Added: 5 years ago
From: LelandHF
Views: 63,250
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (187)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • HD DVD IS DEAD NOW>>

  • A buddy of mine has both consoles like I do,but he also bought the HD-DVD add on and I didn't buy it because I was absolutely sure that Blu-Ray would win the day.

  • Damn, it's faster to watch on my crappy PC than on YouTube XL PS3.

    Plus on PC YouTube got much better quality cause you know, PS3 is outdated (needs Flash 10).

    HD-DVD and Blu-ray are awesome, but since HD-DVD didn't have region coding I would've wish HD-DVD stayed instead of BD.

    Yeah yeah, I know BD is 50GB (dual), and HD-DVD is 30GB (dual).

  • big ass remote

    

  • Can I play games on the HD-DVD Drive?

  • I wish the ps3 had came with a mail in rebate for 5 free blu ray movies.

  • I <3 the remote! I bought mine 2 months ago, and I already have 15 HDS in my collection, don't know why you are saying its dead its its bullshit, cose for me both sound and picture are as high as a blurayyyy!!!!

  • @Supralover79 The only difference between an HD-DVD and a Blu-ray Disc, is the space.

    There are releases that are exactly the same for HD-DVD/BD.

  • I like the way the remote looks.

  • wrong wrong wrong xbox 360 dose not upscals dvd i cant get it to work the dvd look as shit as thay where you need A HD DVD player to do that

  • hd dvd sould have ne i think dvd sounds write

  • i just brought one off ebay two days ago i wonder how it will work when it arrives for blueray i have a PS3 for bluerays and 360 for the older format of HD so doesn't matter cause i got two consoles

  • I miss HD-DVD. The user interface was so awesome.

  • Blue Ray won, nobody is selling HD DVDs so this is obsolete.

  • yeah, but blu-ray is too expansive

  • @Rafakino21

    The joke is that most movies for BR are made available for HD-DVD, and that those cost not more than 5 dollars, and you have some value, since the medium died and soon it will be a rarity to have a mint condition HD-DVD player with some movies. =D

  • can you play youer xbox 360 games on it plz

  • no you can't

  • nope

  • did you ever find out? as my dvd reader is getting glitchy and might buy one of these (there really cheap since blueray won)

  • You suck ass. The Xbox 360 is great!

  • PS3 sucks ass

  • This hd dvd was a huge epic fail another microsft rip off. Lets just stay with the standards for now. Cause it has better features and the guy in the video said it upscales a normal dvd.

  • It kinda sucks, and I've seen it, it looks a bit blury.

  • fail

  • wow sick game! Get em free like me ;o)

    xbox360 . watchit4free . com (without the spaces!) still waiting for mirrors edge to download! :P

  • hate all ps3 fans that dont know shit.. newer even played xbox 360 and still says it sucks.. you suck dumb ass..

  • My Xbox 360 dont upscale my dvds or do i need an hdmi cable to upscale them cos atm im only using the HD av cable (The green, red and blue ones) ???

  • Wait im a weee bit confused so does it or dont it play standard dvds on the hd dvd player ???

  • ps3 sucks

  • Don't buy this!!

    There aren't new movies on this!

    The Xbox 360 does fine with DVD upscaling and on top of that we are gonna have 1080p movie streaming soon.

    Oh yea and there is also Netflix.

  • @MegaShot419 Uh, duh, this is for collector's only now.

    I mean, why would a casual person would want obsolete technology???

  • this thing is now 50 bucks

  • try 30

  • two drives for one console, not cheap also!

    crazy microsoft....

  • i didnt watch the full vid cause my internet is only dial up but heres my question ok my xbox 360 dvd drive doesent work anymore,, if i bought the external drive could i play games through it???

  • go to my channel theres a website where u can get free console!!! and is totally legal and u can be any age check it out go on my channel and click the link :P

  • Oh, no slow-motion, no cd playback...hmm...who cares?

    Oh, did you mention the 5 times better resolution and triple as good, sound quality?

    I think the HD DVD drive was a great extension to the 360. Of coure, the blu-ray player in PS3 is superior but I mean the PS3 is superior to the 360 anyway...

  • @ziryab92 PS3 is technically superior, but if you compare side by side you won't notice which is which.

    BD had more space than HD-DVD, that's why it won.

    But damn it, BD is region locked while HD-DVD was free region everywhere!

