泳兒 - 電燈膽KTV

[rockorblues]

唱功，當然是泳兒

感情，我覺得是Stephy

[miran6789]

這可是live!!! 聽過鄧麗欣三次唱這首歌的live，沒有一次可以不失音唱完首歌­，最嚴重一次更是一段中每句至少三四粒音不知跑去哪，形成個ke­y好似浮下浮下咁，極難聽! 當時更令我懷疑鄧小姐錄碟是否請槍，後來有朋友解釋現在科技進步­......聽過鄧麗欣隻碟，我反而嫌她唱得太輕，欠了後悔撮合­朋友那份恨錯難返的酸，和嫉妒的恨，我不是這兩位小姐的粉絲，但­真心覺得泳兒唱live好過鄧麗欣播碟。當然聽歌很個人的，尤其­先入為主。

[lmkit83]

無感情

[kev121314]

10X times better than stephy



[storagebox2036]

"stephy雖然冇唱功，可以專注感情上面"

佢應該去拍戲, 以後唔好再唱歌...

[yukzhao516]

@idunnoiii CD版-.-....

[DenniswaSo]

如果你認為好過原唱， 又冇原因，咁只係無溪之談。 你冇解釋既原因可能係： 你覺得泳兒一定好過stephy因為泳兒唱功好過stephy， stephy只係一個餅碎成員，冇實力， 咁樣你就有籍口話泳兒唱得好過stephy。 但係如果係放下2個好/唔好既印象， 我相信你冇得解釋。 stephy雖然冇唱功，可以專注感情上面， 但唔好忘記聽歌唔係只聽唱功。 如果所有人唱歌只顧技巧冇感情， 咁樣已經失去左做一隻歌出來本身既意義！ 技巧唔係唔重要，只不過至少唔好太多走音影響歌要表達出來既情感­。 講真香港樂壇作既歌係盡量配合歌手既風格同聲線...... 泳兒唔係唱得唔好，只係佢把聲好難唱出沉重既感覺， 同埋唱出電燈膽戈種無奈、妒忌戈種感情。 補充返，其實我感覺到泳兒做電燈膽既經驗， 唔夠stephy多，可能stephy性格比較天真， 喱個情況會出現得多 :p 。 最後我想講，隻歌其實好難唱， 我相信好少人會因為做電燈膽， 產生出咁強烈既妒忌心。 雖然我都有試過妒忌人拍拖， 但係肯定個程度真係冇stephy 咁大！ 因為個個人都咁唸 ' 人地拍拖關你鬼事? ' 就唔會有太大妒忌心:s 。

[chingyi078]

佢唱,好似串鄧小姐咁

[net893]

@chingyi078 唱人首歌就串人 我叫你個名係咪鬧緊你? :o)

[chingyi078]

@net893 我意思都係話佢唱得好過鄧小姐好多啫!

都搵嘢黎講...

[NotSoFat]

1:43 till 1:55 is enchanting

[connie59do]

the lyric is great

[yiujai0421]

有啲歌 唔知點解感覺靜系stephy唱到感覺:O

就算stephy佢可能走音.

[CHIUCHIFAI]

論唱功就一定係泳兒好d，

不過佢唱既感情好明顯係由外來人去估做電燈膽既感情，

但實際上有d唔係好match個做電燈膽既感情...

而Stephy就歌到做電燈膽既感情...

[mhfai]

好好聽!!

[lanchichu]

我唔係佢d fans,但我覺得泳兒呢首歌唱幾ok呀

[wingyan1010]

泳兒唱得係好,冇走音,反而我覺得佢似照唱,冇自己既感覺...­

[nichoysw]

好過stephy好多好多倍

[shywynne]

把聱係好聽

不過好造作,

聽得好辛苦

[3113ching]

一睇就知佢唔係電燈膽

所以冇乜感情!

[Li2xTh]

泳兒唱得好聽D, 不過好似冇乜感情...

[abc12324061]

Stephy好聽D,就算泳兒唱功幾好,Syephy獨特的聲佢­點都學唔到

[lsc946]

超好聽的

[amy19941028]

其實鄧麗欣的CD VER. 真係好好聽的。

[Manty6638]

啦啦啦.........果段好古怪

[szesze520kit]

我好鐘意呢首歌

[tengteng2525]

各有各好lo ..唱功一定係泳兒好好多

stephy就唱出歌詞入面哥種感覺 ..其實睇下自己中2邊一種架姐

[Silentscythe]

完全唔明白D 人點解會話stephy 唱得好聽D, 泳兒無論音色, 音準, 唱功, 都高過stephy 幾個lv......你地覺得佢唱得細聲係你地聽緊單聲道呀..­..

