Added: 3 years ago
From: FuzzyLomkins
Views: 23,268
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (121)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Am I wrong, or am I right...does sarge tap the child with the BIG gun and say "reload youre gun behind the wall son" ????? can anyone see anyone firing back? A few mean looking walls and much "WHOOP WHOOP" casualties...one kebab salesman, one dog...and American pride lol.

  • I bet that depleted uranium tastes wonderful that their pig daddys in washington is giving them to unload on innocent people. Imagine to all those still thinking our country should invade others. If a bunch of military troops dropped in here from overseas and started firing down on us wouldn't you pick up your AK-47 and go burn their ass up too? I mean then then would make us the Americans insurgents against them and "terrorists" in this fake ass war on terror. Our government is the terrorists.

  • Fucking war mongrels...

    you CAN'T make PEACE with VIOLENCE..

  • Comment removed

  • this song really doesnt have much to do with this kinda soldier, also why did you leave the sound in the war footage, should be listening to the lyrics.

  • I wish I could make a dam NIN video without youtube stripping the soundtrack

  • I suppose the irony of Marines in a video titled "The Good Soldier" would be lost on any but a serviceman.

  • By far THE BEST homemade video PERIOD!....I wanna be back over there so bad....NIN got me through the years over there!

  • dedicated to the veterans and soldiers... END THE WAR! 

  • This is the best homemade NIN video I have ever seen

  • @jamesjnnngs07 thank you, but i really just took couple of war videos and put them together and matched music as much as I could.

  • @FuzzyLomkins Well, you did an awesome job. I like how you made the gunfire coincide with the bass and drum patterns. Nicely done

  • should hav muted the live audio (except for the opening scene)

  • really good video, i like the beginning scene, the shots

    its hard

  • Looks familiar

    

  • Man, every man in uniform, and American-made weapon I see in this video saddens me so much. I just don't think it's our place to shooting at people of another nation in their own land, I don't even know why they're there, does anyone?

  • Man!!!!............this is .....happening.

  • War is a video game

    ... somewhere in the US

  • Christ almighty, that first 10 seconds of footage is fucking disturbing.

  • the 5 people that disliked this are rag heads

  • You know, I would personally like to thank you for making this video. We all have watched homemade music videos made by piecing together video together that has some significance to the song itself, and how many views do they get? A couple thousand... so I am glad to be one of the few that recognize your and other's effort.

  • @JordMcDrummer thank you :)

  • things haven't changed other than now he "signs his name with a capital" O

  • Wow... I was hoping for better comments on such a deep song, and kick ass video, but all I seem to see here is uneducated people throwing back and forth rediculous remarks, name calling, and meaningless points of perception... I suppose Reznor's right when he says this is not were I should be... Good day gents...

  • @SlainAngel06 Yup. Very, very few of us give enough of a shit to turn off all the distractions in our lives and get centered. I feel ya.. Reznor's a fucking legendary artist when it comes to describing this "Human Condition". "We're in This Together" is a perfect song about this too.

  • i hope every bullet in the video hit it's mark. 

  • very true. also, terrorism is a technique, not an enemy one can fight.

    this entire sham is a sick power game. i can feel civil war brewing..

    i can feel civil war coming in 12-25 years. my friends can feel it too, in our bones.

  • @coyotama sounds creepy

  • @coyotama no not 12-25 years... how about 12-25 months....

  • @coyotama There are times I'm afraid you're right. It's hard to conceive, but it seems distinctly possible with how divisive and hostile people have started getting. And our "news" media constantly whipping people into a frenzy over this and that isn't helping. I hope it's a misperception.

  • It would be better if it didn't have all the sounds from the videos.

  • Get some!

  • I hate those pussy sand monkeys all they do is hide, ambush, and rig there country with bombs and we all loose people be cause of it, and i might loose my dad because of the prick sand people over there. war sucks ass

  • @fathoody curse the one who told you it is a good idea to touch a electric fence, cursing an electric fence is as much stupid as touching it

  • @argonium79 Maybe........

  • cool song.

    and lets stop fighting about stuff like this. fighting never solves anything.

  • @V19torrent you wanna tell that to the man with the big gun?

  • @timheresy he'll agree with me ;)

  • your art is resistance...

  • fuck war!...folks WAR is not a video GAME!.......everyone who support war is in my eyes a stupid and morbid freak!.......this is a anti-war message....the song is great

  • @theNINrocker No it isn't, you have no idea. He's painting a dreamscape with this song, and to think that war is not necessary is stupid and has been proven COUNTLESS TIMES over the past millenia. You cannot just sit back and allow evil to rule the world without fighting back; you know this as well as I do, and the day we separated religion from State is the day we took a turn for peace.