  • so does the hd dvd also play games in better quality or is it just movies. im confused

  • to play a bluray movie on the ps3, open packaging, turn on PS3, insert disc.

  • is there a image quality differnce if a normal dvd is played in the hd dvd drive or the xbox 360 drive? Component or VGA for 1080?

  • Hi guys how can i watch my dvds on a xbox 360 with a 1080 resolution?

  • Blue ray won because of votes, but Hd won because of how many people actually own hd.

    Sony fights verry cowerdly, how can blue ray win if so many ppl own a 360?

  • A load of people own 360's. That does not mean many of them own the HD DVD drive.

  • many people own 360 but most people dont play games.

  • that is where you are wrong my friend...

    the 360 is designed as a gaming machine, i know i own one

    however! the PS3 if focused on multimedia!

    therefore if you buy a 360 for multimedia, it is a stupid buy

  • i meant the world. my bad. i read my comment. he said hd dvd should of won because lots of people have 360's. but most grown ups dont play games or have 360's. hope that made more sense i read this comment and confusing myself. oh well.

  • oh thanks for clarifying that logic makes more sense. =)

  • they dont care about this shit even if you have 1 million xbox its all because of the piracy thats why bluray win

  • xbox 360 is an awesome gaming machine but the ps3 has somany features that no thing can compare to it price wise

  • i have an xbox 360 elite and i love as my gaming machine but thank goodness i got a ps3 for my entertaiment....because i used that for blu ray (im glad it won) and music and otha stuff...blue ray is so much better

  • wow that was so bulky thank god blu ray won

  • it's features,like a lot of people said,hddvd had more features,but bad hd.

  • there wasn't that much difference..

  • Other than that,microsoft should just start making a blu-ray player for xbox 360,i mean cmon do you guyes think sony made blu-ray?They helped,but there were tons,TONS of companies that helped and sony added the fine blu-ray in,i mean just rip out the hd-dvd and put in blu-ray in there and you got an xbox 360 blu-ray dvd player :) for the standard price of it,or even cheaper,i mean be honest,the hd-dvd player was built with a cool look right?But a defeated format.And i bet microsoft can help with

  • i dunno how HD DVD lost. its a great format. and this HD DVD player add-onn is probably the best HD DVD player in the market.and it also had an attractive price tooo. but oh well

  • I agree. And as for the price. I bought one just for all the cheap dvds.

  • mm is it worth buying it?? i mean does it really looks cool??? because i have an HD TV and i want to see movies in HD, but ive never seen something in HD...

    so .. yeah, is it worth the money?

  • HD DVD is dead. but dont cry, you could still upscale DVDs to 1080p through HDMI. and you could always buy HD movies form the Market place, and soon we will be getting Netflix

  • lol ok haha thnks!!!

  • yea but if you go on ebay, they have these selling for like 10$ with like 20 HD-dvd's and they are about as good as blu-ray.

  • hey!!! thnx that is what i wanted to know :D

  • yea their is honestly no difference. Matter of fact, Hd-dvd was better than blu-ray because it had soo many features, but it wasn't built into the xbox360 like blu-ray was....which was a shame that toshiba gave up so easily because this was a really good format.

  • wow reaALLY!!!!! sounds very interesting!! i didnt knew that!! thnkx!!! :D

  • unfortunately, Production line of HD DVD is no longer existed:(

  • do you need to have the wifi adapter

  • Didnt M$ learn from Sega? Console add ons NEVER sell well.

  • i wish my xbox was working :(

  • Can the Xbox 360 Elite play Hd DVD by its self?

    --

    Sent from my Helio Ocean

  • REST IN PEACE HD DVD :'(, We will miss having you in our xboxes, but you died, and we're fucked :'(

  • if we r suppose to be in the so called HD era why couldnt we keep hd dvd's and get rid of regular dvds

  • @NoSemos look on the bright side. what did come out on HD DVD is not extreamly cheap =)

  • if they do that then sony will make money off every xbox thats made you idiot!!

  • cant you people see that i was joking thats why typed the lol, u fool

  • i hope MS releases a new 360 called the supe elite with BUILT IN wi-fi and blu-ray player and see how thoes ps3 wankers take that shit lol

  • first and formost SONY will NEVER have worked their asses off to give MS a blu-ray player fr Xbox and second if they did, Sony would be charging a lot of money fr MS to use it and the Xbox would be over $600 and sony would be making the money. so again this would never happen

  • it obvious that it would never happen, i was just having some fun, there is more chance of america and iraq being allies than this happening lol

  • I have a ps3 and love it, as I saw this video I noticed that he said ps3 does not up-scale movies to 1080P well it does, and blu-ray plays the same as the hd-dvd except it does not scratch which is a big bonus on the games.