[yukakit1990]

如果要鄧麗欣唱呢個key一定拉斷佢條聲帶

[lo20411an]

vincy 比stephy 唱得好呀!

[WPSing]

唔好係咁同原唱比較... 唱得好聽就得啦!

[joey8mama]

點解後面好似快左d咁~我係指第一段~



[katielove1314]

特登簡e隻歌溪落stephy都吾夠佢紅呀你

[gskhor90]

her legs are really turning me on for some reason.

[o0kinki0o]

stephy唱得好好多，泳兒唱得怪怪地，古怪~

[comecomesupermarket]

我都覺得stephy唱得好聽d,,,

只不過係stephy臨場發揮得5夠好..,,

而且太多人對佢有偏見la><

你地以為泳兒冇走音咩???!

如"誰當初冇心.." "他日你們..." 明顯聽出有2次"電燈膽"哩3個字...

仲有多次聽得出佢5夠氣....

最重要係佢唱得5及stephy傳情同過多哭腔...

我並5係stephy ge fans,,,更5係針對vincy,,

我只係睇5過戈d對人5對事ge人...

不喜勿插~

[kinofthemoon]

stephy好聽好多囉

泳兒唱大聲係咪會走音?

[oicq747285250]

因為stephy做過電燈膽

泳兒就冇咁多戀愛經歷

[chansiumingholunsing]

鄧麗欣唱兒歌都嚇親細路LA

[icacoca]

其實佢無升key...

只係佢本身把聲高d~

[acirren]

唔睇樣真係好OK

[JayYipPianoLover]

@acirren 個樣真係咁唔掂咩...

[hoyeeip]

唱現場係泳兒好, 但STEPHY唱得出個種慘FEEL



[chengh09]

好聽係OK既~

不過D動作誇張左D囉

[TheSnowybb]

泳兒的確唱得比鄧麗欣好聽，但鄧麗欣在感情方面掌握得較好，所以­兩個版本我也喜歡

[amdk2007]

呢D先叫唱歌咯! 如果佢再靚D, 鄧走音仲有存在價值咩???

[sux9992003]

To alll Vincy haters: May I ask what makes youguys think to that Vincy isn't better than that piece of shit Stephy? Give me 1 legit reason so I will shut the fuck up!

[FB4822]

stephy好聽d 囉

[hiuningtang]

電燈膽都係Stephy唱得好聽d 只可以話冰兒音準方面比較好 但唱不出感覺...

[sumiji888]

应该是实力派出来不是？ 不行 。。声音好单薄

[tsz0v0]

@walaleyin

太白啦-.-

[pungkywong]

Stephy唱得好聽D

[Ofelia200136]

I don't think this version is beyond Stephy's version cuz her voice is too clear for this sad song

[DenniswaSo]

stephy唱得出戈種壓迫感

泳兒唱唔出

泳兒聲低溫柔

唔岩隻歌

好聽 同 感動係2樣野來

[elise20100704kawaii]

冇stephy果只feel-.-

[MzDreamii]

i wouldn't compare stephy and vincy's version because I'd be comparing a pre-recorded song to this live one. I thought Vincy did really well live here, she's great~!

[abc123cura]

Stephy has more feeling when she sings, however, vincy's voice is stronger n better. That's what i think.

[aesopw95850]

唱得很像沒stephy好聽

沒有感情

[iiluv8boy]

原來這首歌是有意思的，我們一起來忘記這個世界有歌手的存在，我­們唯一要做的就是細心聆聽，事實只有一個，就是歌詞很有意思.

[sifng]

所以話一定要去現場听D會唱歌的人唱現場先至過癮，唱得好好好.­......

[cheungwc]

泳兒唱得好過李昊嘉係事實,但係有冇形像師教吓佢上台唱歌時啲手­勢, 隔離條片“英皇新秀歌唱大賽2005(死性不改)”同“電燈膽”­佢隻手啲動作好唔自然,好似唱歌要靠隻右手發力咁

[keiitea129]

點解我覺得vincy唱得好輕鬆.. stephy.. 就成日都好似唱唔上去.....

[killa0807]

@keiitea129

因為泳兒把聲夠高音, 佢平時D歌都幾高下...

所以唱le 首歌會輕鬆過stephy

[uohecc]

oh so it IS possible to sing this song without going out of tune !

[neckocat123]

no feel, yes ...

[swissperfection]

I like李昊嘉's version the most!!

20091004 亞洲星光大道 粵語K歌淘汰賽 6 李昊嘉 電燈膽

[DenniswaSo]

泳兒把聲太可愛

唱唔到個feel 出來~

[winnyxian9924]

she like very difficult 2 sing~

stephy is better~

[hobbles477]

@winnyxian9924

Dude Stephy cant sing it without going out of tune live

[sheeplo1983]

好聽是不能否認, 所謂的感情亦只屬錯覺.

