?... What was the Reason for this video? I think we all need to read "Meditations on Violence" -Rory Miller. It addresses the Reality of violence and the not so Reality Based Instructors. If you instructor has never used it (Fight/ SD) then it is a guide not a real way (Tao). "Fighting is for stupid people"
people shouldnt get so uptight when criticised it only reveals their insecurities- RBSD is my field and I can say there is a lot of bollocks in it- this video isnt anywhere near as cruel as it could be. My problem with it is the hypocrisy- you've got MMA nerds taking the piss out of RBSD nerds- if you spend more time on your pc than in training YOURE STILL A FUCKING NERD!
attending an MMA class or even competing does not automatically validate your opinion, You can train it and still be SHIT.
rbsd is overrated..from what I've seen u learn a chin jab and a couple primitive strikes!!ohhh yeah that shit works!!bad mindset too..yeah lets rip dudes ears off and pluck out his eyeballs in an unarmed h2h situation!! prison sentence for u bud!!errrrrr
Look if really based self defense was praticed in a realistic manner nobody would have a problem with it.However many RBSD schools are nothing more than traditional M.A schools set in a paramilitary environment.That is why so many people have turned to the combat sports, because they know the skills they learn there will one day save their lives.
How come it barely showed WHY RBSD sucks? Let's see some bad training techniques etc rather than a family of black women (what was the point in that?) and a number of fights with still photos? If you're going to slag something off, do it properly!
It's nto a video of RBSD that suck, it's the "sucks month of Bullshido's RBSD". not the "RBSD sucks month". they are called Bullshido's RBSD. There are however many SD thigns otu there that aren't very good, and this video shows what the realities are in real fights/altercations, with some humour in there too.
What I love about Bullshido is the inability of any of the "heroes" that hang on that site to take criticism. Phrost is so full of shit. Watch their throwdown vids. It is always some mismatched bunch of slap kickboxing.
Well, Phrost has a habit of taking the most extreme and absurd examples available in a given art and using them to point out how his target art sucks, which is an intellectually bankrupt and cheap way to promote one's POV. I find it ironic that while fulminating against BS in the martial arts, he spews plenty of his own.
I recently saw a video of Phrost in a "pro" fight. He got spanked by a mediocre fighter. I think Neal needs to shut the f**k up and stick to the keyboard wars!
Good point the reason they put this stuff up is what they do in a ring with rules does not work in reality look at the jail house brawl you would be stupid to go to the ground with someone in that enviroment so people are looking for something that works in the world we live in not a MMA gym.
Amen brother, I have a background as a bouncer,B.E.A Agent,corrections/SWAT,& as a demostic/overseas operator & in neither of these arenas did I ever want to volunteer to go to the ground & try to "submit" the enemy.I teach reality based self preservation tactics that were tried & presure tested in actual worse case scenarios I've been in & even when we work on ground fighting tactics our mission priority is to get back up on our feet, not pretend we're are UFC combatants in a sports match.
RBSD does not suck,only some practicioners do. I know this is a hard concept for Bullshido activists everywhere but, it's called Budo. It's where you act partway decent and show minimal respect for everybody.
the RBSD element of the MA world, such as the Wagners, Larkins and Elmore's tend to feed on white middle class fears whether they are founded or not. They offer sub-standard training with an emphasis on LARPing with makeshift weapons.
In fact, last months BBMag Wagner responded to criticism of his claims to teach self defense against a sniper (where the writer made a joke of wondering if the next article would be on cruise missile defense) and affirmed that perhaps that wouldn't be a bad idea in this day and age.
?... What was the Reason for this video? I think we all need to read "Meditations on Violence" -Rory Miller. It addresses the Reality of violence and the not so Reality Based Instructors. If you instructor has never used it (Fight/ SD) then it is a guide not a real way (Tao). "Fighting is for stupid people"
I have no point... but to live.