  • @TheGr8one1022 i agree that we shouldnt just let evil rule. good people have to take a stand. but we have to draw a real line between defending our freedom and finding excuses to blow the Bedouins to bits. I believe that war MAY not be neccessary if everyone agrees so, but it never does turn out that way, does it?

  • this is awesome

  • 0:06 awesome puppy refuses to die

  • Comment removed

  • The message of the song and the album doesnt fit at all if this is meant to be a tribute to the fighting in Iraq:O

  • I know that.

  • good

  • Actually, if you ever tried to play the ARG, The Good soldier is about the airbourne crusaders and their use of diagra and stuff. But that, is another story

  • @libbern it isnt a tribute its just a footage of war in iraq and how the soldiers handle that there is nothing glorious about this video

  • @libbern The album is a concept album, based off of a fictional future setting. It's called Year Zero, check it out.

  • Comment removed

  • @libbern How can this be a tribute to those mass murders?

  • @libbern Well, it's a good thing this song isn't a tribute to those in Iraq, isn't it you fucking wanker?

  • @Groovebonesful

    Indeed it is, you fucking kangaroo rapist.

  • @libbern Well... not much you can say to that.

  • murder is not a good thing

  • thank you, capten obvious!

  • @FuzzyLomkins You helped as well, captain fucking sarcasm!

  • @Groovebonesful You should probably go to the gyno and get that sand out of your vagina.

  • 1:40 made me laugh!! god bless the troops.

  • Best soldier is that who not pick up sides

  • War is necessary, if it was up to the hippies we never would have stood up to Hitler or the Japanese Empire, and we'd all be speaking a different language right now. Oh and we stopped the Bosian genocide, but I guess I'm the only one that cares about INNOCENT ppl being killed, you have to fight to save them

  • How did "you" stop the Bosnian genocide?

  • well "I" didn't stop the bosnian genocide the coalition countries did US, Canada, Britain etc...

    You don't see holocaust camps there any more do you?, if you ask me that country should have stayed Yugoslavia, fucking Tito!

  • Save your simple, predictable and low arguments

  • ??? you mean facts, where's your argument? or you just like to instigate problems with no intellect.

  • @area51er6 - 100% right bro. The leftys act so heartbroken about certain people but couldn't give a shit about others. Does anybody really truly believe that if we just 'talked to them', that hate groups like the Taliban would see the error of their ways and stop fighting? Yeah right. Saddam was given over a decade to get his shit right (according to U.N rules, you know, the group the leftys love) and he snubbed his nose at everything thrown at him. Like it or not, sometimes war is the answer.

  • Please, don't generalise all "lefties" as acting heartbroken and not giving a shit about some people. I think both sides of the argument are valid, but there's no need to start using blatant, stereotypical, discriminatory digs to prove a point.

  • @xxgrungegoddxx Why would you ever thumbs up this post? By designating yourself as a lefty, you have ALREADY generalized yourself, and thus DESERVE to be stereotyped. You brought it upon yourself by subscribing to a set of beliefs not determined by sound opinions, but determined solely by "possibly valid" opinions.

  • War can be the awnser, it's sad taht sometimes people on both sides and inocent parties have to die as a result of the actions of leaders. I don't know if i believer Iraq was necassary, whether i believe it was a good thing or not is a different matter.

  • a bit 'out of sync' .. how does this perpetrate a good soldier? FUCK BLACKWATER.. they now changed their name , they used loopholes in the system and changed their name like puff daddy did under legal pressure.. fuck you criminals!!!

  • Väga hästi kokku pandud.

  • aitäh :)

  • no one even watched this in that time. what is the point of this and how does it happen ?

  • FUCK. everything becomes lame as soon as i try to make something interesting. Not lame, lametastic.

  • you idiots. haven't you even seen g force 3d the hamsters at war ? see the hamsters can be used as robots, in its huge robotic cover it has a torture button, it knows it's there and it tries to keep you from pushing that button so it basically kills everyone who comes close to it . ( you don't have to build it, but it's possible ) no it isn't....( not when your'e telling what to do you care chicks : )

  • I hate the beginning of the video.... It was sad how I just witnessed those guys get maurdered by those weapons... War sucks...

  • I know, regardless of what kind of people they were, I couldn't stomach being the guy to pull the trigger.

