Added: 1 year ago
From: guarunteedubliner
Views: 31,025
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (33)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Who's the singer in this one? 

  • @bookishmuch Ronnie Drew

  • great

  • the text is in the wrong order

  • Listened to this on the greatest hits vinyl album. Great song. RIP ronnie

  • to all the irish ..down under ...god be with u

  • WOW, What a voice, and what a moving performance!

  • R.I.P. Ronnie

  • When history forgets an event like this its the songs that keep them alive. I've never heard of Australians dying in WWI. but its songs like this that are a joy to listen to and keep those memories alive that need to be kept alive.

  • @MrBz123wee By all means . . . go listen to his version, then. : )

  • @MrBz123wee slim dusty doesn't hold a candle to ronnie drew..

  • @Glenn600ad look slim is better and more well known than Ronnie Ronnie is still good and this is just my opinion but imo Slim is better hes the grandfather of country music

  • @Glenn600ad Shut up!

  • @MrBz123wee And where's the rest of your joke?

  • @guarunteedubliner my joke? Slim Dusty, The Band played Waltzing Matilda: 70,078. Eric Bogle(a great singer no doubt) The BPWM 8,940 the views speak for themselves, put that in your pipe and smoke it

  • @MrBz123wee Look at views for John.

  • @MsSloppyseconds john williamson? if that is who you are reffering to the i agree hes a champion

  • @MrBz123wee If YouTube views are how you measure a man's talent, I wonder how you might have survived before the internet existed to give you your ideals of music.

  • @guarunteedubliner Great comment, and oh so true.

  • @guarunteedubliner im just expressing my opinion, I just think that slim is way more known than ronnie drew, but this is still a good version

  • @MrBz123wee I'm mostly just taking the piss. I'm not some sort of music purist. I guess my jests came off as a bit harsh. Sorry for that. Slim is wonderful, but Ronnie's m'hero. That's all, really. Hope you're well, and that I didn't offend you.

  • @MrBz123wee That, surely, is a matter of opinion......

  • Raw and heartfelt.Why have a pitch perfect voice if you don't feel it.Ronnie always meant it and felt it.One of the most effective anti-war songs going.Robert Wyatt could learn a thing from this song. God bless Ronnie you are truely missed. RIP.

  • The "war to end all wars" didn't. Futile, senseless, proved nothing. Millions killed, maimed, for what? For nothing! Little more than 21 years later, again death and destruction. For what? Utterly senseless. Tragic.

  • Great version sung with great feeling.

  • The best version of this song...... who is this??

  • @Tootie414 Ronnie Drew. 

  • @Tootie414 Ronnie Drew, one of the greatest Irish folk singers of all time (Luke Kelly may be was better I just can't decide) (look up "The Dubliners" or Ronnie Drew or even Luke Kelly for some legendary Irish Folk). (Even try looking for "The Pogues" and "The Dubliners" as they did a few songs together and more than a few pints)

    I think "Matilda" sung by an Aussie is always best, but the raw, gritty quality that this lad gives to it, is something else.

  • @biggmick1 Well said. Ronnie's way of putting a song across was so raw and real that whatever he was getting across held that same quality. Luke . . . Luke was a treasure as well. High King of Balladeers, unmatched forever, in my opinion. All the Dubs were (and are!) so human--I think that's their appeal. So, Tootie should just delve right in and lookit some of their work!

  • @Tootie414 Listen to Eric Bogle and John Monroe in his last few shows before he stopped touring. His voice has gotten deeper and more mellow, which adds more depth to the song.

    Another great Eric Bogle song is "A reason for it all" check it out.

    I/M

  • wow it's Ronnie Drew its good and this song is brillient , some other singers are a bit better, and Ronnie has some songs nobody can match him. God Bless Ronnie

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more