  • does the hd dvd play the games and make them look any better I was just wondering I know hd dvds lost but since they are cheap I was wondering if I got one and pu a game in it would it play it at 1080p or will it still look like the other 1080i

  • Doesn't play the games and all the precessing/scaling for gameplay and movie playback is done by the Xbox 360 itself. Think of it as a drive and nothing else. The 360 can scale the games to 1080p weather you the have drive or not. but for $50 if you can find it is a great deal.

  • im so bord with the xbox 360 i ask around and people say call of duty 4 is the best game!

    but what else?

    they just say erm iv got a wii and thats good or im going to get gta4 i dont like gta games so i feel stuffed

    i liked gun that amazed me im still waiting for res 5 but i feel so disappointed with 360

    what is the difference in quality with hddvd to normal dvd?

    is any better from the sofa?

    i might just wait for nintendos next console that will be great im sure

  • It's to bad for 360 owners that they stoped making HD DVD's! I've hear thought that they are talking to Toshiba about there BlueRay technology!

  • can i play HD DVD movies on xbox elite

  • you have zoom on 300 just press the A button

  • actually you can do that on all HD DVD's

  • HD-DVD is dead but the Drive is very Cheap, last week i buy it for ca. 20 Euros!

  • I have coolers, on both of my xbox 360`s HD-DVD players,

    but not all have ones have !

  • do this player plays regular dvds

  • Yes. You can use it to take the wear and tare off the main drive. And playing a DVD in either drive (and not requiring the HD DVD drive itself) up-res a standard DVD to HD (I believe it requires the VGA or HDMI compatible 360 purely for copyright reasons.)

  • you know there selling the HD DVD players for 39.99 now used.

  • Because they failed, stores make them cheap to get them off the shelves to make way for Blu-ray.

  • I gives ca. 60 USD for it`!

  • Wow the movie looks good even on youtube. HD DVD is good with computers and 360. But Blu ray fans sorry but the Blu ray Disc are not compatabul with PCs.

  • lol.. i seems that ur brain is not up to date. HD-DVD's original inventor TOSHIBA has anounced that they gave up HD-DVD's development due to the fact that most of the medias now choose blu-ray discs. BTW, a lot of laptops r equipped with blu-ray disc drive nowadays, and blu-ray drive for desktops r everywhere also.

  • does an XBOX 360 has a builtin HD-DVD?

  • no microsoft scams people by selling expensive accessories.

  • Who knows, next generation or another format !

  • i got a the harry potter 1-5 movie bundle for $49.83 AUD and many more, including Into The Wild for $7.92 AUD lol

  • wii+360+pc = next generation

  • the ps3 also upscals dvd you stupid fuck,and dont post fake infomation asseholle.

  • I posted this in November 2006 right before the PS3 came out. I did NOT have the ability to upscale for several months after its release (and after I posted this review) For the record the 360 also didn't have the ability to upscale DVDs until it was also updated in early 2006. get you facts straight before you look like a moron next time.

  • I had, Xbox 360 with HD-player and PS3 with 60 GB- Blu-Ray.

  • i dont watch hddvd i prefer blu ray on my ps3 but i want to buy one as a collectable as last 360 item prolly until next console

  • part 2 anywhere?

    xxx

  • ha!ha!ha!ha!ha!

  • ha!ha!ha!ha!ha!

  • blu ray is blu gay lolololololol

  • why did it win then

  • in wikipedia it said HDDVD wont be producing anymore in stock anymore,so blu-ray wins the war

  • yep

  • lol it reeks like epic fail !!!!!

  • yes cheaper HD DVD drives

    ive made my decision

    and its not the blu-ray crap

  • HD-DVD got pwned

  • hd-dvd is dead! they anounsed today they were not going to ship out any more hd-dvds!blu-ray wins! the future is blu!

  • "Look how small the dvd box is" "Look at all the fucking attachments and silly and whorish my gaming system looks". I just want to stick my weiner in the usb ports and hump it.

  • Circuit City has discontinued the HD-DVD format so it can expand it's Blu-Ray lineup.

