Added: 3 years ago
From: DWaDDLJ
Views: 19,666
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (126)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • my fav companions

    1. donna

    2. rose

    3. martha

     4. amy & rory

  • i love the bit from 0:27 to 0:32

  • Does anybody know where I can watch all the Doctor Who series?!?!?

  • i cried so much!!! i loved these two together.

  • fantastic video the six people that didnt like this need to have their memories erased.

  • This scene made me realize how much I loved Donna.

  • Donna Noble was the only (human) character that I ever cried and mourned for. In the back of my head, I knew that she was fictional, but I went through all of the stages of grief, and it took 2 days before I could feel any sort of okay after I saw what happened to her. She was my favorite of all the companions and I think that series 4 was the best of the new Dr. Who so far.

    Erin

  • @erienspice yeah it's amazing eh? we almost feel like they are real people after they go :)

  • @andrewdafoe I think it just really shows how good the writing and the acting was, so I give props to that.

  • my heart breaks whenever I see her leave! It's so sad

  • They were great together.

  • Donna....the best companion ever....Would love to see her come back, even if she meets the new Doctor....maybe the cracks in time have something to do with Donna...

  • that clip is so good

  • @angelkkr thanks :)

  • i was one of the ones that douted catherine tate ,but after this performance WOW

  • @lwest20 so glad you liked her in the end :)

  • She was my favorite i cried when she left :'(

  • no dont go

  • im crying so much <3

  • so beautiful done!! 

    and omg i'm still crying!

  • Thamkyou so much. Sorry it made you cry though. :)

  • Poor donna 0:50

  • Yes, poor Donna...thanks for watching :)

  • cried my eyes out on the finale and i still cry whenever i watch the finale, i havent seen all of the DW series but i was hooked the moment i watched the with david and catherine

  • i think they suited each other ....them two are ma fav...shame donna had to go :( and now david tennants gone to :( doesnt feel like doctor who no-more with out them :( i hate the new doctor

  • I wasn't very keen on DT when he was announced, in fact I hated him...but he won me round in the Christmas Invasion. So don't give up yet, as you may end up liking Matt even if not as much as DT. Thanks for watching :)

  • HE hasn't even done anything yet, get over yourself. It not going to suddenly suck because David isn't the doctor. New companions aren't going to suck because they aren't other companions. That doesn't mean don't be sad about him leaving, but don't write someone else off because of it. Honestly.

  • Dr Donna - Genius! I look forward to her coming back. She was a real asset to the show.

  • Yep she was definitely great! Thanks so much for watching :)

  • No worries. Just watched part 2 of End of Time. Looks like Donna will be happy. I hope she will return a few times. Very special lady xx

  • The Doctor Donna shall return.

  • And when the DoctorDonna returns, I have no doubt it will be her final sacfarice.

  • question. if there cant be a time lord / human metachrisis. doesnt this mean the human doctor that stayed with rose will die too ? ? ?

  • No because he has a time lord brain with human heart, but Donna had a human brain with Time Lord brain then mixed into it, so she would have died with the with all that knowledge, but the other Doctor will die only when death comes, because he can't regenerate. Thanks for watching. :)

  • That is untrue. he like Donna is half human half timelord, we know that he has a time lord mind with a human mind, specifically Donna's, mixed in with it, hence why he starts talking like her. It is likely that it is just one of many plot holes that can be found in every doctor who episode.

  • No its not a plot hole really, because the other Doctor already had the mind of a Tme Lord, a mind that can already cope with all things Time Lordy like the actual Doctor, and took in Human traits, like Donna's personality. The only thing that really affected him was that he didn't grow an extra heart, which plays a part in the regeneration process. Donna has a Human brain, the Time Lord stuff was extra, and could eventually kill her.

  • This is a beautiful video. It was so sad for to the Doctor to wipe Donna's memory in order to save her life.

    They were well suited together. This song fits with the video very well.

    I'm planning to sing this song with all my friends at work because one of my manager's is leaving so we're gonna sing this at the leaving do.

    Thanx for making this lovely video.

    5 stars and faved.

  • Thanks so much....this somg is a brilliant song for when the people in your life move onto new pastures.....hope all goes well at the do....

    Thanks again for your lovely comments :)

  • Well, we know she is coming back in the Christmas specials "The End of Time".

    So well see them again in the Woniverse.

  • We shall see, rose came back. I personally dont think donna is though

  • I wish she had been on for longer. They didn't get enough use out of her as a companion. It feels like in the older series the companions would be along for much longer, but here it feels like every season they're changing them.