[esun34]

Vincy sings this sooo much better than Stephy!!

[1222zz1222]

話鄧小姐唱得有感情既只係因為你地聽得多聽出感情.......­................

[cocoleung19951210]

但係我都聽唔出有感情-.-

[glisenti516]

鄧麗欣收得皮

[Usazuki6554]

咬字真係太清楚喇,唱到咁肉緊搞到冇曬feel。不過唱功好係真­嘅

[RachOo]

vincy's voice is BETTER than stephy's voice. I love vincy! Amazing talent!

[yanwingching]

stephy係感情好d,但係冇唱功,感情幾豐沛都冇用啦,

況且,stephy又唔駛顧及唱功(係毫無唱功可言),感情一定­發揮得好d啦!

[kaka8917]

泳兒真的很有實力!很好的LIVE!!

[davidhuen]

唱到首歌的feel外，唱功也明顯較穩定



[Lohoshimanlighting]

泳兒把聲好清麗

[bymax1007]

KTV 和音多超正常

又唔係mv

[abcdefgkafuu]

泳兒不嬲唱歌都ok

[januslee114]

我認為佢好過原唱

[SmirnOffLemon]

我鍾意D燈+傘...好特別///

[wimmichun]

佢唱吾到個feel!!佢唱功可能系會好d..

但系stephy把聲好聽過泳兒

所以唱得有d怪-__-



[tsuiwc]

@wimmichun

絕對唔認同你個講法

佢係有實力就唔會俾人叫鄧走音

相反泳兒從未走過音

仲有好多讚佢有實力....

[wimmichun]

@tsuiwc

有實力就代表唱得好??

有實力都要有feel先得...

仲有我冇講過stephy有實力..不過stephy把聲好聽過­泳兒{本人意見}

同埋我想講泳兒唱到好似有d想走音-____-

[hmcheung11]

泳兒絕對唱得好過stephy!

泳兒加油!!

[superwoman5181]

我吾係泳兒Fans，但呢首歌我絕對覺得泳兒唱得好過鄧小姐N甘­多倍，吾明白有D人話鄧小姐唱得如何比泳兒有感情，或者各人看法­吾同啦，我就感受吾到鄧小姐的感情勒，只知道鄧小姐唱CD就好似­唱到讀書甘，唱LIVE 仲成日走音，咩感覺感情都比距把聲嚇走曬啦。

[jc9319xxxx]

我唔係泳兒既fans~

但就好鍾意呢首歌~

我覺得實力最重要~起碼放幾耐都仲有人記得你係唱得架~

好好加油~

[TensaZ]

holy she sang it so so much better than Stephy...

Stephy sings like she has a flu or a blocked nose... lol

[Shirley186186]

Stephy is more suit to sing this song.

Vincy is a really good singer, and true I think that Vincy is better at singing LIVE than Stephy, but I still prefer Stephy for singing LIVE in this song! Plus, Stephy improved a lot at singing LIVE.

Also, true, Vincy needs to put more feelings into this song. But remember, this is a very hard song. So I think Vincy needs to care about her voice when she is singing this song, so it's kinda hard to care about the feelings too.

[bymax1007]

鄧小姐 係CD聲

泳兒係live 囉唔該

[lap1031]

有唱功同有感情係兩樣野黎嫁--

佢係就係有唱功,但係真係聽唔出感情

[jasonchong902]

@lap1031 感情都係可以汁出黎家姐 = =

[errorlocks]

把聲好似天使，我有少少鍾意左佢。

[loveMissangelababy]

音樂蓋過左把聲la=.=..

[cpc1237]

我覺得泳兒唱的較好 是實力派唱將

[tezukaxryoma]

better than stephy's version, but still I don't think she can handle this song...

[Rima616]

好似聽到啊kay把聲,,幻聽?

[pt9826]

電燈膽 是 電燈泡嗎？？？？

[roxykk]

@pt9826 我們香港人說的電燈膽是電燈泡不過我們說的意思是當兩個人談戀愛­的時候有人在跟著他們一起行，有一些煩著他們的感覺

[MrOscar0881]

佢係無走音..但我都覺得原唱好聽d

[sapphirekat]

more steady

[evaniscrazy]

@wchwing147 what do you mean?

[kd06]

佢個key升左幾度﹖

[bumble0216]

鄧麗欣 好D阿 好明显 泳兒 has no feeling

[zebrafang]

5系挂....

好明显 泳兒 好好多...

鄧麗欣 唱到吊颈甘....

[QTRAINIE]

好聽過原唱千萬陪 ...

