I love the original version of this, but Carrie's voice is undeniable. It's so beautiful. Truly a gift from heaven. I have to rewind 3:30-3:40 over and over again...She's amazing.
That's funny that you think country singers tend to have the same voice quality - there maybe be two that sound alike but for the most part they are recognizable for me - it would be difficult for me to tell rockers apart because I don't really know them or the songs - Jamie and Carrie's voices really compliment each other here
I hunch, if you were pair them together today with this song. I think Carrie probably would probably outdo Jamie, remember this first time as full fledge country singer and debut, she said could have done better, if she wasn't so nervous, but she did excellent job.
wow--- both have beautiful voices.. but, ive noticed how country singers tend to have the same voice quality ( i guess the same way that you can't tell some rockers apart unless it's axl rose or chad kroeger)
to 7kjckgx, what are you listen, Carrie topped Kelly without a problem, Carrie is a whole better than Kelly, that is not in doubt. Carrie is one that boost American Idol, Carrie is called back every finale not Kelly. I say that says something.
Their voices compliment each other so well - they do such a great job - CMT actually put this performance into their video rotation - it was one of the best performances at the Greatest Duets show
if you remember this was Carrie's coming out after winning Idol and she said after doing this she was very nervous, performing someone's else song, even though this genre. plus all country veterans that were there. Give her credit, she did excellent job, lot better than lot of people just as nervous.
personally i like this version BETTER than linda and reba. they are good but i like this one better. and as for carrie being off key... shes perfect. Where do you hear this *supposed* "off key" miss music perfectionist?
I know "off key" when I hear it. Also, people don't "usually" sing harmony by themselves. Carrie was singing "by herself" when I heard the off key notes. Oh well...
Two words! GOOSE BUMPS. These two ladies may have done a better job with this song than even the beautiful and talented ladies of the original rendition. And that is in no small way an insult to Reba, or Linda. It simply speaks to Jamie and Carrie's chemistry and resinence. Goose bumps!
this isnt that good,atleast not compared to kelly clarkson and reba or kelly and martina,carrie doesnt have the range for that part she struggled with towards the end,how she gonna try and sing it just like kelly clarkson,should known that wasnt gonna happen,kellys voice is one of a kind
Not very many artists can sing well "live". She saounds like she's in the studio everytime she sings live. Thats real talent. She's so awesome. I'm glad to say that were from the same city and state....Carrie is the most sucessful artist born from American Idol and that's a proven fact.
I like carrie but to be honest, kelly is the most successful. Over 18 million albums sold, and sold out WORLD tours as the sole headliner. She also has toured more than any other idol (by herself), making around $40 million.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Carrie Underwood Is Good I Think She Is The 2nd Best American Idol,But She Isnt Half As Good As Kelly Clarkson,Sorry To Say It But She Cant Do It Like Kelly At All She Tried To Do It The Same Damn Way Kelly Did,But Kelly Blows Her Away Espcially The Martina Mcbride And Kelly Clarkson Version Of This,Kelly Is The Best No Doupt
I still prefer martina n kelly clarkson way better....sorry...but carrie underwood is good but i think kelly did way much better..no offense....so far american idol successfull is kelly clarkson n carrie underwood....BRAVO!!! :)
I think it's all what someone prefers - I prefer Carrie's and Jamie's version because I like their voice quality better than the other versions - the duet itself is amazing they sound terrific together and yes, this was May or June 2005, if they were to do the duet today it would be even better. CMT actually put it into their daily video rotation because they thought it was that good and it is the most streamed live performance video on the CMT website
As much as i LOVE CARRIE, im sorry to say that MARTINA AND KELLY did WAY BETTER on this song Or even Reba and kelly. Carrie sounded horrible on the "i have nothing to gain part". But having said that...i love Carrie i have both her CD's.
This is one of the Best Duets I have ever seen and heard I wish they'd make a video of Jamie and Carrie doing this Duet and put it on the Market I'd definately get it.
Its is pretty amazing to think how far Carrie has come since this performance! Jamie Oneil has always been a spectaclar but under exposed voice. Togeather they are magical!
HEY GUYS!!! CHECK OUT the Carrie Underwood's new video ''So Small'' that the youtube it's not letting no one watch it and deleting it all the time!!! And also CHECK OUT on my channel the Rihanna's new video ''Hate That I Love You'' FEATURING NE-YO!! I just want to share it with everybody :)
Quit all the fussing and just enjoy the song please. They were both good in this performance. Who cares who is a better singer or not, can't you just listen to this song and enjoy their performance? And if not, they just don't watch it.