  • Yeah they do change them, but I think that is to keep every series feeling fresh....and to think if that wasn't the case, then we wouldn't have got Donna at all....and you never know, anyone can come back in Sci-fi....

    Thanks so much for watching and commenting :)

  • Yes, but the series also needs to give us time to grow fond of these characters. To get attached to them, rather then having them just be a flash in the pan, to be forgotten when subsequent companions come along.

  • I was so mad when she came on, she was so annoying as the bride! I hated her.

    But I love her now... I'm sad she had to go.

  • I'm glad you liked her in the end.... :)

    Thanks for watching and commenting :)

  • I may be just a little off mark but if it is true about the metta crisis...what will the Donna/Doctor be going through? After all, he is part and part also, and if she cant exist then surely he cant either? Any thoughts, anyone?

  • Hiya....the Doctor.2 was already a time lord but he inherited human bits like only one heart from Donna.....but Donna was human and she inherited his brain.....so a time lord being the better specias can last with human features....but a human is too fragile to have time lord parts as such....

    Hope that answers your question :)

  • If i owned Doctor who instead of the BBC, David would still be the doctor : )

    great vid : D

  • Thankyou....

    Yeah we will all miss DT...he has been great, but I wish Matt Smith all the best too, as I once wasn't willing to give DT a chance when CE left....how wrong was I???? I like DT even more than CE now....so I'm Not making that mistake again....

    Thanks for watching and commenting :)

  • Great song choice, but so very very sad. How can you not cry over that? Beautifully done.

  • Hi Tigger....thankyou so much...

    And its RTD's fault your crying....not mine...

  • i love thsi video it so cool and so sad

  • fantastic video. I Love donna and the doctor together. I wish could David Tennet play the doctor forever

  • Thankyou so much....

    and I agree the tenth Doc and Donna work very well together.... :)

  • Great idea to actually have them speaking, rather than just immediately loading the music vid.

    So sad what happened. There's no doubt that Donna would have stayed with him forever, especially as he's moved on from abandoning his companions, e.g. Sarah Jane, Jack etc, and actually can handle them staying with him for as long as they want.

  • thanks so much...glad you liked it...

    Yep she could have stayed....but I guess even if the Doctor would want that, he knows no one can saty with him forever....so sad :(

  • yeah. he even says that to rose. while they can stay with him for the rest of their lives, he can't do the same as he will out live them.

    But with Donna, their was no romance issues that caused problems like with Rose and Martha and I do think she was the one person above all others he really wanted to stay for as long as possible. So sad this couldn't happen, and that losing her was the only way to save her :(

  • I cried soooo much when I saw that scene the first time. I didnt feel that sad when the doctor made Rose stay in Pete's world. It's so heartbreaking...

  • I know...I still cry...

    thanks for watching and commenting :)

  • she will ALWAYS be the Doctor Donna.

    we will never forget her, but she can never remember...

  • Yes she will...and no we wll never forget...

    Thanks for watching and commenting :)

  • look at me donna

  • It was worth it. :)

  • Thanks :)

  • Great video and the song as well. But I had the hard time watching the end of Journey's End without crying.

    Seeing this part with Doctor removing the memories of the Doctor from Donna made me cry all over again.

    Thanks for sharing. :)

  • I know ezactly how you feel....in fact I cry at the end of nearly every series 4 episode and runaway bride, cos I keep remembering that Donna will not remember any of this :(

    But thanks for watching and leaving such nice comment....and sorry to make you cry....

  • I, also, how you feel. I still cry after watching that scene. The worst part for me is that I know so few Doctor fans that I can not explain it others.

  • Oh I know how you feel, that is why I come here to able to share my love for the show...

    Thanks for commenting :)

  • i love this video itos cool and so sad

  • I never ever thought I'd cry for Catherine Tate but I did and still do xx

  • I still cry cry too :(

    Thanks so much for commenting and watching :)

  • After reading this I wanted to make sure before I went on a rant about how retarded you were. I got the offical ratings and basicly this series got 7.3 million views (based on last episode) and the best being 8.4. So actually you're part of a very small, less than 10% fraction, that think that Donna is bad. This based on the fact that at the end of this series those less than 10% people where avoiding the show on purpose and not missing it by accident. My point: You're a thick twat.

  • The best times with donna.........oh donna noble i am so sorry. but we had the best of times.The best.

  • Yep we sure did....thanks for watching and commenting :)

  • Donna is, in my opinion, the best companion the doctor has ever had. DT & CT were a brillaint combination, I miss her and I am going to miss him so much I can't imagine someone else as the Dr, but I have to say that after watching Strictly come dancing, Tom Chambers could be a good choice.

