You've obviously never been a part of any good music anything, and you should really never leave positive comments for crappy performances, ever, in fact you should never critique anyone, ever.
I have judged and trained professional vocalist's for 40 years. In all my time, I have never heard someone completely butcher a piece quite as successfully as this young lady has. Just as the line from the movie Rigoletto goes, "you sing like a goat."
@musiccriticforlife54 i know this was posted over a year ago but still i can't help but say what is on my mind that is what your problem is "I have judged " the keyword is Judge when you judge you leave no room for improvement judging uses harsh hurtful words like you have in this post because you are listening for how you think she should sound you aren't listening to her voice her voice is beautiful and no she has not butchered it she did a lovely job
I don't think you realize what kind of talent you have! I believe in you. You should be melting peoples faces off with that gorgeous voice of yours! I bow before you. congrats!
WOW WOW AND WOW! when i first started watching this I wasnt expecting such a big and beautiful voice to come from such a meek looking person. With many singers u can just see the arrogance as they sing, not u and i commend u! bravo. oh i must knw did you win the talent show? if u ddnt smthngs wrong.
Nicely done! I think the tempo seemed a little slow, but really awesome job! Of course there's always room for improvement...but that shouldn't take away from the fact that you did a great job here
NO, NO NO! IT'S ALL THE SAME!!! Take the music out of your throat and put it into your head! EMOTION must come through in your voice, my dear Jill. You do well, though.
Meh, I don't care what people think, it doesn't have to sound exactly like the original, I mean come on! D8 She's a girl peoples, it isn't going to be all deep like the original as you would hope it would!
You deserve a five star rating, that was really pretty and it sounded really good to me. Don't mind these other peoples, they don't know what they're thinking
you need to use more breath support....you sound very airy and off key. ..there are moments that are good...but over all you need to work on your vocalization some more.
It's good, but, in my opinion, it needs a little tweaking. at times you and the piano were off, and i think the piano and the singing really need to go together to make the song complete. Don't try to push the high notes, let them come nice and easy. "pain" was good, but hold it a little longer for a better effect. overall, the song was ok.
hahahahahaha i know the little children were like...hey check out my booger hahaha but u sang a classic song and its really heart warming wihtout getting off key---that was wonderful<3 i love this song the chords make me wanna cry
I think this would have been better live. Recordings never do anyone justice. Pretty good other wise. :)
cheshirhatter 6 months ago
@musiccriticforlife54,
Well said, that just made my day! This was terrible and the accompaniment was worse!!
@helloakayan,
You've obviously never been a part of any good music anything, and you should really never leave positive comments for crappy performances, ever, in fact you should never critique anyone, ever.
leadtrumpet14 1 year ago
Where did you get the music for this song? I have wanted to find a copy of this and others from the movie for ages and have been unable to.
joeyswish2008 1 year ago
I have judged and trained professional vocalist's for 40 years. In all my time, I have never heard someone completely butcher a piece quite as successfully as this young lady has. Just as the line from the movie Rigoletto goes, "you sing like a goat."
musiccriticforlife54 1 year ago
@musiccriticforlife54 i know this was posted over a year ago but still i can't help but say what is on my mind that is what your problem is "I have judged " the keyword is Judge when you judge you leave no room for improvement judging uses harsh hurtful words like you have in this post because you are listening for how you think she should sound you aren't listening to her voice her voice is beautiful and no she has not butchered it she did a lovely job
RiskaNTora 4 months ago in playlist mix
I don't think you realize what kind of talent you have! I believe in you. You should be melting peoples faces off with that gorgeous voice of yours! I bow before you. congrats!
helloakayan 1 year ago
you are so good you make the pianist sound like crap...
helloakayan 1 year ago
WOW WOW AND WOW! when i first started watching this I wasnt expecting such a big and beautiful voice to come from such a meek looking person. With many singers u can just see the arrogance as they sing, not u and i commend u! bravo. oh i must knw did you win the talent show? if u ddnt smthngs wrong.
Dsolo990 1 year ago
Great Job.