However: Jamie is a very good singer. And she is bit better compared to Carrie - in this song! But this was in 2005, Carrie was in the early beginning of her career. Today, two years later, there is absolutely no doubt that she is a brilliant singer.
Yes...Carrie's overrated. She is good, but her fans make her out to be something rare and she isn't. She is the result of pretty good talent, very good marketing, some very good song choices (probably not choices made by her) and a pretty face. Her singing ability is not exceptional among the others at the top of the country charts.
I'm not being negative. I'm just making an observation. You're the one who replied to specifically my comment. If you don't want a difference of opinion, you shouldn't offer up your own difference of opinion.
ok yes people like taylor swift, brad paisley, and kenney chesney sell and have good music, carrie is MUCH more brilliant singing wise... the only person in this country business that maybe be better than carrie vocally wise is martina so i dont kno wut ur talking about
sadly country fans nowadays care a lot about female image as well. I mean carrie is young, blond, thin, and pretty. Of course she will sell, regardless of talent. Look at britney spears and jessica simpson. Image Sells. That is why someone like Tricia is ignored, because she isn't a barbie.
oh yeah her!! well, i don't think she's ugly (she kinda looks like helen hunt) and though she is a bit chubby, ruben won american idol and he's fatter than a whale
oh that's a nice comment... but on Ruben's image, he may have won AI but what has he really done since. i think it is because of his image that he hasn't done so well and because of Carrie's that she has.
YEAH DUH, i know that! of course Clay Aiken became more famous than Ruben, they don't want him cuz of his image (but why did they pick him anyway??)
And besides, I think Carrie sings better than Kelly Clarkson, but they're both image wise.
There have also been numerous of jokes made to Clay Aiken that he looks like a gay elf.
:)
That dude with the fray hair won also but didn't make so much fame! (people that audition for AI are all diseased nobody's and only the pretty survive)
This was one of the first 'official duets' of Carrie Underwood after AI award and matched with the sultry and powerful vocals of Jamie O'neil rocketed to CMT top 100 duets ever! Not bad! I could listen to Jamie over and over and over but in duet with Carrie it is as good as it gets! I loved how Carrie broke into a smile to the crowd!
they should do more duets
Cstars1012 2 years ago 2
I love This Song I Love You Reba
Reba220 2 years ago 3
love love love this video its awesomeeeeeeeeeeee.
sharbear009 2 years ago 2
DAMN...thats whats up right there..carrie is tha shit....we love and miss you from oklahoma!!!
anikole86 2 years ago 3
Not so crazy about Jamie O'Neal but Carrie is amazing!:)
jaymejean28 2 years ago 3
I love the original version of this, but Carrie's voice is undeniable. It's so beautiful. Truly a gift from heaven. I have to rewind 3:30-3:40 over and over again...She's amazing.
GoNinjaGo1989 2 years ago 5
Why didn't Reba perform on this shoow
Reba220 3 years ago
because she didnt
jaymejean28 2 years ago
Love this video and all Carrie Songs she has such an incredible voice.Carrie is the best female in country today.
sharbear009 3 years ago 10
One of my favorite duets of all time. Carrie is just impeccable.
AmericanIdolManiac 3 years ago 3
I love all carries songs
sharbear009 3 years ago 5
Loved it Carrie has an awesome voice
sharbear009 3 years ago 8
That's funny that you think country singers tend to have the same voice quality - there maybe be two that sound alike but for the most part they are recognizable for me - it would be difficult for me to tell rockers apart because I don't really know them or the songs - Jamie and Carrie's voices really compliment each other here
fiddleDdee 3 years ago 2
I hunch, if you were pair them together today with this song. I think Carrie probably would probably outdo Jamie, remember this first time as full fledge country singer and debut, she said could have done better, if she wasn't so nervous, but she did excellent job.
row759 3 years ago
wow--- both have beautiful voices.. but, ive noticed how country singers tend to have the same voice quality ( i guess the same way that you can't tell some rockers apart unless it's axl rose or chad kroeger)
carrie sounds different..
chatterbox1229 3 years ago
Yeah, both Jamie and Carrie have very powerful voices - they sound great together - their harmonies are garet
fiddleDdee 3 years ago 2
Jamie O'Neal has an awesome voice---holy mackeral!! You never really hear it like you can in this song. She's got some chops!!