  • Yeah I'm going to miss them both too very much so...

    LOL...maybe chambers would be good... :D...but the bets are closing on Paterson Joseph...so he seems more likely to be the 11th Doc...

    Thanks for watching and commenting :)

  • This made me cry when I watched it on tv, and now I'm tearing up again. I'll miss Donna. :(

  • Sorry it made you cry agian...I miss Donna too....

    thanks for commenting :)

  • i love thsi video it so cool and so love this guy

  • thanks so much... :)

  • What a Brilliant video, i miss Donna they've gotta find a way 2 bring her back they did it with rose so there must be a way 2 get Donna back n not only hav we lost Donna but Davids goin as wel. 5/5 n faves

  • Thankyou so much....I'm glad you liked it....

    And yeah....its so sad that now we will lose DT as well....that DoctorDonna partnership may not return in future....but I hope it does, even if for five minutes like Time Crash....

    thanks again for your lovely comments... :)

  • I WAS SO sad that i heard that donna not gonna come bak and the person who plays her adn same for david tennett :-(

  • So was I...and I am feeling the same for DT as well...he will be missed...

    thanks so much for watching and commenting... :)

  • yeha i cant wait to see the 11th doctor but the 10th doctor always be top

  • same here..... :)

  • Aww So Sad At 3:23.

    Very Very Very Very Good Vid! =]

    5*'s & Im Gunna Sub You!

    Keep It Up!

  • Oh thankyou so much....Im really glad you like it....again thankyou :)

  • We all miss dr donna they had the best of times

  • Yep very true...

    Thanks so much for commenting:)

  • i love this video i tos cool and so sad

  • Thankyou so much :)

  • dont use my spoilers plz

  • I won't, but if anyone from the Sun watches this and sees your comment...don't be suprised to see it in their newspaper by the end of the week :D

  • i would be in the news and interviews XD

  • Yeah! but you'll only be called "the inside Source"! :D

  • Will You Delete The Comment

  • What your spoiler one???

  • Yea

  • Thats amazing, Well Done! I love it! Hope Donna comes back that would be great

  • Oh thankyou so much....yeah it would be great if she did, but only if she didn't die :)

  • i miss donna 2..i fink she ws the bst companion the doctor has had :D i cried wen she left nd i hope they ind a way 2 bring her bak!

    DONNA RuLEZ! x

  • It would be great if she came back, but that might mean her head might explode! But yeah she does rule!

  • Or a total romantic i mean i smiled my head of i also started crying because it was the mommet that all us RoseShippers waited for our whole dr who lives and the greatest moment in all Rose fanfics. But yeah she was a best friend it was reli nice but it makes me cry so much because you can see pure emmotion and pain in her eyes and the sorrow in the doctors eyes in that momment when she realises shes going to lose everything and basicly die.

  • LOL, never saw it like that :D, but we were waiting, and she just wanted to see her best friend happy, and I doubt she was reading any fanfics :D but I know what u mean...and yes I still can't get over that memory wipe scene, I think I would have found it easier if she had died, I know thats harsh, but to live on without knowing about the wonders she did...is heartbreaking..

  • I feel exactly the same way. Becaus ethis is final but not completely which is why its so difficult because even if she comes back shell never know i mean shes the most importnt person in the universe she saved the world at least twice but she can never ever know in her whole life just how amazing she is. That secene realy shows everyone just how amazing Catherine is at acting because that moment was so emotional so real. It just brings all the pain you have from past moments into that moment

  • Yep CT is absolutly amazing...and I hope she wins some awards, as that will be the final way to quiet down the naysayers....

  • Yeah dr who cactualy won that thing they won last yeah or te yeah b4 wiv rose so thats well good

  • I love the video not too keen on the song but LOVE the video. I was in tears just by the first clip but i think you shud have played it until se fell into the doctors arms But it still gets a 5/5 from me.

    =D

  • I'm so glad you liked, I never thought about doing it the way you suggested, but I'll keep that in mind, thanks so much for watching :)

  • Its okaii i love watching videos its fun =D

    Man i reli miss Donna she was amazing. :'(

  • Yeah I miss her too, she became the best companion ever IMO....

  • IMO? And who was your fave b4 her? Mines rose still is but Donnas only a litle bit behnd she was so amazing, funny and such a good actress i mean everyone just thinks Catherine Tate-the comedianbut now its Catherine Tate-Comedian and amazing emotional actress

  • Same as you, Rose, and I liked Martha too, but she never reached that same position as Rose, until Donna came along, she was as you say amazing, but more so becuase she was the Doctor's best friend, which is exactly what he needed, and the prove of what a great friend she was is the way she smiled when the Doctor saw Rose, only a best friend would do that! :)

  • i love t hsi video it so cool

  • Thankyou so much, I'm glad you liked it :)

  • Nice work. Donna will be missed :(

  • thankyou so much...and yes Donna will be missed....actually I miss her her already:(

  • Donna wasn't my favourite character but I adored her in the end. She was the chalk to his cheese and they matched so well! In the soley 'we're best friends and no we dont want to bone but we want to spend our lives together' type of way.