April5729 1 year ago
you have a fantastic voice! :D have you sung any other pieces (as in put them on youtube)? I'd love to hear them. :)
frodobaggins115 2 years ago
Nicely done! I think the tempo seemed a little slow, but really awesome job! Of course there's always room for improvement...but that shouldn't take away from the fact that you did a great job here
Siogadream 2 years ago
NO, NO NO! IT'S ALL THE SAME!!! Take the music out of your throat and put it into your head! EMOTION must come through in your voice, my dear Jill. You do well, though.
gothicpyrotech360 2 years ago
actually she did a very very very freakin awesome job...... beautiful operatic voice..
ac360lover17 2 years ago
AWESOME!
BRAVO!
She who contolls the breath caontrolls the voicde!
goodwinj82 2 years ago
Wow, that was beautiful! I was literally sitting here trying to fight back tears. Very well done. FIVE STARS.
Yryr8258 2 years ago
wow..beautiful voice
Wolffire04 2 years ago
Maam, im going to be polite as i can with this one:::: THAT WAS FUCKING LOVELY, AB SO FUCKING LUTLEY LOVELY!!!!
Panamastar1 2 years ago
You're beautiful and so is your voice! Very well done, opera is so magical and you sang this so extremely fantastic!
optimisticautiously 2 years ago
Meh, I don't care what people think, it doesn't have to sound exactly like the original, I mean come on! D8 She's a girl peoples, it isn't going to be all deep like the original as you would hope it would!
You deserve a five star rating, that was really pretty and it sounded really good to me. Don't mind these other peoples, they don't know what they're thinking
ClassicSnap 2 years ago
HI, I was wondering where you got the sheet music for this? I wish to perform this myself and cant find this ANYWHERE!
Adorian11 3 years ago
you need to use more breath support....you sound very airy and off key. ..there are moments that are good...but over all you need to work on your vocalization some more.
highhurdler15 3 years ago
oh shut up....loser! she did awesome!
goodwinj82 2 years ago
It's good, but, in my opinion, it needs a little tweaking. at times you and the piano were off, and i think the piano and the singing really need to go together to make the song complete. Don't try to push the high notes, let them come nice and easy. "pain" was good, but hold it a little longer for a better effect. overall, the song was ok.
celtictigress 3 years ago
yeah... don't force those high falsetto notes, just straighten your back, stand proper, and relax the throat. also, practice your tone.
uknowitstrue321 3 years ago
Excellent job its a very changeling song to sing and you did quit well keep up the awesome work love it
RiskaNTora 3 years ago
props to you. it takes a lot for a person to put themselves in the spotlight knowing people will criticize. beautiful voice.
tehanismom 3 years ago 2
she killed that song eww leave it to joseph puar sing it, it only souds good when he does it
xevanescencexloverx6 3 years ago
what was that
PDDR2008 3 years ago
ick.
PrincessIcicle 3 years ago
i like it but i wish i could hear her better. and if that person wasnt talking other wise woah you can sing! 5/5
Dreamerinlove050 3 years ago 3
Hey thanks! It's hard to record music in a gym full of people and with little kids who just want to play! :o)
mamapierce 3 years ago
hahahahahaha i know the little children were like...hey check out my booger hahaha but u sang a classic song and its really heart warming wihtout getting off key---that was wonderful<3 i love this song the chords make me wanna cry
darknluv 3 years ago
Ward, as in LDS church ward?
Great job. I love this song. It's odd hearing it with a female voice, versus John Paur's voice though. :)
PeanutbutterCrazy 4 years ago
Beautiful job !
SSanguineSS 4 years ago
Wow amazing voice... the piano sorta took your voice over but I could still hear you Beautiful...
Codered2008 4 years ago
beautifullllll....i love it...u were great
YoungvSquad 4 years ago
Wow. My mum luvs the Rigoletto Movie. You were great!
DylanSprouseRox 4 years ago
Hey thanks so much! I love to sing. Thanks for the compliment! :o)
mamapierce 4 years ago
you sing this Beautifully :) I love the movie and you have a wonderful voice...No Pitch problems whatsoever....Just wow....
MtnSiren89 4 years ago