  • Exactly... It would kill me to have to kill other people... Like I said before... WAR SUCKS!!! lol

  • The video matches the song perfectly. you mixed the song with the real sounds beautifully. great video.

  • thank you :)

  • If I didn't know any better, I'd guess that was TF 1-26 "Blue Spader" from the BRO. Samarra '04. What a lovely little shithole of concentrated insurgency. Zarqawi-perverted anti-coalition sentiment.  Rez rocks btw.

  • excellent video man!

  • Idiot

  • and whys that, sweetheart?

  • Just enjoy the song and video and stop being a dick head who bring up religious warfare in a youtube video.

  • Goddamned idiots...

  • whoa, at 3:00 it looks like that soldier has an M1 garand

  • So fucking what. I'd like to kill you just for being a dick head, but that doesn't mean I will follow through, nor does it mean I have the means to actually do it. These are important factors to consider before you can determine if I represent a "real" threat to your life.

  • yeah seriously. i like how we're paying taxes and the leader of the IRS doesn't. obama is an idiot. but americans don't care. he is still jesus to them

  • 9/11 was like a near direct result of the US meddling in foreign affairs for jingoistic purposes though. 9/11 happened because not only did you piss these guys off enough to want to do it, by meddling in the Isreal/Palestine issue (which is really none of your business) but you also TRAINED these fucking guys on how to conduct guerilla warfare (i.e. terrorism) during the Cold War..

  • Guerilla Warfare is not the same as Terrorism

  • There's a lot of common ground. If these guys were trained how to use firearms and improvised explosives, sabotage infrastructures, etc. you really think it takes that much of a leap to use it against civilians to create terror?

  • Yes improvised explosives and the like are not far off from terrorism. But they do not necessarily mean guerilla warfare. Although those tactics can be and are used in guerilla warfare, they do not MAKE guerilla warfare. Guerilla warfare can be conducted without these methods. Just differentiating.

  • Yes, fair enough, I suppose. My point was that the same people that are responsible for terrorism against the west at present were also trained in methods that are commonly used as part of terrorist campaigns by the CIA, and that less intervention in foreign affairs by the US would result in less blowback and ultimately result in a safer US (and allies).

  • Yes, I agree with you there. It's just me being pedantic. Yes, the US did create their own worst enemy.

  • lol bull, dumb sandniggers got owned. just because the leaders can hide in caves and holes doesnt mean that they've outsmarted us, they will be found eventually once we put in the proper resources into finding them. sure, we are fueling an idea, but that idea will never amount to anything that will actually rival the united states.

  • @Sanguinis92 Both Al-Qaeda and the Taliban have conducted both Guerrilla Warfare and Terrorism, as it were. The main defining difference is that the former is targeted toward military personnel, whilst the latter is targeted toward civilians.

  • The Quran for the most part teaches tolerance and acceptance of non islam, however there are different parts of it that can be interpreted differently, kinda like the Bible sais thou shalt not kill and yet the crusades happened. Now all of islam MIGHT be hell bent to destroy America, it isnt it slightly more likely that ppl are mad because... idk... large portions of their populations are starving whereas in the US obecet is a public health concern... just off the top of my head....

  • there's a verse somewhere in the bible that tells you to kill homosexuals, yet also says killing is wrong.

  • Comment removed

  • War is necessary hell.

  • I'm gonna go ahead and ad that to the list of reasons war is retarded

  • how can war be a retard if it newer was an opposite? :D war just sucks.

  • (srry for the double post...)

    I mean... they could just be yelling orders and whatnot... but im pretty sure i hear quite a bit of whooping (ie yelling "wooooo!" at explisions) and such too

  • no, youre not the only one. I think they`re actually having fun. Maybe this way they can keep the moral high.

  • yeah maybe... still messed up tho

  • you're stuck in a city in a desert. Your armor chafes and so does your ridiculously heavy backpack, while you're getting shot at, and you don't even know by whom so everyone is potentially your killer

    giving up is not an option

    Stupid jokes are the only way to save your sanity

  • Am I the only one disturbed by how much fun the soldiers seem to be having?

  • they join the army cos they into that sort of stuff and enjoy the thrill

    personally i'd be shitting myself if i was out there

  • didnt you know thats how it keeps you from going crazy out there....

  • Thanks for actually using the song. All of these remixes and "live videos" suck compared to the original, and the addition of actual warfare is a nice touch

  • thank you :) I love this song and when I listen to it, I always imagine kind of stuff like soldiers and tanks so I tought war footage would make the video perfect.

  • totally kik ass dude

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more