SummerGalLongIsland 3 years ago
Kelly spoiled it for me. No one will ever top her. Good try thou Carrie.
7kjckgx 3 years ago
to 7kjckgx, what are you listen, Carrie topped Kelly without a problem, Carrie is a whole better than Kelly, that is not in doubt. Carrie is one that boost American Idol, Carrie is called back every finale not Kelly. I say that says something.
row759 2 years ago 3
Their voices compliment each other so well - they do such a great job - CMT actually put this performance into their video rotation - it was one of the best performances at the Greatest Duets show
fiddleDdee 3 years ago 2
if you remember this was Carrie's coming out after winning Idol and she said after doing this she was very nervous, performing someone's else song, even though this genre. plus all country veterans that were there. Give her credit, she did excellent job, lot better than lot of people just as nervous.
row759 3 years ago
personally i like this version BETTER than linda and reba. they are good but i like this one better. and as for carrie being off key... shes perfect. Where do you hear this *supposed* "off key" miss music perfectionist?
kAtIeRoKz 3 years ago
What song is this?
ProjectRevolution 3 years ago
hi could you send me this as an mp3 so i can download it i really want it but i can't find it anywhere
ustanep 3 years ago
my goodness this song gives me chills! such a sad song, but sang SO wonderfully by both of these amazing artists..
misslovenick 3 years ago 3
Carrie was off key a couple time.
dreamer216 3 years ago
No she wasn't...she sang the harmony part while Jamie sang the melody a couple of times, but she wasn't off key.
ty7986 3 years ago
I know "off key" when I hear it. Also, people don't "usually" sing harmony by themselves. Carrie was singing "by herself" when I heard the off key notes. Oh well...
dreamer216 3 years ago
they killed it! i loved it
shaysbaby314 3 years ago 4
They did an amazing job on the song...it's almost as good as Reba and Linda!
loveyoureba 3 years ago 3
Almost??? They; (or at least Carrie); can never compare to Reba and Linda!
dreamer216 3 years ago
i love this shot
MarieCareBear 3 years ago
great song i cant get enough of it
gshmmc 3 years ago
good duet there realy close there vioces
gshmmc 3 years ago
I love this duet! CARRIE UNDERWOOD ROCKS!!!!!!!!!
Carriesfan4life 3 years ago 4
it's rare that i like a duet different from the original like this, but this was awesome
sassyosaur 3 years ago
Their voices are so compatible with each other. An awesome duet!
warriorbard 3 years ago 2
Two words! GOOSE BUMPS. These two ladies may have done a better job with this song than even the beautiful and talented ladies of the original rendition. And that is in no small way an insult to Reba, or Linda. It simply speaks to Jamie and Carrie's chemistry and resinence. Goose bumps!
gizmozdaddy 3 years ago 4
there couldn't be a better sounding duet in my opinion i loved this!
JuSTiNBiEBeRiSmYlOvE 3 years ago
GREAT JOB GUYS.
Rebahoney63 3 years ago
I would love to hear Reba and Carrie do this.
I love the Reba-Linda Davis the best though.
Eurotuned83 3 years ago 5
um no they didnt sing it before reba and kelly sorry
SurferBoy8708 3 years ago 3
Their voices go together as good as Martina McBride's and Reba's!!!!!
JPLBTKWAY 3 years ago
one of the best duets i've ever heard...their voices flows so nicely together..
Lady209 3 years ago
this isnt that good,atleast not compared to kelly clarkson and reba or kelly and martina,carrie doesnt have the range for that part she struggled with towards the end,how she gonna try and sing it just like kelly clarkson,should known that wasnt gonna happen,kellys voice is one of a kind
SurferBoy8708 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
they sang it before kelly and reba did!
ashleylh456 4 years ago
This is way better than Reba anf Kelly on the Reba Tribute show.
cntry4me2 4 years ago 2
I personally like Reba and Kelly's alot better. They have more emotion in their song.
pqlee 4 years ago
love this song....and Carrie sounds great!
Renee1475 4 years ago
Kelly and Martina completely owned this song. Carrie doesn't have the power for this song, in my opinion. I like Jamie's voice, though.
watson8escape 4 years ago
Never heard the song, but I like it. Anything with Carrie singing it is wonderful though!
Renee1475 4 years ago
jamie is WAY better, it's not cuz she has more experience, she just has that beautiful and natural country voice :)
kumani90 4 years ago
This is why she won american idol!!