    It's Blu-Ray inventory is much bigger. Seven Circuit City stores were contacted. Three confirmed that the store has discontinued the HD-DVD format altogether, meaning Blu-Ray exclusive. This decision is probably based on company sales of the two formats which consisted of 87% for Blu-Ray disc and 13% for HD-DVD.

    It will be any day before Toshiba announces the death of HD-DVD.

    BLU RAY WINS!!

  • fuck you you are a bich the hddvd is so good like bluray and bluray dont have thats cool features

  • hahahahahaha thats why everyone is moving to blu ray asshole!!!

    see you dont even have anything good to say you cockhead!! name me how many supporters hd dvd currently have!!

    blu ray is taking over and did!!

    live with it blu ray OWNS HD DVD

  • i dont sayng bluray sucks i just sayng hddvd its not bad ok?

    peace

    i dont undestende why we have to be on a big war betwen xbox 360 and ps3 just can we all admit the tow conssoles are good and some peapol prefere a xbox 360 or a ps3

  • i remeber that the 360 fanhoes were saying that blu ray was going to loose and that hd-dvd was going to win look at them now!!

    hahahhahaha!!!!!!!!!

    the are begging for blu ray!!

  • fuck everybody with hd dvd or not the xbox 360 is the goodest sistem.

    Have some times better graphics then ps3 and fuck bluray

    STANSTEPUP mother fuckers and dont talk more im sick of riding yours fucking coments...

  • yeah ps3 has to hold back for games it shares with the xbox thats why GTA4 is being released later it had to get rid of things for space and graphics

  • Yeah, I mean who cares? HDDVD is still a HD product, it's good enough, besides Blu-ray movies don't usually use up a lot of space, about the size of a HDDVD.

  • It is not really a question of fanboyism anymore; companies that previously supported HD-DVD are mass migrating to Blue-Ray, Blue-Ray makes up the vast majority of sales now and retailers only really offer HD-DVD as a secondary choice.

    Blue-ray has basically won, by the end of the year I wouldn't be surprised if HD-DVD sales stopped completely.

    At the end of the day taking the price hit to include Blue-Ray on PS3 really paid off.

  • 5698xbox5698, enjoy your new betamax.

  • The music is from Virtua Tennis? =D

    HD DVD = awesome! ;-)

    BTW, Blu-Ray doesn't have those cool features and in-movie menu.

  • It is from the Dreamcast version of Virtua Tennis.

  • I still play that game on my Dreamcast 8D

    Awesome music, awesome gameplay!

  • Niyooh hate to tell you m8! but Blueray does have that funky - in-movie menu!..

  • The one thing that bothers me about the 360 HD-DVD add-on is that it does not support DD+ and Dolby True HD, which are mandatory per HD-DVD spec. I'm a 360 owner, and if HD-DVD was not losing right now, I would've bought a Toshiba A30 or XA2 instead of the 360 HD-DVD add-on just to have the support of new codecs.

  • Yeah and the Xboxes with HDMI are only 1.2 complaint. At the time this was better than the first gen Toshiba players (those could not do 1080P) and it still boots quicker than most other stand alone players. You also have to remember that you must have a new surround sound receiver to process those new codecs.

  • i dont know if i buy this,since blu-ray is getting all the movies

  • blu-ray works with a blue laser, hd-dvd doesn't. The advantages of a blue laser are apparent. 30gb tops for hd-dvd, 50gb or more for blu-ray now! it's clearly the better technology, but it is more expensive. you get what you pay for.

  • They both use the same blue laser diode. However the Blu-Ray is angled differently than HD DVD thus having the data layer closer to the surface make the beam less diffused, allowing the pits and lans to be smaller so more can be packed onto the surface area of the disc allowing more data to be stored. The disc however is more susceptible to scratches so a clear "armored" coating has to be applied from the factory.

  • "thats right, you heard me A LOAD SCREEN!" lol

  • ps3 does upscale dvds these guys dont know shit!

  • If you look at the date of this review, it was posted two days before the PS3 was released in America. The firmware that was current at the time of release did not scale anything (remember the whole downres for 1080i TV problem) The firmware update that enable scaling was not released until months after the initial release. Granted the 360 did not upres DVDs either out of the gate but had the function enable soon after launch as well.

  • xbox 4 life

  • The blu-ray is un-needed technology, and will become obsolete to HD-DVD

    HD-DVD will become the standard of home entertainment.