  • I'm glad you liked her in the end, and yes they matched really well...thankyou so much for watching and commenting :)

  • Oh thankyou so much....I'm so glad you liked it....thanks again :)

  • Brilliant and very sad. Thanks a lot for this

  • No thankyou for watching it and for your lovely comment :)

  • wen i heard she was the new companion i thought it wuld be realy bad but now i think she's the best companion. beautiful vid tho *crying* so sad, i miss donna!

  • I'm glad you liked her in the end, because yes she was the best companion....

    Thank you for commenting and sorry it made you cry....:)

  • beautiful

    the video

    the song

    and

    the characters

    makes me cry

  • Hey you've seen it before...stop depressing yourself by watching it, I can't watch it anymore...and I made it...but its the memory wipe scene that gets me going...

  • yeah

    but its greatand deserves to be watched again and again

    :)

  • Aww thanks...:)

  • Awesome, that part where he says goodbye always makes me tear-up. Felt the transition to the song was alittle jarring after the silent and somber farewell but once it got going I really liked it. Him, her, and you all Brilliant.

  • Yeah I know what you mean....I wasn't 100% sure where exactly to start the song...I did think it to be a bit cliche from I did start it...but I thought what the heck....too depressed to think sraight...

    But thankyou for honest comments...and glad you liked it in the end....:)

  • *sobs* BEAUTIFUL!

  • Oh thankyou so much...sorry it made you cry though :)

  • when she was first on I hated her and was so upset she was the new companion but then we got to know her and I loved her. As the Doctor said she was brilliant I am so sad she is gone and in such a cruel way. memories make a person and now the Donna we know and love is dead. I think this was a sadder goodbye then the first time with Rose

  • I know many people felt like you did...but I'm glad that you were able to like her in the end...because as you say she was brilliant...

    thankyou so much for your lovely comment...:)

  • And Donna was his bestfriend. Something he's never had [and exactly what he needed after Rose and Martha]. Sure he was friends with Rose and Martha but, the kind of friendship he had with Donna was unique and very different from the friendships he's had before. After losing Rose, the turmoil Martha left in her wake, Donna's exactly what he needed & now he's lost her too. Just like Rose, he can never be around her or [in Donna's case] see her again without it killing her.

  • My God MrsCKane.....you've said some truly beautiful things and I agree whole heartdly with everything apart from your initail feelings for Donna/CT...as I liked her from Runaway bride....but other than that wow for everything you've said....

    And thankyou for such lovely comments about my vid as well....:)

  • Once more the Doctor has lost a companion, no not just a companion, he lost his bestfriend. I've always thought Rose was his Soulmate, Martha was his Angel of the Night -she helped him heal after losing Rose & was his Friend but her love for him got in the way, so she knew the only way they could both be happy in some way was to leave.

  • [This should have come before the other post, hehe, sorry]

    Wow, what's left to say? You've all said what I was thinking while watching that truly Fantastic video!

  • [Continued from last post] I wasn't sure about Donna Noble when we first saw her character & that she was played by Catherine Tate but, I'm happy to say, I was completely Wrong. Catherine did a bang up job of playing Donna Noble & I'm gonna miss her so much next series. I cried my eyes out [again] when the Doctor said goodbye to Rose yet again [forever] but, I have to say I cried just as much when Donna's fate was revealed.

  • What a beautiful piece -- brilliant, in fact! I love the clips you chose and the entry into the video is quite moving. And...as the song says, I think -- "it's not the end!"

    I loved Donna as a companion b/c she cared deeply for the Doctor and changed him (as others have said) but her love was different from Rose or Martha (and even Jack) so she was able to "touch" him in a different way. CT is an amazing actress and will be greatly missed! Thanks for the tribute!

  • Aww thankyou so much for your lovely comment...:)

    And yes your right Donna loved the Doctor in a very different way....and probably a way that everyone wishes to be loved...especially the Doctor...you have put that so Beautifully...thankyou :)

  • Yes, I think you are right that the Doctor needs exactly this kind of love -- this kind of companion. I'm anxious to see who is next, and, of course, how River Song factors into this. But...I still am "heavy of heart" for Donna's loss. I keep telling myself -- "it's just fiction" but darn it all -- so well done, I'm still sappy and sad! Thanks, again. Back to work. Ha!