FreeFloFighter 3 years ago
people shouldnt get so uptight when criticised it only reveals their insecurities- RBSD is my field and I can say there is a lot of bollocks in it- this video isnt anywhere near as cruel as it could be. My problem with it is the hypocrisy- you've got MMA nerds taking the piss out of RBSD nerds- if you spend more time on your pc than in training YOURE STILL A FUCKING NERD!
attending an MMA class or even competing does not automatically validate your opinion, You can train it and still be SHIT.
streetfightsecrets 3 years ago
rbsd is overrated..from what I've seen u learn a chin jab and a couple primitive strikes!!ohhh yeah that shit works!!bad mindset too..yeah lets rip dudes ears off and pluck out his eyeballs in an unarmed h2h situation!! prison sentence for u bud!!errrrrr
e4phil 3 years ago 2
we all act like we know what were talkin about eh?
how many of you have been, stabbed, beaten, robbed at gunpoint, expierenced warfare?
assblaster17 4 years ago 5
Look if really based self defense was praticed in a realistic manner nobody would have a problem with it.However many RBSD schools are nothing more than traditional M.A schools set in a paramilitary environment.That is why so many people have turned to the combat sports, because they know the skills they learn there will one day save their lives.
Plato86 4 years ago 4
How come it barely showed WHY RBSD sucks? Let's see some bad training techniques etc rather than a family of black women (what was the point in that?) and a number of fights with still photos? If you're going to slag something off, do it properly!
practicaltaekwondo 4 years ago
It's nto a video of RBSD that suck, it's the "sucks month of Bullshido's RBSD". not the "RBSD sucks month". they are called Bullshido's RBSD. There are however many SD thigns otu there that aren't very good, and this video shows what the realities are in real fights/altercations, with some humour in there too.
WesDereq 4 years ago
38 years training Combat Jujutsu 26 years teaching it , Military, LEO and Bouncing and all i can say to this is Yup Amen :)
TimA340 4 years ago 2
What I love about Bullshido is the inability of any of the "heroes" that hang on that site to take criticism. Phrost is so full of shit. Watch their throwdown vids. It is always some mismatched bunch of slap kickboxing.
writeguy73 4 years ago 2
Well, Phrost has a habit of taking the most extreme and absurd examples available in a given art and using them to point out how his target art sucks, which is an intellectually bankrupt and cheap way to promote one's POV. I find it ironic that while fulminating against BS in the martial arts, he spews plenty of his own.
Kyle359 4 years ago 3
I recently saw a video of Phrost in a "pro" fight. He got spanked by a mediocre fighter. I think Neal needs to shut the f**k up and stick to the keyboard wars!
writeguy73 4 years ago
Good point the reason they put this stuff up is what they do in a ring with rules does not work in reality look at the jail house brawl you would be stupid to go to the ground with someone in that enviroment so people are looking for something that works in the world we live in not a MMA gym.
snakeeyes007 4 years ago
Amen brother, I have a background as a bouncer,B.E.A Agent,corrections/SWAT,& as a demostic/overseas operator & in neither of these arenas did I ever want to volunteer to go to the ground & try to "submit" the enemy.I teach reality based self preservation tactics that were tried & presure tested in actual worse case scenarios I've been in & even when we work on ground fighting tactics our mission priority is to get back up on our feet, not pretend we're are UFC combatants in a sports match.
kastle1972 3 years ago
Bullshido's?????? where??? study about that!!!!
never a nort american people go to get Bullshido!!!!
crobosan 4 years ago
GTAAAAAB!
alecband 4 years ago
hahaha Gtab made it into this one!
dougdoug2006 4 years ago
Elmore isn't RBSD, he's unaffiliated. But I see you got the new Issue.
PhantomOnmitsu 4 years ago
RBSD does not suck,only some practicioners do. I know this is a hard concept for Bullshido activists everywhere but, it's called Budo. It's where you act partway decent and show minimal respect for everybody.
PhantomOnmitsu 4 years ago 4
the RBSD element of the MA world, such as the Wagners, Larkins and Elmore's tend to feed on white middle class fears whether they are founded or not. They offer sub-standard training with an emphasis on LARPing with makeshift weapons.
BafuNation 4 years ago
In fact, last months BBMag Wagner responded to criticism of his claims to teach self defense against a sniper (where the writer made a joke of wondering if the next article would be on cruise missile defense) and affirmed that perhaps that wouldn't be a bad idea in this day and age.
BafuNation 4 years ago
EPIC
Argooh 4 years ago
i need a heeeeeeeeeroooooooooo
gurakshun 4 years ago
"I'm holding on to a hero til the end of the night..
And he's gotta be strong and he's gotta be fast
but he can't be especially bright!"
BULLSHIDO!
kungfu2u2 4 years ago
Great stuff.
tenshirisu 4 years ago