    I'm not a fanboy either. i don't own a ps3 wii or an xbox 360

  • omg blueray is already winning

  • he is right blu ray is winning 4-1

  • the problem though with bluray is sony. it is a sony thing only. this will hurt it a lot

  • We wouldnt be able to tell the difference between king kong hd dvd here wouldnt we?

  • Probably geting this for Christmas.I love christmas.

  • prety cool.

    HD-DVD 4 EVER

  • well it shouldn't play xbox or 360 games because it can be used USB with a PC, and if games could be read by the drive then it would be pretty easy to script software to play xbox and 360 games on a computer

  • Awesome review.

  • fuck the fucking ps3

  • no it really isn't, blu ray runs on a base of mpeg2

  • near the wii's release nintendo did officially say that they would make a wii with dvd capabilities, and at that time they said it would be out in summer of this year but they havent said anything since.

  • i heard there bringing out a new wii some time in the future which will play hd dvd, this is a n attempt from microsoft and nintendo to defeat ps3'ds blu ray i believe. however im not sure if this is tru

  • False

  • i took a dump inside the mouth of regime2008 's mom

  • wow, it can be placed anywhere near the console!

    i didnt realize!!

  • What is of interest is inside the case is a relatively generic PC ATA drive with a ATA to USB converter board. It's so non-proprietary that one can connect the drive via USB to a PC or Mac and the computers recognize it as an external drive. Now in regards to placement with the Xbox, just be careful not to block the vent holes.

  • Heh, you stupid fanboys you. >:3

  • i got a question... to watch a dvd on high definition.. i can get a normal dvd movie or i gotta an hd dvd movie..?

  • rite now there are new dvd players that upscales ur dvd's to 1080p but they are expensive

  • Your standard DVD will look better but it won't look as good as a hd-dvd, think about it, if the drive made all old DVD's hi-def, why would anyone BUY HD-DVD's?

  • my hd-tv is 720p n 1080i, can it play 1080p hd-dvd's? or will it just play an hd-dvd at 720p?

  • It will downgrade the resolution to the highest that your tv is capable of displaying which would be 1080i. Personally I would try to change it to 720p since some people say compared to 1080i, 720p actually looks better.

  • what an ass review

  • HDDDDVVVVDDDD....Jezz! Imagine some Grandma trying to ask a sales clerk for the HDDDVVVDDD version of Chicken Run. I hate even saying the word HD DVD! Blu-Ray may or may not be the future, but at least it has a better ring to it. I love all these Sega 32x add-ons for my Xbox360, not! Make an all-in-one unit, and give us HDMI out as well as true bluetooth for other devices and take the blow-dryer/heater out of my Xbox360.

  • HD-DVD is fantastic, I have the Standalone A1 player and the picture is amazing. Bluray is the next beta max, that was a sony product, so was UMD movies ha!

    HD-DVD rules

  • at the moment more movie studio's are going with blu ray and if you don't know what this means ill dumb it down for you. "if more studio's backup a format that format will win".

  • Xbox 360 Rules!

  • One thing I do dispute in the review is that the Xbox 360 has no problem rewinding or ff the videos from the marketplace. Actually, any more than 2x is a bit choppy and 8x or more is just rough as can be. This player might be a little more rough doing it but it is not very smooth at any speed searching through videos from the marketplace.

  • Microsft give its customers the choice on whether to buy the HD DVD drive or not, thereby keeping console cost's down, Sony on the other hand put in the Blu Ray player in every console thereby forcing customers to pay up to $599 or £425, even if you do not have a HDTV you are paying that price for a drive you will only use for games, when Sony could just have put games on DVD's and put a regular DVD player in the less expensive package.

  • Interesting. with an extra $200, you get an extra drive, extra wires, extra brick, all taking up extra space and to top it all off... a worthless movie. The ps3 still offers true-hd out of the box, i dont think we see any promises broken. Xbox fans are buying the betamax.

  • u dumb fuck, MS doesnt force useless media types (blu ray) to ppl who dont want a new betamax lol

  • CD-Rom debut for ps1, DVD debut for ps2, now Blu-Ray is debuting for the ps3. Its innovation 101, and its what sony does best. Now how about you do some reasearch on who supports blu-ray and the latest studios abandoning HD-DVD for blu-ray and then make the unbiased decision oh which will lose the format war. dumbshit.