She's just the best!
badshizz12 4 years ago
Not very many artists can sing well "live". She saounds like she's in the studio everytime she sings live. Thats real talent. She's so awesome. I'm glad to say that were from the same city and state....Carrie is the most sucessful artist born from American Idol and that's a proven fact.
scuzzle2006 4 years ago
I like carrie but to be honest, kelly is the most successful. Over 18 million albums sold, and sold out WORLD tours as the sole headliner. She also has toured more than any other idol (by herself), making around $40 million.
jaydel3 4 years ago 6
HELL NO! kelly clarkson is the one that got the most fame EVER!!
kumani90 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Carrie Underwood Is Good I Think She Is The 2nd Best American Idol,But She Isnt Half As Good As Kelly Clarkson,Sorry To Say It But She Cant Do It Like Kelly At All She Tried To Do It The Same Damn Way Kelly Did,But Kelly Blows Her Away Espcially The Martina Mcbride And Kelly Clarkson Version Of This,Kelly Is The Best No Doupt
SurferBoy8708 4 years ago
Brilliant
AuntCecelia 4 years ago 2
I still prefer martina n kelly clarkson way better....sorry...but carrie underwood is good but i think kelly did way much better..no offense....so far american idol successfull is kelly clarkson n carrie underwood....BRAVO!!! :)
aizfiz 4 years ago
I think it's all what someone prefers - I prefer Carrie's and Jamie's version because I like their voice quality better than the other versions - the duet itself is amazing they sound terrific together and yes, this was May or June 2005, if they were to do the duet today it would be even better. CMT actually put it into their daily video rotation because they thought it was that good and it is the most streamed live performance video on the CMT website
fiddleDdee 4 years ago 4
As much as i LOVE CARRIE, im sorry to say that MARTINA AND KELLY did WAY BETTER on this song Or even Reba and kelly. Carrie sounded horrible on the "i have nothing to gain part". But having said that...i love Carrie i have both her CD's.
ptrev06 4 years ago 6
i think if you let carrie sing this song again ,she'll own this
simple reason: this was right after the idol thing ,its been two years now and here voice has improved so much =)
DragonTribe 4 years ago 3
You're right;
her voice has improved.
but this was not right after Idol.
It was in August of '06.
Carrie won in May of '05.
kIZle007 4 years ago
Actually, this was right after she won idol in '05. :)
lovinmusic102 3 years ago
This is one of the Best Duets I have ever seen and heard I wish they'd make a video of Jamie and Carrie doing this Duet and put it on the Market I'd definately get it.
OldGoat34 4 years ago
Its is pretty amazing to think how far Carrie has come since this performance! Jamie Oneil has always been a spectaclar but under exposed voice. Togeather they are magical!
MBPFRANCE 4 years ago 2
They sound great together! ROCK ON CARRIE!!!!!!!!!!!
kuchipatchiluver 4 years ago 2
Great performance! Especially from Jamie O'Neal. They have a great chemistry on stage.
dragonsoul320 4 years ago 2
Funny, I just heard this song sung be Reba and somebody else. Jamie and Carrie are soooo much better.
lam0210 4 years ago 4
Jamie is a MILF
TheHornyBug 4 years ago
im only saying yum yum to both
rocketmancanada1 4 years ago
I should say most streamed by country music fans however CMT did air this video alot when it was first filmed.
fiddleDdee 4 years ago
This is one of the most played videos of a live performance on CMT, Country Music Television
fiddleDdee 4 years ago
HEY GUYS!!! CHECK OUT the Carrie Underwood's new video ''So Small'' that the youtube it's not letting no one watch it and deleting it all the time!!! And also CHECK OUT on my channel the Rihanna's new video ''Hate That I Love You'' FEATURING NE-YO!! I just want to share it with everybody :)
THE TWO ARE AMAZING!!
cindykeiko 4 years ago
Carrie and Jamie did a great job on this duet!!
fiddleDdee 4 years ago 2
they=then
Jadekt14 4 years ago
Quit all the fussing and just enjoy the song please. They were both good in this performance. Who cares who is a better singer or not, can't you just listen to this song and enjoy their performance? And if not, they just don't watch it.
Jadekt14 4 years ago
However: Jamie is a very good singer. And she is bit better compared to Carrie - in this song! But this was in 2005, Carrie was in the early beginning of her career. Today, two years later, there is absolutely no doubt that she is a brilliant singer.
Mayflower1357 4 years ago
Jamie's good.
Spit1025 4 years ago
Carrie's overrated. Jamie's just as good, but Carrie gets all the attention.
