
you obviously have never lived near an american housing project, i have
thank god thank god for the police
'Sé do bheatha, a bhean ba léanmhar,
Do b' é ár gcreach tú bheith i ngéibheann,
TheWilliamcale 2 years ago
the thing is that capitalist ideology relies on personal experience which it presents to the world as an adequate replacement for a systematic approach. it's a myth, just like smith's 'invisible hand'.
btw. what does an irish pirate song got to do with any of this?
bifutake 2 years ago
my god your a socialist how boring and pathetic
take a course in economics
and dont speak of Gráinne Ní Mháille (c. 1530 c. 1603), also known as Granuaile or Gráinne Mhaol, sometimes known in English as Grace O'Malley with such disreaspect bloody heathen
TheWilliamcale 2 years ago
my bad, you're not a spammer, you're a troll
bifutake 2 years ago
well duh
but at least a troll knows socialism
is the refuge of semi literate malcontents
socialism is the ideology of the resentful loser in society who cant or more often wont put forth the effort to make it in the
free market
TheWilliamcale 2 years ago
correction, troll thinks he knows what socialism and capitalist 'free market' are
bifutake 2 years ago
I don't claim to be an expert
and a lot of economics confuses me
but i dare say i know more than you do
okay? would you like me to proove it?
TheWilliamcale 2 years ago
are you going to cite friedman now? stop sending me private messages please
bifutake 2 years ago
you cant defend your position can you?
TheWilliamcale 2 years ago
yeah, that must be it
bifutake 2 years ago
well why dont you try?
TheWilliamcale 2 years ago
remind me, what argument have you made so far?
bifutake 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
socialism has never worked
and only a fool persists in advocating a delusion
and while your at it
define socialism
TheWilliamcale 2 years ago
you're the one that started making noise about socialism and completely ignored what i actually said (regarding a systematic approach).
"lemme hear that dirty word - socialism!"
bifutake 2 years ago
so you are unwilling to even define what socialism means to you?-Connotation is a subjective cultural and/or emotional coloration in addition to the explicit or denotative meaning of any specific word or phrase in a language, i.e. emotional association with a word.
TheWilliamcale 2 years ago
though i've never said i was a socialist, i'm very sympathetic to the ideas of social equality and direct democracy, which i could identify with some of its fundamental principles. but i'm very unwilling to discuss it further with a person who advocates neoliberal capitalist values, even today when they've been discredited beyond any doubt. you are, my friend, what "we socialists" call, a reactionary. look it up on wikipedia. now if you'll excuse me, i have more important things to do
bifutake 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you cant articultae what you are,
and you think free market economics has been discredited?!
why? you have no sense of history do you? capitalism is cyclical there have always been recessions and boom and bust cycles, you really do need to study economics, i'm going to send you some videos on the indian economy and i want you to watch them, they explain
why the best way to eliminate poverty IS the free market.
TheWilliamcale 2 years ago
:epicfacepalm:
bifutake 2 years ago
We have not lived in an unfettered capitalist society! All economic problems that exist in this country are due to government policies that have been imposed on our economy. The federal reserve plays a big role in driving up the prices of goods and services due to inflation .
Pentazoid111 2 years ago
@Pentazoid111 Go suck Ron Paul's dick.
jimmyleg5 2 months ago
@TheWilliamcale Socialism has never been attempted authentically. Any time it has it has been destroyed from within or without by threatened power. If you had any understanding of what socialism is you wouldn't be attempting tired and antiquated "critiques"
unsung1984 1 year ago 2
@TheWilliamcale I also see that in your critiques you have no addressed any of the social issues addressed in this film and have again only thrown out tired critiques against socialism. So sad.
unsung1984 1 year ago 2