  • Hey its not only you...blame RTD for writing such a horrible and devestating end to a brilliant companion....

  • Yes, that is why I am here. Needed some others who were sad with me... It was a terrible ending. Seems it would have been easier if she had died -- but, of course, I am NOT suggesting that. At least this way...well, we'll see.

    Be well!

  • Wow, she knows how to fix the chameleon circuit? She was smart.

    For those of you who don't know (including me until today), the chameleon circuit was what allowed the TARDIS to shape-shift into different objects for stealth-purposes, but it got damaged and has since remained stuck in the shape a telephone booth.

  • Oh i love that police box...I hope no one ever fixes the Chameleon circiut! :D

    Thanks for your comment...:)

  • Oh, thanks for that explanation. I missed that somehow... Sometimes I think EVERYTHING in this series has some significant meaning!

    :-)

  • Donna was the best.

    Credit to Catherine Tate for giving us this amazing character. I loved the fact that the prophecy said the most loyal companion would die. Donna was always there for the Doctor and he knew that. She brought so much out of him and was there for him on so many levels.

    They were best mates and thats what will be missed next series, the friendship.

    Catherine Tate is a brilliant actress and I will be following her work.

  • I agree with everything you have said there...she was amazing...I did have my doubts about the character at first because in the RB, Donna didn't like the Doctor much, but I still knew CT would do an amazing job, I had already watched her in Bad Mothers Handbook...and she was brilliant in that as well...

    Thankyou so much for watching and commenting :)

  • i love this video thank u sooo much for making it i loved donna . she was soo funny and brilliant

  • Yep she defenetily was brilliant....

    thankyou so much for your lovely comment :)

  • Great Video Btw

    One Of The Best Ive Seen :]]]

    Faved It :]]

    Ill Miss Donna She Was Fantastic. Best Companion By Far In My Books!

  • Aww thankyou soooo much,

    Yeah Donna def was the best...and yeah I'll miss her too...

    Again thankyou so much for your lovely comments and for favouriting it....it means a lot :)

  • Its Okaii :]]

    I Wish I Was As Clever As You As Making Vids Lol

  • Aww don't say that, that vid doesn't do anything clever...I just put clips together with the music....its the clips and song that speak volumes...not the way I made it....

    I bet any chance you could have done a much better job...:)

  • I Have Tried On Windows Media Player But I Just Get Frustrated Every Time I Try Lol

    That Video Is Awesome Lol !!

    Im Going To Be Watching This For Years Over And Over AGain :]]

    Lol I Could Do A Better Job ... No Im Jokin Are You Avin A Laugh I CAn HArdly Change A Lightbulb Let Alone Make A Video To That Standard!!!

    --jane150x--

  • Donna is that you???? Remember your Brilliant :D

    It can be fustrating, but just stick to it, and you'll be fine...actaully when you say windows media player do you mean windows movie maker??

  • Lol Ye

    O Ye Lol I Do Mean Windows Movie Maker. Lol Im Loosing It :]]

    Im Going To HAve Another Crack At Making A Vid This Summer Hols But It Probs Wont Work Lol

    Thanks For The Reasurance!

    -jane150x--

  • All the best, I'm sure it will be brilliant! :)

  • Lol ill put it on youtube if it gets completed to show you the crap i make lol

    thanks anyways :]]

    love

    --jane150x--

  • Donna was wonderful...

  • she was

    Thankyou so much for commenting :)

  • You don't have to thank me, I comment because the video is awesome :) you did great work:)

  • Aww...I'm sorry but I'm gonna have to thank you again...for such lovely comments....thankyou :)

  • This video is so sad. I miss Donna : (

  • So do I....and sorry for making such a sad vid....

  • It's a good-sad video though

  • Thanyou :)

  • god it's just SO wrong that she had to forget about everything especially about how brilliant she was. *misses Donna*

    Lovely vid!

  • I know...and I still cannot get over,,,so much so that I cannot even watch Partners in crime without welling up...how sad is that :(

    Thankyou so much btw for your comments:)

  • Still makes me cry everytime. Great vid of the two, they had some great times together Donna will be missed! :(

  • I know same here....will miss her a lot...

    thankyou so much for your comment :)

  • beautiful

    made me cry

    :(

  • Thanks again...

    but its not my vid that made you cry...its the horrible memory wipe scene :(

    Again thanks...:)

  • yeah...

    but the vid is still beautiful

    :)

  • I loved this.

    When i watched the end of the episode on tv i was so sad...