02attaboy 4 years ago
Carrie's overrated? Oh, good joke. :-)
But Carrie would sound even better if she sang this today. This duet was in 2005.
Mayflower1357 4 years ago
Yes...Carrie's overrated. She is good, but her fans make her out to be something rare and she isn't. She is the result of pretty good talent, very good marketing, some very good song choices (probably not choices made by her) and a pretty face. Her singing ability is not exceptional among the others at the top of the country charts.
02attaboy 4 years ago
You are wrong: Carrie's singing ability is exceptional.
Let's stop being negative, unnecessarily.
Mayflower1357 4 years ago
I'm not being negative. I'm just making an observation. You're the one who replied to specifically my comment. If you don't want a difference of opinion, you shouldn't offer up your own difference of opinion.
02attaboy 4 years ago
ok yes people like taylor swift, brad paisley, and kenney chesney sell and have good music, carrie is MUCH more brilliant singing wise... the only person in this country business that maybe be better than carrie vocally wise is martina so i dont kno wut ur talking about
bigbluegrl23 4 years ago 2
sadly country fans nowadays care a lot about female image as well. I mean carrie is young, blond, thin, and pretty. Of course she will sell, regardless of talent. Look at britney spears and jessica simpson. Image Sells. That is why someone like Tricia is ignored, because she isn't a barbie.
jaydel3 4 years ago 3
Sadly, you're right...and who's Tricia?
kumani90 4 years ago
I mean trisha yearwood. She has been "pushed aside" because she isn't exactly the "right image."
jaydel3 4 years ago
oh yeah her!! well, i don't think she's ugly (she kinda looks like helen hunt) and though she is a bit chubby, ruben won american idol and he's fatter than a whale
kumani90 4 years ago
oh that's a nice comment... but on Ruben's image, he may have won AI but what has he really done since. i think it is because of his image that he hasn't done so well and because of Carrie's that she has.
gigga143 4 years ago
YEAH DUH, i know that! of course Clay Aiken became more famous than Ruben, they don't want him cuz of his image (but why did they pick him anyway??)
And besides, I think Carrie sings better than Kelly Clarkson, but they're both image wise.
There have also been numerous of jokes made to Clay Aiken that he looks like a gay elf.
:)
That dude with the fray hair won also but didn't make so much fame! (people that audition for AI are all diseased nobody's and only the pretty survive)
kumani90 4 years ago
Probably referring to Trisha Yearwood. Also a great singer, but no one beats Reba, she is the best!
LDSMom5199 3 years ago
carrie underwood was the best american idol winner yea kelly is good but carrie is so much better
crazynessisme 4 years ago
if you really wanna see how it's done check how Kelly Clarkson and Martina McBride did it.
shannonk68 4 years ago
whats the song?
jump5fan101 4 years ago
This is like one of the greatest duets like ever!! they sound sooooo good together!!!
hottwinkie 4 years ago 2
This was one of the first 'official duets' of Carrie Underwood after AI award and matched with the sultry and powerful vocals of Jamie O'neil rocketed to CMT top 100 duets ever! Not bad! I could listen to Jamie over and over and over but in duet with Carrie it is as good as it gets! I loved how Carrie broke into a smile to the crowd!
MBPFRANCE 4 years ago
i love the way carry done this but at the bridge if u notice she runs out of breath lol but still gives me chills
jimbo171987 4 years ago
HUH!?! Jamie, YES! Who's the other one???
snosux1 4 years ago
did u just say whos the other one... carrie underwood?, one of the most popular country singers right now... keep up!
bigbluegrl23 4 years ago
i absolutely LOVE this version... carrie and jamie are great!
bigbluegrl23 4 years ago
whats the song?
musicislife888 4 years ago
does he love you.
pmmhjabsrock 4 years ago
If you aren't familiar with Jamie O'Neal,go out and buy her 2004 CD entitled "BRAVE". It is spectacular. Every song is great!!
soundsatdjs1964 4 years ago
Oh my goodness! They are my two of my favorite singers! Thanks for posting this!
aznbasketballluvr 4 years ago
Jamie O'neal's vocals are great!
jojoejoe 4 years ago
as good as the orginal maybe better! Love Carrie and Jamie aint bad to look at either....
jkoncz 4 years ago 2
Wow! I've been waiting for this video for so long. Thanks for posting it.
I think this was the first time CARRIE was really embraced by the Country Community.
Her vocals are just amazing!!! And she's so gorgeous!!!!!!!!
etrejos11 4 years ago