[abu0216]

唔知點解其他歌手唱人d歌梗係唔係咁like,..

[kin313810]

香港歌星真的太忙!!!!!!!泳兒剛出道沒什麼工作時聲音好聽­到不得了,現在感覺退步了,應該是練習不足吧

[jing713]

都係走音邊緣。。

但支持 你啦！

[chantim02]

唱得好!

[stanley6769]

如果LIVE比....更係泳兒好聽

但係Stephy CD版真係好聽過家陣泳兒LIVE

[elmofung15]

邊有CD Version難聽過live-.-

[toyickon]

CD走音就真係有病la!

再加上用合成器,又邊會錯?

[him118]

的確係會發生

[pangmandy2]

其實我覺得泳兒樣唔差..

歌又好好聽@@

[MoMoWorms]

可惜就係一路紅唔起...

[mika880829]

@MoMoWorms 唔紅咩?!我覺得唔係噃~

[mika880829]

@MoMoWorms 仲有,我覺得佢只係差一首將佢爆起嘅歌,,,,,好似阿KAY咁­,都係唱咗喜帖街先比人叫天后JA 嘛~

[christophermok]

she does a beta job in singing this live.. compared to stephy

[soaringcow]

im suprised stephy's looks got her so far. vincy has some pretty nice songs :)

[rome9283]

講真如果首歌俾人吾會咁紅...

我地吾可以馬後砲

[pong1904]

佢好聽過原唱好多!!!!

[aocpang]

周董出道前仲樣衰啦-.-

但實力彌補了一切

[tsuiwc]

佢都唔算係醜樣, 祖兒出道個樣咪仲普通, 人紅會變靚ma. 加油!!

[applepie0425]

@tsuiwc agree! 個天會自動幫佢整容.人紅做咩都好睇

[grass1018]

好聽過原唱九萬幾倍左右啦

[sky001]

Vincy;s voice is nice!! Her pitch is sooooo high!!!

[kammyyu100]

有驚喜.好聽過stephy九萬倍.可惜個樣唔爭氣...

[hk02025]

唔係抄歌,係唱人d歌姐!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­

[oscarsapp]

咩紙紮公仔阿!收LA

[sampang1996]

2:56

[komonkey1356]

2:29~2:35 有d怪聲 咩黎QAQ?

[bnm936]

和音...

[ccabc033]

...很強的一個女歌手..

水準好過好多姐級^^ 泳兒,, 我地會睇住你升呢

[biggun001]

大家都知走音就是鄧麗欣的唱歌風格

[f77e74]

泳兒唱呢首歌綽綽有餘。

[53219cc]

咸濕狗公...

[hkdiana]

每個人有每個人既風格, 總之, 唱得好好聽, 唔須要不停比較, 對唱者唔公平.

[whatthely1]

佢唱得比原唱好一百萬倍@@

日日聽泳兒既歌都唔會厭呀=v=

支持你!!!

[lhho0131]

音色近似完美

可惜唱唔出果種feel

[abcwing18]

佢唱得比原唱好,,,

但佢冇原唱唱出電燈膽戈種感覺...

[BigBallHim]

Stephy有佢一半都好;)

[lum120235]

勁,e首歌本身難唱。可惜佢紅唔起

[joouyang]

In my view, both sing it very well!

[lap1031]

佢唱唔到果種feel,不過唱功真係唔錯

如果佢係原唱既話,反而可能首歌會紅唔到

ps:唔係雙方fans

[michaelsin]

@lap1031 我反而覺得會紅到囉如果俾泳兒唱既話=]

ps: 只談唱功 & 個人特色

[kittencat1983]

@lap1031 我覺得佢唱先唔會浪費首歌

呢首好歌俾Stephy唱真係哂料 ~

[tsuiwc]

@kittencat1983

同意, stephy根本就唱唔到d高key位!!



[Mable1010]

@lap1031 好認同你既講法...

[729648225]

@lap1031

超贊成！

[mandyball1]

都唔明做咩要做比較.

[angelwishes90]

I swear its the song... the song is just hard to sing. Stephy has problems singing live, but no where as bad as she appears when she's singing this song live. Now even Vincy has problems reaching certain notes and holding her breath long enough to finish endings of words.

I think its unfair ppl keep blaming all of it on Stephy... She's still newish and improving, but this song is just too difficult for someone like her who's still trying learning and improving...

[jinnysam22]

i just downloaded this song... i heard even more key errors than this. (i think its the same version)

[ricci2665]

有唱功!!

但是覺得她可以放多一點感覺落去 :)

[tsang6482]

唱得不會差過Stephy

Stephy本身唱得好好咩..我唔知既囧?