Personally I always thought this was lipped...even the spoken part of the song sounded EXACTLY like the studio version. Tone and drawl. I'm probably wrong tho.
completely live awsome. best live vocal past 2006. if she only sang songs live from the current album she was promoting we would still think she sang as good as daydream. her voice changes all the time hence singing old songs isn't her best suit.
I wish she wouldve done more of the song before the climax..So it has time to build up, cuz on the cd, for some reason, everytime it plays, my body feels the need to lip synch to it. lol..its real emotional.
Actually, she has strived to sing all hit songs subject to time. For example, when she saw a fan requesting her to sing Can't take That Away, she said Hero is the same sort of song. It is definitely better if she do fewer snippets.
I agree. There's no buildup whereas in the studio version there's this huge climax and you can just feel the emotion as it reaches that top. Here it's like 'wow, high note... but what's the point?' because we don't really see why she's putting so much emotion into just one moment.
I mean, hardcore fans will know the song and understand the buildup :P. But for others they'll just wonder.
I HATE DJ Clue shouting his name and that "Desert Storm" crap. But at any rate, I love how she sang "I Wish You Knew." It's one of my favorite tracks on The Emancipation of Mimi.
Personally I always thought this was lipped...even the spoken part of the song sounded EXACTLY like the studio version. Tone and drawl. I'm probably wrong tho.
Crzymofo69 9 months ago
completely live awsome. best live vocal past 2006. if she only sang songs live from the current album she was promoting we would still think she sang as good as daydream. her voice changes all the time hence singing old songs isn't her best suit.
jesparza562 2 years ago
she is the best
chiwochiwon 2 years ago 2
oooo i bought the dvd and she sang this. i <3 this song!
butterFLYlikeabird 4 years ago
Cool! But I have to admit that that shown filmed wasn't her best perfromance. Still good.
michaelchanyc 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lipped
foreverlonging 4 years ago
Are you sure?!
michaelchanyc 4 years ago
yeah lets be real here it's exactly like the CD... BUT! she DOES do it live on the DVD version!
foreverlonging 4 years ago
oh my god!! that's enough! y do haters that word always comes out from their mouth??.!! u suck!
naksnaks625 3 years ago
Yes it is lipsynched, please opne you eyes and ears, She cant have the sonority of her voiceduring the Unplugged days
roncerod 3 years ago
OMG I love Mariah Carey she is my favorite singer ever♥ she sounds so amazing in this song its crazy.
Blakelover4ever 4 years ago 2
yes, it is pityful. TEOM album is awesome, i love every song inside it. Each song is so impressive. But most promoted are RnB songs.
Puikideo 5 years ago 2
I wish she can sing the whole song in the coming shows or concert. I would like to hear Circle, Joyride as live performances :>
Puikideo 5 years ago 2
it's not so possible as she is going to release new album that means new songs are coming out.
michaelchanyc 5 years ago
she is amazing!
bleakosity 5 years ago
I wish she wouldve done more of the song before the climax..So it has time to build up, cuz on the cd, for some reason, everytime it plays, my body feels the need to lip synch to it. lol..its real emotional.
lilheir 5 years ago
Actually, she has strived to sing all hit songs subject to time. For example, when she saw a fan requesting her to sing Can't take That Away, she said Hero is the same sort of song. It is definitely better if she do fewer snippets.
michaelchanyc 5 years ago
I agree. There's no buildup whereas in the studio version there's this huge climax and you can just feel the emotion as it reaches that top. Here it's like 'wow, high note... but what's the point?' because we don't really see why she's putting so much emotion into just one moment.
I mean, hardcore fans will know the song and understand the buildup :P. But for others they'll just wonder.
TropicalMariahLover 5 years ago
Umm there is a buildup because this is opening up the concert...
foreverlonging 4 years ago
Great!love mc!
RobinLue 5 years ago
I HATE DJ Clue shouting his name and that "Desert Storm" crap. But at any rate, I love how she sang "I Wish You Knew." It's one of my favorite tracks on The Emancipation of Mimi.
joshuakeria 5 years ago
I agree with you. DJ here wounded the whole song
michaelchanyc 5 years ago